AFC South: Kyle Orton
Should the Colts claim Kyle Orton?
November, 23, 2011
11/23/11
7:56
AM ET
By
Paul Kuharsky | ESPN.com
The Indianapolis Colts can have quarterback Kyle Orton if they want him.
The question is, should they want him?
OrtonWhy they should: They stand to end up with with a historically bad record, just six weeks away from 0-16. They are deciding whether to move forward with Curtis Painter or change up to Dan Orlovsky. Orton is, without a doubt, a better quarterback than either of them. But he’d come in needing to learn what the Colts do, or they’d need to bend what they do to him. And that’s a lot to take on at this stage of the season.
The Colts aren’t big benders. Claiming Orton would be doing something different. It’s been a season when many critics have wondered why the Colts wouldn’t do something -- anything -- different to give themselves a better chance at winning. Grabbing Orton would be just that.
Why they shouldn’t: Frankly, if Orton came in and helped the Colts win a couple games, he could screw up the team’s draft position. The Colts have a pretty strong hold on the No. 1 overall pick in the April draft, and the consensus around the league is that Stanford’s Andrew Luck is the best quarterback to come out of college in some time.
I’m sure there is a salary-cap issue, but if the Colts really wanted Orton, they could find a way.
My verdict: Why not? A claim would make a statement to Colts fans that the team is still interested in improving and is unafraid of making a bold move.
That said, I’d be surprised if they do it. Staying the course has been a big deal for Indianapolis, and they’ve talked as if staying steady will win them something even if it means they don’t win a game.
The question is, should they want him?
The Colts aren’t big benders. Claiming Orton would be doing something different. It’s been a season when many critics have wondered why the Colts wouldn’t do something -- anything -- different to give themselves a better chance at winning. Grabbing Orton would be just that.
Why they shouldn’t: Frankly, if Orton came in and helped the Colts win a couple games, he could screw up the team’s draft position. The Colts have a pretty strong hold on the No. 1 overall pick in the April draft, and the consensus around the league is that Stanford’s Andrew Luck is the best quarterback to come out of college in some time.
I’m sure there is a salary-cap issue, but if the Colts really wanted Orton, they could find a way.
My verdict: Why not? A claim would make a statement to Colts fans that the team is still interested in improving and is unafraid of making a bold move.
That said, I’d be surprised if they do it. Staying the course has been a big deal for Indianapolis, and they’ve talked as if staying steady will win them something even if it means they don’t win a game.
For Titans in Pittsburgh, big steps back
October, 9, 2011
10/09/11
9:20
PM ET
By
Paul Kuharsky | ESPN.com
Jared Wickerham/Getty ImagesMatt Hasselbeck had problems connecting with his receivers and ended the day with a 72.0 rating.The Tennessee Titans were “disgusted” over their 38-17 loss to the Pittsburgh Steelers at Heinz Field. They were ticked off that they “got kicked around" and were recipients of “an old-fashioned butt whooping.”
“They kicked our butts and we kicked our own butts,” defensive end Dave Ball said, referring to a scene where Jim Carrey’s character beats himself up in a bathroom in the movie “Liar Liar." "It was a perfect s--- storm."
But Ball and others who so eloquently discussed the result were quick to sandwich it with resolve regarding the potential for it to be duplicated.
“You’re not going to see this Titans team again,” Ball said. “I guarantee that. You’re not going to see the same thing happen again.”
Tennessee is 3-2 heading into its bye, and with Houston, Jacksonville and Indianapolis all dropping games too, the Titans didn’t lose any ground in the AFC South standings.
“That’s good,” quarterback Matt Hasselbeck said.
That’s about all that’s good from the day.
A look at three elements of the disaster:
The start: Tennessee marched 69 yards on 13 plays on a game-opening drive but stalled badly in the red zone with two penalties, an incomplete pass and a sack.
Rob Bironas' 29-yard field goal felt like a win for the Steelers, and when Antonio Brown returned the ensuing kickoff 52 yards to midfield, things really started to lean in Pittsburgh’s favor.
“After that we really stalled,” Hasselbeck said. “We didn’t look like we looked on the first drive.”
The Titans' next five series produced two first downs and 49 yards. It was 28-3 by the time they put together another effective drive.
The timing was off, with Hasselbeck frequently throwing behind guys -- some of it inaccuracy, some of it bad communication or lingering unfamiliarity. The team was in two-minute drive mode starting with its second drive of the second half.
“I just have more questions than answers right now,” Hasselbeck said.
Coach Mike Munchak didn't like the idea that a field goal instead of a touchdown was that big a letdown at the start.
"I hope we're not going to go into the tank because we got held to three points instead of seven," he said.
It wasn't the only reason but it helped.
Ben Roethlisberger: Cornerback Cortland Finnegan knew the Titans were thoroughly outplayed, but the corner who picked Roethlisberger's one really bad pass raised his eyebrows in surprise when he was told the Steelers' quarterback threw five touchdowns.
Coming into Pittsburgh, the Titans had faced Luke McCown, Joe Flacco, Kyle Orton and Colt McCoy. Hardly a murderer’s row of quarterbacks.
The Steelers smartly adjusted their offense for their quarterback, who has a sprained left foot. He didn’t hold the ball for a long time and scramble around like he typically does. He got rid of it pretty quickly while benefiting from some max protection that aided a beat-up line.
In such circumstances, the defense then needs to keep things in front of it, hit pass-catchers quickly and limit first downs.
The Titans didn’t.
“They used a different game plan than last week against the Texans,” end Jason Jones said. “They were going to max protect or they were going to get it out quick. We had our opportunities to get to him and didn’t. But it was dink and dunk and max protect.”
Rookie defensive tackle Jurrell Casey had the Titans' lone sack.
Special teams: The Steelers crushed the Titans with that big kickoff return from Brown and a fake punt where Daniel Sepulveda threw a 33-yard pass to Ryan Mundy.
Even when the Titans did good things on special teams, they turned bad.
The Titans recovered a third-quarter onsides kick after cutting the lead to 28-10, but Steelers defensive end Brett Keisel got a piece of Hasselbeck’s throw on the very next play and LaMarr Woodley picked it off. When linebacker Tim Shaw blocked a Sepulveda punt in the fourth quarter, Finnegan returned it 30 yards for a touchdown. But an illegal block in the back call against Jamie Harper wiped away the score.
“It’s a three-phase game, and special teams we’ve got to pick it up,” said linebacker Gerald McRath. “We’ve definitely got to pull our weight. We let the team down.”
Moving forward ...
The Titans pulled off a 3-1 first-quarter record after dropping their opener with a lousy performance in Jacksonville. Hasselbeck said they hope to match it in the season's second quarter. They'll have to win three in a row at home after their bye to do so: against Houston, Indianapolis and Cincinnati.
That good start began to create some hype, and the Titans said they hadn’t bought in. But if any self-satisfaction had crept in anywhere, the Steelers snuffed it out.
“I just feel that you can feel people patting you on the back and that’s not what helps you win games,” Hasselbeck said. “I think typically what helps you in games is hard work and feeling like you’ve got something to prove and feeling like you’ve got to give everything you’ve got.
“I’m just slow to accept that stuff.”
After this dud, you can see why that’s the safe route.
» NFC Final Word: East | West | North | South » AFC: East | West | North | South
Five nuggets of knowledge about Week 3:
Watch the Jaguars' defense: It did not play badly in New York, it’s just that the Jets were given so many chances by the Jacksonville offense. Cam Newton is due for a comedown, and a defense that loaded up on veterans this offseason needs to see a payoff Sunday in Carolina. Put the spotlight on Paul Posluszny, Clint Session, Matt Roth, probable new starting safety Dwight Lowery and Drew Coleman. They were brought in to make this a good defense now, and if they can’t fare well against a rookie quarterback and a rebuilding team, it will be a major disappointment. The defense should play well enough to give Blaine Gabbert a chance to win his first start if he plays efficiently.
Blitz alert: The Texans are probably sick of hearing about how challenging the blitz packages of Saints defensive coordinator Gregg Williams will be. But they’ll also be reviewing the possibilities and reminding themselves of their schemes for handling blitzes. Matt Schaub is better when teams sit back and play coverages rather than coming after him. Still, although New Orleans wants to blitz and has the people to do it, the Saints are only 18th against the pass through two games. Although they collected eight sacks against the Packers and Bears, they’ve allowed an opponent passer rating of 95.6. There will be room for Schaub to succeed.
Quick and short: I expect the Colts will try to combat the Steelers' high pressure 3-4 front with quick, short passes, hoping for yards after the catch. Kerry Collins can certainly connect with Joseph Addai in such circumstances. He has done OK with Reggie Wayne and Dallas Clark. The guy who needs to be a bigger part of things is Austin Collie, who was targeted 10 times a week ago but had only three receptions for 24 yards. To move it better, particularly in the red zone, where it was a struggle against the Browns, I think Collins-to-Collie has to become a bigger part of things.
Denver’s health: The Broncos were awfully banged up last week against Cincinnati when they managed to win without several key guys -- defensive end Elvis Dumervil, linebacker D.J. Williams, cornerback Champ Bailey, receiver Brandon Lloyd and running back Knowshon Moreno. At least some of those guys will return, and the Titans will face a better team than the one they have been watching on tape. Kyle Orton led Denver to a win at LP Field last season, so this is a trip the Broncos know they can make successful. Underrated Titans left tackle Michael Roos will be ready for Dumervil if the defensive end is back.
Making Newton uncomfortable: Newton has been very comfortable in his first two NFL games, even as Carolina has dropped both. For the Jaguars, making Newton do things he has not been doing well is a major goal. What might that entail? According to ESPN Stats & Info, Newton has been the best quarterback in the NFL throwing outside the numbers, where he has a passer rating of 109.5 and a Total QBR of 91.6. Take away receivers on the perimeter and make him look inside the numbers and you’ll find a much more average player: passer rating of 63, QBR of 39.2. The pressure is on Rashean Mathis and Derek Cox, particularly against Steve Smith, who is responsible for a good share of Newton’s numbers to the outside.
Five nuggets of knowledge about Week 3:
Watch the Jaguars' defense: It did not play badly in New York, it’s just that the Jets were given so many chances by the Jacksonville offense. Cam Newton is due for a comedown, and a defense that loaded up on veterans this offseason needs to see a payoff Sunday in Carolina. Put the spotlight on Paul Posluszny, Clint Session, Matt Roth, probable new starting safety Dwight Lowery and Drew Coleman. They were brought in to make this a good defense now, and if they can’t fare well against a rookie quarterback and a rebuilding team, it will be a major disappointment. The defense should play well enough to give Blaine Gabbert a chance to win his first start if he plays efficiently.
[+] Enlarge
Derick E. Hingle/US PresswireThe Saints will look to bring pressure on Matt Schaub to slow down the Texans' air attack.
Derick E. Hingle/US PresswireThe Saints will look to bring pressure on Matt Schaub to slow down the Texans' air attack.Quick and short: I expect the Colts will try to combat the Steelers' high pressure 3-4 front with quick, short passes, hoping for yards after the catch. Kerry Collins can certainly connect with Joseph Addai in such circumstances. He has done OK with Reggie Wayne and Dallas Clark. The guy who needs to be a bigger part of things is Austin Collie, who was targeted 10 times a week ago but had only three receptions for 24 yards. To move it better, particularly in the red zone, where it was a struggle against the Browns, I think Collins-to-Collie has to become a bigger part of things.
Denver’s health: The Broncos were awfully banged up last week against Cincinnati when they managed to win without several key guys -- defensive end Elvis Dumervil, linebacker D.J. Williams, cornerback Champ Bailey, receiver Brandon Lloyd and running back Knowshon Moreno. At least some of those guys will return, and the Titans will face a better team than the one they have been watching on tape. Kyle Orton led Denver to a win at LP Field last season, so this is a trip the Broncos know they can make successful. Underrated Titans left tackle Michael Roos will be ready for Dumervil if the defensive end is back.
Making Newton uncomfortable: Newton has been very comfortable in his first two NFL games, even as Carolina has dropped both. For the Jaguars, making Newton do things he has not been doing well is a major goal. What might that entail? According to ESPN Stats & Info, Newton has been the best quarterback in the NFL throwing outside the numbers, where he has a passer rating of 109.5 and a Total QBR of 91.6. Take away receivers on the perimeter and make him look inside the numbers and you’ll find a much more average player: passer rating of 63, QBR of 39.2. The pressure is on Rashean Mathis and Derek Cox, particularly against Steve Smith, who is responsible for a good share of Newton’s numbers to the outside.
Draft-day trades: What we'll be missing
April, 8, 2011
4/08/11
11:26
AM ET
By
Paul Kuharsky | ESPN.com
Is there less buzz about the upcoming NFL draft than usual?
I certainly think so. The lockout and labor impasse are putting a damper on everything. There has been no free-agency build up. And there won’t be trades involving veteran players.
ESPN Stats & Info’s Mark Malzewski sifted through the past 11 drafts to find all the draft-day trades involving players.
There have been 37 such trades, or 3.4 per draft. That included two deals involving drafted players, and those aren’t allowed this time either. (Think Eli Manning and Philip Rivers in 2004.)
These trades included significant names such as Jason Campbell, Pacman Jones, Randy Moss, Trent Green and Ahman Green.
Last year the Jaguars gave up a fourth-round pick to Oakland for linebacker Kirk Morrison and a fifth-rounder.
We’ll see no such movement in this draft and it certainly takes away one layer of intrigue. Allow trades for veterans in this draft and it could be way more interesting considering all the quarterback uncertainty around the league.
Quarterbacks Kevin Kolb, Carson Palmer, Kyle Orton and Matt Flynn, who could eventually be traded, will not go anywhere.
Here’s the year-by-year review of the sort of trades we won’t be seeing.
I certainly think so. The lockout and labor impasse are putting a damper on everything. There has been no free-agency build up. And there won’t be trades involving veteran players.
There have been 37 such trades, or 3.4 per draft. That included two deals involving drafted players, and those aren’t allowed this time either. (Think Eli Manning and Philip Rivers in 2004.)
These trades included significant names such as Jason Campbell, Pacman Jones, Randy Moss, Trent Green and Ahman Green.
Last year the Jaguars gave up a fourth-round pick to Oakland for linebacker Kirk Morrison and a fifth-rounder.
We’ll see no such movement in this draft and it certainly takes away one layer of intrigue. Allow trades for veterans in this draft and it could be way more interesting considering all the quarterback uncertainty around the league.
Quarterbacks Kevin Kolb, Carson Palmer, Kyle Orton and Matt Flynn, who could eventually be traded, will not go anywhere.
Here’s the year-by-year review of the sort of trades we won’t be seeing.
D. A. Wade from Orlando writes: Assuming the NFL CBA issue doesn't resolve before the draft in April, how does a team determine its draft needs? Do NFL teams operate on the assumption that all free agents will be lost, or do they assume the free agents will be retained, or is it a case-by-case basis? Or do teams draft without regard to their needs? Thanks for the insight.
Paul Kuharsky: I would think they‘d expect there will be some form of free agency at some point.
So it’ll be an interesting flip -- for years if you didn’t get something in free agency, you’d say, “Well, we address it in the draft.” Now you’ll say, “If we didn’t get it in the draft, we can get it in free agency.”
The wrench this time is a team may not have worked real hard to retain its own guys in February because it didn’t want to give out bonuses heading toward a lockout.
But in a league where more and more of the quality programs are draft builders, it almost seems to make more sense with the draft first, particularly if those salaries are in line to wind up more manageable.
I think bad, panicky teams will panic and force need in the draft, while better non-panicky teams won’t, and will get even better.
Cory from Denver writes: If there is a lockout and the NFL season is lost, what happens to Indianapolis hosting the Super Bowl? Do they host the following year or lose out completely? Thanks.
Paul Kuharsky: Can’t take away New Orleans’ Super Bowl in 2013 or NY/NJ’s in 2014. Presumably Indy would go to the back of the line and get the game played in 2015.
But the season won’t be lost. Players won’t be able to hold out that long.
Jim in Greenville, S.C., writes: With the draft so full of DTs in the first 2 rounds, could you see the Titans going to a 3-4 by taking someone like Marcell Dareus in the first and Drake Nevis (LSU) in the second or is it far more complicated than that? I'd love to see Jason Jones on the outside of a 3-4. Would he fit there? Would he stay healthier in that rather than the current circumstance?
Paul Kuharsky: It’s amazing how many people like to suggest the Titans should go to a 3-4. Even if they intend to go bigger at defensive end and part with Jason Babin, Dave Ball and Jacob Ford, all free agents, they still have some of their best players on the defensive line -- Jones, Derrick Morgan, William Hayes. Their three linebackers last year were unproductive, and Stephen Tulloch is a free agent to be. So you want a team with two starting linebackers who were unproductive, Gerald McRath and Will Witherspoon, to change to a defense that calls for more linebackers? I’m not following the logic no matter who they can draft. It’s a two-year transition minimum, and they’ve got personnel that can be effective in a better 4-3.
Jeff in Nashville writes: Are we going to get a follow-up article to your "Cocky Mallett..." article that details how impressively he threw the ball today? His on field performance has garnered rave reviews across the board and one person even said it was the best QB performance at the combine in the last 10 years. When should we expect that article?
Paul Kuharsky: So defensive. Are you related to him or just a passionate Arkansas fan? Apparently you stopped paying attention right after you read the entry you didn’t like.
Here’s a piece I did less than 24 hours later on how the interviews can be over-interpreted. Did you also miss this one highlighting Mallett’s workout?
Also you do know that he SHOULD dominate a workout with no defenders or decision-making involved, right?
Chris in Phoenix writes: What are the odds that the Colts look into the recently released Tommie Harris since both Antonio Johnson and Dan Muir are currently FA's as well? I would also like to know your thoughts on the impact he would have with his unique speed at the defensive tackle position playing alongside Dwight Freeney and Robert Mathis.
Paul Kuharsky: I don’t think the Colts are in a panic over the contract status of Daniel Muir or Antonio Johnson. I could see the Colts drafting a guy to be a front-liner with Fili Moala.
I would have been very surprised to see the Colts active cutting players before free agency.
Logan in Duluth, Minn., writes: In regards to the NFL schedule length, I was wondering why they have to have either 16 or 18 games. Would it not possible to drop two preseason games and add one regular season game? Is it because of playoff tie breakers?
Paul Kuharsky: An odd number of games is sloppy. Then some teams have an extra home game, others have one fewer. How does that affect competitive balance as teams vie for the same division crown or playoff berth?
And they would never drop two preseason to add one regular season. They have to have the same number of total gates or more, otherwise they are giving up money and they won’t be doing that.
Titansfan from Dover, Del., writes: What is the situation with Chris Johnson's contract?
Paul Kuharsky: He’s under contract. They can’t talk about an extension until July, presuming a new CBA is in place by then. A player/team can’t renegotiate the same deal twice inside a year.
Jesse in Muncie, Ind., writes: I am trying to find the complete draft order, but I can only get the first round. Are all seven rounds not yet determined? If that's the case, when will they be set?
Paul Kuharsky: Three rounds are set. Compensatory selections are announced in late March, and they start at the end of the third round and are tacked on to the end of every round after that. That’s why there isn’t a seven-round order yet.
Brent H. at Columbia, Tenn., writes: With the Broncos turning to Kyle Orton as the starter to open camp, could the Titans target Tim Tebow as a possible trade candidate as the QB of the future? He may not have the skills to be the answer immediately, but will be as ready as any rookie QB that we draft, and possesses great intangibles and leadership that the Titans have lacked from their QB position in the past (see Vince Young).
Paul Kuharsky: The Broncos have no idea who will start. John Fox and his staff have not been on the field with those guys. It doesn’t matter what they say right now.
If the Titans scouts weren’t high on Tebow a year ago, why are the high on him now?
They don’t need a quarterback with physical gifts OR with intangibles. They need one with both. Who cares if Tebow can lead if he can’t throw?
Jwill25 from Columbia, S.C., writes: Now that it seems like the Raiders will not be able to sign Nnamdi Asomugha, would it make since for the Colts to cut Kelvin Hayden? Hayden is scheduled to make a little over $9 million next season and for $4-5 million more we can get a top-notch cornerback in his prime that can hold up a hold season. Not to mention the numbers he produces turnover-wise is worth that much alone. I really believe he could do for us what Charles Woodson does for Green Bay. What are your thoughts?
Paul Kuharsky: That’s not what Hayden is scheduled to make, it’s what he’ll count against the cap. He’s scheduled to make $6.015 million. Asomugha will cost a lot more than that.
And Jim Irsay has publicly said they won’t chase Asomugha. So that basically ends that.
Jonathan in Nashville writes: Chris Johnson Trade!?!?I happened to catch the tail-end of a conversation on XM Radio this morning that the Titans were going to "Shop" CJ around for a QB trade, is this true and if so why would they give up their best offensive player?
Paul Kuharsky: Not true. If it was true, why would the team be talking about it?
A top three running back is not worth a top 10 or 15 quarterback. Who’s trading a good quarterback for a good running back, when the rushing champ was undrafted and the good quarterbacks are almost all high picks?
Drew from Richmond, Va., writes: Any info on this DeMario Pressley? I mean from what I can put together he is essentially a second year player when it comes to playing time who has not proven that he is a playmaker much less a starter. The Colts already have six men listed at defensive tackle. Can we expect a few guys getting cut off that list, and how did this guy grab attention when there are bigger names on the market at that position? I agree that the Colts need to strengthen the run defense and start with the middle of the line but is this guy close to an answer?
Paul Kuharsky: I wouldn’t get excited about Houston’s toss-offs. Maybe he’s a serviceable, back-of-the-rotation guy.
Claiming a guy off waivers is a much cheaper and lower-risk option than signing Shaun Rogers or Tommie Harris or Marcus Stroud. They never said Pressley is a big answer. Such an addition means they think he’s worth bringing in and working with. He could easily be cut two weeks after coaches get to know him. Having him means nothing about their willingness to draft or look at a free agent later.
That said, don’t get caught up in big names. Did you know a lot about Antoine Bethea before they brought him in? Robert Mathis? Jerraud Powers?
Joe in Murfreesburo, Tenn., writes: Mel Kiper Jr. has the Titans taking a DE at #8 in the draft. I don't know if Mel remembers, but the Titans are fine at defensive end. They don't need to re-sign Jason Babin. In fact, they might be better off avoiding a big deal if it turns out he was just a one-year wonder. Derrick Morgan will be back, and he will be ready to go with Dave Ball OR Babin on the other side. Either way, they have much bigger needs than to draft another defensive end, when they will basically have a first-round rookie in Morgan next year. Talk some sense into the man Paul, we need a QB.
Paul Kuharsky: Of course they need a quarterback. But if they don’t like an option they have at No. 8, they’d be dumb to force it.
Babin, Ball and Ford are all en route to unrestricted free agency, they are all undersized and they all faded down the stretch. There is great defensive end talent high in this draft and the Titans have indicated they’d like to have more well-rounded, sturdy guys at the spot.
I’d have no problem with the Titans taking an end to go with Morgan and Hayes. A sustained pass rush that can defend the runs makes everyone better -- including a second-round quarterback.
Jarell from Atlanta by way of Gary, Ind., writes: I read a piece you linked the other day about the Colts free agents. I was shocked to realize how many of our guys are going to be up for free agency, who do you think we keep, specifically between Joseph Addai and Melvin Bullitt? I think Charlie Johnson is a talent, though not the best option at tackle, but the only option we have right now. And what about the tackles... Antonio Johnson came on last season at the end, and can be the reason why the rush defense fell behind while he was out in the playoffs. And Daniel Muir has become a staple in our community...what do you think?
Paul Kuharsky: Well first, I think being a staple in the community doesn’t mean much if you’re a middling player looking for a contract.
I don’t see them choosing between Addai and Bullitt and don’t know why you do.
Think they’d like to have Addai, Bullitt, Johnson, Johnson, Muir and Clint Session all back. They generally work hard to keep their own. I don’t think Addai, either Johnson or Muir draw a lot of interest from other teams. They are all tailored to the Colts, a team that works hard to keep core, valuable guys they drafted or brought in as rookies.
A quality O-line pickup could mean Charlie Johnson is moved to guard or sixth man. A quality defensive tackle in the draft or free agency could mean the end of Antonio Johnson or Muir.
Bullitt may be the toughest to retain because there is a lot of safety need around the league. The Texans and Jaguars would both be wise to chase him.
***
We’re Colts and Titans heavy, so I tweeted a request for Texans and Jaguars questions and did a rapid fire Twitter session. (I’m @ESPN_AFCSouth.)
@JoeDowntownVS2 so have the texans still decided safety dosent matters even after last year?
PK: Should have looked at available guys. But they still have draft and real free agency. If they don't act then, they're nuts.
@TheMizellGroup being that Garrard never seems to close out the season we know have consecutive seasons in the "L" are we drafting a QB
PK: Absolutely they'll look hard at a developmental QB.
@DustyGmoe With the signings yesterday from #Texans, can you tell where they will go in the first two rounds?
PK: Defense, defense, defense. OLB, FS, SS, CB and despite what they say, DT.
@baron_von_brad any other team make a play for Hawk?
PK: Don't think there was time and he may not have been interested knowing they were working on a new deal.
@HoustonDiehards is gerald sebsabaugh's history w/ Wade going to land him in Houston once free agency happens? Or are we counting on Nolan?
PK: Nolan in the mix. I hope they do better than Sensabaugh.
@tntitansfan10 how much long will Garrard be Jags QB?
PK: Five or six games if they aren't good ones.
@JasonEmbry With Texans' defensive changes, what does future hold for Okoye? And should Texans upgrade No. 2 WR?
PK: Will get a chance to play 3-4 end for Wade. I'd like to see another option at No. 2, though they invested in Walter.
@Hodari11 Does Rahean Mathis have any trade value?Trade now instead of getting nothing when he leavesWants alot more than he is worth
PK: It's not baseball, where you trade a vet for prospects before he's done. They need Mathis, too young in secondary without him.
@AnnaMegan Is getting a new deal for Vonta Leach a must for Texans?
PK: He was very good last year and I wouldn't mess with the formula. But FBs are generally replaceable.
@eggsngrits Not a #Texans fan, but I have to ask: Why would Arian Foster report to camp for a one-year $480k tender offer?
PK: Because he's under contract to do so. I think they'll try to reward him, but they get a financial reward for grabbing him.
@sumpteravada if we had had the social network we hve now n the 80s...wud Marino/Montana/Moon/Elway been held under the microscope?
PK: Their lives would have been different for sure.
***
Hate the contents of this mailbag? Change the next one by writing me here, via Twitter @ESPN_AFCSouth or via Facebook at Paul Kuharsky ESPN.
Paul Kuharsky: I would think they‘d expect there will be some form of free agency at some point.
So it’ll be an interesting flip -- for years if you didn’t get something in free agency, you’d say, “Well, we address it in the draft.” Now you’ll say, “If we didn’t get it in the draft, we can get it in free agency.”
The wrench this time is a team may not have worked real hard to retain its own guys in February because it didn’t want to give out bonuses heading toward a lockout.
But in a league where more and more of the quality programs are draft builders, it almost seems to make more sense with the draft first, particularly if those salaries are in line to wind up more manageable.
I think bad, panicky teams will panic and force need in the draft, while better non-panicky teams won’t, and will get even better.
Cory from Denver writes: If there is a lockout and the NFL season is lost, what happens to Indianapolis hosting the Super Bowl? Do they host the following year or lose out completely? Thanks.
Paul Kuharsky: Can’t take away New Orleans’ Super Bowl in 2013 or NY/NJ’s in 2014. Presumably Indy would go to the back of the line and get the game played in 2015.
But the season won’t be lost. Players won’t be able to hold out that long.
Jim in Greenville, S.C., writes: With the draft so full of DTs in the first 2 rounds, could you see the Titans going to a 3-4 by taking someone like Marcell Dareus in the first and Drake Nevis (LSU) in the second or is it far more complicated than that? I'd love to see Jason Jones on the outside of a 3-4. Would he fit there? Would he stay healthier in that rather than the current circumstance?
Paul Kuharsky: It’s amazing how many people like to suggest the Titans should go to a 3-4. Even if they intend to go bigger at defensive end and part with Jason Babin, Dave Ball and Jacob Ford, all free agents, they still have some of their best players on the defensive line -- Jones, Derrick Morgan, William Hayes. Their three linebackers last year were unproductive, and Stephen Tulloch is a free agent to be. So you want a team with two starting linebackers who were unproductive, Gerald McRath and Will Witherspoon, to change to a defense that calls for more linebackers? I’m not following the logic no matter who they can draft. It’s a two-year transition minimum, and they’ve got personnel that can be effective in a better 4-3.
Jeff in Nashville writes: Are we going to get a follow-up article to your "Cocky Mallett..." article that details how impressively he threw the ball today? His on field performance has garnered rave reviews across the board and one person even said it was the best QB performance at the combine in the last 10 years. When should we expect that article?
Paul Kuharsky: So defensive. Are you related to him or just a passionate Arkansas fan? Apparently you stopped paying attention right after you read the entry you didn’t like.
Here’s a piece I did less than 24 hours later on how the interviews can be over-interpreted. Did you also miss this one highlighting Mallett’s workout?
Also you do know that he SHOULD dominate a workout with no defenders or decision-making involved, right?
Chris in Phoenix writes: What are the odds that the Colts look into the recently released Tommie Harris since both Antonio Johnson and Dan Muir are currently FA's as well? I would also like to know your thoughts on the impact he would have with his unique speed at the defensive tackle position playing alongside Dwight Freeney and Robert Mathis.
Paul Kuharsky: I don’t think the Colts are in a panic over the contract status of Daniel Muir or Antonio Johnson. I could see the Colts drafting a guy to be a front-liner with Fili Moala.
I would have been very surprised to see the Colts active cutting players before free agency.
Logan in Duluth, Minn., writes: In regards to the NFL schedule length, I was wondering why they have to have either 16 or 18 games. Would it not possible to drop two preseason games and add one regular season game? Is it because of playoff tie breakers?
Paul Kuharsky: An odd number of games is sloppy. Then some teams have an extra home game, others have one fewer. How does that affect competitive balance as teams vie for the same division crown or playoff berth?
And they would never drop two preseason to add one regular season. They have to have the same number of total gates or more, otherwise they are giving up money and they won’t be doing that.
Titansfan from Dover, Del., writes: What is the situation with Chris Johnson's contract?
Paul Kuharsky: He’s under contract. They can’t talk about an extension until July, presuming a new CBA is in place by then. A player/team can’t renegotiate the same deal twice inside a year.
Jesse in Muncie, Ind., writes: I am trying to find the complete draft order, but I can only get the first round. Are all seven rounds not yet determined? If that's the case, when will they be set?
Paul Kuharsky: Three rounds are set. Compensatory selections are announced in late March, and they start at the end of the third round and are tacked on to the end of every round after that. That’s why there isn’t a seven-round order yet.
Brent H. at Columbia, Tenn., writes: With the Broncos turning to Kyle Orton as the starter to open camp, could the Titans target Tim Tebow as a possible trade candidate as the QB of the future? He may not have the skills to be the answer immediately, but will be as ready as any rookie QB that we draft, and possesses great intangibles and leadership that the Titans have lacked from their QB position in the past (see Vince Young).
Paul Kuharsky: The Broncos have no idea who will start. John Fox and his staff have not been on the field with those guys. It doesn’t matter what they say right now.
If the Titans scouts weren’t high on Tebow a year ago, why are the high on him now?
They don’t need a quarterback with physical gifts OR with intangibles. They need one with both. Who cares if Tebow can lead if he can’t throw?
Jwill25 from Columbia, S.C., writes: Now that it seems like the Raiders will not be able to sign Nnamdi Asomugha, would it make since for the Colts to cut Kelvin Hayden? Hayden is scheduled to make a little over $9 million next season and for $4-5 million more we can get a top-notch cornerback in his prime that can hold up a hold season. Not to mention the numbers he produces turnover-wise is worth that much alone. I really believe he could do for us what Charles Woodson does for Green Bay. What are your thoughts?
Paul Kuharsky: That’s not what Hayden is scheduled to make, it’s what he’ll count against the cap. He’s scheduled to make $6.015 million. Asomugha will cost a lot more than that.
And Jim Irsay has publicly said they won’t chase Asomugha. So that basically ends that.
Jonathan in Nashville writes: Chris Johnson Trade!?!?I happened to catch the tail-end of a conversation on XM Radio this morning that the Titans were going to "Shop" CJ around for a QB trade, is this true and if so why would they give up their best offensive player?
Paul Kuharsky: Not true. If it was true, why would the team be talking about it?
A top three running back is not worth a top 10 or 15 quarterback. Who’s trading a good quarterback for a good running back, when the rushing champ was undrafted and the good quarterbacks are almost all high picks?
Drew from Richmond, Va., writes: Any info on this DeMario Pressley? I mean from what I can put together he is essentially a second year player when it comes to playing time who has not proven that he is a playmaker much less a starter. The Colts already have six men listed at defensive tackle. Can we expect a few guys getting cut off that list, and how did this guy grab attention when there are bigger names on the market at that position? I agree that the Colts need to strengthen the run defense and start with the middle of the line but is this guy close to an answer?
Paul Kuharsky: I wouldn’t get excited about Houston’s toss-offs. Maybe he’s a serviceable, back-of-the-rotation guy.
Claiming a guy off waivers is a much cheaper and lower-risk option than signing Shaun Rogers or Tommie Harris or Marcus Stroud. They never said Pressley is a big answer. Such an addition means they think he’s worth bringing in and working with. He could easily be cut two weeks after coaches get to know him. Having him means nothing about their willingness to draft or look at a free agent later.
That said, don’t get caught up in big names. Did you know a lot about Antoine Bethea before they brought him in? Robert Mathis? Jerraud Powers?
Joe in Murfreesburo, Tenn., writes: Mel Kiper Jr. has the Titans taking a DE at #8 in the draft. I don't know if Mel remembers, but the Titans are fine at defensive end. They don't need to re-sign Jason Babin. In fact, they might be better off avoiding a big deal if it turns out he was just a one-year wonder. Derrick Morgan will be back, and he will be ready to go with Dave Ball OR Babin on the other side. Either way, they have much bigger needs than to draft another defensive end, when they will basically have a first-round rookie in Morgan next year. Talk some sense into the man Paul, we need a QB.
Paul Kuharsky: Of course they need a quarterback. But if they don’t like an option they have at No. 8, they’d be dumb to force it.
Babin, Ball and Ford are all en route to unrestricted free agency, they are all undersized and they all faded down the stretch. There is great defensive end talent high in this draft and the Titans have indicated they’d like to have more well-rounded, sturdy guys at the spot.
I’d have no problem with the Titans taking an end to go with Morgan and Hayes. A sustained pass rush that can defend the runs makes everyone better -- including a second-round quarterback.
Jarell from Atlanta by way of Gary, Ind., writes: I read a piece you linked the other day about the Colts free agents. I was shocked to realize how many of our guys are going to be up for free agency, who do you think we keep, specifically between Joseph Addai and Melvin Bullitt? I think Charlie Johnson is a talent, though not the best option at tackle, but the only option we have right now. And what about the tackles... Antonio Johnson came on last season at the end, and can be the reason why the rush defense fell behind while he was out in the playoffs. And Daniel Muir has become a staple in our community...what do you think?
Paul Kuharsky: Well first, I think being a staple in the community doesn’t mean much if you’re a middling player looking for a contract.
I don’t see them choosing between Addai and Bullitt and don’t know why you do.
Think they’d like to have Addai, Bullitt, Johnson, Johnson, Muir and Clint Session all back. They generally work hard to keep their own. I don’t think Addai, either Johnson or Muir draw a lot of interest from other teams. They are all tailored to the Colts, a team that works hard to keep core, valuable guys they drafted or brought in as rookies.
A quality O-line pickup could mean Charlie Johnson is moved to guard or sixth man. A quality defensive tackle in the draft or free agency could mean the end of Antonio Johnson or Muir.
Bullitt may be the toughest to retain because there is a lot of safety need around the league. The Texans and Jaguars would both be wise to chase him.
***
We’re Colts and Titans heavy, so I tweeted a request for Texans and Jaguars questions and did a rapid fire Twitter session. (I’m @ESPN_AFCSouth.)
@JoeDowntownVS2 so have the texans still decided safety dosent matters even after last year?
PK: Should have looked at available guys. But they still have draft and real free agency. If they don't act then, they're nuts.
@TheMizellGroup being that Garrard never seems to close out the season we know have consecutive seasons in the "L" are we drafting a QB
PK: Absolutely they'll look hard at a developmental QB.
@DustyGmoe With the signings yesterday from #Texans, can you tell where they will go in the first two rounds?
PK: Defense, defense, defense. OLB, FS, SS, CB and despite what they say, DT.
@baron_von_brad any other team make a play for Hawk?
PK: Don't think there was time and he may not have been interested knowing they were working on a new deal.
@HoustonDiehards is gerald sebsabaugh's history w/ Wade going to land him in Houston once free agency happens? Or are we counting on Nolan?
PK: Nolan in the mix. I hope they do better than Sensabaugh.
@tntitansfan10 how much long will Garrard be Jags QB?
PK: Five or six games if they aren't good ones.
@JasonEmbry With Texans' defensive changes, what does future hold for Okoye? And should Texans upgrade No. 2 WR?
PK: Will get a chance to play 3-4 end for Wade. I'd like to see another option at No. 2, though they invested in Walter.
@Hodari11 Does Rahean Mathis have any trade value?Trade now instead of getting nothing when he leavesWants alot more than he is worth
PK: It's not baseball, where you trade a vet for prospects before he's done. They need Mathis, too young in secondary without him.
@AnnaMegan Is getting a new deal for Vonta Leach a must for Texans?
PK: He was very good last year and I wouldn't mess with the formula. But FBs are generally replaceable.
@eggsngrits Not a #Texans fan, but I have to ask: Why would Arian Foster report to camp for a one-year $480k tender offer?
PK: Because he's under contract to do so. I think they'll try to reward him, but they get a financial reward for grabbing him.
@sumpteravada if we had had the social network we hve now n the 80s...wud Marino/Montana/Moon/Elway been held under the microscope?
PK: Their lives would have been different for sure.
***
Hate the contents of this mailbag? Change the next one by writing me here, via Twitter @ESPN_AFCSouth or via Facebook at Paul Kuharsky ESPN.
Palmer heads my list of QBs for Titans
January, 24, 2011
1/24/11
11:33
AM ET
By
Paul Kuharsky | ESPN.com
Cincinnati quarterback Carson Palmer is ready for a change of scenery.
The Titans are in need of a quarterback.
Scott Boehm/Getty ImagesCarson Palmer made the Pro Bowl in 2005 and 2006.I’d tossed out Palmer’s name after Tennessee announced it was finished with Vince Young, but once Marvin Lewis got a new contract from the Bengals and said Palmer was his guy, I backed down. Now I’ll jump on the idea again even as Mike Brown of the Bengals says they won't move the quarterback.
Palmer is no sure thing. He’s not been the same quarterback since the knee injury he suffered in the 2005 playoffs. An elbow problem that surfaced in 2008 has also been an issue.
If he’s physically OK, I would put him at the head of my wish list for the Titans. Jeff Fisher and offensive coordinator Mike Heimerdinger have long coveted a traditional dropback passer who can scan the full field.
Heimerdinger’s health is a question going forward; he’s battling cancer. But if quarterbacks coach Dowell Loggains returns or Fisher puts a coach in place who would assume Heimerdinger’s duties if needed, they’d be in line with a similar philosophy.
Those coaches would likely love to work with a healthy Palmer. His chances of rehabbing his career in Tennessee might be as good as anywhere.
If Tennessee’s offensive line gets back to form, it’s capable of providing time and protecting such a guy. If he’s handing off to Chris Johnson and throwing to the likes of Kenny Britt, Jared Cook, Nate Washington and Damian Williams, I believe the Titans would have a chance to be an effective offense and their bigger issue would be defensive repair.
I’m leaving Kevin Kolb off this list because I think he’ll simply be too expensive on the trade market, or maybe completely unavailable as the Eagles worry about Michael Vick making it through a full season.
Conventional wisdom says the Titans will both draft a quarterback and find a veteran.
Here’s my veteran wish list:
Two other names that could surface: Marc Bulger (Baltimore) and Shaun Hill (Detroit).
All the Titans need now is a new CBA that would allow for trade offers and free-agent movement.
The Titans are in need of a quarterback.
Scott Boehm/Getty ImagesCarson Palmer made the Pro Bowl in 2005 and 2006.Palmer is no sure thing. He’s not been the same quarterback since the knee injury he suffered in the 2005 playoffs. An elbow problem that surfaced in 2008 has also been an issue.
If he’s physically OK, I would put him at the head of my wish list for the Titans. Jeff Fisher and offensive coordinator Mike Heimerdinger have long coveted a traditional dropback passer who can scan the full field.
Heimerdinger’s health is a question going forward; he’s battling cancer. But if quarterbacks coach Dowell Loggains returns or Fisher puts a coach in place who would assume Heimerdinger’s duties if needed, they’d be in line with a similar philosophy.
Those coaches would likely love to work with a healthy Palmer. His chances of rehabbing his career in Tennessee might be as good as anywhere.
If Tennessee’s offensive line gets back to form, it’s capable of providing time and protecting such a guy. If he’s handing off to Chris Johnson and throwing to the likes of Kenny Britt, Jared Cook, Nate Washington and Damian Williams, I believe the Titans would have a chance to be an effective offense and their bigger issue would be defensive repair.
I’m leaving Kevin Kolb off this list because I think he’ll simply be too expensive on the trade market, or maybe completely unavailable as the Eagles worry about Michael Vick making it through a full season.
Conventional wisdom says the Titans will both draft a quarterback and find a veteran.
Here’s my veteran wish list:
- Palmer. Maybe I am leaning too much on my memories of him back when he was very good, but if the Titans had a chance to get him back to that form, I’d want to see it.
- Kyle Orton, Denver. He can really throw it. He’s the sort of hard worker and stand-up guy the Titans covet.
- Matt Flynn, Green Bay. The sample size is small, but the trade price might be more reasonable. There is always a Rob Johnson/Scott Mitchell issue, where you worry about getting a guy who flashed and it turned out to be just a flash.
- Matt Hasselbeck, Seattle. He's too prone to getting beat up, but he’d have better protection with a fixed Titans’ line and is another smart guy.
- Chad Pennington, Miami (free agent). His health is a question and he does not have a big arm. But he’s a guy who might give the Titans enough while a rookie is developed.
Two other names that could surface: Marc Bulger (Baltimore) and Shaun Hill (Detroit).
All the Titans need now is a new CBA that would allow for trade offers and free-agent movement.
Our politically correct culture spills over into the NFL for sure.
Once upon a time it was a place where players and coaches would rip on each other as they felt warranted. Now, people fear bulletin board material as much as they fear Mario Williams on third-and-long going against a rookie left tackle.
So I took note when Josh McDaniels did a little crying about Jeff Fisher and the Titans’ tactics this week, especially on the heels of a Broncos’ win in Nashville
From John Glennon’s article on the back-and-forth between the coaches:
The Giants talked about this too, this idea that the Titans somehow seek to induce penalties or response to physical play.
Doesn’t everybody? Shouldn’t everybody? If my guy gets your guy to commit a penalty, he’s getting a plus, not a minus on his report from the game.
Tennessee has too many penalties this season and needs to play cleaner games. The Titans aren’t good enough to give away yards and first downs.
But that’s not been a historic trait of Jeff Fisher teams. Do we think all of a sudden he decided coaching his team to be dirty is the way to go? That it’s a missing ingredient in his formula, one that will help him get back to the playoffs and do better there?
I don’t.
And while I fear anything that makes me seem an apologist for any AFC South team on any issue, Sen’Derrick Mark’s penalty for a hit on Kyle Orton wasn’t flag worthy. It’s a defender hitting a quarterback with the ball still in his hand in the thighs.
So I thought Fisher’s reply was pitch perfect:
"We play aggressive -- we don't play cheap," Fisher said. "If there's things after the whistle or during the play, players are fined for them. But we're not a cheap football team. I don't know what he's referring to.
"We did have six sacks against the quarterback and numerous other times they did have some difficulty with protection and blocking our defensive line. Maybe he's referring to that."
Once upon a time it was a place where players and coaches would rip on each other as they felt warranted. Now, people fear bulletin board material as much as they fear Mario Williams on third-and-long going against a rookie left tackle.
So I took note when Josh McDaniels did a little crying about Jeff Fisher and the Titans’ tactics this week, especially on the heels of a Broncos’ win in Nashville
From John Glennon’s article on the back-and-forth between the coaches:
“You can put in any tape you want to of Tennessee and there's going to be 10 penalties,” [McDaniels said.] “You either coach it or you allow it to happen. That's how I look at that.
"Our guys did a great job of keeping their poise and composure and not getting drawn into a big unsportsmanlike game because I know that's what they were trying to entice us into doing."
McDaniels said the Titans go beyond just being physical.
"There's a way to play tough and physical without being excessive and playing dirty after the snap," McDaniels said. "There's a lot of teams in this league that play like that. Tough and physical but also within the rules."
The Giants talked about this too, this idea that the Titans somehow seek to induce penalties or response to physical play.
Doesn’t everybody? Shouldn’t everybody? If my guy gets your guy to commit a penalty, he’s getting a plus, not a minus on his report from the game.
Tennessee has too many penalties this season and needs to play cleaner games. The Titans aren’t good enough to give away yards and first downs.
But that’s not been a historic trait of Jeff Fisher teams. Do we think all of a sudden he decided coaching his team to be dirty is the way to go? That it’s a missing ingredient in his formula, one that will help him get back to the playoffs and do better there?
I don’t.
And while I fear anything that makes me seem an apologist for any AFC South team on any issue, Sen’Derrick Mark’s penalty for a hit on Kyle Orton wasn’t flag worthy. It’s a defender hitting a quarterback with the ball still in his hand in the thighs.
So I thought Fisher’s reply was pitch perfect:
"We play aggressive -- we don't play cheap," Fisher said. "If there's things after the whistle or during the play, players are fined for them. But we're not a cheap football team. I don't know what he's referring to.
"We did have six sacks against the quarterback and numerous other times they did have some difficulty with protection and blocking our defensive line. Maybe he's referring to that."
» NFC Decisive Moments: East | West | North | South » AFC: East | West | North | South
The Titans had a four-point lead Sunday with two minutes left in the fourth quarter at LP Field. Broncos quarterback Kyle Orton lined up in the shotgun on second-and-25 from midfield.
Titans end William Hayes slid around Denver right tackle Ryan Harris and got both hands on Orton. But the quarterback slid to his right and moved up in the pocket. He pump-faked, then let the ball fly.
It was on target to Jabar Gaffney and safety Chris Hope wasn’t pursuing at an ideal angle. He never turned his head as Gaffney tried to come back to the ball, drawing a pass interference call that cost Tennessee 49 yards and set up the Broncos for the go-ahead touchdown.
It felt like the Titans were in control of the game before that play. If they could have stopped the Broncos from gaining 25 yards on the ensuing three plays it was going to be over. That’s a scenario anybody would take.
But Hayes and Hope failed them, Orton made the play and the Titans unraveled, losing 26-20.
The Titans had a four-point lead Sunday with two minutes left in the fourth quarter at LP Field. Broncos quarterback Kyle Orton lined up in the shotgun on second-and-25 from midfield.
Titans end William Hayes slid around Denver right tackle Ryan Harris and got both hands on Orton. But the quarterback slid to his right and moved up in the pocket. He pump-faked, then let the ball fly.
It was on target to Jabar Gaffney and safety Chris Hope wasn’t pursuing at an ideal angle. He never turned his head as Gaffney tried to come back to the ball, drawing a pass interference call that cost Tennessee 49 yards and set up the Broncos for the go-ahead touchdown.
It felt like the Titans were in control of the game before that play. If they could have stopped the Broncos from gaining 25 yards on the ensuing three plays it was going to be over. That’s a scenario anybody would take.
But Hayes and Hope failed them, Orton made the play and the Titans unraveled, losing 26-20.
Mailbag: Vince Young-free if you so desire
October, 2, 2010
10/02/10
11:11
AM ET
By
Paul Kuharsky | ESPN.com
Rick Alba Jr in Houston writes: I believe Bob McNair should open up his pocket book and pay his staff more to be there earlier. They give us only four hours before kickoff to tailgate and party, unlike Washington where I was for the Week 2 game the game started at 4:15 and we were out in the parking lot BBG at 8 am. I guess what I’m trying to say is just open up earlier around 6 am it would ease the traffic so much easier and I can almost guarantee their wouldn’t be as bad as it has been in the past.
Paul Kuharsky: I’ll give you some volume on this by including you here.
If opening earlier solves even a bit of this, they should open earlier.
I do think they are in a bit of a tough spot. Any business wants to make its customers happy before considering other people who will come to the store but not make a purchase, so to speak.
Zack Hensley in Pensacola, Fla., writes: Just in case you're in need of some affirmation of your abilities as a professional sports writer today, I wanted to drop a line to let you know that your interview with Bill Polian is probably the best work of yours I have read to date. Particularly, your questions on specific players on the O-line, D-line, and LB corps really got to the heart of some things I have been curious about. Thanks. Keep up the good work.
Paul Kuharsky: Nice of you to say, I appreciate it. I think, though, anyone who follows the Colts and gets 15 minutes with Polian is going to get stuff that Colts’ faithful find very interesting.
Michael Harley in Nashville, Tenn., writes: The mediocre performance of the Titans passing game is a constant topic of conversation around my parts. A reoccurring theory is that Mike Heimerdinger's offense is too complicated for the players the Titans have. As recently as the Steeler game, you hear comments from the coaches to the effect of "we opened up the playbook too much." Is Dinger's offensive scheme (passing) really so complicated that our players can't understand it or execute it very effectively? We just can't understand why we don't take advantage of the fact that teams are stacking the line in order to stop CJ, but we seem to be unable to take advantage of that with our passing game. What are your thoughts?
Paul Kuharsky: While he can campaign for and dream about pieces that fit what he wants to do, Dinger is obligated to tailor the offense to what he has during the season. Generally, he’s done a good job of that.
The passing game needs to be better against those fronts. But keep in mind the game we’re having this conversation after a 19-point win.
Jeremy Lambert in Winston-Salem, N.C., writes: Please tell me I'm not wrong to be completely petrified about the Colts' defense, particularly the pass defense. This is the second year for Larry Coyer, so I thought going into this season that this would be the best defense Peyton Manning ever had, that this year Manning wouldn't have to carry a team on his back and yet still get all of the blame himself when the team comes up short in the postseason. I realize it's only three games, and that there is a plenty of time to make adjustments. But over 300 yards in a game through the air? From Kyle Orton?!?! No disrespect to Kyle Orton but....
Paul Kuharsky: Indy’s defense has not been as good as I expected either. But the Colts have had some injuries and are still settling in. We need to see a little more before judging. And if they can hold a team to six points in five red zone trips on a “bad” defensive day, they could be just fine.
For those uninterested in any further discussion of Vince Young, your mailbag has concluded. Good day.
For those still interested in the discussion, please continue …
Edgar Hernandez in Austin, Texas, writes: I really, really loved your reporting when you did the video on punt returners. Please do more of that and less of "Hey, Bud: We know you like to proclaim ‘VY is my guy’ Since it rhymes and all. Did you call Vince Young last week to tell him to get to work like an NFL starting quarterback?" If you don't think VY works like a NFL starting QB you should be a man and ask Jeff Fisher if he agrees with you. Vince is being criticized for missing a meeting while taking Steve McNair's kids to a fathers’ breakfast and for being late to one other meeting. That's pathetic. Especially when you consider that the Steelers have been stellar on defense these first three games. As a fan of your reporting I just wanted to give you my opinion regardless of how bias I'm being. Hope you have a nice week.
Paul Kuharsky: My job is to do a mix of all kind of things, including the ones you mention.
I don’t generally waste public questions when I know that public answers will be, and that doesn’t mean I am not a man that means spin is a waste of time. And I don’t particularly want to do the work for the local TV sports reporters, who eat that stuff up.
Fisher’s not going to criticize his quarterback in public because he knows it would hurt the quarterback’s fragile confidence. Heck, he never criticized McNair who was at the complete opposite end of the toughness spectrum.
Don’t you think there might be behind-the-scenes conversations with key people on big issues that factor into, contribute to, or temper stances of people with roles like mine?
Also, we’re not including the meeting Young was excused for in this discussion. It’s been very difficult for Young apologists to grasp this. No one has written Young should have been at that meeting the morning of the breakfast for which he was excused. He was quite late returning from it. And then he missed a meeting later in the week. That’s two things, not one. Why are you so eager to dismiss them? Did you think he looked like a prepared quarterback against Pittsburgh?
Edgar Hernandez, Austin, Texas writes: Hey Paul, why didn't you ask Fisher if Vince was benched for missing/being late to a meeting after pressing him so hard about it today. You seemed very, very, very very concerned about it. You sounded so confident in stating your question as fact about him missing/being late to a meeting causing his benching. As a media member shouldn't you and Wyatt be reporting facts and not something that's ambiguous, like he was "late/missed" a meeting. Are you trying to create a controversy where Fisher has clearly stated there isn't one? As a fan of the Titans the ambiguous statements are really what bothers me. I know you're not a fan of VY, but everything you write about him has a negative undertone. It almost seems personal.
Paul Kuharsky: It’s not personal.
Young either lied or cannot connect the dots. You can choose. He was late for one meeting last week and missed another. (How is that ambigous?) Then, as a result, he got benched during a bad game.
He knew he’d been late and missed the meetings. He was told the team didn’t like his preparations. It’s not a hard connection to see that’s why he was benched. So when he said he didn’t know why he was benched, was he telling the truth?
Lawrence Embry from Fort Worth, Texas, writes: Hey, what's your deal with Vince Young? I get the feeling you give him negative press because you don't like the idea of black guys playing quarterback.
Paul Kuharsky: Nope, I write critical things about him because he’s not very good.
In the division I cover, Manning is spectacular, Matt Schaub is quite good, Young is flaky and inconsistent and David Garrard is on his way out. That’s just how they rate.
Paul Kuharsky: I’ll give you some volume on this by including you here.
If opening earlier solves even a bit of this, they should open earlier.
I do think they are in a bit of a tough spot. Any business wants to make its customers happy before considering other people who will come to the store but not make a purchase, so to speak.
Zack Hensley in Pensacola, Fla., writes: Just in case you're in need of some affirmation of your abilities as a professional sports writer today, I wanted to drop a line to let you know that your interview with Bill Polian is probably the best work of yours I have read to date. Particularly, your questions on specific players on the O-line, D-line, and LB corps really got to the heart of some things I have been curious about. Thanks. Keep up the good work.
Paul Kuharsky: Nice of you to say, I appreciate it. I think, though, anyone who follows the Colts and gets 15 minutes with Polian is going to get stuff that Colts’ faithful find very interesting.
Michael Harley in Nashville, Tenn., writes: The mediocre performance of the Titans passing game is a constant topic of conversation around my parts. A reoccurring theory is that Mike Heimerdinger's offense is too complicated for the players the Titans have. As recently as the Steeler game, you hear comments from the coaches to the effect of "we opened up the playbook too much." Is Dinger's offensive scheme (passing) really so complicated that our players can't understand it or execute it very effectively? We just can't understand why we don't take advantage of the fact that teams are stacking the line in order to stop CJ, but we seem to be unable to take advantage of that with our passing game. What are your thoughts?
Paul Kuharsky: While he can campaign for and dream about pieces that fit what he wants to do, Dinger is obligated to tailor the offense to what he has during the season. Generally, he’s done a good job of that.
The passing game needs to be better against those fronts. But keep in mind the game we’re having this conversation after a 19-point win.
Jeremy Lambert in Winston-Salem, N.C., writes: Please tell me I'm not wrong to be completely petrified about the Colts' defense, particularly the pass defense. This is the second year for Larry Coyer, so I thought going into this season that this would be the best defense Peyton Manning ever had, that this year Manning wouldn't have to carry a team on his back and yet still get all of the blame himself when the team comes up short in the postseason. I realize it's only three games, and that there is a plenty of time to make adjustments. But over 300 yards in a game through the air? From Kyle Orton?!?! No disrespect to Kyle Orton but....
Paul Kuharsky: Indy’s defense has not been as good as I expected either. But the Colts have had some injuries and are still settling in. We need to see a little more before judging. And if they can hold a team to six points in five red zone trips on a “bad” defensive day, they could be just fine.
For those uninterested in any further discussion of Vince Young, your mailbag has concluded. Good day.
For those still interested in the discussion, please continue …
Edgar Hernandez in Austin, Texas, writes: I really, really loved your reporting when you did the video on punt returners. Please do more of that and less of "Hey, Bud: We know you like to proclaim ‘VY is my guy’ Since it rhymes and all. Did you call Vince Young last week to tell him to get to work like an NFL starting quarterback?" If you don't think VY works like a NFL starting QB you should be a man and ask Jeff Fisher if he agrees with you. Vince is being criticized for missing a meeting while taking Steve McNair's kids to a fathers’ breakfast and for being late to one other meeting. That's pathetic. Especially when you consider that the Steelers have been stellar on defense these first three games. As a fan of your reporting I just wanted to give you my opinion regardless of how bias I'm being. Hope you have a nice week.
Paul Kuharsky: My job is to do a mix of all kind of things, including the ones you mention.
I don’t generally waste public questions when I know that public answers will be, and that doesn’t mean I am not a man that means spin is a waste of time. And I don’t particularly want to do the work for the local TV sports reporters, who eat that stuff up.
Fisher’s not going to criticize his quarterback in public because he knows it would hurt the quarterback’s fragile confidence. Heck, he never criticized McNair who was at the complete opposite end of the toughness spectrum.
Don’t you think there might be behind-the-scenes conversations with key people on big issues that factor into, contribute to, or temper stances of people with roles like mine?
Also, we’re not including the meeting Young was excused for in this discussion. It’s been very difficult for Young apologists to grasp this. No one has written Young should have been at that meeting the morning of the breakfast for which he was excused. He was quite late returning from it. And then he missed a meeting later in the week. That’s two things, not one. Why are you so eager to dismiss them? Did you think he looked like a prepared quarterback against Pittsburgh?
Edgar Hernandez, Austin, Texas writes: Hey Paul, why didn't you ask Fisher if Vince was benched for missing/being late to a meeting after pressing him so hard about it today. You seemed very, very, very very concerned about it. You sounded so confident in stating your question as fact about him missing/being late to a meeting causing his benching. As a media member shouldn't you and Wyatt be reporting facts and not something that's ambiguous, like he was "late/missed" a meeting. Are you trying to create a controversy where Fisher has clearly stated there isn't one? As a fan of the Titans the ambiguous statements are really what bothers me. I know you're not a fan of VY, but everything you write about him has a negative undertone. It almost seems personal.
Paul Kuharsky: It’s not personal.
Young either lied or cannot connect the dots. You can choose. He was late for one meeting last week and missed another. (How is that ambigous?) Then, as a result, he got benched during a bad game.
He knew he’d been late and missed the meetings. He was told the team didn’t like his preparations. It’s not a hard connection to see that’s why he was benched. So when he said he didn’t know why he was benched, was he telling the truth?
Lawrence Embry from Fort Worth, Texas, writes: Hey, what's your deal with Vince Young? I get the feeling you give him negative press because you don't like the idea of black guys playing quarterback.
Paul Kuharsky: Nope, I write critical things about him because he’s not very good.
In the division I cover, Manning is spectacular, Matt Schaub is quite good, Young is flaky and inconsistent and David Garrard is on his way out. That’s just how they rate.
RTC: New low for Jack Del Rio era
September, 27, 2010
9/27/10
10:28
AM ET
By
Paul Kuharsky | ESPN.com
Reading the coverage…
Houston Texans
Houston was outplayed in every phase, writes John McClain.
Gary Kubiak may have seen this one coming, says Richard Justice.
The Texans allowed too much pressure on Matt Schaub, says Jeffrey Martin.
Andre Johnson said he re-aggravated his ankle sprain, say McClain and Jenny Dial.
McClain’s report card.
The Texans should have been as desperate as the Cowboys, says Jerome Solomon.
It takes the worst to bring out the best in the Cowboys, says Alex Marvez.
The Cowboys exposed the Texans’ flaws, says John P. Lopez.
Tony Romo is in a higher class than Matt Schaub, says Andrew Perloff.
Battle Red Blog is unhappy with Eugene Wilson and Frank Bush.
Indianapolis Colts
They gave up yards in bunches, but the Colts won anyway, says Phil Richards.
The Colts showed off their depth at receiver with a huge day from Austin Collie and a nice contribution from Blair White, says Mike Chappell.
Peyton Manning continues to raise the bar, writes Bob Kravitz.
Preparation paid off in a big interception for Jacob Lacey, says Chappell.
Despite a patchwork line, Kyle Orton had huge numbers against the Colts, says Richards.
Kravitz’s report card.
The Colts showed they are more experienced and more savvy, says John Oehser.
Mike Silver details how Manning took Blair White up on a suggestion.
Observations on a well-coached team, from Nate Dunlevy.
He was wrong about Collie, says Nate Dunlevy.
Smart and efficient football won it, says Stampede Blue.
Jacksonville Jaguars
It’s a 1-2 start for the third consecutive season after a blowout loss to the Eagles, says Vito Stellino.
Gene Frenette declares this a new low for the Jack Del Rio era.
The Eagles abused Jacksonville’s beleaguered offensive line, says Tania Ganguli.
David Garrard can’t explain a horrible game, says Jeff Elliott.
The Jaguars are allowing far too many deep balls, says Ganguli.
Garrard played with trepidation and didn’t look athletic, says Vic Ketchman.
The notion that an upgraded pass rush would fix it all was off, says Ketchman.
Considering the possibilities with Terry O’Brien.
Tennessee Titans
The Titans rebounded with a big win against the Giants, say Jim Wyatt.
Take-aways keyed the Titans’ win, says John Glennon.
A chop-block penalty against the Giants that gave the Titans a safety turned the momentum, says Glennon.
Kenny Britt had a big touchdown catch in a homecoming, says Wyatt and Glennon.
Vince Young bounced back nicely, says David Climer. (My take on new stuff about Young’s Pittsburgh week is here.)
That was beyond humiliating for the Giants, says Mike Freeman.
The Titans are still a defensive team, says Bob McClellan.
Cortland Finnegan thinks he’s targeted by officials, says Terry McCormick.
The Titans enjoyed a reunion with Keith Bulluck, says McCormick.
Alterraun Verner filled in for Jason McCourty after he suffered an arm injury, says Darren McFarland.
Houston Texans
Houston was outplayed in every phase, writes John McClain.
Gary Kubiak may have seen this one coming, says Richard Justice.
The Texans allowed too much pressure on Matt Schaub, says Jeffrey Martin.
Andre Johnson said he re-aggravated his ankle sprain, say McClain and Jenny Dial.
McClain’s report card.
The Texans should have been as desperate as the Cowboys, says Jerome Solomon.
It takes the worst to bring out the best in the Cowboys, says Alex Marvez.
The Cowboys exposed the Texans’ flaws, says John P. Lopez.
Tony Romo is in a higher class than Matt Schaub, says Andrew Perloff.
Battle Red Blog is unhappy with Eugene Wilson and Frank Bush.
Indianapolis Colts
They gave up yards in bunches, but the Colts won anyway, says Phil Richards.
The Colts showed off their depth at receiver with a huge day from Austin Collie and a nice contribution from Blair White, says Mike Chappell.
Peyton Manning continues to raise the bar, writes Bob Kravitz.
Preparation paid off in a big interception for Jacob Lacey, says Chappell.
Despite a patchwork line, Kyle Orton had huge numbers against the Colts, says Richards.
Kravitz’s report card.
The Colts showed they are more experienced and more savvy, says John Oehser.
Mike Silver details how Manning took Blair White up on a suggestion.
Observations on a well-coached team, from Nate Dunlevy.
He was wrong about Collie, says Nate Dunlevy.
Smart and efficient football won it, says Stampede Blue.
Jacksonville Jaguars
It’s a 1-2 start for the third consecutive season after a blowout loss to the Eagles, says Vito Stellino.
Gene Frenette declares this a new low for the Jack Del Rio era.
The Eagles abused Jacksonville’s beleaguered offensive line, says Tania Ganguli.
David Garrard can’t explain a horrible game, says Jeff Elliott.
The Jaguars are allowing far too many deep balls, says Ganguli.
Garrard played with trepidation and didn’t look athletic, says Vic Ketchman.
The notion that an upgraded pass rush would fix it all was off, says Ketchman.
Considering the possibilities with Terry O’Brien.
Tennessee Titans
The Titans rebounded with a big win against the Giants, say Jim Wyatt.
Take-aways keyed the Titans’ win, says John Glennon.
A chop-block penalty against the Giants that gave the Titans a safety turned the momentum, says Glennon.
Kenny Britt had a big touchdown catch in a homecoming, says Wyatt and Glennon.
Vince Young bounced back nicely, says David Climer. (My take on new stuff about Young’s Pittsburgh week is here.)
That was beyond humiliating for the Giants, says Mike Freeman.
The Titans are still a defensive team, says Bob McClellan.
Cortland Finnegan thinks he’s targeted by officials, says Terry McCormick.
The Titans enjoyed a reunion with Keith Bulluck, says McCormick.
Alterraun Verner filled in for Jason McCourty after he suffered an arm injury, says Darren McFarland.
What I think they’re thinking at the four team headquarters in the AFC South ...
Houston Texans
We’re going to be pretty good.
Our guys will hear a lot of talk about how we can’t beat the Indianapolis Colts this weekend. We need to strike a delicate balance. Our guys need to know we can beat them and they have to see the confidence of the coaches in the plan to do so. But they also can’t put too much on it. If this is our Super Bowl and we should lose it, we can’t leave ourselves in position where it’s too difficult to say afterward that it was just one of 16. The bandwagon adds passengers with a win, loses many with a loss. If we lose, let’s just make sure we don’t give it to them.
Indianapolis Colts
We’re going to be pretty good.
Sure, a game in Houston to start isn’t an easy task. But if we do our thing and worry very little about them, it should turn out fine. There is a major psychological upper hand here, and we don’t intend to surrender even a morsel of it. We’ve got three beat-up guys on the offensive line in Jeff Saturday, Charlie Johnson and Tony Ugoh, so we won’t know who’s going to be blocking for Peyton Manning and Joseph Addai until just before kickoff. No matter for us. The big plays at the big moments will come from our guys.
Jacksonville Jaguars
We’re going to be pretty good.
There will be a lot of hype about Tim Tebow’s homecoming this week and we expect to see him in the game in a few touchdown-scoring situations. If that storyline angers us, so be it. We just have to be sure to channel that anger in a way that will benefit us. Our defensive front is rebuilt, their line is overrated. Let’s hit Kyle Orton the way we failed to hit quarterbacks last year. Let’s hit him in a way where he won’t have the time to try to go after our weak safeties. And after all the concern about Maurice Jones-Drew, let’s do all we can for him to have a big day.
Tennessee Titans
We’re going to be pretty good.
The Raiders are no soft spot. Their defense is better; good enough to cause us problems. And who knows how their offense has transformed with Jason Campbell, a semi-capable quarterback, taking snaps? We’ll look to do our thing, which means a steady diet of Chris Johnson on offense and a big effort from the defensive front to get Campbell out of sync. If we get those two things, and we always think we will, we'll be in good shape. While Colts at Texans gets the division’s biggest billing and Tebow is a story in Jacksonville, we’ll quietly move to 1-0.
Houston Texans
We’re going to be pretty good.
Our guys will hear a lot of talk about how we can’t beat the Indianapolis Colts this weekend. We need to strike a delicate balance. Our guys need to know we can beat them and they have to see the confidence of the coaches in the plan to do so. But they also can’t put too much on it. If this is our Super Bowl and we should lose it, we can’t leave ourselves in position where it’s too difficult to say afterward that it was just one of 16. The bandwagon adds passengers with a win, loses many with a loss. If we lose, let’s just make sure we don’t give it to them.
Indianapolis Colts
We’re going to be pretty good.
Sure, a game in Houston to start isn’t an easy task. But if we do our thing and worry very little about them, it should turn out fine. There is a major psychological upper hand here, and we don’t intend to surrender even a morsel of it. We’ve got three beat-up guys on the offensive line in Jeff Saturday, Charlie Johnson and Tony Ugoh, so we won’t know who’s going to be blocking for Peyton Manning and Joseph Addai until just before kickoff. No matter for us. The big plays at the big moments will come from our guys.
Jacksonville Jaguars
We’re going to be pretty good.
There will be a lot of hype about Tim Tebow’s homecoming this week and we expect to see him in the game in a few touchdown-scoring situations. If that storyline angers us, so be it. We just have to be sure to channel that anger in a way that will benefit us. Our defensive front is rebuilt, their line is overrated. Let’s hit Kyle Orton the way we failed to hit quarterbacks last year. Let’s hit him in a way where he won’t have the time to try to go after our weak safeties. And after all the concern about Maurice Jones-Drew, let’s do all we can for him to have a big day.
Tennessee Titans
We’re going to be pretty good.
The Raiders are no soft spot. Their defense is better; good enough to cause us problems. And who knows how their offense has transformed with Jason Campbell, a semi-capable quarterback, taking snaps? We’ll look to do our thing, which means a steady diet of Chris Johnson on offense and a big effort from the defensive front to get Campbell out of sync. If we get those two things, and we always think we will, we'll be in good shape. While Colts at Texans gets the division’s biggest billing and Tebow is a story in Jacksonville, we’ll quietly move to 1-0.
» NFC Final Word: East | West | North | South » AFC: East | West | North | South
Five nuggets of knowledge about Week 11:
AP Photo/Wade PayneIt is difficult to argue with Vince Young's winning record.
VY is just winning. Quick, name the top five winning quarterbacks drafted since 2000. They are Tom Brady (.775), Ben Roethlisberger (.713), Philip Rivers (.684), Vince Young (.653) and Kyle Orton (.643). I’ve certainly been critical of Young, but it’s hard to argue with his effectiveness in the most important category for anyone, wins. He’s from Houston, and there will be plenty of Titans and Texans No. 10 jerseys in the Reliant Stadium stands.
MJD can make a big mark. Against the league’s worst run defense, Maurice Jones-Drew has a chance to make personal and team history. He needs three rushing touchdowns to pass Fred Taylor’s team record of 14 set in 1998 and 140 rushing yards to get to 1,000 for the first time in his career. Take that, anyone who questioned whether he could handle the featured role when the team decided to let Taylor go.
The Colts are streaking. They are seeking a 19th consecutive regular-season win and would surpass the 2003-04 Patriots for the second-longest such streak in history. They’ve also won seven in a row against the Ravens. In the past six of those games, Peyton Manning has completed 64.1 percent of his passes for 1,477 yards with 11 touchdowns and three picks. Baltimore’s aggressive by nature, and that’s not typically the best defensive approach against Manning.
Can the Texans target Michael Griffin? The Titans' free safety struggled in the first game and has regressed this season. There will be a cornerback involved, of course, but Houston should do all it can to get Andre Johnson into situations in the secondary that involve Griffin. He’s bitten on too much play-action this season and it’s hard to figure why he worries at all about the run when there are so many defenders between him and the ball carrier.
Houston and Jacksonville can prove themselves contenders. The Colts are going to win the AFC South. The only question is how the other three teams line up and whether one of them wins a wild-card berth. The Texans and Jaguars are both 5-4 and the difference between 6-4 and 5-5 is giant. A Jacksonville win over Buffalo would mean the Jaguars top last season’s win total. A Houston win over Tennessee would put the team two games over .500 the latest in a season since the team came into existence.
Five nuggets of knowledge about Week 11:
AP Photo/Wade PayneIt is difficult to argue with Vince Young's winning record.MJD can make a big mark. Against the league’s worst run defense, Maurice Jones-Drew has a chance to make personal and team history. He needs three rushing touchdowns to pass Fred Taylor’s team record of 14 set in 1998 and 140 rushing yards to get to 1,000 for the first time in his career. Take that, anyone who questioned whether he could handle the featured role when the team decided to let Taylor go.
The Colts are streaking. They are seeking a 19th consecutive regular-season win and would surpass the 2003-04 Patriots for the second-longest such streak in history. They’ve also won seven in a row against the Ravens. In the past six of those games, Peyton Manning has completed 64.1 percent of his passes for 1,477 yards with 11 touchdowns and three picks. Baltimore’s aggressive by nature, and that’s not typically the best defensive approach against Manning.
Can the Texans target Michael Griffin? The Titans' free safety struggled in the first game and has regressed this season. There will be a cornerback involved, of course, but Houston should do all it can to get Andre Johnson into situations in the secondary that involve Griffin. He’s bitten on too much play-action this season and it’s hard to figure why he worries at all about the run when there are so many defenders between him and the ball carrier.
Houston and Jacksonville can prove themselves contenders. The Colts are going to win the AFC South. The only question is how the other three teams line up and whether one of them wins a wild-card berth. The Texans and Jaguars are both 5-4 and the difference between 6-4 and 5-5 is giant. A Jacksonville win over Buffalo would mean the Jaguars top last season’s win total. A Houston win over Tennessee would put the team two games over .500 the latest in a season since the team came into existence.
BACK TO TOP
Page: 1
ABOUT THIS BLOG
Paul Kuharsky
Kuharsky joined ESPN.com in 2008 after 12 years covering the Oilers/Titans and the NFL for The (Nashville) Tennessean. The New Jersey native and Columbia graduate lives in Nashville with his wife and son.
