Ultimately, Garrett and the Cowboys chose Tyron Smith over J.J. Watt - and the decision wasn’t really that difficult.
The offensive line needed to be re-built because the Cowboys had released Marc Colombo, Leonard Davis and Kyle Kosier in the offseason and the defensive line, at the time, was in good shape with defensive ends Kenyon Coleman and Jason Hatcher and nose guard Jay Ratliff.
Watt said he spoke with the Cowboys at the combine, but they didn’t invite him to Dallas or speak with him at Wisconsin.
“When they were on the clock at No.9 that was the first time my family and I really started to watch what was going on,” Watt said. “You never know where you’re going to go or how things are going to work out but let’s start tuning in right now
Besides, Garrett believed the only way the Cowboys could become a contender again was with a dynamic offensive line.
“Certainly that first pick was critical for us,” Garrett said. “We had let three veteran offensive lineman go and we were really young and under-resourced there and we felt like we needed to get some cornerstone players.
“We were fortunate that Tyron Smith was coming out that year. We felt he could be a left tackle and be a cornerstone player for us for a long time. Remember he was only 20-years-old at the time and he was coming out early and we just felt like he had all of the traits to be a great, great player for a long time at a really important position.”
Smith played right tackle as a rookie and did a solid job. He was above average in 2012, his first year at left tackle, but midway through the 2013 season he became a dominant player.
Last year, he earned his first trip to the Pro Bowl.
“Often times it’s difficult to identify a player’s intangibles. By definition, you can’t see intangibles but we always argue that you can see evidence of them in their play. (Tyron) got ringing endorsements from everyone around him and he jumped off the tape at us.
“He was a young player who had everything: Physical ability. Mental make up. He played at a big school and was productive. We felt if we could get him in here he could be a great player for us.”
IRVING, Texas -- The Dallas Cowboys host the Houston Texans at AT&T Stadium for the first time in the $1.2 billion stadium's history, and it's a surprisingly big game, with these teams a combined 6-2 after they were a combined 10-22 last season.
When these teams met on Oct. 15, 2006, at Texas Stadium, Tony Romo threw the first two passes of his career in mop-up duty of a 34-6 Cowboys win.
NFL Nation reporters Tania Ganguli and Todd Archer offer up this week's Game Preview:
Todd Archer: The Cowboys are a surprising 3-1. The Texans are a surprising 3-1. I'm still on the fence about how real the Cowboys truly are. Are you ready to take the Texans for real?
Tania Ganguli: Well, I don't like to think too much about these things because when I do I tend to talk myself out of my correct first instincts. Back in the preseason when we had to predict the schedule I thought the Texans would start 3-1, beating Washington, Oakland and Buffalo while losing to the Giants. This part of the schedule is a kinder, gentler portion, which is especially useful to the Texans for two reasons. First, it allows a team with a new coaching staff to sort things out. Second, the Texans have had to play without No. 1 overall pick Jadeveon Clowney, who is probably two or three weeks from returning, and it hasn't hurt them as much as it could have. I think this team will get better as the season progresses because of those two factors, but I also think the Texans will have much tougher tests than they had in their three wins. And I think that will start this week -- I certainly didn't anticipate the Cowboys being as hot as they are heading into this week.
I half expected the Cowboys to blow Sunday night's game against the Saints. I guess I'm on the fence about them, too. You know them better: What's keeping you from thinking the Cowboys are for real?
Archer: I guess it's just recent history. They were impressive against the Saints last week, but, like you, I was already beginning to think about epic-collapse angles when New Orleans made it 31-17 early in the fourth quarter. Just when you think the Cowboys have things figured out, they revert back to form. It wouldn't surprise me to see them play poorly Sunday. This team does not have a lot of margin for error, especially defensively. And for as well as we all said the Cowboys played against the Saints, they still allowed 438 yards and that came after they allowed an Austin Davis-led offense for the St. Louis Rams to put up 448 yards. My trepidation has nothing to do with the offense, although it has had too many turnovers. It's about the defense. I still see a lot of warts and not a lot of depth. What the Cowboys have done is make timely plays. I don't think they can be expected to just shut down opponents. If they can make them drive the field, then that's OK. Who knows, maybe if they win this week I'll change my tune?
For years we were able to marvel at some of the things DeMarcus Ware did with the Cowboys. I'm wondering if that's the same way with J.J. Watt. Is there anything he can't do?
Ganguli: Well, Texans kicker Randy Bullock said he's never seen him kick. So there's no proof he can do that. He is also not good at golf, unless he's made great strides since he and I talked about this topic a year ago. And he's shown a distinct lack of ability to celebrate in a cool-enough fashion for some of his teammates when he scores touchdowns. Watt has taken a lot of heat, some of it from himself, for that hand in the air, sort of high-step thing he did as he crossed into the end zone after his 80-yard pick-six against the Bills. In all seriousness, though, Watt has a habit of finding a new way to amaze over and over again. Beyond the interception, he had nine quarterback hits on Sunday, which was more than any player had in the first three games of the season combined. Watt is constantly thinking of new ways to use his freakish athletic ability, and he's finding them. His position doesn't really fit into any traditional label -- he's defining it as he goes. And what makes Watt so valuable to the Texans is that really the only way to neutralize him is to pay him a lot of attention. When that happens, it can open up opportunities for other members of the Texans' front.
How big is the loss of Morris Claiborne for this team and how will it change what the Cowboys do?
Archer: It's funny how Watt is such a vital piece to that defense and the Cowboys were hoping Claiborne, whom they moved up to take with the sixth pick of the 2012 draft, would have the same impact on their secondary. It just hasn't happened. Some of it is injury. Some of it is poor play and a lack of confidence. As for the loss of Claiborne, I don't think it will be that big a deal and it definitely won't change what the Cowboys do. What changes is who they do it with. Sterling Moore will take over as the No. 3 corner and he's played better than Claiborne and maybe should have played more anyway. He's a smart player and knows what he can't do so he keeps himself in good spots. I don't know if the Cowboys will be appreciably better with Claiborne out for the season, but I don't believe they will be worse. Saying that about the loss of a high first-round pick compared to a former undrafted player is certainly damning.
To me what was somewhat impressive in seeing the Texans last week was seeing them have success without Arian Foster or Andre Johnson having to carry the day. Are we seeing a changing of the guard with that offense?
Ganguli: The Texans did have success, but they had a lot of problems offensively and their running game is something Texans coach Bill O'Brien talked about needing to improve after Sunday. Foster admitted to not being 100 percent healthy during that game and he had only eight carries. The Texans rushed for just 37 yards. You can commend the Texans for figuring out a way to win without doing what they like to do, which is run the ball effectively. As for Johnson, he is a great safety blanket for quarterback Ryan Fitzpatrick, if he needs it. Johnson is a smart player who runs routes well and communicates well with both his quarterback and his coaches. As they're playing together more, though, Fitzpatrick is clearly developing more confidence in second-year receiver DeAndre Hopkins. It's looking like he's starting to believe more and more, as Hopkins piles up his athletic grabs, that Hopkins will catch any jump ball that goes his way.
What's gotten into DeMarco Murray?
Archer: It's more like what's gotten into the Cowboys' playcaller, Scott Linehan. They're actually calling runs and calling a lot of them. Murray has always been productive, but they just didn't call on him as much. The Cowboys have invested three first-round picks in the offensive line in the past four years and have hit on Tyron Smith, Travis Frederick and Zack Martin. They finally have the pieces in place to back up their actions. Murray's numbers, however, are pretty staggering. He's done something only Jim Brown, O.J. Simpson and Emmitt Smith have done with four straight 100-yard and one-touchdown games to open a season. That's ridiculous company. He's carried it 99 times in the first four games for 534 yards. He's breaking long runs. He's making tough runs. The line is doing a great job. As a result that has taken pressure off Tony Romo to do everything. It's a simple formula that the Cowboys have finally figured out.
Police spokesperson Barry Bowling said a report was filed Sept. 20 and that the matter is still under investigation. Spillman hasn't been charged or arrested.
According to a source, Spillman, who was signed by the Cowboys on Aug. 31, has cooperated fully in the investigation.
Police say the incident occurred at the Gaylord Hotel on Sept. 20, the day before the Cowboys played at St. Louis. The team flew to St. Louis later that Saturday, and Spillman played against the Rams that Sunday.
There was no immediate response from the Cowboys. Spillman's agent, Ron Slavin, and attorney Bruce Ashworth declined to comment to The Associated Press.
Several Cowboys players stay at the Gaylord Hotel until they find apartments, which is the case with Spillman.
Attorney Gloria Allred earlier Wednesday sent a letter to Jeff Pash, the NFL's executive vice president and general counsel regarding the alleged assault.
In the letter, Allred said Pash invited the alleged victim to be interviewed by NFL investigators "on a confidential and appropriate basis."
Allred's letter raises concern about the type of interview her client might have with league officials.
"The fact that you chose to make public your requests to interview our client confidentially causes us concern about whether the interview itself would be kept confidential or tweeted out by you as you did with your letter to me," Allred's letter to Pash said. "However, I am willing to meet with you to discuss your request and also to learn the answers to our important questions posed in my original letter to you (which was not shared with the press)."
The results could not have been better. Romo has completed 40 of 52 passes for 479 yards and five touchdowns and one interception since undergoing this routine.
"You want to feel healthy," Romo said. "You want to feel good. You want to feel like you're maximizing your opportunities to be at your best within each day and obviously within each week and start over and do it again. I don't think about it anymore than that."
Romo took part in Wednesday's walkthrough and spent the early part of the regular practice in the weight room. When the team portion of practice starts, Romo is on the practice field observing the plan.
"It's a full day for him," coach Jason Garrett said. "There's no question about that."
In each of the last two games, Romo has had runs of 16 and 21 yards. He finished the win against the New Orleans Saints with 20 yards on six carries with his yardage total dipping because of three kneeldowns.
He still outgained Philadelphia Eagles back LeSean McCoy, who had 17 yards on 10 carries last week against the San Francisco 49ers.
"Me and him are battling," Romo joked. "Just the speed out on game days I'm sure. I'm sure he's looking at my moves and seeing if he can incorporate them. I think he's safe. I think at the end of the year when you add it up, he'll probably pass me."
Bryant has not missed a game, but he had been a limited participant in the previous six practices. In the two games since getting hurt Bryant caught nine passes for 133 yards and two touchdowns in wins against the St. Louis Rams and New Orleans Saints.
Linebacker Rolando McClain also went through a full practice for the first time since injuring his groin against the Titans.
Defensive tackle Henry Melton (hamstring) and defensive end Anthony Spencer (knee) were limited. Both played last week against the Saints and barring any setbacks will be available Sunday against the Houston Texans.
Quarterback Tony Romo (back) and linebacker Bruce Carter (quadriceps) were the only Cowboys not to practice. Romo will practice on Thursday, following the same plan he has used the past two weeks. Carter will not play against the Texans, but hopes to return Oct. 12 against the Seattle Seahawks.
This Sunday afternoon, Watt and the Texans visit the Dallas Cowboys in a battle between 3-1 teams.
"He's a tremendous player, like I said, but they also have a lot of good players in their linebacking corps. Jared Crick on the other end is a good player as well," Frederick said. "He's another Big Ten guy. The guys in the middle are big run stoppers and it's not just one guy. We're not playing the Houston J.J. Watts. We're playing the Houston Texans and it's going to be a good challenge."
Watt has more quarterback hits (16) than 13 other NFL teams. The closest player to Watt in terms of quarterback hits is Seattle's Michael Bennett, who has eight. The Cowboys see him in Week 6.
But Watt's ability to rush the passer from different parts of the line of scrimmage is a challenge. As the right defensive end, Watt will meet the left tackle, and in the Cowboys' case that's Tyron Smith, who is coming off his first Pro Bowl season.
"It's always fun going up against a good player, and everybody is in this game for the competition and that's basically all it is," said Smith, who worked out with Watt prior to the 2011 NFL draft. "He's one of the top players at his position, and I give him credit for what he's done so far."
Can the Cowboys control Watt?
Can the Cowboys contain Watt?
"I think it’s the same thing," Frederick said. "He's one part of a bigger defense, and our job is to control and move against the Texans defense."
Last week, Melton (hamstring) didn't practice until Friday and was listed as questionable going into the game against the New Orleans Saints. Melton did play against the Saints.
Defensive end Anthony Spencer (knee), who made his season debut last week, was limited.
Tony Romo (back) and Bruce Carter (thigh) didn't practice on Wednesday. Romo is expected to practice this week and play in Sunday's game against Houston. Carter most likely won't play.
Linebacker Rolando McClain (groin) and wide receiver Dez Bryant (shoulder) were full participants on Wednesday.
When defensive tackle Josh Brent was involved in a car accident in December 2012 and subsequently charged with intoxication manslaughter since the wreck resulted in practice squad player Jerry Brown’s death, the Cowboys deactivated Brent for the final four games of the season.
Brent, who spent nearly five months in jail and 45 days in a rehabilitation facility, rejoined the team this week after the NFL reduced his suspension.
“Part of what our jobs are as coaches is to create the right environment for our players to function both on and off the field,” Garrett said, “so we need to be clear about where we are and we need to be clear that we have a structure in place to help anybody who has any off-the-field issue.
“We have a lot of resources here to help guys, if you’re dealing with anything off the field. That was the first message. Having said that, there are standards we have about all off-the-field behavior and certainly domestic violence applies to that. We’re very clear about how we’re going to handle things.”
Three weeks ago, it was a big deal. Now, it’s considered a blessing for backup quarterback Brandon Weeden to get practice repetitions he’d otherwise never get, while Romo goes through a series of core-strengthening exercises.
In his first two games, Romo completed 42 of 66 passes for 457 yards with two touchdowns, three interceptions and a passer rating of 75.1. In the last two games, Romo has completed 40 of 52 passes for 479 yards with five touchdowns and one interception with a passer rating of 128.6.
He’s also moving better in the pocket, eluding defenders and creating more time to find receivers. He was sacked seven times in the first two games and once in the last two games.
He also has had runs of 16 and 21 yards in the last two games, converting key third-down situations each time.
“I’m continuing to get healthier each week that goes by and that’s encouraging,” Romo said. “My ability to move and react and fire and activate everything when you want it -- for me personally that has been a huge difference since the first two weeks.”
Linebacker Bruce Carter (quad) also missed practice and will miss Sunday's game.
Safety Jakar Hamilton, who was reinstated by the NFL after being suspended the first four games for violations of the league's substance abuse policy, participated in his first practice.
Defensive tackles Henry Melton (hamstring) and Terrell McClain (groin) and linebacker Rolando McClain (groin) took part in individual drills during the open portion of practice. All three practiced just once last week because of health issues.
Kathy Carr is never far from Carr’s mind or body.
“I just know her skin was on it,” the Dallas Cowboys cornerback said twirling the bracelets around his wrist, “so we’re skin-to-skin still.”
Carr’s mother died July 30 after an eight-year battle with breast cancer. She was 59.
On Sunday the Cowboys and NFL will celebrate Breast Cancer Awareness month in an attempt to raise awareness to beat the disease. October has always been special to Carr because of his mother’s fight. The pink cleats, wrist bands and towels he wears are more than just a symbol.
“It means a lot just because of the story behind it, my personal connection,” Carr said. “But in my case, I can smile. It’s a victory that my mom was a strong fighter, courageous. Stood there in the midst of all the cancer, everything going bad for her, and was still able to experience life and her family. That’s what it’s all about to me.”
Barely two months have passed since her death and Carr said he is still trying to digest everything that has taken place. He has closed his inner circle to just a handful of friends. He has leaned on his brother Tony for support on and off the field. Tony put him through those workouts during the summer so he could remain in shape.
His father, John, has been visiting him the last two weeks and was supposed to return to Michigan on Tuesday but Carr asked him to stay longer.
“I think we both need each other,” Carr said. “You know men, we don’t really talk about what’s going on, but we can kind of look at each other ... I just kind of looked at him like, 'You can't leave right now. I need you right here, man.' It's been cool. It’s life. My parents always try to prepare for me something happening in life, even with them, and death and all those things that you try not to think about. It’s inevitable. You never understand it. I’m not trying to understand it. When it’s all said and done, we’ll know why everything happens in this world. You just have to continue to try to live a great legacy and continue to motivate and do great things. That’s what I took from everything my mom went through was she still was trying to get after it and motivate her grandchildren, kids at school or just whoever she came across. I’m going to try to finish out her task.”
Kathy Carr was a teacher for 33 years in the Flint Community Schools. Her devotion to her family and students will never leave Carr.
“I know my mom would be an advocate for getting women of all ages aware and getting the proper medical attention needed to prevent or stop whatever the case may be, or spread awareness,” Carr said. “She was a selfless person. I mean it was never about her. She was always thinking about the next person. I guess I kind of got it from her because I put myself last and think about everyone else.”
On Sunday against the Houston Texans Carr will wear his pink cleats, and he will talk to her before he takes the field. She is gone in body but not in spirit.
“She’s always with me,” he said.
Parcells told that to his players when things were going well. He didn't want them to read about their successes for fear it would infect their work. It was Parcells trying to affect the players' minds.
At 3-1, the Cowboys are something of a surprise. They have the NFL's leading rusher in DeMarco Murray. They have a dominating offensive line. They have a defense that has played better than many thought.
"Don't read your own clippings," Carr said, offering up a definition for don't eat the cheese. "It's 17 weeks and you can't come up for air until the 17 weeks. You know around here how things go in December and January and those last couple of games. It's crucial that, like you said, you don't eat the cheese, keep the chip on your shoulder, stay hungry and just keep that attitude because we're still in the process of establishing our identity as a football team."
Coach Jason Garrett does not offer up any Parcells-like imagery. He prefers to talk about the process and having a great Wednesday and Thursday and Friday. Carr claimed to be unaware of the Cowboys' schedule beyond this week and how four of their next five are at home.
"We're not going to have any issues with complacency," Garrett said. "We'll make that point very loudly and clearly. But one of the byproducts of doing this new schedule the way we're doing it is the emotional part kind of goes away by the time we get to the tape, and that's a really good thing. When we watch the tape, it's about learning. There's no better environment to learn in than the game. The game is just such a valuable teaching tool. You keep the standard high. You hear me say this all the time, build on the good stuff. Recognize it and build on it. Those are good things. That should give guys confidence, that should make us feel good as a team. Having said that, there's plenty of stuff that you got to address. We're going to address it and we're going to get it right."
It's one thing for Carr to understand the one-game-at-a-time process. He is in his seventh season. He is used to life in the NFL, but the majority of teammates are not.
The Cowboys haven't been 3-1 since 2008. Only Jason Witten, Tony Romo, L.P. Ladouceur, Anthony Spencer, Doug Free and Orlando Scandrick remain from that team. Only 16 players have been around for the four-game winning streak the Cowboys experienced in 2011.
The majority of the Cowboys have not experienced what it's like to have sustained success in a regular season. They know nothing more than 8-8.
"I think we're young enough to not even think about the cheese, that's how young we are, which is good," Carr said. "Don't even know about the cheese. As long as nobody puts no mouse traps around they're not going to know what it is."