ESPN College Football

Purdue's quarterback derby will once again be a three-man race in 2012.

Robert Marve on Friday received a sixth year of eligibility from the NCAA, meaning he'll compete with Caleb TerBush and Rob Henry for the Boilers' starting spot this fall. Marve, who began his career at Miami, sat out the 2007 season because of injury and missed all but four games of Purdue's 2010 season after suffering a torn ACL.

Purdue had lousy luck with its sixth-year applicant last year, wide receiver Keith Smith, but Marve becomes the third Boilermaker to receive an additional year in the past four years, joining defenders Jason Werner and Torri Williams.

Knee issues limited Marve at the start of the 2011 season, and he spent most of the fall backing up TerBush, completing 56 percent of his passes for 633 yards with four touchdowns and five interceptions. Henry would have started ahead of both men had he not suffered a torn ACL weeks before the season.

"I am extremely blessed by the NCAA’s decision and proud to be at Purdue for another season," Marve said in a statement. "I'm looking forward to next year and winning games for the Boilermakers."

Barring more injury issues, Purdue will be extremely deep at the quarterback spot for the 2012 season, when the Boilers have an opportunity to make some noise in a wide-open Leaders division.

"In all of my years of coaching, I’ve never been around a player that has worked so hard at becoming an elite athlete and, because of injury, has seen so little reward for his efforts," Purdue head coach Danny Hope said in a statement. "This is a big boost to our program getting him back."

Although Marve hasn't lived up to his recruiting hype, he has one more chance for a breakout season with Purdue. His return certainly adds intrigue to the Boilers' quarterback battle.

This will be the last mailblog for a little while -- vacation coming -- but keep sending in those questions. And don't forget to follow me on Twitter.

Let's get going.

John from Las Vegas writes: Was Roy Helu's performance at the combine expected? Look at the numbers, he seemed to put together some very solid times. How much weight do the times actually carry?

Adam Rittenberg: John, you never fully know what to expect from prospects at the combine, but Helu certainly helped himself with his performance. His 40-yard dash times (4.43 and 4.42) exceeded some folks' expectations, and he also did very well in the two shuttles and the three-cone drill. It also helps that Helu boasts good size for a pro back. The thing to remember is some teams value combine tests more than others, and Helu has to fit a team's needs and its system. But the Huskers' star opened eyes in Indy, which is a very good thing.

---

Ryan from West Lafayette, Ind., writes: Adam, explain to me how in the world Keith Smith does not get another year of eligibility? He played in one game this year and got hurt in the second. I've seen countless players over the years who've played two or three full games and got hurt and the NCAA granted them a medical redshirt. The boilers could have really used him this year.

Adam Rittenberg: Ryan, one thing to remember is Smith applied for a sixth year, not a medical hardship waiver, so it's slightly different. The NCAA doesn't provide much of an explanation for its ruling, and Smith as of earlier today hadn't received one. I think the issue with Smith has more to do with the 2007 season than the 2010 campaign. He redshirted in 2007 for more reasons than just injury. He left school in the spring because of a family situation and fell behind academically. He also had an ankle injury that limited him during in-season practices. My guess is that if serious injury had been the sole reason Smith took the redshirt in 2007, he would have received the sixth year. In the cases of Purdue players Jason Werner and Torri Williams, injuries fully wiped out two seasons for both men, and both received sixth years from the NCAA.

---

Jerry from Columbus, Ohio, writes: Adam:Great job on the season grades. But somehow I missed a few. Is there a way to find the links to the full list of team grade videos?

Adam Rittenberg: No problem, Jerry. You can find each of the team grade videos below:

• Illinois
• Indiana
• Iowa
• Michigan
• Michigan State
• Minnesota
• Northwestern
• Ohio State
• Penn State
• Purdue
• Wisconsin

---

Nick from Iowa City, Iowa, writes: My friend and I have been arguing about who made a bigger impact on the kirk ferentz hawkeye football era so far, Ricky Stanzi or Brad Banks? I agree Banks was the better COLLEGE qb, but overall stanzi won three bowls including a bcs and is going off to the NFL, proving that Iowa can produce Nfl caliber qbs. what do you think about these two qbs?

Adam Rittenberg: Good debate, Nick! Banks undoubtedly had the best individual season of the two in 2002, when he won Big Ten Player of the Year honors and was the runner-up for the Heisman Trophy. But in terms of overall impact on the program, I would go with Stanzi as well. The quarterback position looked bleak in 2008 until he emerged as the guy and led the comeback against Penn State. Three bowl wins also can't be overlooked. Banks only had two seasons in Iowa City and played behind Kyle McCann in 2001. But his 2002 season certainly stands out in Iowa history, and it seems like the '02 team is celebrated more than any of Stanzi's squads. You can make good cases on both sides. I like this discussion.

---

Tony from Iowa City, Iowa, writes: All of this talk about MSU being a football or basketball school has got me wondering, where do other schools see themselves? Is Illinois football or basketball? Wisconsin? Iowa (maybe for wrestling)? With not a whole lot going on in this month before spring practices hit full swing, this might be a fun topic to dive into with each school in the B10.

Adam Rittenberg: Tony, this is always a fun topic to discuss. I explored it in March 2009 in this post, which identified the flagship program (football or men's basketball) for each Big Ten school.

• Illinois: basketball
• Indiana: basketball
• Iowa: football
• Michigan: football
• Michigan State: basketball
• Minnesota: push
• Northwestern: football
• Ohio State: football
• Penn State: football
• Purdue: basketball
• Wisconsin: push

I'd make a few adjustments to this list after a few more years on the job. Michigan State, after our recent debate, could be labeled a football school or at least a push. Minnesota might be labeled a hockey school. The others likely remain the same.

The longer the NCAA waited to render a decision on Keith Smith, the less likely it seemed that the star receiver would see the field again for Purdue.

Smith finally got the news Monday, and it wasn't what he or Purdue fans wanted to hear.

The NCAA denied Smith a sixth year, ending his college career two days before Purdue is to open spring practice. Smith applied for a sixth year in November after two torn ligaments in a Week 2 win against Western Illinois ended his 2010 season.

The NCAA typically makes decisions on sixth-year applicants in early to mid February. Minnesota safety Kim Royston, who missed all of last season with a broken leg, got the good news in late January. The NCAA granted sixth years to Purdue players in each of the past two Februarys: linebacker Jason Werner in 2010 and safety Torri Williams in 2009.

But for some reason, Smith's case wasn't compelling enough for a sixth year. Count me among those disappointed by the decision.

Not only is Smith an outstanding player -- he earned first-team All-Big Ten honors in 2009 after leading the league in both receptions (91) and receiving yards (1,100) -- but he's a classy kid with an infectious personality who deserved a better end to his college career.

Smith showed why type of guy he is in the way he handled the injury setback last season.

I spoke this afternoon with Purdue coach Danny Hope, who hasn't heard why Smith's application was denied (Purdue's compliance department deals with the NCAA, not the coaches). One possible explanation why the decisions differed for Werner, Williams and Smith: both Werner and Williams missed two full seasons because of injury while Smith sat out the 2007 season only partially because of injury.

I'm checking with the NCAA and hope to get a response soon.

"We’re all very disappointed," Hope said. "Disappointed for him and obviously, he's a very valuable team member, so we’re all disappointed. But it’s just reality. Sometimes life can throw you a curveball, you have to adjust your swing."

There's no doubt Smith will make the necessary adjustments.

"I told Keith months ago that either way, I think he’ll make it in the National Football League," Hope said. "Getting a year back would have given him opportunity to improve after the injury and show what he can do. He’s been great. He’s been extremely upbeat throughout the whole process and has had a plan regardless of the scenario."

Smith attended the NFL combine in Indianapolis and went through interviews with teams. He couldn't participate in drills as he continues to rehab from the knee surgery.

Purdue brings back some decent depth at receiver even without Smith. Justin Siller returns from injury, and the Boilers also have Antavian Edison, Gary Bush and O.J. Ross, who impressed before getting hurt.

Hope also is excited about Normando Harris, who moves to receiver from safety, and incoming freshman Raheem Mostert.

"I think we’re going to be OK numbers wise," Hope said. "We're going to have to produce to fill those shoes, but we’ve got some good players coming back."

Purdue's coaching staff for 2011 appears set as the team on Tuesday announced the hiring of DeMontie Cross as linebackers coach.

Cross spent the past five seasons with the Buffalo Bills, serving as assistant linebackers coach from 2006-09 and inside linebackers coach in 2010. He replaces Mark Hagen, who left last month to join Indiana's staff.

"He has coached linebackers at the highest levels of football, both professionally and collegiately," Purdue coach Danny Hope said in a prepared statement. "He also has secondary experience and, with pass defense, it's a real shot in the arm to have someone who has worked with both areas. DeMontie is a high-energy coach with a passion for the game. We have some very talented linebackers returning for the 2011 season, and I know they will enjoy getting to know him and working with him going forward."

Donn Landholm, demoted from his defensive coordinator post after the season, will assist Cross with the outside linebackers and take on additional recruiting responsibilities, according to a news release. Gary Emanuel will serve as Purdue's sole defensive coordinator while continuing to work with the defensive line.

Cross, an All-Big 12 safety at Missouri, brings a good deal of experience coaching linebackers to Purdue. He spent five seasons as outside linebackers coach at Iowa State and tutored several Big Ten products with the Bills, including former Penn State star Paul Posluszny and former Purdue defensive end Akin Ayodele.

Cross inherits a group that loses Jason Werner but brings back some experienced options (Joe Holland, Dwayne Beckford, Chris Carlino) as well as promising freshman Will Lucas.

You know how to reach me.

Let's get started.

Drew from D.C. writes: Hey Adam,I think teams that have both a featured speed back as well as a power back (Stanford, Wisconsin) have done very well. In my opinion, defenses can't shut down someone like John Clay on a 4th and 1. Do you think more teams should start recruiting larger backs like Clay in the future to go along with their speed backs?

Adam Rittenberg: Totally agree, Drew. Everyone talks about speed these days, but I believe the ability to change speeds sets a team apart. It's like a pitcher who only throws a fastball. Eventually, he'll be hit hard. But a guy who has two or three great pitches can win a bunch of games. Wisconsin RBs coach John Settle said having James White in the mix as a speed back took the Badgers' rushing attack to another level this fall. That's true, but you also needed the foundation of power supplied by Clay. I think teams always want a guy with size to run the ball, but there seem to be more smaller backs available.

---

Mike from Denver writes: Adam--In response to your comment in last week's chat regarding location and the population shift affecting PSU recruiting, I completely disagree. If PSU consistently hauled in the best high school talent from PA, NJ, NY, and MD, they would have a top 5 class every year. Again, I think joining the Big Ten hurt PSU in this respect, because as an independent PSU used to beat up on Syracuse, Rutgers, and Maryland, and beat Pitt 2/3 of the time, helping with recruiting these regions. I realize we can't turn back time, but I wish PSU had more exposure in the Northeast. Thanks.

Adam Rittenberg: More exposure? Really? Penn State has its share of issues, but exposure doesn't appear to be one of them. Big Ten teams get far more exposure nationally than teams in, say, the Big East. I know a lot of folks living in the Northeast who have little trouble catching Big Ten games on TV. Penn State never had an exposure problem as an independent, and I don't think things have changed since it joined the Big Ten. I also don't know if beating out so-so teams from the Big East and the ACC on the recruiting trail is the key to boosting your overall recruiting. Penn State can sustain itself with recruits from places like Pennsylvania, New Jersey and Maryland, but it wouldn't hurt to dip into the Sun Belt region a little more.

---

Greg from Clyde, Ohio, writes: How would a season have to transpire for Jim Tressel to win Big Ten Coach of the Year? When I looks at individual seasons, I can sort of see why somebody else won it. Nevertheless, in a decade at Ohio State Tressel has seven conference titles and five BCS wins, more than any other 3 Big Ten coaches put together!

Adam Rittenberg: Greg, although Tressel undoubtedly wishes the circumstances were different, the 2011 season sets up perfectly for him to finally win Big Ten Coach of the Year. The reason: the five-game suspensions for Terrelle Pryor and four others to begin the season. Tressel already has won points by getting the players to pass up the draft and return to serve their punishments at Ohio State. If the Buckeyes can survive their absence for the first half of the season -- not to mention the loss of a sizable and decorated senior class -- and go on to win the Big Ten for the seventh consecutive season, Tressel would have to be the pick for Coach of the Year.

---

Ryan from Oskaloosa, Iowa, writes: In response to "I just wish we could move on to more relevant things like who is in the divisions." And that's the thing with the division names, I can name the teams in each of the divisions but I still can't remember which group is the "Legends" and which is the "Leaders". Both names project a strong image but together they are like oil and water--they just don't mix, or aren't complimentary to each other. While those of us who follow the Big Ten and are fans of one team in particular we might come to remember that our team is in the Legends/Leaders division and get it correct. But what about the rest of the country, more importantly the media outlets who are going to give the 30 second highlight and in all probability reverse the division names, not care that they screwed up and the rest of the country won't notice either. It doesn't seem to me that is a good way to brand your image.

Adam Rittenberg: Great points here, Ryan. It won't be easy for a lot of folks to keep the names straight with Legends and Leaders. I know the Big Ten wanted to avoid geography when naming the divisions because of the way it assigned the teams, but would East/West have been so bad? The league already has been dealing with creative math (11 teams, now 12) for years. Although Wisconsin clearly isn't in the eastern half of the league, an East/West designation likely would help casual observers understand who goes where. These are just division names, after all, and their primary function should be providing clarity. The Big Ten instead used them to broadcast its message as a conference and did so on a huge platform, which was clearly the wrong move.

---

Evan from Tuscaloosa, Ala., writes: Adam, love the blog. I read it on a daily basis. Have you heard any new on Keith Smith? I saw that Case Keenum was granted a 6th year of eligibility and he played 4 games this year. Would this signal that Smith should get his 6th year of eligibility?

Adam Rittenberg: Evan, we should hear something soon on Keith Smith, by the end of February at the latest. I'd be stunned if he doesn't receive a sixth year of eligibility. The Keenum case is a good one, and there's precedent at Purdue the last two seasons with linebacker Jason Werner and safety Torri Williams, both of whom received sixth years in February. Smith deserves a sixth year, and he should get one soon.

---

Hunter from Saint Johns, Mich., writes: Dear Adam, I was wondering if you have any word on who is or could be considered for the offensive coordinator position for Michigan State? I have yet to hear anything about that from any your blogs or in the local newspapers for Lansing, MI.

Adam Rittenberg: Hunter, I've heard very little about the vacancy at Michigan State and have seen next to nothing in the media about it. Mark Dantonio could promote from within his staff. Dave Warner coaches quarterbacks, a position often held by an offensive coordinator, while Dan Roushar (line), Mark Staten (tight ends) and Brad Salem (running backs) all boast a lot of experience. Whether he looks within or to the outside, I'd expect Dantonio to stick with a coordinator who runs a pro-style offense, which has produced good success in East Lansing. I'll see what I can find out.

Let's look back before a very quick look ahead.

Team of the Week: Michigan State. The Spartans put the final stamp on a special season by winning at Penn State for the first time since 1965. The victory gave Michigan State a share of the Big Ten championship for the first time since 1990. Michigan State took control of the game early behind quarterback Kirk Cousins, running back Edwin Baker and a stout defense, and held on late to prevail 28-22. Minnesota and Indiana both deserve mentions as well for winning rivalry games and earning the right to do this and this.

Biggest play: Two defensive plays propelled Minnesota and Indiana to wins Saturday. Gophers cornerback Troy Stoudermire stripped the ball from Iowa's Marcus Coker late in the fourth quarter, which led to Minnesota running out the clock to preserve a 27-24 victory. Indiana linebacker Jeff Thomas picked off a Rob Henry pass in overtime, allowing the Hoosiers to drive for the game-winning field goal. Michigan State's recovery of an onside kick after Penn State had cut its deficit to six points also stands out.

Specialist spotlight: Indiana freshman Mitch Ewald came up big against Purdue with two field goals, the first to send the game into overtime and the second to win it in the extra session. Minnesota's Eric Ellestad went 2-for-2 on field goals and recovered his own onside kick against Iowa, helping the Gophers jump out to a 10-0 lead. Ohio State's Jordan Hall prevented Michigan from gaining any momentum with an 85-yard kick return for a touchdown midway through the second quarter. Northwestern's Venric Mark had a 94-yard kick return for a touchdown against Wisconsin, and his 273 return yards mark the second-highest single-game total in Big Ten history. Ohio State's Devin Barclay went 3-for-3 on field-goal attempts. The day featured good punting performances from Purdue's Cody Webster (56-yard average, three inside the 20-yard line), Iowa's Ryan Donahue (47.5-yard average, two inside the 20-yard line), Michigan State's Aaron Bates (46.5-yard average, two inside the 20-yard line) and Wisconsin's Brad Nortman (39.6-yard average, four inside the 20-yard line).

Filling the void: A quick shoutout to Jeff Horton, who did a very good job in a very difficult situation at Minnesota as interim coach. Horton kept the team focused despite the midseason firing of head coach Tim Brewster, and the Gophers ended the year with two solid wins against Illinois and Iowa. Although Minnesota will bring in a new coach, I would hope Horton gets consideration to remain on the staff. Otherwise, I'm sure he'll latch on elsewhere.

Game balls (given to players on winning or losing teams not recognized in helmet stickers)

• Ohio State defensive end Nathan Williams: Williams ended the regular season on a very strong note with 2.5 tackles for loss, a sack, a fumble recovery and two pass breakups as Ohio State held Michigan scoreless in the second half.
• Indiana receiver Tandon Doss: Doss recorded three touchdown catches for the second multi-touchdown game of his career. He added 18 rushing yards on two carries and had 117 yards on six kickoff returns with a long of 30 yards.
• Indiana linebacker Jeff Thomas: In addition to the interception in overtime, Thomas recorded three tackles for loss against Purdue.
• Michigan State cornerback Chris L. Rucker: The senior recorded three pass breakups, a forced fumble and five tackles for a playmaking secondary in the win against Penn State.
• Purdue linebacker Jason Werner: Werner finished his college career by recording 3.5 tackles for loss and eight total tackles in the overtime loss to Indiana.
• Minnesota running backs DeLeon Eskridge and Duane Bennett: The Gophers backfield tandem finished an up-and-down season on a good note, combining for 158 rush yards and two touchdowns on 32 carries in the win against Iowa.
• Wisconsin safety Jay Valai: Valai recorded six tackles with a forced fumble and an interception as the Badgers recorded seven takeaways in the rout of Northwestern.
• Michigan defensive end Ryan Van Bergen: It was another rough day for the Wolverines' defense, but Van Bergen did his part with three tackles for loss, a sack and five total tackles.

There's only one Big Ten game on the docket this week and it comes to you Friday night on ESPN2.

Illinois (6-5) at Fresno State (7-4): The Illini can secure their first winning season since 2007 and possibly earn a berth to a Florida bowl with a victory. Fresno State typically plays very well at home, but has dropped games to Nevada and Hawaii on its home turf. The Bulldogs won last year's contest in Champaign 53-52 after one of the wildest plays you'll ever see, a two-point conversion by Fresno State offensive lineman Devan Cunningham following a tipped pass. Illinois' Mikel Leshoure rushed for 184 yards and two touchdowns against Fresno State last year and comes off of a 330-yard rushing performance at Wrigley Field.

Although Purdue still has a chance to become bowl eligible this season, many are looking ahead to 2011 and, hopefully, better fortunes on the injury front.

The Boilers are trying to ensure that star receiver Keith Smith is part of the plan next fall.

As expected, Purdue is petitioning the NCAA for a sixth year of eligibility for Smith, who tore two ligaments in his knee Sept. 11 against Western Illinois and underwent surgery last month. Although Smith didn't say whether he'd seek a sixth year in his last media appearance, it seemed likely.

The NCAA likely won't rule on Smith's status until February, but Purdue has fared well in recent applications for sixth years of eligibility. Linebacker Jason Werner received one last winter and safety Torri Williams was successful the previous year.

Smith, a first-team All-Big Ten receiver in 2009, would be a big help as Purdue restores its offense next fall. The Boilers should get quarterbacks Robert Marve and Caleb TerBush, running back Ralph Bolden, receiver Justin Siller and others back in the fold.

Here's hoping Smith is successful in his application. He's not only one of the Big Ten's best players but one of the league's classiest people.

Let's look back at Week 3 before gearing up for a riveting slate of games Saturday in the Big Ten (sarcasm, people).

Team of the Week: Michigan State. After suffering a series of close losses in the past three years, Michigan State finally turned the tables -- against one of its top rivals, no less. A seesaw game featured some offensive fireworks on both sides, and for certain stretches, Michigan State achieved the type of offensive balance that could make it very dangerous when Big Ten play rolls around. But the Spartans once again seemed to wilt in the clutch as quarterback Kirk Cousins took some costly sacks. Notre Dame regained the momentum late in regulation and in overtime, but Michigan State changed everything with a gutsy fake field goal call that resulted in the game-winning 29-yard touchdown pass. Although coach Mark Dantonio's health setback put the celebration on pause, Michigan State has an opportunity to build off this win.

Best game: Notre Dame at Michigan State. The game featured four lead changes, 938 yards, 65 points and the most memorable play of the young college football season, as punter/holder Aaron Bates found tight end Charlie Gantt for a 29-yard touchdown on the fake field goal try in overtime. Quarterbacks Cousins and Dayne Crist both had their moments, as did receivers Michael Floyd and B.J. Cunningham. Just a very entertaining game between rivals. Honorable mentions go to Wisconsin-Arizona State, which featured several wild special-teams plays, and Iowa-Arizona, which featured a furious Hawkeyes rally from a 27-7 halftime deficit and an Arizona counterpunch in the clutch.

Biggest play: Isn't it obvious by now? No one expected the fake field goal, especially from a typically conservative coach like Dantonio. It was the right call at the right time and Bates, a former high school quarterback, deserves credit for going to his second read after Le'Veon Bell was covered. If Michigan State goes on to have a big season, we'll all point to this play. Wisconsin also received two huge special-teams plays from safeties Shelton Johnson and Jay Valai. Johnson tripped up Arizona State kick returner Kyle Middlebrooks at the 1-yard line as the second quarter clock expired, saving six points and a huge momentum swing going into halftime. The 5-foot-9 Valai showed off his hops by blocking the potential game-tying PAT attempt with 4:09 left as Wisconsin won 20-19.

Specialist spotlight: Bates had a huge night against Notre Dame, and his game-winning pass to Gantt overshadowed his prowess as a punter, as he averaged 45.4 yards on eight punts. Illinois punter Anthony Santella leads the nation in punting average (48.9 ypg) after averaging 48.7 yards per boot on Saturday against Northern Illinois. Northwestern kicker Stefan Demos went 3-for-3 on field goal attempts against Rice, and Wisconsin punter Brad Nortman averaged 43 yards on four punts and had one downed inside the 5-yard line against Arizona State.

Game balls (given to players from winning teams not selected for helmet stickers):

• Wisconsin TE Lance Kendricks: Kendricks knew he'd have to step up Saturday as Wisconsin played without two of its top receivers (Nick Toon and David Gilreath). The senior tight end looked like a wide receiver again as he hauled in seven receptions for 131 yards and a touchdown, even though he was interfered with in the end zone. He shares the game ball with quarterback Scott Tolzien (19-25 passing, 246 yards, 1 TD).
• Michigan RB Michael Shaw: Denard Robinson didn't have to do it all against UMass as Shaw racked up career highs in both rushing yards (126) and touchdowns (3) on only 12 carries. He shares the game ball with Robinson, who had another big day, and receiver Darryl Stonum (3 receptions, 121 yards, 2 TDs).
• Ohio State LB Ross Homan: Homan has carried over his stellar play from 2009 and continues to become one of the league's top defensive playmakers. The senior had seven solo tackles, a forced fumble and an interception against Ohio. Kudos also go to fellow Buckeyes defender Tyler Moeller, who recorded his first career interception, a forced fumble and 1.5 tackles for loss.
• Michigan State RB Le'Veon Bell: Bell is the early leader for Big Ten Freshman of the Year after recording his second 100-yard rushing performance in his first three collegiate games. The big man rumbled for 114 yards and a touchdown on 17 carries against Notre Dame. He shares the game ball with receiver B.J. Cunningham (7 receptions, 101 yards, TD) and fellow back Edwin Baker (14 carries, 90 rush yards, TD).
• Northwestern LB Quentin Davie: The senior leads the Big Ten in interceptions after recording his third -- a pick-six, no less -- in Saturday night's blowout win at Rice. Davie recorded a game-high 10 tackles, including 1.5 for loss and a pass breakup. He shares the game ball with defensive linemen Vince Browne, Corbin Bryant and Jack DiNardo, who combined for 7.5 tackles for loss, 1.5 sacks, a forced fumble and a fumble recovery.
• Purdue WR Cortez Smith: The Boilers need a No. 1 receiver to emerge after losing Keith Smith, and Cortez Smith looks reads to fill the void. He recorded five receptions for 117 yards and two touchdowns against Ball State. He'll share the game ball with defenders Gerald Gooden (5 tackles, forced fumble, pass breakup), Kawann Short (two pass breakups, blocked PAT) and Jason Werner (INT, 1 TFL).

How bizarre: The league-wide special teams struggles as well as a few odd highlights stood out in Week 3. Who can remember the last time the Big Ten had so many meltdowns with punting, kicking, kickoff coverage and punt coverage? Then again, the three biggest plays on Saturday came in the kicking game: Michigan State's game-winning fake field goal, Johnson's touchdown-saving tackle on a kickoff return and Valai's PAT block to preserve a 20-19 lead.

OK, moving on to Week 4. Do we have to? I know it's my job to get your excited for Big Ten football 24-7-365, but this week provides a major challenge, to say the least.

Northern Colorado (2-1) at Michigan State (3-0): Spartans offensive coordinator Don Treadwell takes over the head-coaching duties from Mark Dantonio, who suffered a mild heart attack following the Notre Dame win. The Spartans look for a more complete defensive performance before Wisconsin visits on Oct. 2.

Central Michigan (2-1) at Northwestern (3-0): Northwestern aims for its second perfect nonconference mark in the past three seasons after going 35 years with at least one non-league loss. Central Michigan should test Davie and the Wildcats' defense, which has forced nine turnovers in the first three games.

Bowling Green (1-2) at Michigan (3-0): The Wolverines' sputtering defense likely won't face Falcons starting quarterback Matt Schilz, who isn't expected to play because of a shoulder injury. Michigan's offense will light up the scoreboard, but the D has to get better before Big Ten play.

Austin Peay (2-1) at Wisconsin (3-0): Yawn. If Wisconsin can't dominate the Governors (ello, guvna!), Badgers fans should get worried. This provides a good chance for the Badgers to assess their depth on both sides of the ball.

Ball State (1-2) at Iowa (2-1): Although the Cardinals hung in there at Purdue, Iowa should have no trouble Saturday. The bigger question is whether the Hawkeyes can clean up their play in the kicking game, on the offensive line and in the secondary after the Arizona loss.

Toledo (2-1) at Purdue (2-1): Quarterback Robert Marve's left knee injury doesn't appear to be serious, and the Boilers need to get No. 9 through this game and into the bye week without further setbacks. Arizona shredded Toledo's defense in the season opener, and Purdue should have opportunities to further develop a receiving corps missing star Keith Smith.

Eastern Michigan (0-3) at Ohio State (3-0): The Buckeyes could score 70 in this one. I'm not kidding. Eastern Michigan has surrendered 111 points in its first three games.

Temple (3-0) at Penn State (2-1): This is the most interesting game in the Big Ten. Temple heads to State College with a ton of confidence as coach Al Golden might be auditioning for the Nittany Lions' faithful. Penn State's running back race now is open as slumping senior Evan Royster tries to hold off junior Stephfon Green and dynamic freshman Silas Redd. Should be a good one in Happy Valley.

Akron (0-3) at Indiana (2-0): Ben Chappell and the Hoosiers' offense likely will carve up another bad team Saturday, as Akron has been blown out by Syracuse and Kentucky and lost at home to Gardner-Webb (ouch). The bigger question is whether the Hoosiers' defense can shut down the Zips.

Northern Illinois (1-2) at Minnesota (1-2): It's must-win time for embattled coach Tim Brewster and his Golden Gophers, who performed a lot better Saturday against USC but still couldn't finish off a good team. Northern Illinois will test Minnesota's new-look defense with quarterback Chandler Harnish, and Minnesota needs to reignite the run game despite Duane Bennett's ankle issues.

Bye: Illinois (2-1)

As play gets started here in Madison and in Minneapolis, here's my take on what has happened so far around the Big Ten today.

The league boasts a perfect 5-0 record, although there are some concerns in several places.

Ohio State 43, Ohio 7: The Buckeyes continued to look like one of the nation's best teams Saturday. Then again, Ohio made it pretty easy for the Scarlet and Gray, committing five turnovers to give itself absolutely no chance in this one. There are a ton of positives for Ohio State right now, but the best is the fact the Buckeyes' defense has maintained its opportunistic play from 2009, when it tied for third nationally in takeaways (35). Ohio State has forced 12 turnovers in the first three games and committed only two of its own. Quarterback Terrelle Pryor had an efficient first half (17-for-20 passing, 2 TDs) but threw his first two interceptions of the season.

Michigan 42, Massachusetts 37: It looked really dicey for a while as Massachusetts built a 17-7 lead late in the first half and rallied late, but the Michigan offense made sure this wouldn't be Appalachian State Part II. Denard Robinson committed his first turnover of the season early on but did little else wrong, putting up more insane offensive numbers (241 passing, 105 rushing, 3 total TDs). He got big lifts from running back Michael Shaw (12 carries, 126 rush yards, 3 TDs) and wide receiver Darryl Stonum (3 receptions, 121 receiving yards, 2 TDs). For all the good news on offense, Michigan's defense looks very vulnerable and likely will cost the Wolverines several games once Big Ten play begins. Massachusetts racked up 26 first downs and 439 yards against the Wolverines, who are really struggling in the back end.

Penn State 24, Kent State 0: The shutout is nice, Penn State fans should be a little worried now. Something is wrong with All-Big Ten running back Evan Royster. The senior had another pedestrian performance (11 carries, 38 yards, 1 TD) against a good run defense, but teammate Stephfon Green (11 carries, 59 rush yards) found some room to roam. After scoring two touchdowns in the first 11 minutes, Penn State couldn't find the end zone until midway through the fourth quarter. Quarterback Rob Bolden, looking a bit like a freshman these days, tossed two interceptions and Royster fumbled early in the second half.

Purdue 24, Ball State 13: Purdue survived its first game without All-Big Ten wideout Keith Smith, but starting quarterback Robert Marve left today's game with an apparent left leg injury. Cortez Smith stepped up nicely in place of Smith against Ball State, recording five receptions for 117 yards and two touchdowns. Backup quarterback Rob Henry provided a nice lift with a touchdown pass and 65 rushing yards and a touchdown, but the injury bug keeps hitting Purdue hard this season. Purdue's defense did a nice job, as Ricardo Allen and Jason Werner recorded interceptions and Ball State finished with only 106 pass yards.

Illinois 28, Northern Illinois 22: You can't underestimate the importance of this win for Ron Zook's squad. The Illini didn't want to head into the bye week at 1-2, especially with a daunting stretch to open Big Ten play (Ohio State, Penn State, Michigan State). Northern Illinois took a first-quarter lead behind talented quarterback Chandler Harnish, but the Illini rallied and then held off the Huskies. It's about time people start giving Mikel LeShoure some credit. He has been one of the nation's best running backs since late last season and put up more big numbers today (24 carries, 180 rush yards, 1 TD). Quarterback Nathan Scheelhaase struggled with his passing but contributed 115 rush yards and a touchdown. Although Harnish gave Illinois fits with his legs and his arm, Vic Koenning's defense did enough to secure the victory.

Purdue's recent struggles in defending the run just don't add up.

The Boilers have had their share of outstanding defenders the last two seasons, particularly in the front seven. Remember these names?

• All-Big Ten end Ryan Kerrigan has recorded 20 sacks, 30 tackles for loss and nine forced fumbles in the last pwo seasons.
• Tackle Mike Neal recorded 11.5 tackles for loss and 5.5 sacks last fall before becoming a second-round pick in the NFL draft by the Green Bay Packers.
• Linebacker Jason Werner racked up 14.5 tackles for loss, 4.5 sacks and two forced fumbles last fall.
• Safety Torri Williams recorded 167 tackles in his final two seasons as a Boilermaker.
• Tackle Alex Magee was a third-round draft pick of the Kansas City Chiefs after finishing his Purdue career in 2008.
• Another lineman who played in 2008, Ryan Baker, is now with the Miami Dolphins.

With so many individual standouts, how has Purdue finished last in the Big Ten in rushing defense in each of the past two seasons?

"It's everybody against the run," co-defensive coordinator/defensive line coach Gary Emanuel told me Tuesday night. "It's not just the front seven, it's not just the back end. It's everybody, together."

Purdue has struggled to find that cohesion on a consistent basis. Gaps haven't always been controlled. The line hasn't always fit where it's supposed to. And when opposing ball-carriers break through the first wall of defenders, tackles haven't always been made.

Enter Emanuel, a seasoned defensive line coach whose extensive résumé includes a previous stint at Purdue from 1997-2004. He worked alongside current Boilers head coach Danny Hope from 1997-2001 and mentored standout linemen like Anthony Spencer, Shaun Phillips and Akin Ayodele.

When Emanuel returned to West Lafayette, he saw a defense that had the parts but didn't always play well as a whole.

The best news?

"The biggest thing is we don't have guys with a bunch of egos," Emanuel said.

Kerrigan sets the tone for the group. He's one of the nation's best pass rushers, but you'd never guess it if you met him off the field.

Emanuel sees similarities between Kerrigan and the other stars he has coached, including Spencer, Phillips and former Boiler Rob Ninkovich.

"They loved football, they didn't have egos, they loved practicing, they loved to play, they were interested in learning and they wanted to be good," Emanuel said. "He's [Kerrigan] probably one of the more coachable big-time players I've been around. He has no ego at all."

Kerrigan and junior end Gerald Gooden have taken charge of the group, but Emanuel also likes his young linemen like Kawann Short, Brandon Taylor, Justin Kitchens and Bruce Gaston, a true freshman who should see the field this fall. He hopes the sum of the parts finally stuffs the run in 2010.

"You have to do some scheming, but it’s basically fundamentals: emphasize tackling a little bit more, having a system of tackling, having a team that runs to the ball, emphasizing 11 hats to the ball," Emanuel said of his preseason plan. "It's a work in progress.

"It’s not going to be fixed overnight, but it has to be."

Purdue officially wraps up spring practice Wednesday, but the team has voted on six co-captains for the 2010 season. The six captains marks the most in Purdue history, surpassing the five selected in 1992.

Drum roll, please ...

• Senior DE Ryan Kerrigan
• Senior LB Jason Werner
• Junior DE Gerald Gooden
• Senior TE Kyle Adams
• Senior FB Dan Dierking
• Senior WR Keith Smith

Some predictable choices here, including Werner, who also served as a captain in 2009. Werner received a sixth year of eligibility from the NCAA in February and told me he hoped to serve as a captain again this fall.

"With another year of experience and now that it’s official that I’m the oldest guy on the team, it's one of those things I'd like to take," he said in late February. "You’ve been around the most, you've seen the most, so you've got the most information to give and help the other guys. I really take that on as a personal challenge to do what I can."

Smith missed spring ball following wrist surgery but spent time coaching the other wide receivers. He brings good vocal leadership to the table.

It's not a surprise at all that quarterback Robert Marve wasn't named a captain, as he hasn't played a game for Purdue yet. But all indications this spring suggested Marve, who had his troubles at Miami, is establishing himself as a leader on offense and earning his teammates' respect.

The thought first dawned on me late Friday afternoon in Columbus, as large groups of reporters circled around Ohio State linebackers Ross Homan and Brian Rolle after practice. Finally, Homan and Rolle were getting the attention they deserved.

One problem you encounter when a league boasts so many elite players at one position is that most of them tend to get overlooked. The Big Ten had three consensus selections for first-team all-conference in 2009: Michigan State's Greg Jones, Penn State's Navorro Bowman and Iowa's Pat Angerer. I'd put those three against any group in college football, and I'd like my chances. If you're running a 3-4 scheme, toss in Wisconsin linebacker Chris Borland, the Big Ten Freshman of the Year in 2009.

But the performances of Jones, Bowman, Angerer and Borland overshadowed guys like Homan. How many linebackers record 108 tackles, five interceptions, 10 passes defended, five tackles for loss, a forced fumble and two fumble recoveries and don't make first-team all-conference?

The good thing for Homan is he has another season to get the attention he deserves. The same can't be said for Minnesota's all-senior linebacking corps of Nate Triplett, Lee Campbell and Simoni Lawrence, each of whom ranked among the Big Ten's tackles leaders last fall. Or Indiana's Matt Mayberry, a blog favorite who flew under the radar. Or Iowa's A.J. Edds, who finished the season with five interceptions and nine passes defended. Penn State's Josh Hull got some love with a second-team All-Big Ten pick from the coaches, but his value to the defense wasn't really known outside Happy Valley.

Those players have moved on, but here are a few linebackers who will step into the spotlight in 2010:

Ross Homan, Sr., Ohio State
2009 stats: 108 tackles, 5 interceptions, 10 passes defended, 5 tackles for loss, 1 forced fumble, 2 fumble recoveries

Brian Rolle, Sr., Ohio State
2009 stats: 95 tackles, 7 tackles for loss, 1 interception, 1 fumble recovery, 2 passes defended

Quentin Davie, Sr., Northwestern
2009 stats: 90 tackles, 11.5 tackles for loss, 5 sacks, 4 forced fumbles, 6 quarterback hurries, 1 interception

Jason Werner, Sr., Purdue
2009 stats: 77 tackles, 14.5 tackles for loss, 4.5 sacks, 2 forced fumbles, 1 interception, 3 passes defended

Eric Gordon, Sr., Michigan State
2009 stats: 92 tackles, 7.5 tackles for loss, 3.5 sacks, 1 forced fumble, 1 blocked kick

Jeremiha Hunter, Sr., Iowa
2009 stats: 89 tackles, 2 forced fumbles, 1 blocked kick, 1 interception, 5 passes defended

Mike Taylor, So., Wisconsin
2009 stats: 46 tackles, 6.5 tackles for loss, 1 forced fumble, 1 fumble recovery, 1 interception, led the team in tackles before suffering season-ending injury against Iowa on Oct. 17.

Tyler Replogle, Sr., Indiana
2009 stats: 80 tackles, 6.5 tackles for loss, 2 sacks, 1 interception, 2 pass breakups

Joe Holland, Jr., Purdue
2009 stats: 81 tackles, 3.5 tackles for loss, 1.5 sacks, 1 interception, 2 passes defended

Ian Thomas, Jr., Illinois
2009 stats: 95 tackles, 4.5 tackles for loss, 4 passes defended, 1 sack, 1 fumble recovery

Purdue's injury-plagued spring practice has claimed a big piece of the offense.

Junior running back Ralph Bolden, the Big Ten's third leading rusher last season (77.9 ypg), suffered a non-contact injury to his right knee Wednesday in practice. Head coach Danny Hope didn't know the extent of Bolden's injury Friday but described it as serious and said the running back would be out for the rest of spring practice and possibly longer.

According to The (Lafayette) Journal and Courier, the Boilers coaches are preparing for the possibility Bolden won't play during the 2010 season. Bolden suffered a torn ACL in the same knee during his senior year of high school.

"If he's healthy and ready to go, we would love to have him," Hope said. "But we're not going to put our eggs all in one basket. We have to get some other guys ready to go."

Bolden would be a big loss for Purdue, which moves sophomore Al-Terek McBurse into the starting role this spring and also had wide receiver Keith Carlos switch to running back. Bolden's breakaway speed helped him briefly lead the nation in rushing last fall, and he had worked hard to improve his strength and vision during the offseason.

Injuries are really piling up for Purdue, which is without 20 players and 10 starters, including defensive end Ryan Kerrigan, linebacker Jason Werner and kicker Carson Wiggs. It's so bad that the Boilers postponed practices Saturday and Monday and will make them up after the spring game on April 19 and April 21.

Spring (football) is in the air.

• Indiana will be more multiple on defense in 2010, using both three-man and four-man fronts, Dustin Dopirak writes in The (Bloomington) Herald-Times (subscription required).
• There's no official word from Wisconsin on backup quarterback Curt Phillips, but Phillips' knee injury appears serious, Jeff Potrykus writes in the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. Injuries are piling up throughout the Badgers' offense, Jim Polzin writes in The Capital Times.
• Injuries will also impact Purdue this spring, as linebacker Jason Werner and others are out, Mike Carmin writes in The (Lafayette) Journal and Courier.
• Jobs are open throughout Minnesota's depth chart this spring, including the one at quarterback, John Shipley writes in the (St. Paul) Pioneer Press. The Star Tribune's Kent Youngblood examines key questions for the Gophers as spring ball begins.
• The Chicago Bears were keeping a close eye on Iowa's pro day, ESPNChicago.com's Jeff Dickerson writes. If you missed Marc Morehouse's position-by-position look at Iowa in 2010, check it out here.
• The kicking game is in the spotlight this spring at Michigan, which must replace both starting specialists, annarbor.com's Dave Birkett writes.
• Penn State's turnaround since 2005 can be traced to the signing of heralded recruit Derrick Williams, Matt Brown writes in The Daily Collegian.

The spring superlatives series, which examines the strongest and weakest position groups for each Big Ten team, marches on with Purdue.

After winning four of its final six games, Purdue has high hopes for 2010. The Boilermakers return a lot of skill players on offense, and Miami transfer Robert Marve looks like the front-runner to take over at quarterback. The defense needs to fill all four starting spots in the secondary, but end Ryan Kerrigan and linebacker Jason Werner lead the front seven.

Strongest position: Wide receiver/tight end

• Key returnees: Keith Smith (91 receptions, 1,100 receiving yards, 6 TDs); Kyle Adams (29 receptions, 249 receiving yards); Keith Carlos (21 receptions, 242 receiving yards, 1 TD); running back Ralph Bolden (20 receptions, 261 receiving yards, 2 TDs); Cortez Smith (17 receptions, 177 receiving yards, 2 TDs); Jeff Lindsay (16 receptions 162 receiving yards).
• Key losses: Aaron Valentin (54 receptions, 621 receiving yards, 7 TDs).
• The skinny: A year ago, the Boilers had huge questions here as Smith was the lone returnee with any significant experience. Purdue now boasts one of the Big Ten's deepest group of pass-catchers, led by Smith, who topped the league in receiving yards last fall and earned first-team all-conference honors from the media. Purdue needs a new No. 2 wideout, but hopes are high for Cortez Smith and Carlos. The coaches are also high on young wideouts Antavian Edison and Gary Bush. The tight end position should be very solid with both Adams and Lindsay in the fold.

Weakest position: Defensive back

• Key returnees: Albert Evans (30 tackles, 2 pass breakups)
• Key losses: Torri Williams (84 tackles, 2 INTs, 1 forced fumble, 2 fumble recoveries, 8 passes defended); Dwight Mclean (62 tackles, 1 INT, 1 forced fumble, 4 passes defended); David Pender (40 tackles, 1 INT, 14 passes defended, 1 blocked kick, 1 forced fumble, 1 fumble recovery); Brandon King (30 tackles, 3 INTs, 1 forced fumble, 1 fumble recovery, 5 passes defended).
• The skinny: Purdue loses all four starters in the secondary, including tackles leader Williams and second-team All-Big Ten selections in Pender and King. Evans is the lone returnee with significant experience, and he'll miss spring practice with an injury. Players like junior college transfer Mike Eargle, Charlton Williams, Gavin Roberts and Chris Quinn need to step up this spring. "We have a lot of depth issues in the secondary," head coach Danny Hope said.