Overreacting in the ACC


We live in a hot-take world, but sometimes hot takes are wild overreactions based on how we feel right now, this very instant! With that in mind, we take a look at some of the biggest overreactions in 2014, and why they were wrong.

Overreaction: FSU should have been left out of the playoff.

Why: This became a popular opinion after the Seminoles lost to Oregon 59-20 in the Rose Bowl. But the idea that an undefeated team from a Power 5 conference should have been left out of the playoff because a blowout proves it was undeserving is laughable. Let’s start with the most important point: Florida State won all of its games before the playoff began. Contrary to popular belief, the Noles actually played a good schedule. Nine of their opponents made bowl games -- all of them with the Power 5 designation. Those nine teams went 6-3 in their bowl games. Compare that to TCU, which played seven bowl teams. Those seven teams went 1-6 in their bowl games. Florida State ended up playing two teams ranked in the final top 15; TCU played one. Florida State played three ranked teams in the final poll; TCU played two. The Noles needed their backup quarterback to beat 10-win Clemson, which destroyed Oklahoma in the bowl game. Ask the SEC how easy it was to beat Georgia Tech in 2014. These points alone prove that Florida State played a better schedule. But critics want to complain that Florida State played too many close games and never really passed the eye test. That when the Noles played an elite team like Oregon, they fell apart and therefore showed they never beat anybody good. These are all specious arguments. Yes, Florida State played close games. But the last time I checked, Florida State WON all of those games. Since when is blowing out every opponent proof that you are more deserving? Last I checked, Oregon blew out nearly everybody on its schedule but ended up losing by 22 in the national championship game. That blowout is forgiven, but Florida State’s was held up as a cautionary tale for future unbeaten Power 5 teams that win too many close games? Bottom line: Florida State absolutely deserved its spot in the playoff. No logical case can be made otherwise.

Overreaction: Miami must fire Al Golden. Now.

Why: The frustration among the Miami fan base is completely understandable. Going 6-7 at Miami is never acceptable, especially given the talent on the 2014 roster. Losing four games to end the season is never acceptable. We could go on, but you get the point. We can all agree that this past season failed to meet everybody’s standards. But the vitriol and negativity surrounding Golden have reached nuclear levels in South Florida. The cupboard is not bare here, far from it. Given the NCAA sanctions cloud that lingered over Miami for more than two years, Golden deserves another shot at getting the Canes pointed in the right direction. Brad Kaaya looks better than any quarterback Miami has had since Ken Dorsey. Despite losing Duke Johnson and Clive Walford, the Canes return a bevy of skill players across the board, including Joe Yearby, Stacy Coley and Braxton Berrios. Defensively, there are high hopes for improvements on the line, and the secondary has a chance to be even better. Although the Canes took some tough losses this past season, they showed against Florida State how well they can play when they have the heart, desire and motivation to win. Golden must now get his players to give that type of effort every weekend. Because the talent is there -- talent Golden brought into Miami when there were serious doubts about the program’s future.

Overreaction: Week 3 ACC Power Rankings: Georgia Tech at No. 13.

Why: Georgia Tech needed a great escape to beat Georgia Southern after looking not so hot in its first two games, against Wofford and Tulane. So we buried the Jackets. But, would you look at that? The Jackets finished 11-3, so uh, yeah that was really, really wrong.

Looking ahead to 2015

Overreaction: Florida State will take a step back!

Why: Depends on your definition. 2015 could be the year somebody else wins the ACC, but nobody should count Florida State out, not for the foreseeable future. The Noles have to replace the heart of their team, but they also return plenty of talent in Dalvin Cook, Jalen Ramsey, Roderick Johnson and plenty of others. The schedule sets up for the Noles to win 10 games again. And given their recent domination over Clemson, there are no guarantees the Tigers will take the Atlantic back.

Overreaction: Deshaun Watson is injury-prone.

Why: Watson got injured three different times since arriving on campus last January, including a season-ending knee injury that will cost him the spring. Already, there are those wondering whether Watson can stay healthy for a full season. Take a deep breath, everyone. Watson has played only one year. Yes, he got hurt. But that happens to football players. Nobody is calling the Ohio State quarterbacks injury-prone. People said the same about Miami running back Duke Johnson, and he played a complete 2014 -- his best yet. Give Watson a chance.

Overreaction: Virginia Tech cannot compete for another ACC title.

Why: There are many who believe Frank Beamer’s best days are behind him after a third straight lackluster season. But Beamer and his staff think this year’s team will give them their best shot at winning the Coastal Division since 2011. All their best skill position players will return, as will quarterback Michael Brewer. The defense should be just as good, if not better, with the expected return of Luther Maddy and Brandon Facyson plus the emergence of Dadi Nicolas and potential All-American Kyle Fuller. There is little doubt the Hokies are a team to watch in 2015.