Grantland: Blue and Gold and Red All Over
May, 29, 2012
5/29/12
4:00
PM CT
By
Matt Fortuna | ESPNChicago.com
Grantland's Michael Weinreb penned a piece on the future of Notre Dame football this past weekend, and the story is worth checking out.
Weinreb revisits the program's history, reminding us that there were, in fact, other dark periods before this one, and he looks at the all-encompassing job it takes to win with the Irish in the present day of college football.
I've seen the piece generate a good amount of discussion so far on the internet, and was curious to hear from you guys on it. Is there more to winning at Notre Dame than just having the right (and, in many ways, perfect) head coach? Drop me a note in the mailbag and I'll run the best responses later on.
Weinreb revisits the program's history, reminding us that there were, in fact, other dark periods before this one, and he looks at the all-encompassing job it takes to win with the Irish in the present day of college football.
The bigger question, of course, is whether anyone can really get it anymore. This is now the most fallow period in Notre Dame history; the longer it goes on, the more pervasive the sense that Notre Dame football is gone for good, that the Irish may hang around Saturday afternoons on a third-place network desperate for a foothold in the sporting universe, but will never really be relevant to the 21st century. With every Champs Sports Bowl defeat, the notion that a small, independent Midwest Catholic institution with high academic standards can become a national power -- and can recruit nationally -- in a sport weighted toward the South (and toward superconferences) starts to feel less and less tenable.
"Davie and Willingham and Weis all led them to nine- or 10-win seasons," says Lou Somogyi, a senior editor at Blue & Gold Illustrated and a longtime chronicler of Notre Dame football. "But can they get to that 11- or 12- or 13-game thing? It's very hard. The world changes, and sometimes you have to be willing to change with it. Just because that's how you've always done it doesn't mean it's right."
I've seen the piece generate a good amount of discussion so far on the internet, and was curious to hear from you guys on it. Is there more to winning at Notre Dame than just having the right (and, in many ways, perfect) head coach? Drop me a note in the mailbag and I'll run the best responses later on.

- coachfitz51 Pat Fitzgerald
“@DaveEanet: @coachfitz51 Stay away from the 2 horse in the 7th race: Red Wings!” Go @NHLBlackhawks
about 6 hours ago
- coachfitz51 Pat Fitzgerald

- coachfitz51 Pat Fitzgerald
On our way to #preakness ...THANK YOU @UnderArmour for an amazing weekend- let's go racing! GO CATS!
about 6 hours ago
- coachfitz51 Pat Fitzgerald

- ESPNChiColleges ESPNChicago
Source: Marcius to transfer to DePaul http://t.co/IBdRxuXnlC
1 day ago
- ESPNChiColleges ESPNChicago

- ESPNChiColleges ESPNChicago
DePaul clear winner in arena deal http://t.co/E3hriL04Tx
1 day ago
- ESPNChiColleges ESPNChicago

- coachbeckman Tim Beckman
Good Luck to Michaela Ward and Meredith Thomas in Sectional Final today! Score those Goals!
1 day ago
- coachbeckman Tim Beckman

- coachbeckman Tim Beckman
Good luck to Michaela Ward today in the Sectional Championship! Score those Goals!
1 day ago
- coachbeckman Tim Beckman

- coachbeckman Tim Beckman
Grades will be in today and Monday. Last 3 semesters the Fighting Illini have set a new record for team GPA and over 3.0! Do it again!
1 day ago
- coachbeckman Tim Beckman

- coachbeckman Tim Beckman
The Illini Travel Camps will be up in Chicago on June 1 and 2! We will travel to Southern Illinois on June 8th! See you around OUR state!
1 day ago
- coachbeckman Tim Beckman

- coachfitz51 Pat Fitzgerald
RT @jschmidt39: Great NClub event tonight with fmr NU student-athletes! Great seeing @CoreyWootton too! Go Cats! #B1GCATS http://t.co/NlXs…
1 day ago
- coachfitz51 Pat Fitzgerald

- coachfitz51 Pat Fitzgerald
RT @RaferWeigel: .@DinaBairWGN gave a very moving speech today about surviving cancer at her awards lunch. Uplifting and heartwarming. She'…
1 day ago
- coachfitz51 Pat Fitzgerald

- ESPNChiColleges ESPNChicago
Video: Northwestern AD Jim Phillips http://t.co/JaGgl0WO09
2 days ago
- ESPNChiColleges ESPNChicago

- ESPNChiColleges ESPNChicago
Big Ten releases 2014 football schedule http://t.co/ig5YoPLVvH
2 days ago
- ESPNChiColleges ESPNChicago

- NDMikeBrey Mike Brey
Finished my 1st ACC mtgs. What a powerful basketball conference that has become. It will quickly become the league to get 8-10 NCAA bids.
2 days ago
- NDMikeBrey Mike Brey

- coachfitz51 Pat Fitzgerald
“@TeddyGreenstein: Headed to Wilmette GC for an "18" with Loyola's ... RT @PorterMoser: MT- have fun coach!
2 days ago
- coachfitz51 Pat Fitzgerald

- Howard_Moore Howard Moore
RT @MattLepay: Fun to see @JLeu30 & the Memphis Grizzlies advance to the Western Conf. finals.
2 days ago
- Howard_Moore Howard Moore

- coachbeckman Tim Beckman
Sign up for our Women's 101 camp on May 29 at Memorial Stadium. Camp will include technique/officiating & game day experience! Join the fun
2 days ago
- coachbeckman Tim Beckman

- coachbeckman Tim Beckman
Illini Staff will be on the road for the next 15 days finishing up our May evaluation period. 9 scholarships left! Go Fighting Illini!
2 days ago
- coachbeckman Tim Beckman

- coachfitz51 Pat Fitzgerald
RT @ChicagoSports: RT @kcjhoop: Thibodeau: "Obviously we’re disappointed in losing the series. But I was never disappointed in our team." #…
2 days ago
- coachfitz51 Pat Fitzgerald

- coachfitz51 Pat Fitzgerald
RT @NUFBFamily: Do your thing, #B1GCats fans. RT @BTNBrentYarina: Ready, set, VOTE in BTN's #B1G helmet bracket - http://t.co/uYUpv1t5wc.
2 days ago
- coachfitz51 Pat Fitzgerald

- Howard_Moore Howard Moore
My beloved @chicagobulls should be commended by how they competed with heart and determination all season long! #championshiprun2014
2 days ago
- Howard_Moore Howard Moore



ESPNCHICAGO.COM COLLEGES ON TWITTER
You must be signed in to post a comment