Regarding the Iowa-Michigan State officiating
October, 26, 2009
10/26/09
6:06
PM ET
Posted by ESPN.com's Adam Rittenberg
Many of you have e-mailed asking about the officiating in Saturday night's Iowa-Michigan State clash at Spartan Stadium.
There were two plays in question: the late penalty called on Michigan State cornerback Jeremy Ware for hitting Iowa wide receiver Colin Sandeman and a possible fumble by Iowa's Brandon Wegher near the goal line.
In keeping with its policy, the Big Ten had no comment about the penalty on Ware, which Michigan State undoubtedly submitted to the league for review. Unlike other leagues, the Big Ten doesn't publicly reprimand its officials, who are independent contractors who work the games. Officials who receive poor reviews typically see their game assignments decrease.
After watching the tape several times, I think the officials made the call based more on how Sandeman looked after the play than what Ware did during it. Ware kept his head up and connected with Sandeman's left shoulder and helmet. It wasn't a direct helmet-to-helmet hit. I cringed as I saw Sandeman on the turf, and I think it influenced the late flag. And if you're going to call a penalty there, call it right away.
The Wegher play wasn't reviewed. I'm waiting on clarification from the league on this and will post it as soon as possible.
Many of you have e-mailed asking about the officiating in Saturday night's Iowa-Michigan State clash at Spartan Stadium.
There were two plays in question: the late penalty called on Michigan State cornerback Jeremy Ware for hitting Iowa wide receiver Colin Sandeman and a possible fumble by Iowa's Brandon Wegher near the goal line.
In keeping with its policy, the Big Ten had no comment about the penalty on Ware, which Michigan State undoubtedly submitted to the league for review. Unlike other leagues, the Big Ten doesn't publicly reprimand its officials, who are independent contractors who work the games. Officials who receive poor reviews typically see their game assignments decrease.
After watching the tape several times, I think the officials made the call based more on how Sandeman looked after the play than what Ware did during it. Ware kept his head up and connected with Sandeman's left shoulder and helmet. It wasn't a direct helmet-to-helmet hit. I cringed as I saw Sandeman on the turf, and I think it influenced the late flag. And if you're going to call a penalty there, call it right away.
The Wegher play wasn't reviewed. I'm waiting on clarification from the league on this and will post it as soon as possible.
BIG TEN SCOREBOARD
Saturday, 12/17
Final Temple 37 Wyoming 15 Final Ohio 24 Utah State 23 Final San Diego State 30 Louisiana-Lafayette 32
Tuesday, 12/20
Wednesday, 12/21
Final 18 TCU 31 Louisiana Tech 24
Thursday, 12/22
Saturday, 12/24
Final Nevada 17 21 Southern Miss 24
Monday, 12/26
Tuesday, 12/27
Final Western Michigan 32 Purdue 37 Final Louisville 24 North Carolina State 31
Wednesday, 12/28
Final Toledo 42 Air Force 41 Final California 10 24 Texas 21
Thursday, 12/29
Final Florida State 18 Notre Dame 14 Final Washington 56 12 Baylor 67
Friday, 12/30
Final Brigham Young 24 Tulsa 21 Final Rutgers 27 Iowa State 13 Final Mississippi State 23 Wake Forest 17 Final Iowa 14 14 Oklahoma 31
Saturday, 12/31
Final Texas A&M 33 Northwestern 22 Final/OT Georgia Tech 27 Utah 30 Final Illinois 20 UCLA 14 Final Cincinnati 31 Vanderbilt 24 Final Virginia 24 25 Auburn 43
Monday, 1/2
Final 19 Houston 30 22 Penn State 14 Final Ohio State 17 Florida 24 Final/3OT 17 Michigan State 33 16 Georgia 30 Final 20 Nebraska 13 9 South Carolina 30 Final 10 Wisconsin 38 5 Oregon 45 Final/OT 4 Stanford 38 3 Oklahoma State 41
Tuesday, 1/3
Final/OT 13 Michigan 23 11 Virginia Tech 20
Wednesday, 1/4
Final 23 West Virginia 70 15 Clemson 33
Friday, 1/6
Final 8 Kansas State 16 6 Arkansas 29


You must be signed in to post a comment