Whatever the answer is, the quarterback will face the same challenge on Saturday by making his first career start. We can't peer into the future to see what the end result will be. (Hey, as Bill O'Brien likes to say, we're no genies.)
But we can look back to see how the last five Penn State quarterbacks fared in their first career starts. Here they are:
Matt McGloin, redshirt sophomore vs. Michigan on Oct. 30, 2010 Outcome:PSU 41-31 Stats: 17-of-28 for 250 yards, one touchdown, no interceptions
Synopsis: After Rob Bolden suffered a head injury against Minnesota the week before, McGloin became the next man up. He was the first former walk-on to ever start under Joe Paterno.
After holding on to a 14-10 lead late in the second quarter, McGloin led PSU on two touchdown drives to give the Lions a 28-10 advantage by halftime. Said Paterno after the game: "That's about as well as we can play."
Rob Bolden made history in 2010 as the first true freshman quarterback to start an opener for Penn State under coach Joe Paterno.
Rob Bolden, true freshman vs. Youngstown State on Sept. 4, 2010 Outcome:PSU 44-14 Stats: 20-of-29 for 239 yards, two touchdowns, one interception
Synopsis: He was the first true freshman in a century to start an opener for Penn State, and he fared relatively well against lesser competition.
PSU started off slow and led just 16-7 at halftime, but Bolden was able to get some breathing room when Chaz Powell returned the second-half kickoff 100 yards for a touchdown. Bolden didn't get much help from the running game -- Evan Royster had 40 yards on 11 carries -- but PSU dominated after the touchdown return.
Daryll Clark, redshirt junior vs. Coastal Carolina on Aug. 30, 2008 Outcome:PSU 66-10 Stats: 11-of-14 for 146 yards, one touchdown, no interceptions
Synopsis: Penn State performed as expected against an FCS cupcake and didn't even really need to pass. PSU rushed for 334 yards and led 38-0 by halftime.
Pat Devlin and Paul Cianciolo played later in the game because, well, there was really no reason for Clark to risk injury. Clark said this afterward: "When you first start, you want everything to go right. I don't think I got touched today."
Anthony Morelli, junior vs. Akron on Sept. 2, 2006 Outcome:PSU 34-16 Stats: 16-of-32 for 206 yards, three touchdowns, no interceptions
Synopsis: Morelli started off hot and drove the Lions to a score on their first drive, on a 42-yard touchdown pass to Deon Butler. He was 7-of-10 passing for 110 yards and two scores on just his first three drives -- and he was the first PSU quarterback since joining the Big Ten to throw three TDs in his first career start.
Said Akron coach J.D. Brookhart: "That kid can throw from one half to the other, 20 yards deep. You won't see a better arm this year."
Michael Robinson, redshirt sophomore vs. Wisconsin on Oct. 4, 2003 Outcome:Wisconsin 30-23 Stats: 22-of-43 for 379 yards, two touchdowns, no interceptions; nine carries for 19 yards
Synopsis: Robinson stepped up when Zack Mills went down the week before with a sprained left knee, and he performed admirably. Although PSU didn't win, Robinson guided PSU on touchdown drives of 74, 80 and 70 yards. And, at the time, only one other PSU quarterback (Mills) had thrown for more yards in a game.
Robinson said this to the Philadelphia Inquirer: "Before the game, I kind of thought they would blitz me a little more, because that's what you usually do to a guy making his first start. You kind of want to get in his head a little bit. They played back and basically told me, 'Look, if you're going to beat us, you're going to have to throw the ball.' And I think we did a pretty good job."