AFC South: Randy Moss
Mailbag: Why Mario will get paid big bucks
March, 3, 2012
Mar 3
10:12
AM ET
By
Paul Kuharsky | ESPN.com
Trace in Jacksonville, Fla., writes: I keep seeing all these things about making Mario Williams the "highest paid defensive end in NFL history." Why is this? I mean, he's definitely good, but he's coming off an injury, and he's not even the best DE in the league, much less "in NFL history."
Paul Kuharsky: Not just the highest-paid defensive end in league history, but the highest-paid defender in league history.
It isn’t about being the best defender in league history. It will be the product of several things: He’d be the most impactful defensive free agent coming available. Such commodities can rarely be had for just money. Prices go up each year and the best guy in each, more expensive year, has a chance to get near the top. Williams' physical skill set and body are ridiculous. Pass-rushers may be at an all-time high in value -- it’s such a quarterback league that flustering the quarterback is the next most important thing to having a quality QB.
It’s also not about what he’s done, it’s about what he will be expected to do.
And the next time a top pass-rusher comes available, Williams will become the highest-paid in history. A lot of it is dumb luck on the timing and coming free.
Kevin in Richmond writes: Will the Titans still be eligible for a compensatory draft pick if Randy Moss is signed by another team or does his retirement negate that?
Paul Kuharsky: While the compensatory draft pick formula is complicated and secret, it’s intended for a team to be compensated if the free agent losses it suffered outweigh the free agent gains it made.
What loss did the Titans suffer with Randy Moss? They let a guy they didn’t play reach free agency, and he wasn’t signed elsewhere. I can’t imagine he factors into the compensatory draft pick formula on their behalf.
Ryan in Omaha writes: I read up on that article about Josh Scobee possible on the franchise candidacy for Jax and I can't see that as making any sense at all! Can you explain the logic of throwing 2 million dollars to an upper echelon kicker for a year when we could tag Jeremy Mincey or more likely Dwight Lowery for a year and get a lot more bang for that buck, am I right?
Paul Kuharsky: Two million isn’t a lot in relative terms. I don’t see how you can complain about spending $2 million on Scobee and say you’d rather spend $10.6 million on Mincey. Mincey is not worth close to that. Lowery is good and needs to be re-signed. But $6.2 million seems pretty high for him too.
Tony in Austin, Texas, writes: I agree with your assessment that Titans Safety Griffin has been inconsistent and underperforming. But to upgrade, they need someone better to replace him. Do you see any F.A. candidates? Their draft position doesn't lend itself to picking up either of the top 2 safeties without reaching. I think they need to Tag Griffin, no?
Paul Kuharsky: Well two upgrade candidates have disappeared. SF’s Dashon Goldson and Oakland's Tyvon Branch have been tagged. Washington’s LaRon Landry and Jacksonville’s Lowery may still hit the market.
Even if you don’t get one of them: Do you pay Griffin $6 million out of some sort of fear? You don’t think they can find a safety who can play as poorly for say, $3 million?
Kyle in Kihei, Hawaii, writes: Are there NFL rules prohibiting teams from loaning players to other teams? If Peyton is healthy, why not keep him for a couple more years and loan Luck to the Redskins for cash considerations. I can't get Schefter or @JimIrsay to pay attention to me (although the Rams and Eagles scouts said this was a creative idea) so forward this to the Colts brass so they can at least get it rejected by the competition committee themselves.
Paul Kuharsky: What would the Redskins gain by borrowing Luck? They could develop him to hand him back to the Colts only to have a gaping hole at the spot, again?
What would the Colts gain by lending Luck (beside borrowed time for Manning)? A team isn’t going to hand a guy of such value over to a rival to train in different methods, to get hurt in a different stadium, etc.
Can you imagine the Colts playing the Redskins and setting their own pass-rushers free on their loaned-away franchise quarterback?
It works for some international soccer clubs, not for the NFL.
Mr. Marsh in Dallas writes: Wow, I originally thought this was a comparison article. The column started out discussing RG3 and Luck and their interview performances. But somehow it ended up being an propaganda piece for Luck. One more example of why more diversity is needed within the media.
Paul Kuharsky: I presume you are talking about this piece, though you did not specify.
I don’t really get how diversity is at question when I am writing from my point of view and what I believe will be the Colts’ point of view. Luck is better. I believe so. Every scout and coach I have talked to believes so. The Colts are going to draft him, which more than suggests they believe so.
I don’t know why I would pretend otherwise. Writing well of the best guy is now propaganda, huh?
Joe in Louisiana writes: I seen one story about a month ago about Titans fans trying to advertise for Peyton to come back to Tennessee.... is this talk a dead trend or is there still a chance he could come and be a Titan in the state where he had so much success?
Paul Kuharsky: I don’t really understand the state part of it. Surely he could have success in Washington or Florida as easily as in Tennessee, no? I don’t see geography playing any role in linking the previous and future success.
Some fans have pushed for it. The Titans have made it clear it’s not going to happen.
Paul Kuharsky: Not just the highest-paid defensive end in league history, but the highest-paid defender in league history.
It isn’t about being the best defender in league history. It will be the product of several things: He’d be the most impactful defensive free agent coming available. Such commodities can rarely be had for just money. Prices go up each year and the best guy in each, more expensive year, has a chance to get near the top. Williams' physical skill set and body are ridiculous. Pass-rushers may be at an all-time high in value -- it’s such a quarterback league that flustering the quarterback is the next most important thing to having a quality QB.
It’s also not about what he’s done, it’s about what he will be expected to do.
And the next time a top pass-rusher comes available, Williams will become the highest-paid in history. A lot of it is dumb luck on the timing and coming free.
Kevin in Richmond writes: Will the Titans still be eligible for a compensatory draft pick if Randy Moss is signed by another team or does his retirement negate that?
Paul Kuharsky: While the compensatory draft pick formula is complicated and secret, it’s intended for a team to be compensated if the free agent losses it suffered outweigh the free agent gains it made.
What loss did the Titans suffer with Randy Moss? They let a guy they didn’t play reach free agency, and he wasn’t signed elsewhere. I can’t imagine he factors into the compensatory draft pick formula on their behalf.
Ryan in Omaha writes: I read up on that article about Josh Scobee possible on the franchise candidacy for Jax and I can't see that as making any sense at all! Can you explain the logic of throwing 2 million dollars to an upper echelon kicker for a year when we could tag Jeremy Mincey or more likely Dwight Lowery for a year and get a lot more bang for that buck, am I right?
Paul Kuharsky: Two million isn’t a lot in relative terms. I don’t see how you can complain about spending $2 million on Scobee and say you’d rather spend $10.6 million on Mincey. Mincey is not worth close to that. Lowery is good and needs to be re-signed. But $6.2 million seems pretty high for him too.
Tony in Austin, Texas, writes: I agree with your assessment that Titans Safety Griffin has been inconsistent and underperforming. But to upgrade, they need someone better to replace him. Do you see any F.A. candidates? Their draft position doesn't lend itself to picking up either of the top 2 safeties without reaching. I think they need to Tag Griffin, no?
Paul Kuharsky: Well two upgrade candidates have disappeared. SF’s Dashon Goldson and Oakland's Tyvon Branch have been tagged. Washington’s LaRon Landry and Jacksonville’s Lowery may still hit the market.
Even if you don’t get one of them: Do you pay Griffin $6 million out of some sort of fear? You don’t think they can find a safety who can play as poorly for say, $3 million?
Kyle in Kihei, Hawaii, writes: Are there NFL rules prohibiting teams from loaning players to other teams? If Peyton is healthy, why not keep him for a couple more years and loan Luck to the Redskins for cash considerations. I can't get Schefter or @JimIrsay to pay attention to me (although the Rams and Eagles scouts said this was a creative idea) so forward this to the Colts brass so they can at least get it rejected by the competition committee themselves.
Paul Kuharsky: What would the Redskins gain by borrowing Luck? They could develop him to hand him back to the Colts only to have a gaping hole at the spot, again?
What would the Colts gain by lending Luck (beside borrowed time for Manning)? A team isn’t going to hand a guy of such value over to a rival to train in different methods, to get hurt in a different stadium, etc.
Can you imagine the Colts playing the Redskins and setting their own pass-rushers free on their loaned-away franchise quarterback?
It works for some international soccer clubs, not for the NFL.
Mr. Marsh in Dallas writes: Wow, I originally thought this was a comparison article. The column started out discussing RG3 and Luck and their interview performances. But somehow it ended up being an propaganda piece for Luck. One more example of why more diversity is needed within the media.
Paul Kuharsky: I presume you are talking about this piece, though you did not specify.
I don’t really get how diversity is at question when I am writing from my point of view and what I believe will be the Colts’ point of view. Luck is better. I believe so. Every scout and coach I have talked to believes so. The Colts are going to draft him, which more than suggests they believe so.
I don’t know why I would pretend otherwise. Writing well of the best guy is now propaganda, huh?
Joe in Louisiana writes: I seen one story about a month ago about Titans fans trying to advertise for Peyton to come back to Tennessee.... is this talk a dead trend or is there still a chance he could come and be a Titan in the state where he had so much success?
Paul Kuharsky: I don’t really understand the state part of it. Surely he could have success in Washington or Florida as easily as in Tennessee, no? I don’t see geography playing any role in linking the previous and future success.
Some fans have pushed for it. The Titans have made it clear it’s not going to happen.
Reading the coverage ...
Houston Texans
Shaun Cody’s wrap-up episode of “On the Nose” features a turn to song. While amusing, it’s also somewhat difficult to listen to, so brace yourself. It's very cool that he invested the time and energy he did in these videos all season long. They really gave a lot of Texans a chance to show off a different side of their personalities and gave us a hint about the team's camaraderie.
Indianapolis Colts
Phillip B. Wilson of the Indianapolis Star hopes Jim Irsay won’t say another public word until Peyton Manning’s farewell news conference.
Irsay is desperate for a way to get rid of Peyton Manning without losing paying customers, says Greg Couch of FoxSports.com. (Hat tip to Bob Kravitz on Twitter.)
Jacksonville Jaguars
GM Gene Smith is accumulating opinions, says John Oehser of the Jaguars' team website.
Tony Boselli is pumping up the passion of the Jaguars’ fan base, says Oehser.
Tennessee Titans
John Glennon of The Tennessean writes that Mike Munchak sees Jason Jones playing outside and inside if he re-signs. While Jones can be a swing guy, I think Munchak overemphasizes Jones as both an end and a tackle. Jones played nearly twice as much at end as at tackle last season. The Titans would be best served to admit a mistake and play him inside if they are able to sign him.
Glennon recounts what Randy Moss did not do during his time with the Titans.
Houston Texans
Shaun Cody’s wrap-up episode of “On the Nose” features a turn to song. While amusing, it’s also somewhat difficult to listen to, so brace yourself. It's very cool that he invested the time and energy he did in these videos all season long. They really gave a lot of Texans a chance to show off a different side of their personalities and gave us a hint about the team's camaraderie.
Indianapolis Colts
Phillip B. Wilson of the Indianapolis Star hopes Jim Irsay won’t say another public word until Peyton Manning’s farewell news conference.
Irsay is desperate for a way to get rid of Peyton Manning without losing paying customers, says Greg Couch of FoxSports.com. (Hat tip to Bob Kravitz on Twitter.)
Jacksonville Jaguars
GM Gene Smith is accumulating opinions, says John Oehser of the Jaguars' team website.
Tony Boselli is pumping up the passion of the Jaguars’ fan base, says Oehser.
Tennessee Titans
John Glennon of The Tennessean writes that Mike Munchak sees Jason Jones playing outside and inside if he re-signs. While Jones can be a swing guy, I think Munchak overemphasizes Jones as both an end and a tackle. Jones played nearly twice as much at end as at tackle last season. The Titans would be best served to admit a mistake and play him inside if they are able to sign him.
Glennon recounts what Randy Moss did not do during his time with the Titans.
With Britt done, Washington a key for Titans
September, 26, 2011
9/26/11
4:58
PM ET
By
Paul Kuharsky | ESPN.com
Titans fans are panicked as they consider the team’s options in the wake of the news that wide receiver Kenny Britt tore up his knee against Denver and is lost for the season.
Should the team contact Terrell Owens? Turn back to Randy Moss? Bring back Justin Gage?
Jim Wyatt reports the Titans do have plans to work out Buster Davis and, if he doesn’t sign with a team he promised to visit first, Donnie Avery. Titans beat writers tweeted from Mike Munchak's news conference that the coach said that Moss and Owens are not likely to get a look but that Gage is a possibility.
Davis, Avery or Gage wouldn't jump into the team’s rotation. The Titans expect Nate Washington, Damian Williams, Lavelle Hawkins and tight end Jared Cook to take on more.
Washington has been excellent the past two weeks.
It’s a bit ironic.
In Pittsburgh, he excelled as a scramble option for Ben Roethlisberger. The Titans saw him as a great fit for Vince Young, presuming they’d work the same sort of magic on freelance plays. But it never really panned out and Washington was wildly inconsistent in his first two seasons in Tennessee, dropping far too many passes.
Now, playing with a more conventional pocket passer in Matt Hasselbeck, Washington has found something different. He’s had at least six catches in all three of the Titans’ games so far, with a total of 21 receptions for 258 yards and a touchdown. He’s earning the trust of receivers coach Dave Ragone, offensive coordinator Chris Palmer and Hasselbeck.
It’s one thing being the No. 2 receiver when a top-level threat such as Britt is drawing attention. Now the Titans need Washington to show he can continue to produce while ranking as the top guy.
It’s not an ideal scenario. But it looks a lot better than it did before the Munchak regime got started.
Should the team contact Terrell Owens? Turn back to Randy Moss? Bring back Justin Gage?
Jim Wyatt reports the Titans do have plans to work out Buster Davis and, if he doesn’t sign with a team he promised to visit first, Donnie Avery. Titans beat writers tweeted from Mike Munchak's news conference that the coach said that Moss and Owens are not likely to get a look but that Gage is a possibility.
Davis, Avery or Gage wouldn't jump into the team’s rotation. The Titans expect Nate Washington, Damian Williams, Lavelle Hawkins and tight end Jared Cook to take on more.
Washington has been excellent the past two weeks.
It’s a bit ironic.
In Pittsburgh, he excelled as a scramble option for Ben Roethlisberger. The Titans saw him as a great fit for Vince Young, presuming they’d work the same sort of magic on freelance plays. But it never really panned out and Washington was wildly inconsistent in his first two seasons in Tennessee, dropping far too many passes.
Now, playing with a more conventional pocket passer in Matt Hasselbeck, Washington has found something different. He’s had at least six catches in all three of the Titans’ games so far, with a total of 21 receptions for 258 yards and a touchdown. He’s earning the trust of receivers coach Dave Ragone, offensive coordinator Chris Palmer and Hasselbeck.
It’s one thing being the No. 2 receiver when a top-level threat such as Britt is drawing attention. Now the Titans need Washington to show he can continue to produce while ranking as the top guy.
It’s not an ideal scenario. But it looks a lot better than it did before the Munchak regime got started.
Moss retirement no surprise to Titans
August, 1, 2011
8/01/11
1:11
PM ET
By
Paul Kuharsky | ESPN.com
Randy Moss’ retirement isn’t a big surprise to anyone who saw him up close during the last half of the 2010 season when he was with the Tennessee Titans.
Tennessee claimed him on waivers from Minnesota, and believed he’d help stretch the field and create room for Chris Johnson. But they quickly stopped trying to use him.
Jeff Fisher and his offensive coordinator Mike Heimerdinger couldn’t rationalize why, but it became clear they thought he was done. Others who saw him work said he had simply lost the high-end speed that made him such a threat. The Titans have talked of the possibility of adding a veteran receiver, but never so much as considered that guy being Moss.
He wound up with six catches for 80 yards with Tennessee.
As time passes and the highlights run, the lowlight finish will became a faint memory.
Tennessee claimed him on waivers from Minnesota, and believed he’d help stretch the field and create room for Chris Johnson. But they quickly stopped trying to use him.
Jeff Fisher and his offensive coordinator Mike Heimerdinger couldn’t rationalize why, but it became clear they thought he was done. Others who saw him work said he had simply lost the high-end speed that made him such a threat. The Titans have talked of the possibility of adding a veteran receiver, but never so much as considered that guy being Moss.
He wound up with six catches for 80 yards with Tennessee.
As time passes and the highlights run, the lowlight finish will became a faint memory.
Our free-agent tracker is up and running. Sort through the available talent pool by team or by Scouts Inc. grade. If you’re an Insider, you can also get a scouting report.
I scanned though it for guys in the division who Scouts Inc. believes rate a 75 or better plugging into its rating scale:
90-100: Elite Player
Player demonstrates rare abilities and can create mismatches that have an obvious impact on the game. ... Premier NFL player who has all the skills to consistently play at a championship level. ... Rates as one of the top players at his position in the league.
80-89: Outstanding Player
Player has abilities to create mismatches versus most opponents in the NFL. ... A feature player who has an impact on the outcome of the game. ... Cannot be shut down by a single player and plays on a consistent level week in and week out.
70-79: Good Starter
Solid starter who is close to being an outstanding player. ... Has few weaknesses and usually will win his individual matchup but does not dominate in every game, especially when matched up against the top players in the league.
I scanned though it for guys in the division who Scouts Inc. believes rate a 75 or better plugging into its rating scale:
90-100: Elite Player
Player demonstrates rare abilities and can create mismatches that have an obvious impact on the game. ... Premier NFL player who has all the skills to consistently play at a championship level. ... Rates as one of the top players at his position in the league.
80-89: Outstanding Player
Player has abilities to create mismatches versus most opponents in the NFL. ... A feature player who has an impact on the outcome of the game. ... Cannot be shut down by a single player and plays on a consistent level week in and week out.
70-79: Good Starter
Solid starter who is close to being an outstanding player. ... Has few weaknesses and usually will win his individual matchup but does not dominate in every game, especially when matched up against the top players in the league.
- Titans DE Jason Babin -- 84
- Texans FB Vonta Leach -- 79
- Titans LB Stephen Tulloch -- 79
- Texans G Mike Brisiel -- 78
- Jaguars WR Mike Sims-Walker -- 78
- Colts S Melvin Bullitt -- 77
- Colts LB Clint Session -- 77
- Colts RB Joseph Addai -- 76
- Jaguars LB Justin Durant -- 75
- Jaguars LB Kirk Morrison -- 75
- Titans WR Randy Moss -- 75
» NFC: East | West | North | South » AFC: East | West | North | South » Unrestricted FAs
A look at the free-agent priorities for each AFC South team:
Houston Texans
1. Finally fix the secondary: Not only was the Texans’ secondary awful in coverage last season, but it also needs some stabilizing veteran leadership on the back end of this revamped defense. A safety like Eric Weddle could help cure both issues. There are quite a few safeties in this crop of free agents who would be clear upgrades for Houston. Of course, we have to discuss Nnamdi Asomugha -- and the Texans should certainly be right in the thick of those negotiations. If they can’t land Asomugha, the Texans could pursue Johnathan Joseph or Ike Taylor, who could help fix some leaks.
2. Work the cap: Houston is pretty tight up against the cap as it stands right now. But the team has serious needs on defense -- particularly in the secondary. In order to get the help they need, the Texans might have to restructure a few contracts or let a current player or two go.
3. Lock up Vonta Leach: This offense pretty much has it all. Wideout Andre Johnson makes everyone around him better in just so many ways. And the running game was exceptional last season. But Leach is a key component in that running game. And no fullback opens holes like this guy. Houston should bring him back and dedicate the rest of its free-agent moves to the defense.
Top five free agents: Leach, WR Jacoby Jones, S Bernard Pollard, DE Mark Anderson and QB Matt Leinart.
Indianapolis Colts
1. Get Peyton Manning’s extension done: Manning has been franchised and had surgery again on his neck recently. But there is little doubt who the face of this franchise is. Getting him locked up long term is something that Indianapolis just needs to get done.
2. Get a starting safety signed: Melvin Bullitt is a free agent. He is a solid player, and bringing him back makes a lot of sense. Outside of Antoine Bethea, who is vastly underrated, Indy has very little at this position. The Colts need to get a starter under contract. Also on defense, bringing back linebacker Clint Session, who is a superb fit in this scheme, and adding defensive tackle help also should be priorities if they can fit it under the cap.
3. Add running back help: This could come in the form of bringing back the reliable Joseph Addai. Well, he is reliable when he is healthy. And Addai has a great grasp of the Colts’ offense. I am very high on 2011 draft pick Delone Carter and maybe the light goes on for Donald Brown. But the Colts do need someone in their backfield who can pass protect and can be trusted. In this capacity, Addai seems to be worth more to the Colts than to any other team.
Top five free agents: Manning (franchised), Session, Addai, Bullitt and OT Charlie Johnson.
Jacksonville Jaguars
1. Address holes at linebacker: Linebackers Justin Durant and Kirk Morrison are up for free agency. I would suggest bringing one of those two back and then finding an upgrade from a coverage standpoint at a starting linebacker position to go along with the steady Daryl Smith. James Anderson would be an excellent target, and if healthy, so would another Panther -- Thomas Davis.
2. Address holes at safety: Jacksonville featured one of the worst secondaries in football last season. The Jags tried many bodies at safety, but it yielded minimal results. This is a very strong free-agent safety class, and the Jaguars need to add a starter or two they can count on week after week.
3. Spend! The Jaguars have quite a bit of money to spend in free agency, and under the new rules, they will have to spend. This free-agency period is like none we have ever seen and the action could be fast and furious. Jacksonville needs to stay the course and make wise financial decisions as it tries to add players who can mostly upgrade a hurting defense.
Top free agents: Marcedes Lewis (franchised), WR Mike Sims-Walker, Durant and Morrison.
Tennessee Titans
1. Revamp the Interior offensive line: Although they didn’t play great in 2010, I have faith in the Titans’ offensive tackles. But the interior of the line is a train wreck. That won’t do with a rookie quarterback behind center and in an offense that will be extremely run-heavy. Chris Johnson had little room to run last season. That needs to change. Marshal Yanda and Harvey Dahl would be great targets here.
2. Add a veteran quarterback: Needless to say, the Titans cannot enter the season with just the quarterbacks they currently have on their roster. They must bring in a veteran with some experience. Donovan McNabb would be high on my list. Matt Hasselbeck might also fit the bill.
3. Fortify every level of the defense: Presently, Tennessee is very young at linebacker, just adequate at safety and could lose three of its defensive ends. Making matters more difficult, the team is also installing a different version of the 4-3 defense. The Titans do have some money to spend in free agency. It would be wise if they used those funds on young free-agent talent, as it appears this team is now rebuilding from the ground up. Every level of the defense could use reinforcement.
Top five free agents: DE Jason Babin, LB Stephen Tulloch, WR Randy Moss, DE Dave Ball and DE Jacob Ford.
A look at the free-agent priorities for each AFC South team:
Houston Texans
1. Finally fix the secondary: Not only was the Texans’ secondary awful in coverage last season, but it also needs some stabilizing veteran leadership on the back end of this revamped defense. A safety like Eric Weddle could help cure both issues. There are quite a few safeties in this crop of free agents who would be clear upgrades for Houston. Of course, we have to discuss Nnamdi Asomugha -- and the Texans should certainly be right in the thick of those negotiations. If they can’t land Asomugha, the Texans could pursue Johnathan Joseph or Ike Taylor, who could help fix some leaks.
2. Work the cap: Houston is pretty tight up against the cap as it stands right now. But the team has serious needs on defense -- particularly in the secondary. In order to get the help they need, the Texans might have to restructure a few contracts or let a current player or two go.
3. Lock up Vonta Leach: This offense pretty much has it all. Wideout Andre Johnson makes everyone around him better in just so many ways. And the running game was exceptional last season. But Leach is a key component in that running game. And no fullback opens holes like this guy. Houston should bring him back and dedicate the rest of its free-agent moves to the defense.
Top five free agents: Leach, WR Jacoby Jones, S Bernard Pollard, DE Mark Anderson and QB Matt Leinart.
Indianapolis Colts
1. Get Peyton Manning’s extension done: Manning has been franchised and had surgery again on his neck recently. But there is little doubt who the face of this franchise is. Getting him locked up long term is something that Indianapolis just needs to get done.
2. Get a starting safety signed: Melvin Bullitt is a free agent. He is a solid player, and bringing him back makes a lot of sense. Outside of Antoine Bethea, who is vastly underrated, Indy has very little at this position. The Colts need to get a starter under contract. Also on defense, bringing back linebacker Clint Session, who is a superb fit in this scheme, and adding defensive tackle help also should be priorities if they can fit it under the cap.
3. Add running back help: This could come in the form of bringing back the reliable Joseph Addai. Well, he is reliable when he is healthy. And Addai has a great grasp of the Colts’ offense. I am very high on 2011 draft pick Delone Carter and maybe the light goes on for Donald Brown. But the Colts do need someone in their backfield who can pass protect and can be trusted. In this capacity, Addai seems to be worth more to the Colts than to any other team.
Top five free agents: Manning (franchised), Session, Addai, Bullitt and OT Charlie Johnson.
Jacksonville Jaguars
1. Address holes at linebacker: Linebackers Justin Durant and Kirk Morrison are up for free agency. I would suggest bringing one of those two back and then finding an upgrade from a coverage standpoint at a starting linebacker position to go along with the steady Daryl Smith. James Anderson would be an excellent target, and if healthy, so would another Panther -- Thomas Davis.
2. Address holes at safety: Jacksonville featured one of the worst secondaries in football last season. The Jags tried many bodies at safety, but it yielded minimal results. This is a very strong free-agent safety class, and the Jaguars need to add a starter or two they can count on week after week.
3. Spend! The Jaguars have quite a bit of money to spend in free agency, and under the new rules, they will have to spend. This free-agency period is like none we have ever seen and the action could be fast and furious. Jacksonville needs to stay the course and make wise financial decisions as it tries to add players who can mostly upgrade a hurting defense.
Top free agents: Marcedes Lewis (franchised), WR Mike Sims-Walker, Durant and Morrison.
Tennessee Titans
1. Revamp the Interior offensive line: Although they didn’t play great in 2010, I have faith in the Titans’ offensive tackles. But the interior of the line is a train wreck. That won’t do with a rookie quarterback behind center and in an offense that will be extremely run-heavy. Chris Johnson had little room to run last season. That needs to change. Marshal Yanda and Harvey Dahl would be great targets here.
2. Add a veteran quarterback: Needless to say, the Titans cannot enter the season with just the quarterbacks they currently have on their roster. They must bring in a veteran with some experience. Donovan McNabb would be high on my list. Matt Hasselbeck might also fit the bill.
3. Fortify every level of the defense: Presently, Tennessee is very young at linebacker, just adequate at safety and could lose three of its defensive ends. Making matters more difficult, the team is also installing a different version of the 4-3 defense. The Titans do have some money to spend in free agency. It would be wise if they used those funds on young free-agent talent, as it appears this team is now rebuilding from the ground up. Every level of the defense could use reinforcement.
Top five free agents: DE Jason Babin, LB Stephen Tulloch, WR Randy Moss, DE Dave Ball and DE Jacob Ford.
» NFC: East | West | North | South » AFC: East | West | North | South » Unrestricted FAs
Readiness factor: As poor as any team in the league, simply because of bad timing. New coach Mike Munchak and his staff have not had any time with their guys and are relying completely on tape for their assessments of veterans. The team does not yet have a quarterback who is the probable starter on opening day. Although Cortland Finnegan and Jake Scott did admirable work with group workouts and a two-day minicamp, having rookie Jake Locker along with Rusty Smith and Brett Ratliff as the signal-callers didn’t cut it.
Biggest challenge: Sorting out the quarterback issue. Even if the Titans wanted to go sink-or-swim with Locker from the start -- and the chances are very slim that's where they'll end up -- they have no veteran qualified to help him out. They could take a big swing at free agent Matt Hasselbeck, who would be determined to start as long as possible but also would mentor Locker, who’s already a friend. If they don’t land him, with Kerry Collins retired, the position will be a major concern.
Beyond quarterback: How actively will the Titans shop in free agency? They said they were not done at defensive tackle after the draft. They could use help at linebacker, especially if Stephen Tulloch moves on. Chris Hope is aging and expensive, and they could look to upgrade at strong safety. What goes unaddressed (like interior offensive line, likely) will tell us about their initial confidence level in multiple incumbents.
Key players without contracts for 2011: Defensive ends Jason Babin, Dave Ball and Jacob Ford, Tulloch, guard Leroy Harris, fullback Ahmard Hall, receiver Randy Moss.
Readiness factor: As poor as any team in the league, simply because of bad timing. New coach Mike Munchak and his staff have not had any time with their guys and are relying completely on tape for their assessments of veterans. The team does not yet have a quarterback who is the probable starter on opening day. Although Cortland Finnegan and Jake Scott did admirable work with group workouts and a two-day minicamp, having rookie Jake Locker along with Rusty Smith and Brett Ratliff as the signal-callers didn’t cut it.
Biggest challenge: Sorting out the quarterback issue. Even if the Titans wanted to go sink-or-swim with Locker from the start -- and the chances are very slim that's where they'll end up -- they have no veteran qualified to help him out. They could take a big swing at free agent Matt Hasselbeck, who would be determined to start as long as possible but also would mentor Locker, who’s already a friend. If they don’t land him, with Kerry Collins retired, the position will be a major concern.
Beyond quarterback: How actively will the Titans shop in free agency? They said they were not done at defensive tackle after the draft. They could use help at linebacker, especially if Stephen Tulloch moves on. Chris Hope is aging and expensive, and they could look to upgrade at strong safety. What goes unaddressed (like interior offensive line, likely) will tell us about their initial confidence level in multiple incumbents.
Key players without contracts for 2011: Defensive ends Jason Babin, Dave Ball and Jacob Ford, Tulloch, guard Leroy Harris, fullback Ahmard Hall, receiver Randy Moss.
Quick catch-up on division developments
July, 25, 2011
7/25/11
8:53
AM ET
By
Paul Kuharsky | ESPN.com
Some thoughts on developments around the division while I was away…
Houston Texans
The team promoted Mike Maccagnan to director of college scouting and named Dale Strahm a national college scout. Previously, Strahm was director of college scouting. He’s quite a bit older than Strahm and it appears this move is a changing of the guard at the top of Houston’s college scouting flow chart. Like most people in posts like his, Maccagnan will work in the background for a large part of the year and we won’t see his work come to fruition until next spring.
Indianapolis Colts
Peyton Manning won’t be ready for the start of camp and could miss significant time following his May neck surgery. Being without its top player for a significant chunk of camp after a lockout will surely be a setback for the team. And it’ll make for an incredibly boring preseason when we see Curtis Painter and whoever the team brings in as a stopgap get the work. Remember Jared Lorenzen and Quinn Gray in the summer of 2008? It will be a challenge to get good work for guys on offense without Manning in place.
Jacksonville Jaguars
Jack Del Rio put Blaine Gabbert’s learning curve into perspective on the radio with Pete Prisco. Talking about Gabbert having a playbook, JDR said: “I mean I guess I could give you a book of Chinese and a translation book of Chinese and then see how you are in a month and if you can speak Chinese or not. That’s what I equate it to.” That’s some good stuff there that we should keep in mind as we look for a quick impact from Gabbert.
Tennessee Titans
Of course Randy Moss’ agent is going to boast about Moss’ fitness. It would be news if he wasn’t in shape. It’s way less significant that he is in great shape. We can daydream about how Mike Munchak and Chris Palmer would use Moss more effectively than Jeff Fisher and Mike Heimerdinger did. But I don’t think there is any way the Titans, who talked of releasing Moss last year, bring him back no matter the regime change.
Houston Texans
The team promoted Mike Maccagnan to director of college scouting and named Dale Strahm a national college scout. Previously, Strahm was director of college scouting. He’s quite a bit older than Strahm and it appears this move is a changing of the guard at the top of Houston’s college scouting flow chart. Like most people in posts like his, Maccagnan will work in the background for a large part of the year and we won’t see his work come to fruition until next spring.
Indianapolis Colts
Peyton Manning won’t be ready for the start of camp and could miss significant time following his May neck surgery. Being without its top player for a significant chunk of camp after a lockout will surely be a setback for the team. And it’ll make for an incredibly boring preseason when we see Curtis Painter and whoever the team brings in as a stopgap get the work. Remember Jared Lorenzen and Quinn Gray in the summer of 2008? It will be a challenge to get good work for guys on offense without Manning in place.
Jacksonville Jaguars
Jack Del Rio put Blaine Gabbert’s learning curve into perspective on the radio with Pete Prisco. Talking about Gabbert having a playbook, JDR said: “I mean I guess I could give you a book of Chinese and a translation book of Chinese and then see how you are in a month and if you can speak Chinese or not. That’s what I equate it to.” That’s some good stuff there that we should keep in mind as we look for a quick impact from Gabbert.
Tennessee Titans
Of course Randy Moss’ agent is going to boast about Moss’ fitness. It would be news if he wasn’t in shape. It’s way less significant that he is in great shape. We can daydream about how Mike Munchak and Chris Palmer would use Moss more effectively than Jeff Fisher and Mike Heimerdinger did. But I don’t think there is any way the Titans, who talked of releasing Moss last year, bring him back no matter the regime change.
Adam Schefter discusses comments made by Randy Moss' agent and what type of deal he can expect.
Reading the coverage ...
Houston Texans
The lockout has claimed another victim: The Texans and Saints agreed to cancel their annual joint practices.
Arian Foster won an ESPY award Wednesday night for the Castrol EDGE NFL Strongest Performance.
In an interview with Yahoo! Sports, Foster opened up about how he's been spending his time during the lockout, how he'd advise undrafted free agents and whether there should be a rookie wage scale.
Responding to comments from James Harrison that he was "juiced out of his mind," Brian Cushing said "I'll pray for [Harrison]."
Indianapolis Colts
Peyton Manning, Tom Brady and Drew Brees filed a joint statement Wednesday. "We believe the overall proposal made by the players is fair for both sides and it is time to get this deal done. This is the time of the year we as players turn our attentions to the game on the field. We hope the owners feel the same."
Former Colts defensive lineman Erwin Baldwin didn't care for James Harrison's interview in Men's Journal, tweeting, "Man just seen James Harrison comments dude is a goon."
Jacksonville Jaguars
Black & Teal's Luke N. Sims projects what can be expected from the Jaguars' receivers and offensive linemen this season.
Tennessee Titans
Randy Moss' agent, Joel Segal, told NFL.com that his client is in "freakish shape." "He is determined, motivated and quite frankly has a huge chip on his shoulder. Whatever team ends up getting Randy, they're going to know they're getting the old Randy Moss," Segal said.
Will Mike Munchak have the toughest coaching job in the league after the lockout ends?
Houston Texans
The lockout has claimed another victim: The Texans and Saints agreed to cancel their annual joint practices.
Arian Foster won an ESPY award Wednesday night for the Castrol EDGE NFL Strongest Performance.
In an interview with Yahoo! Sports, Foster opened up about how he's been spending his time during the lockout, how he'd advise undrafted free agents and whether there should be a rookie wage scale.
Responding to comments from James Harrison that he was "juiced out of his mind," Brian Cushing said "I'll pray for [Harrison]."
Indianapolis Colts
Peyton Manning, Tom Brady and Drew Brees filed a joint statement Wednesday. "We believe the overall proposal made by the players is fair for both sides and it is time to get this deal done. This is the time of the year we as players turn our attentions to the game on the field. We hope the owners feel the same."
Former Colts defensive lineman Erwin Baldwin didn't care for James Harrison's interview in Men's Journal, tweeting, "Man just seen James Harrison comments dude is a goon."
Jacksonville Jaguars
Black & Teal's Luke N. Sims projects what can be expected from the Jaguars' receivers and offensive linemen this season.
Tennessee Titans
Randy Moss' agent, Joel Segal, told NFL.com that his client is in "freakish shape." "He is determined, motivated and quite frankly has a huge chip on his shoulder. Whatever team ends up getting Randy, they're going to know they're getting the old Randy Moss," Segal said.
Will Mike Munchak have the toughest coaching job in the league after the lockout ends?
RTC: Is Reggie Wayne top 'old' receiver?
June, 6, 2011
6/06/11
10:27
AM ET
By
Paul Kuharsky | ESPN.com
Reading the coverage…
Houston Texans
Reggie Herring says Brian Cushing will be a tackling machine as a 3-4 inside linebacker, writes Nick Scurfield.
Indianapolis Colts
Dan Pompei ranks Reggie Wayne as the league’s best old receiver. I’m very surprised that Randy Moss also makes the list. He wasn’t used correctly, but showed absolutely nothing in Tennessee.
Anthony Castonzo eats until he can’t eat any more, he told Barry Shuck.
Jacksonville Jaguars
Gene Frenette isn’t big on seeing player workouts. If players don’t want media to see workouts, I can live with that. My issue is if they are unwilling to be available to talk after they are finished.
Tennessee Titans
Ken O’Brien has big expectations for Jake Locker, says Jim Wyatt.
Houston Texans
Reggie Herring says Brian Cushing will be a tackling machine as a 3-4 inside linebacker, writes Nick Scurfield.
Indianapolis Colts
Dan Pompei ranks Reggie Wayne as the league’s best old receiver. I’m very surprised that Randy Moss also makes the list. He wasn’t used correctly, but showed absolutely nothing in Tennessee.
Anthony Castonzo eats until he can’t eat any more, he told Barry Shuck.
Jacksonville Jaguars
Gene Frenette isn’t big on seeing player workouts. If players don’t want media to see workouts, I can live with that. My issue is if they are unwilling to be available to talk after they are finished.
Tennessee Titans
Ken O’Brien has big expectations for Jake Locker, says Jim Wyatt.
Mailbag: Getting Houston's D to average
June, 4, 2011
6/04/11
10:18
AM ET
By
Paul Kuharsky | ESPN.com
Joey Harvey from San Antonio, TX writes: When considering physical demands, how can NHL players handle 80 games a yr and NFL players only 16?
Paul Kuharsky: Hockey is very physical and the ability of players to endure the grind can be remarkable.
Still, I think even most hockey players would tell you the ability to bounce back from a hockey game and from a football game are different. I don’t think a hockey player is taking the pounding in one game that a running back or lineman takes in one game. A hockey shift and a football series are two different things, too.
Rivers McCown from Houston writes: Assuming that the Texans miss out on [Nnamdi] Asomugha because, well, they're the Texans, is signing someone like Carlos Rogers or Ike Taylor along with a safety such as Gerald Sensabaugh enough in your mind to get the Texans defense to average?
Paul Kuharsky: I like the idea of Rogers or Taylor. But Sensabaugh is no big solution. Jaguars have all kind of safety issues and they dropped him a couple years back. Add one of those corners and find a safety and they could be on their way to average.
Ben from the UK writes: After seeing your response on the Plaxico Burress issue, I must say I disagree with your assessment on the Colts' requirements. Your description of what the Colts need as a 'sharp route runner who reads coverage and adjusts' merely sounds like Austin Collie, and to an extent what we still have with Reggie Wayne. Do you not feel we need someone with game-breaking speed and utility around the offense (like for example Reggie Bush minus the ridiculous salary) as opposed to another slower route runner?
Paul Kuharsky: Yes, they need game-breaking speed. I don’t think Burress has it. (And even a speedster needs to run routes the way the Colts expect.)
I refer to someone more knowledgeable than me on such things, Matt Williamson of Scouts Inc.:
Doesn’t sound to me like a guy who would give the Colts what they lack.
Adam C from Central Vermont writes: Missed your chat yesterday Paul due to a busy spell at work. I read that you think the Titans should target a guy like Carson Palmer, but said a second round pick was too expensive to do so. Would Cincinnati really be willing to take less than that? What do you think is an offer the Titans should give to see if Cincy will actually accept?
Paul Kuharsky: Once they spent No. 8 on Jake Locker, the option of giving up a value pick to get a veteran disappeared. They can’t trade now for a guy who they may only stick with as the starter for six games.
So it’s got to be a free agent: Matt Hasselbeck, Kerry Collins or one of the lesser names who will be on the market and cost nothing more than a contract.
@texantakeover writes: Do you think that with the Texans defense vastly improved this year would allow them to overtake the Colts for the division?
Paul Kuharsky: Vastly improved? We’re basing that on a new coordinator, some new assistants and a draft class? I’m going to need to see it all result in better play before I declare the Texans D vastly improved. And even if it’s vastly improved I have trouble seeing Houston winning the division.
Dan from Raleigh, NC writes: The Randy Moss experiment was a failure but the Titans could still use some help on the outside. When FA starts, does Plax get a shot? Or are the Titans' sights aimed exclusively at a veteran QB?
Paul Kuharsky: I don’t see them chasing another big-name veteran receiver. And I can’t imagine Mike Munchak and his staff -- who will put a premium on discipline and character -- are looking to start off with a big acquisition of a guy who just got out of jail.
Paul Kuharsky: Hockey is very physical and the ability of players to endure the grind can be remarkable.
Still, I think even most hockey players would tell you the ability to bounce back from a hockey game and from a football game are different. I don’t think a hockey player is taking the pounding in one game that a running back or lineman takes in one game. A hockey shift and a football series are two different things, too.
Rivers McCown from Houston writes: Assuming that the Texans miss out on [Nnamdi] Asomugha because, well, they're the Texans, is signing someone like Carlos Rogers or Ike Taylor along with a safety such as Gerald Sensabaugh enough in your mind to get the Texans defense to average?
Paul Kuharsky: I like the idea of Rogers or Taylor. But Sensabaugh is no big solution. Jaguars have all kind of safety issues and they dropped him a couple years back. Add one of those corners and find a safety and they could be on their way to average.
Ben from the UK writes: After seeing your response on the Plaxico Burress issue, I must say I disagree with your assessment on the Colts' requirements. Your description of what the Colts need as a 'sharp route runner who reads coverage and adjusts' merely sounds like Austin Collie, and to an extent what we still have with Reggie Wayne. Do you not feel we need someone with game-breaking speed and utility around the offense (like for example Reggie Bush minus the ridiculous salary) as opposed to another slower route runner?
Paul Kuharsky: Yes, they need game-breaking speed. I don’t think Burress has it. (And even a speedster needs to run routes the way the Colts expect.)
I refer to someone more knowledgeable than me on such things, Matt Williamson of Scouts Inc.:
“It is Burress' movement skills that I worry about. Even a few years ago when he was in his prime, Burress was never a real quick-twitch guy. He is a long strider who had build-up speed, but he wasn't quick, elusive or explosive. Now, you just have to think that those movement skill qualities have lessened over the past two years.
“Although he might look great and probably spent a lot of time in prison lifting weights, I tend to think that keeping his explosiveness under the circumstances he was in was close to impossible. And he does turn 34 in August.
"Now, like [Michael] Vick, that isn't to say he can't get those skills back to some extent. But separating from defenders seems like the hurdle Burress is going to have the most difficult time getting over upon his return.”
Doesn’t sound to me like a guy who would give the Colts what they lack.
Adam C from Central Vermont writes: Missed your chat yesterday Paul due to a busy spell at work. I read that you think the Titans should target a guy like Carson Palmer, but said a second round pick was too expensive to do so. Would Cincinnati really be willing to take less than that? What do you think is an offer the Titans should give to see if Cincy will actually accept?
Paul Kuharsky: Once they spent No. 8 on Jake Locker, the option of giving up a value pick to get a veteran disappeared. They can’t trade now for a guy who they may only stick with as the starter for six games.
So it’s got to be a free agent: Matt Hasselbeck, Kerry Collins or one of the lesser names who will be on the market and cost nothing more than a contract.
@texantakeover writes: Do you think that with the Texans defense vastly improved this year would allow them to overtake the Colts for the division?
Paul Kuharsky: Vastly improved? We’re basing that on a new coordinator, some new assistants and a draft class? I’m going to need to see it all result in better play before I declare the Texans D vastly improved. And even if it’s vastly improved I have trouble seeing Houston winning the division.
Dan from Raleigh, NC writes: The Randy Moss experiment was a failure but the Titans could still use some help on the outside. When FA starts, does Plax get a shot? Or are the Titans' sights aimed exclusively at a veteran QB?
Paul Kuharsky: I don’t see them chasing another big-name veteran receiver. And I can’t imagine Mike Munchak and his staff -- who will put a premium on discipline and character -- are looking to start off with a big acquisition of a guy who just got out of jail.
It’s called fantasy football for many reasons, and one of those reasons is we can discuss a new top 200 list in June during a lockout. You know it’s allowing you to adjust your cheat sheets.
Here’s the AFC South representation on ESPN.com’s new pre-free agency list. They’ve used “fa” to denote scheduled free agents. We will leave them on even though we know players like Mike Sims-Walker, Randy Moss and Vince Young are leaving Jacksonville, Tennessee and Tennessee, respectively
I wouldn’t touch Moss at 94, which is where I start to have some issues with this list. From what I saw up close, he’s finished. There are offensive coaches scattered around the country who were part of Jeff Fisher’s staff who would say the same.
Other thoughts:
Here’s the AFC South representation on ESPN.com’s new pre-free agency list. They’ve used “fa” to denote scheduled free agents. We will leave them on even though we know players like Mike Sims-Walker, Randy Moss and Vince Young are leaving Jacksonville, Tennessee and Tennessee, respectively
- 2 -- Arian Foster, HOU
- 3 -- Chris Johnson, TEN
- 5 -- Maurice Jones-Drew, JAC
- 9 -- Andre Johnson, HOU
- 22 -- Peyton Manning, IND
- 28 -- Reggie Wayne, IND
- 47 -- Matt Schaub, Hou
- 50 -- Dallas Clark, IND
- 57 -- Kenny Britt, TEN
- 63 -- Austin Collie, IND
- 82 -- Pierre Garcon, IND
- 83 -- Joseph Addai, IND-fa
- 87 -- Owen Daniels, HOU
- 94 -- Randy Moss, TEN-fa
- 103 -- Mike Thomas, JAC
- 105 -- Marcedes Lewis, JAC
- 126 -- David Garrard, Jac
- 138 -- Vince Young, Ten
- 143 -- Rashad Jennings, JAC
- 151 -- Neil Rackers, HOU
- 154 -- Rob Bironas, TEN
- 163 -- Ben Tate, HOU
- 172 -- Mike Sims-Walker, JAC-fa
- 181 -- Jared Cook, TEN
- 190 -- Adam Vinatieri, IND-fa
- 194 -- Jacoby Jones, HOU-fa
I wouldn’t touch Moss at 94, which is where I start to have some issues with this list. From what I saw up close, he’s finished. There are offensive coaches scattered around the country who were part of Jeff Fisher’s staff who would say the same.
Other thoughts:
- Of the guys rated above 90, Kenny Britt is probably the riskiest. Will he walk the straight line and can you count on him to produce week-to-week?
- Marcedes Lewis is too low. He’s going to remain the prime red-zone passing target. He’s going to be in amazing shape. I see a lot of guys I’d take him ahead of ranked above him (Beanie Wells? Seattle's Mike Williams? Moss?).
- David Garrard, meanwhile, seems too high at 126, though he is the 20th quarterback. I suppose if you draft your backup in the 12th round (in a 10-team league) that’s OK.
- It’s kind of silly to even play pretend with the likes of Joseph Addai, Moss, Sims-Walker, Young, Adam Vinatieri or Jacoby Jones at this point with no idea about where they will land.
- I think Mike Thomas is probably going to be a pretty good value if he’s the 103rd player taken.
- I’d go with Ben Tate as a reserve running back ahead of Rashad Jennings, just based on the mystery connected to Tate, who was hurt and lost for the year early last season.
- The best breakout candidate here is probably Jared Cook. You can certainly take a flier on him earlier than 181st knowing the Titans intend to feature him.
What's inside the AFC South mailbag?
April, 23, 2011
4/23/11
10:25
AM ET
By
Paul Kuharsky | ESPN.com
Ty in Jacksonville writes: Yo PK, in your Jaguars’ schedule analysis you didn't mention the three games in 10 days in December. December 5-15. Has that ever been done before? That’s hairy.
Paul Kuharsky: It’s not the first time a team has had a Monday night and Thursday night game in a three-week span. Heck, off the top of my head I know the Tennessee Oilers had that in November and December of 1997.
But yes, it’s certainly a tough stretch.
Chris Kirk in Indianapolis writes: Re: Booger McFarland not working out well. Not to bust your chops over one line in a post, but I felt compelled to defend Booger. He held up in the middle for us all the way to the super bowl after that bum Cory Simon blew it. All he cost was a second round pick and there’s NO WAY we'd have won the Super Bowl without him. I'd give up my second round pick for a one year rental that yields a Super Bowl title every single year. Plus, the reason he had to retire was a genuine injury (as opposed to Simon concealing an illness when he signed). I'd say most Colts fans view Booger as a solid contributor in our championship year, even if he blew his knee shortly thereafter.
Paul Kuharsky: I don’t disagree with anything you said. Just think they were expecting a longer solution.
Carl Tomlinson in Nashville, Tenn., writes: This may not be true Mr. Kuharsky, but how come I never hear any positive remarks in your article about Vince [Young]. I know he had a lot of issues, but I don't recall you writing about coach Fisher that way. I believe he had just as many issues if not more than Young. I don't believe Chris Johnson's thoughts are to be made light of. He performed his best when Young was at quarterback, and it's not his responsibility to incorporate Moss in the Titan's offense.
Paul Kuharsky: I ripped both Young (here, for example) and Fisher (here) on their way out. But one was professional during his time as a Titan and one was not, and I certainly prefer the former to the latter.
It’s entertaining, but I really don’t care a lick what Chris Johnson thinks about personnel. He said himself he knew it didn’t carry any weight. Johnson could have been a better runner and a better locker room guy in 2010. He has plenty to worry about on his own plate.
And the Titans would look like absolute fools to backtrack and bring VY back now. The ship has sailed.
In fact, since I wrote you back, they reiterated they are done with him.
(Why did they need to reiterate? “Attention fans. We said multiple times we are done with Vince Young. News flash, we are still done with Vince Young. Also, we have relocated from Houston to Nashville and renamed ourselves the Tennessee Titans. Stay tuned for further reiterations.”)
In honor of that, I officially swear off of talking about Young until he resurfaces in the news.
Brian in Orange County, Calif., writes: Any chance ESPN stops showing live shots of players smiling on the phone before the pick is actually made during the NFL Draft. It literally destroys the suspense. The only time I've seen it not be the guy smiling on the phone was Beanie Wells crying on the phone during the Titans’ pick. I thought we took a RB for the second time in a row in the first round and almost died! Luckily it was Kenny Britt. Who can we contact in hopes of them at least holding that footage till the players are announced?
Paul Kuharsky: I have to say I am thinking this qualifies more as a personal pet peeve than an issue upsetting the bulk of viewers. Either way, I appreciate that you think me connected enough to even know who is making those decisions. But I am not.
Mike from Maryland writes: First off, I would like to say that I really enjoy your blog, I check it just about every day. Keep up the good work! Secondly, if there is a free-agent signing period, do you think it would be wise for the Titans to try and get an older wide receiver to mentor Kenny Britt? I think if Britt had a mentor of some type it could help him hone his skills and maybe help Britt stay out of trouble off the field. I'm not sure who is supposed to be potentially available when the dust settles, but do you think it’s a good idea?
Paul Kuharsky: Just about every day? What can I do to get you up to a few times a day?
I don’t think you sign players to help you with other players. You’ve got limited spots, everyone needs to have his place on his own merits. There are people around to do what you are talking about -- his coaches.
They had an older receiver in a mentoring role for half of last season. Do we think Randy Moss helped Britt’s mindset?
Someone with no name from an undisclosed location writes: Oh shock, you don't like Cam Newton, you have hated Young forever. You are transparent my friend. People can see right through. Why don't the Titans take a good QB like "Blaine Gabbert." I would write you a longer email and try to appeal to your intellectual side but intellect is a department that you are sorely lacking in. Paul, I don't how you maintain your job at ESPN. But it speaks volumes about them as a company to keep someone like you employed. And the sad thing is, I know you don't even realize that you're biases are based in a deep seated animus, so it would be useless for me to explain anything to you.
Paul Kuharsky: Call me crazy, but I like my quarterbacks to be able to call plays. Young was still making mistakes in the huddle in his fifth season repeating a play call that was spoken into his ear. And surely Newton will admit that an NFL team isn’t going to be able to create a system for him where he can look to the sideline and tell his huddle “36.” That’s one of the primary things they have in common that makes them both unappealing to me. Sorry if you don’t like the rationale, or if you are inclined to see one that is not there.
I don’t care much for Ryan Mallett either at this point. How does he fit into your complaint about my feelings?
Paul Kuharsky: It’s not the first time a team has had a Monday night and Thursday night game in a three-week span. Heck, off the top of my head I know the Tennessee Oilers had that in November and December of 1997.
But yes, it’s certainly a tough stretch.
Chris Kirk in Indianapolis writes: Re: Booger McFarland not working out well. Not to bust your chops over one line in a post, but I felt compelled to defend Booger. He held up in the middle for us all the way to the super bowl after that bum Cory Simon blew it. All he cost was a second round pick and there’s NO WAY we'd have won the Super Bowl without him. I'd give up my second round pick for a one year rental that yields a Super Bowl title every single year. Plus, the reason he had to retire was a genuine injury (as opposed to Simon concealing an illness when he signed). I'd say most Colts fans view Booger as a solid contributor in our championship year, even if he blew his knee shortly thereafter.
Paul Kuharsky: I don’t disagree with anything you said. Just think they were expecting a longer solution.
Carl Tomlinson in Nashville, Tenn., writes: This may not be true Mr. Kuharsky, but how come I never hear any positive remarks in your article about Vince [Young]. I know he had a lot of issues, but I don't recall you writing about coach Fisher that way. I believe he had just as many issues if not more than Young. I don't believe Chris Johnson's thoughts are to be made light of. He performed his best when Young was at quarterback, and it's not his responsibility to incorporate Moss in the Titan's offense.
Paul Kuharsky: I ripped both Young (here, for example) and Fisher (here) on their way out. But one was professional during his time as a Titan and one was not, and I certainly prefer the former to the latter.
It’s entertaining, but I really don’t care a lick what Chris Johnson thinks about personnel. He said himself he knew it didn’t carry any weight. Johnson could have been a better runner and a better locker room guy in 2010. He has plenty to worry about on his own plate.
And the Titans would look like absolute fools to backtrack and bring VY back now. The ship has sailed.
In fact, since I wrote you back, they reiterated they are done with him.
(Why did they need to reiterate? “Attention fans. We said multiple times we are done with Vince Young. News flash, we are still done with Vince Young. Also, we have relocated from Houston to Nashville and renamed ourselves the Tennessee Titans. Stay tuned for further reiterations.”)
In honor of that, I officially swear off of talking about Young until he resurfaces in the news.
Brian in Orange County, Calif., writes: Any chance ESPN stops showing live shots of players smiling on the phone before the pick is actually made during the NFL Draft. It literally destroys the suspense. The only time I've seen it not be the guy smiling on the phone was Beanie Wells crying on the phone during the Titans’ pick. I thought we took a RB for the second time in a row in the first round and almost died! Luckily it was Kenny Britt. Who can we contact in hopes of them at least holding that footage till the players are announced?
Paul Kuharsky: I have to say I am thinking this qualifies more as a personal pet peeve than an issue upsetting the bulk of viewers. Either way, I appreciate that you think me connected enough to even know who is making those decisions. But I am not.
Mike from Maryland writes: First off, I would like to say that I really enjoy your blog, I check it just about every day. Keep up the good work! Secondly, if there is a free-agent signing period, do you think it would be wise for the Titans to try and get an older wide receiver to mentor Kenny Britt? I think if Britt had a mentor of some type it could help him hone his skills and maybe help Britt stay out of trouble off the field. I'm not sure who is supposed to be potentially available when the dust settles, but do you think it’s a good idea?
Paul Kuharsky: Just about every day? What can I do to get you up to a few times a day?
I don’t think you sign players to help you with other players. You’ve got limited spots, everyone needs to have his place on his own merits. There are people around to do what you are talking about -- his coaches.
They had an older receiver in a mentoring role for half of last season. Do we think Randy Moss helped Britt’s mindset?
Someone with no name from an undisclosed location writes: Oh shock, you don't like Cam Newton, you have hated Young forever. You are transparent my friend. People can see right through. Why don't the Titans take a good QB like "Blaine Gabbert." I would write you a longer email and try to appeal to your intellectual side but intellect is a department that you are sorely lacking in. Paul, I don't how you maintain your job at ESPN. But it speaks volumes about them as a company to keep someone like you employed. And the sad thing is, I know you don't even realize that you're biases are based in a deep seated animus, so it would be useless for me to explain anything to you.
Paul Kuharsky: Call me crazy, but I like my quarterbacks to be able to call plays. Young was still making mistakes in the huddle in his fifth season repeating a play call that was spoken into his ear. And surely Newton will admit that an NFL team isn’t going to be able to create a system for him where he can look to the sideline and tell his huddle “36.” That’s one of the primary things they have in common that makes them both unappealing to me. Sorry if you don’t like the rationale, or if you are inclined to see one that is not there.
I don’t care much for Ryan Mallett either at this point. How does he fit into your complaint about my feelings?
Johnson is irrelevant on Young, Newton
April, 15, 2011
4/15/11
9:28
AM ET
By
Paul Kuharsky | ESPN.com
By saying Vince Young could return to the Titans, Chris Johnson gives volume to a concept that continues to have some life but is simply incorrect.
Johnson told Jim Wyatt that with Jeff Fisher gone, there is a chance for Young to return.
But in the end, Tennessee’s decision to part ways with Young was an organizational one, not one handed down by Fisher. In fact, when owner Bud Adams was sold on making the move, it was the team’s top executive, Steve Underwood, and its general manager, Mike Reinfeldt, who were in Houston making the case for how the quarterback should be handled and why.
It’s not like the Titans brought in an outsider who needed to evaluate Young for himself. Mike Munchak saw all five years of Young’s tenure and is completely on board with the franchise's decision.
The Titans would look like idiots to go back on their repeated proclamation that they are done with him now. And they won’t.
Johnson wants Young back. Surprise. Young’s his pal.
Johnson wants the Titans to draft Cam Newton. Surprise. Newton’s a star.
If you’re a Titans fan, you don’t want Johnson making your personnel decisions. And he knows he doesn't have a platform here, just an opinion.
"At the end of the day, no matter what I think, the coaching staff and the organization is going to make the decision," Johnson said. "They are not going to ask any of the players or have a meeting with the players and ask them what they do."
Johnson talked longingly about Randy Moss when the Vikings traded for him, then saw Moss inhabit a nearby locker after the Titans claimed the receiver off waivers.
Johnson didn’t influence the Titans brass to make that move.
How did that endorsement and the ultimate acquisition work out?
Johnson told Jim Wyatt that with Jeff Fisher gone, there is a chance for Young to return.
But in the end, Tennessee’s decision to part ways with Young was an organizational one, not one handed down by Fisher. In fact, when owner Bud Adams was sold on making the move, it was the team’s top executive, Steve Underwood, and its general manager, Mike Reinfeldt, who were in Houston making the case for how the quarterback should be handled and why.
It’s not like the Titans brought in an outsider who needed to evaluate Young for himself. Mike Munchak saw all five years of Young’s tenure and is completely on board with the franchise's decision.
The Titans would look like idiots to go back on their repeated proclamation that they are done with him now. And they won’t.
Johnson wants Young back. Surprise. Young’s his pal.
Johnson wants the Titans to draft Cam Newton. Surprise. Newton’s a star.
If you’re a Titans fan, you don’t want Johnson making your personnel decisions. And he knows he doesn't have a platform here, just an opinion.
"At the end of the day, no matter what I think, the coaching staff and the organization is going to make the decision," Johnson said. "They are not going to ask any of the players or have a meeting with the players and ask them what they do."
Johnson talked longingly about Randy Moss when the Vikings traded for him, then saw Moss inhabit a nearby locker after the Titans claimed the receiver off waivers.
Johnson didn’t influence the Titans brass to make that move.
How did that endorsement and the ultimate acquisition work out?
ABOUT THIS BLOG
Paul Kuharsky
Kuharsky joined ESPN.com in 2008 after 12 years covering the Oilers/Titans and the NFL for The (Nashville) Tennessean. The New Jersey native and Columbia graduate lives in Nashville with his wife and son.
