Been pondering doing this for some time, and hit a now-or-never point today.
I decided to move forward for two reasons – it forced me to crystallize some preseason opinions, and I feel certain it will generate some debate.
So here’s our first preseason All-AFC South team.
Let’s be clear on criteria: I’ve combined past performance and my expectations for 2012 to create this team. In some spots, I relied more on one than the other.
Defensively, I picked 12 guys, with four linemen and four linebackers. It’s the only way to be fair considering we have two 4-3s and two 3-4s. And as we’ve got teams that start two tight ends and teams that start two backs, but I went with my favored two-tight end set. (Going three wide would have been pushing it, right?)
Also let’s acknowledge it’s an uneven playing field.
Titans right tackle David Stewart, for example, has minimal competition in my eyes considering the three other guys who will start at the position on Sunday: inexperienced Cameron Bradfield for Jacksonville and Derek Newton for Houston, and shaky veteran Winston Justice in Indianapolis.
So here’s the team. Blast away.