Rank Spencer above Spears among recent 1st-rounders
Jean-Jacques Taylor made that point well this morning. But I have one beef with my colleague’s column.
You can’t use Marcus Spears as an example of a successful first-round pick and put Anthony Spencer in the blah category by comparison.
They’re both well below DeMarcus Ware and well above Bobby Carpenter in the scale of success by recent Dallas first-rounders. But Spencer should rank above Spears.
Spears signing a long-term deal with the Cowboys last summer isn’t evidence that he lived up to his billing. He remained with the Cowboys because the market determined that he was an affordable option to be part of the defensive end rotation.
It’s telling that Spears lost his starting job soon after signing a five-year, $19.2 million deal. There’s no guarantee he’ll even make the roster this season.
If the Cowboys could sign Spencer to the same deal, they’d do it in a split second. The reality is that Spencer, even with his mediocre sack totals, will end up getting more than twice that much money on the open market.
The Cowboys put the franchise tag on Spencer – overpaying him this season – because they aren’t prepared to commit to paying a premium price for him for the long term. They gave Spears a long-term deal because it didn’t cost that much by NFL standards.
That doesn’t make Spears a better pick than Spencer. They’ve both been serviceable, but Spencer has been better than Spears. And the Cowboys need better than both from their first-rounders.
103.3 FM ESPN PODCASTS
Play Podcast ESPN NFL Insider Ed Werder joins Fitzsimmons & Durrett to discuss Jerry Jones' recent comments, Cowboys OTAs, Dez Bryant and more.
Play Podcast Todd Archer joins Fitzsimmons & Durrett to discuss the latest Tony Romo news and what he will be watching for in OTAs.
Play Podcast Nate Newton joins Fitzsimmons & Durrett to discuss his comments on how Jason Garrett should handle being on the hot seat and not let Jerry Jones get in the way.
Play Podcast Cowboys safety Barry Church joins Fitzsimmons & Durrett to discuss the new defensive scheme and the impact it will have on him, how much more intense he expects practice to be with Monte Kiffin and his expectations.
Play Podcast ESPN Insider Ed Werder joins Fitzsimmons & Durrett to discuss the latest Cowboys news, including Jason Garrett downplaying Tony Romo's involvement in offensive planning and play calling.
Play Podcast John Lynch joins Fitzsimmons & Durrett to discuss playing for Monte Kiffin and Rod Marinelli, why Cowboys fans should be excited about the new defensive staff, why Valley Ranch will no longer resemble a country club and his thoughts on the Cowboys' roster.
Play Podcast Herm Edwards joins Fitzsimmons & Durrett to discuss the latest Cowboys news and give his take on what new face will make the biggest impact for Dallas.
Play Podcast Nate Newton joins Fitzsimmons & Durrett to discuss what he saw at the Cowboys' rookie minicamp and how he helped Rod Marinelli on the defensive side of the ball.