That doesn't mean Weeden should be benched. The notion that the Browns should sit him for Sunday's game against the Cincinnati Bengals is short-sighted.
Let's be honest, making the playoffs isn't a realistic goal for Cleveland. The main objective is to figure out whether Weeden can be a franchise quarterback. The Browns need to start him for 16 games because they can't go into next season with any questions about Weeden.
It's not going to be easy or pretty at times. Case in point: Sunday's season opener when Weeden posted a quarterback rating of 5.1. According to ESPN Stats & Information, that's the lowest passer rating by a rookie in a season opener since 1960. Washington's Norm Snead previously held that distinction (7.5 in 1961).
I admit that I didn't break down any film of Snead, but I did see Weeden's disastrous debut. Greg Little continues to drop passes. Trent Richardson couldn't keep the Eagles honest with 39 yards rushing on 19 carries.
Where the supporting cast really let down Weeden is pass protection. He threw under duress 11 times. Only Michael Vick and Andrew Luck faced more consistent pressure. Staying poised in a collapsing pocket is where Weeden needs the biggest improvement. Three of his four interceptions came under pressure. This shouldn't come as a surprise. Shortly after the Browns drafted Weeden in the first round, two college defensive coordinators who beat Weeden say he got rattled when pressured.
"It's one bad game," Weeden told reporters Wednesday. "If I continue to do bad things, that's on me. I think they (the Browns) have a lot of confidence in me and my abilities and they wouldn't have named me the starter if they didn't. I've just got to prove to them that I'm the guy. When it's all said and done and you drop the helmet, you've got to play better."
It didn't help matters for the Browns or Weeden that his dismal outing came during the same time Robert Griffin III (the quarterback the Browns failed to land in a pre-draft trade) was lighting it up for the Redskins. RG3 is the first quarterback in league history to throw for 300 yards, two touchdowns and no interceptions and win in his NFL debut. So, Weeden had one of the worst debuts ever for a rookie quarterback and RG3 had one of the best.
But no one expected Weeden to be RG3. They do, however, expect Weeden to solidify the Browns' quarterback position. That's why the Browns drafted him with the No. 22 pick. That's why they can't even think about benching him after one game.