ESPN's Mel Kiper Jr. says no. "He's overrated, overhyped. I don't think he should be a top-eight pick but we know he will be."
ESPN's Todd McShay says yes. "I think at No. 4, the Cleveland Browns have a very difficult decision to make. I think the right move is to upgrade the quarterback position and take Ryan Tannehill at No. 4."
I'm siding with Kiper on this one. I would take Alabama running back Trent Richardson over Tannehill. The QB is too much of a risk with only 19 starts in college.
To see the Kiper-McShay debate on the rise of Tannehill, click on the video. The ESPN draft analysts talk about Tannehill after first discussing Robert Griffin III.