ACC: 2012 Sugar Bowl

Sugar Bowl extra: Inside the numbers

January, 4, 2012
ESPN's Stats & Information department took a closer look inside the numbers behind Michigan's 23-20 overtime win against Virginia Tech on Tuesday night in the Allstate Sugar Bowl:

Despite the loss, Bud Foster's defense did a standout job on Michigan quarterback Denard Robinson. He was unable to find running room all night as six of his 13 total carries went for zero or negative yards. Virginia Tech shut down the inside zone read, allowing Robinson only one net yard rushing between the tackles all night.

Denard Robinson Rushing Inside Tackles

First 12 Games Sugar Bowl

Attempts: 104 8

Yards: 527 1

Yds per rush: 5.0 0.1

TD: 7 0

20-yd rush: 5 0

Virginia Tech quarterback Logan Thomas was actually the better quarterback. He was extremely effective running and passing on third down. Entering Tuesday, Thomas had only completed 48 percent of his third down passes.

Logan Thomas 3rd Down Passing

First 13 Games Sugar Bowl

Pass-Att: 47-98 (48.0) 5-7 (71.4)

Yds per att: 7.1 9.0

Pass effic.: 129.3 147.0

*30 yards, 3 first downs on 7 rush attempts
NEW ORLEANS — When Virginia Tech lost to Clemson in the ACC championship game, Hokies' running back David Wilson questioned the playcalling. On Tuesday night, after the Hokies lost to Michigan in the Allstate Sugar Bowl, Wilson called out the officiating.

When asked what the difference in the game was, Wilson said, "the referees."

"They did play a factor in this game," he said. "Jayron had a pass interference call, both of them were fighting for the ball, and it wasn't anything dramatic. Then they called me down, they showed the replay and I clearly wasn't on the ground. And then Danny Coale's catch. Those were three key plays that changed the momentum in that game. They definitely played a factor in the way the game turned out."

Me: Do you think it would've come down to those calls, though, if you guys were able to produce more in the red zone? On the 4-yard line, twice, and not to bring up a bad memory, but you kind of went the wrong way for a while there.

DW: "Nah, those calls were key calls. They definitely played a factor in how the game turned out."

Truth? I thought Coale's catch in the end zone in overtime was exactly that — a catch. But here's the thing: Officiating didn't lose the game for Virginia Tech or win it for Michigan. Here's what did:

  • A roughing the kicker penalty led to a Michigan touchdown.
  • A fumble on a kickoff led to a Michigan field goal.
  • A holding penalty on a Michigan kickoff led to Virginia Tech starting its final regulation drive inside their own 10.
  • Virginia Tech also missed a 37-yard field goal in overtime, the final margin of victory.
RED ZONE OFFENSE (or lack thereof)

Virginia Tech reached the red zone six times and only scored one touchdown. According to ESPN's Stats & Information group, entering the game, Virginia Tech scored touchdowns on 53.1 percent of their red-zone trips (ranked 10th in the ACC) and their red-zone troubles Tuesday were due to its inability to run the ball successfully.

ACC sinks deeper into BCS hole

January, 4, 2012
James GayleAP Photo/Bill HaberJames Gayle and the Hokies just couldn't get it done as Virginia Tech lost again on the BCS stage.
NEW ORLEANS -- This wasn’t the ACC’s only chance to make a statement.

This was the ACC’s 14th chance, to be exact.

Following Virginia Tech’s 23-20 overtime loss to Michigan on Tuesday night in the Allstate Sugar Bowl, the ACC dropped to 2-12 in its BCS games. That’s 14 years of developing a reputation, over a decade of results that won’t be erased with one Discover Orange Bowl win, or any other statement nonconference game for that matter. Clemson is up next on the BCS stage, but no matter what the Tigers do on Wednesday night against West Virginia, it won’t change the perception of the ACC overnight, nor will it ease the frustration of Virginia Tech’s narrow loss to an unimpressive Michigan team.

For those within Virginia Tech’s locker room following the loss, this was obviously a heartbreaker. It wasn’t a lack of effort; it was a lack of execution. You could see the devastation on receiver Danny Coale’s face when his would-be touchdown reception in overtime was reviewed and called an incomplete pass. You could hear the frustration when running back David Wilson unabashedly singled-out the officiating as the difference in the game. Twice. And you could tell by the look on coach Frank Beamer’s face as he made the long walk to the interview podium after the game that he knew they didn’t get it done and he was going to have to answer for it. Again.

Beamer dropped to 1-5 in BCS games. The ACC dropped another notch with him.

Beamer’s program has been the one tasked with representing the ACC the most often, and while getting to a BCS bowl is an accomplishment in itself, it’s no longer enough to satisfy fans or quiet critics.

“I think everybody in Virginia Tech football put a lot into this ballgame, I can tell you,” Beamer said. “And we wanted to get a win for the ACC and wanted to get a win for Virginia Tech. We haven’t done as well as we want to in these BCS games.”

This one might sting even more than last year’s embarrassing loss to Stanford in the Orange Bowl because it was oh-so-painfully close. Buried in the big picture was a great story about a third-string kicker, Justin Myer, who made the first four field goals of his career and sent the game into overtime before his fifth and most important attempt went wide right, his lone miss of the game. No shame in that performance. There was no shame in the terrific job Bud Foster’s defense did on quarterback Denard Robinson, who had a forgettable performance and was bailed out by receiver Junior Hemingway and the Wolverine's defense. Michigan was held to 184 total yards and just 56 rushing yards.

For a majority of the game, Virginia Tech looked like the better team. It had the better quarterback. It had the better defense. But it didn’t have an answer for the nation’s No. 5 red zone defense.

While there were some calls that could be questioned by the officials (aren’t there always?) it wouldn’t have come down to that had Virginia Tech scored more than one touchdown in six trips.

The Hokies’ performance against Michigan was a microcosm of the ACC’s story in BCS bowls: missed opportunities. It all started in the first quarter, on Virginia Tech’s first offensive possession, and you could almost hear the exasperation throughout ACC country on Twitter.

On first and goal from Michigan’s 4-yard line, Wilson ran for a loss of 22 yards. Uh oh

On fourth-and-1 from Michigan’s 4-yard line, Logan Thomas was held for no gain. Here we go again

Michigan recovered a fumble on a kickoff that led to a field goal and a 10-6 lead. Not again

Thomas intercepted in the third quarter, a play that led to a Michigan touchdown. Again?!

After making the first four field goals of his career, Myer missed what could have been the game-winning 37-yard attempt. Sigh, typical ACC.

It took longer than four quarters for Virginia Tech and the ACC to fall into this hole, and even with two teams in BCS bowls for the first time in league history, it’s going to take more than that to dig out of it.

Video: Virginia Tech WR Danny Coale

January, 4, 2012

Heather Dinich talks to Virginia Tech wide receiver Danny Coale after the Hokies' 23-20 overtime loss to Michigan in the Allstate Sugar Bowl.

Video: Virginia Tech DE James Gayle

January, 4, 2012

Heather Dinich talks to Virginia Tech defensive end James Gayle following the Hokies' 23-20 overtime loss to Michigan in the Allstate Sugar Bowl.

Video: Wrapping up the Sugar Bowl

January, 4, 2012

Wrapping up Michigan's hard-fought win and Virginia Tech's heartbreak in the Sugar Bowl.
NEW ORLEANS -- Virginia Tech running back David Wilson said after the Allstate Sugar Bowl that he is still undecided about whether he is leaving school early for the NFL draft, and that he hasn't yet heard back from the NFL advisory board.

Wilson said he will make an announcement next week regarding his decision.

He also said that his performance in the 23-20 overtime loss to Michigan or the team's performance will not factor into his decision. Wilson finished with 82 yards on 24 carries.

NEW ORLEANS -- Both Virginia Tech and Michigan faced doubts coming into this game, and both teams had their share of blunders, but in the end the Allstate Sugar Bowl delivered a thriller that went into overtime thanks to a third-string kicker who converted on all but the one field goal that mattered the most. Here's a look back at the highlights of the game as Michigan beat Virginia Tech 23-20:

How the game was won: Michigan's kicker made the field goal in overtime, and Virginia Tech's did not. Brendan Gibbons nailed his 37-yard attempt, while Justin Myer's 37-yard attempt sailed wide right. The Hokies weren't able to capitalize on their opportunities in the red zone during regulation and it was too little, too late. The Hokies had three turnovers and seven penalties. Myer tied the game at 20 and sent it into overtime and had made the first four field goals of his career -- 37 yards, 43, 36 and 25 -- but he missed the last and most important.

Stat of the game: Virginia Tech was in the red zone five times in regulation and came away with just one touchdown. The Hokies were on the four-yard line twice in the first half.

Stat of the game II: Michigan had just 56 rushing yards.

Player of the game: Michigan receiver Junior Hemingway. He had two highlight-worthy touchdown catches, both in traffic, and finished with 63 yards and two touchdowns on just two receptions. His 45-yard touchdown pass in the second quarter gave the Wolverines a 7-6 lead and the momentum heading into halftime. He then out jumped Antone Exum for an 18-yard touchdown catch to give Michigan the 17-6 lead in the third.

Second guessing: With 7:21 left in the game, Virginia Tech opted for a fake punt, a questionable move at best. The Hokies' defense was dominating, and it probably would have been best to either punt the ball or just go for it. Michigan didn't bite and Virginia Tech punter Danny Coale didn't stand a chance.

What Virginia Tech learned: The Hokies' defense can't do it all. Bud Foster's group did a great job, but Virginia Tech's dependence on field goals was the difference. The good news? They learned they have a kicker. They also learned that quarterback Logan Thomas is good enough to be in the Heisman conversation next year, but he'll need more from the players around him and a rebuilt offensive line to get there.

What Michigan learned: Denard Robinson doesn't have to do it all. With a much-improved defense, the Wolverines found they can win without a spectacular performance by Robinson.

What it means: The Big Ten got some validation, while the ACC sunk another rung deeper on the respect level.

Record performance: Virginia Tech running back David Wilson surpassed former teammate Ryan Williams to set the school record for rushing yards.
NEW ORLEANS -- Michigan quarterback Denard Robinson has looked both subpar and spectacular in this game. He's made poor throws and bad decisions, but his two remarkable touchdown passes have been the difference. For Robinson to have minus-one yard rushing on 10 carries and still be winning is just one of the many baffling facets of this game so far.

It's also looking like a typical ACC implosion.

Virginia Tech somehow snuck into this BCS bowl as the ACC's first at-large team, but it can't seem to find its way into the end zone here at the Mercedes-Benz Superdome. Kicker Justin Myer has been the only offense for the Hokies. If Virginia Tech is going to get back into this game, its best hope might be another big play or turnover from the defense.
NEW ORLEANS -- This game changed in less than a minute. Virginia Tech lost control and Michigan gained all of the momentum, thanks to a big passing play and a fumble on a kickoff return. It took until the waning minutes of the second half for the Wolverines' offense to wake up, but because of Virginia Tech's inability to capitalize in the red zone, it only took a few plays to change the game. Here's a quick look back at the first half:

Turning point: On third-and-17 from the 45-yard line, Michigan quarterback Denard Robinson threw a 45-yard touchdown pass to receiver Junior Hemingway. Free safety Eddie Whitley was in position to make the interception, but he missed it and Michigan took the lead and the momentum for the first time all game.

Stat of the half: Michigan had 116 of its 145 total yards in the second quarter. The Wolverines' offense was stifled in the first quarter, and didn't score until the final 49 seconds of the first half.

Best player in the half: Virginia Tech quarterback Logan Thomas. Despite the scoreboard, he's been sharp and accurate with the passing game, and his size and strength continue to be an asset in the running game. He completed 8 of 11 passes for 117 yards, and also led the Hokies in rushing with eight carries for 26 yards.

Michigan fortunate

January, 3, 2012
NEW ORLEANS -- Michigan is fortunate it's only trailing Virginia Tech 6-0 in the second quarter. Anyone paying attention to this game probably feels like it should be 21-0 Virginia Tech. The Hokies are controlling every aspect of this game except the scoreboard.

On their first possession they were as close as the 4-yard line when David Wilson lost 22 yards. Twice they settled for a field goal, and on the last drive, Michigan came up with a big stop on fourth-and-one -- again from the 4-yard line.

If Virginia Tech winds up losing this game, those opportunities are going to come back to haunt them. If Virginia Tech and Michigan both continue to play the way they have this half, though, there's no reason to continue to doubt the Hokies. They've been solid on third downs, Mike O'Cain's playcalling has been an edge, and Michigan quarterback Denard Robinson has been less than spectacular.
NEW ORLEANS -- Michigan coach Brady Hoke spent much of Sugar Bowl week raving about Virginia Tech running back David Wilson.

It seemed pretty clear Hoke and his staff would gear the defense toward stopping Wilson, the Hokies outstanding junior running back who entered the game ranked sixth nationally in rushing. And so far, Michigan is bottling up Wilson, who has seven carries for minus-8 yards, including a 22-yard loss that negated a great touchdown opportunity.

The problem for Michigan is Virginia Tech quarterback Logan Thomas, who has been brilliant so far. Thomas has completed 7 of 10 pass attempts for 101 yards, converting three third-and-long situations. The mammoth sophomore also has 22 rush yards.

It's pick your poison with the Virginia Tech offense, but Michigan needs to slow down Thomas' passing ability.

Virginia Tech leads 6-0 early in the second quarter.

Myer coming through for Hokies

January, 3, 2012
NEW ORLEANS -- Virginia Tech kicker Justin Myer, the third option on the depth chart at one point, has accounted for all of the Hokies' points so far tonight.

Raise your hand if you saw THAT one coming.

With Virginia Tech's top two kickers suspended for this game, Myer was one of the biggest question marks heading into the match, but so far, he's 2-for-2 and the Hokies are up 6-0 on Michigan because of it. He was 0-for-2 entering this game.
NEW ORLEANS -- This looks like a game Virginia Tech can win -- if it cuts down on its mistakes. It was an odd start to the game for both teams, as standout Michigan quarterback Denard Robinson began with four carries, two fumbles, a loss of a yard and a pick.

Yes, that Denard Robinson.

And Virginia Tech standout running back David Wilson let his ego run the offense for a play and went backwards for a baffling loss of 22 yards.

Yes, that David Wilson.

Wilson's run plus an untimely penalty forced Virginia Tech to settle for a field goal, but the good news for the Hokies was that reserve kicker Justin Myer made it -- a 37-yarder for his first made field goal of the season. That should get some jitters out, not only for Myer, but for Virginia Tech fans as well.

Michigan center David Molk missed the first series with a foot injury he re-aggravated from earlier in the season, but it wasn't enough to keep him out for more than a series. Still, Virginia Tech's defense has had the edge early. Kyle Fuller came up with an interception just when Michigan's offense seemed to finally get going. Michigan's defense has given up too many big plays, and the Hokies' passing game is looking much better than it did in the ACC title game against Clemson. Logan Thomas has been the better quarterback so far. Michigan had 29 yards of total offense while the Hokies had 110. The Hokies have controlled the clock, and so far, the game.

Pregame observations

January, 3, 2012
NEW ORLEANS -- Michigan is louder. At least right now, as I'm typing this and the stadium is still nowhere near full. Both teams are out on the field warming up, and the Wolverines have their crowd roaring already. Big Ten blogger Adam Rittenberg and I are going with 60-40 Michigan at this point.

For Virginia Tech, I kept my eye on one player for the most of warmups: kicker Justin Myer. He took a lot of practice field goal attempts between the 30- and 40-yard line, and there's no question he's got a powerful leg and the distance. As for the accuracy? I'll be honest with you: it's too difficult to tell from up here. My seat is so high I can't even see "The Beard." And I've got binoculars. (One classic sign I did see was "Oops. We're a week too early." And it had the Bama and LSU logos on it.)

Keep an eye on Myer tonight. The kicking game could be the difference. Whether it's a missed field goal, or Virginia Tech forcing something that's not there on a play they normally wouldn't go for, special teams could be a game-changer.



Friday, 11/28
Saturday, 11/29