Could Giants replace Mario with committee?
August, 17, 2012
8/17/12
5:13
PM ET
By
Ohm Youngmisuk | ESPNNewYork.com
Two years ago, an unknown wide receiver named Victor Cruz destroyed Rex Ryan's defense and emerged out of nowhere in a preseason game between the Giants and Jets.
Cruz is now an established playmaker with a history of doing well against Rex's Jets (read about how Cruz got Darrelle Revis' respect here).
Now the Giants are searching for another receiver to emerge as a third threat to go along with Hakeem Nicks and Cruz. And Domenik Hixon, Jerrel Jernigan, Ramses Barden and Rueben Randle could all use a stellar performance against the Jets to stake their claim to replacing Mario Manningham.
But unless one person runs away with the competition and shines in the next three preseason games, the Giants could very well fill that third receiver spot by committee. It's conceivable that they could start the trusted veteran Hixon as the third receiver but then bring in Jernigan, Barden and Randle in certain situations.
"I think some guys do some things better than others," Eli Manning said when asked about filling the third receiver spot by committee. "Depending on the route, on the concepts, on where you want to put that player ... whether that receiver is going to be playing inside or outside, you can decide who's going to be in that situation.
"I think that's why you usually carry six receivers, so you can put guys in certain spots, have them do what they do best."
A good showing on Saturday against the Jets could go a long way for one of those receivers in the competition for the third receiver spot.
"I don't know if there's just one guy right now," Manning said when asked if any of the guys competing for the third spot has jumped out to him. "Obviously, Hixon is a guy who has been around, knows the offense well. I thought Ramses has done a good job.
"And with Jernigan and Rueben competing for that third spot, young guys ... I think these preseason games are big, when you see them against live action, against good corners, see their releases, and see if they're doing a good job getting open."
Tell us what you think of the third receiver battle so far and what you want to see happen below.
Cruz is now an established playmaker with a history of doing well against Rex's Jets (read about how Cruz got Darrelle Revis' respect here).
Now the Giants are searching for another receiver to emerge as a third threat to go along with Hakeem Nicks and Cruz. And Domenik Hixon, Jerrel Jernigan, Ramses Barden and Rueben Randle could all use a stellar performance against the Jets to stake their claim to replacing Mario Manningham.
But unless one person runs away with the competition and shines in the next three preseason games, the Giants could very well fill that third receiver spot by committee. It's conceivable that they could start the trusted veteran Hixon as the third receiver but then bring in Jernigan, Barden and Randle in certain situations.
"I think some guys do some things better than others," Eli Manning said when asked about filling the third receiver spot by committee. "Depending on the route, on the concepts, on where you want to put that player ... whether that receiver is going to be playing inside or outside, you can decide who's going to be in that situation.
"I think that's why you usually carry six receivers, so you can put guys in certain spots, have them do what they do best."
A good showing on Saturday against the Jets could go a long way for one of those receivers in the competition for the third receiver spot.
"I don't know if there's just one guy right now," Manning said when asked if any of the guys competing for the third spot has jumped out to him. "Obviously, Hixon is a guy who has been around, knows the offense well. I thought Ramses has done a good job.
"And with Jernigan and Rueben competing for that third spot, young guys ... I think these preseason games are big, when you see them against live action, against good corners, see their releases, and see if they're doing a good job getting open."
Tell us what you think of the third receiver battle so far and what you want to see happen below.

- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk
Brandon Jacobs on playing FB >> RT @gatorboyrb: @LicensePlateGuy @HenryHynoski I ain't playing no damn fullback.”
about 3 hours ago
- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk

- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk
NFCE broken down by DG >> RT @espn_nfceast: Eli Manning remains Giants' old reliable http://t.co/12kCSUEKkA
about 3 hours ago
- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk

- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk
RT @HenryHynoski: Humbled beyond belief by the support that has been extended my way from my family, fans, and the Giants organization. One…
about 3 hours ago
- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk

- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk
@PatrickMcEnroe Awesome that @rogerfederer is finally on Twitter. Now can you get my idol Stefan Edberg on Twitter, PMc?
about 3 hours ago
- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk

- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk
Giants surely know this >> RT @corryjoel @AdamSchein @SNYtv Seahawks are only team with two WRs averaging over $8M per year (Rice & Harvin)
about 5 hours ago
- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk

- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk
Forgot to tweet this: Hynoski will have knee surgery http://t.co/g3wO2R3sIi
about 8 hours ago
- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk

- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk
Ramses Barden re-signs with Giants http://t.co/ek9GK4YLWC
about 8 hours ago
- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk

- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk
Chatting at 1 http://t.co/TmOuVuYVOH
about 9 hours ago
- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk

- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk
As @Edwerderespn tweeted, sources didn't expect Nicks 2 attend 2nd voluntary OTA. @mortreport reported Nicks' WED absence 4 personal reasons
about 10 hours ago
- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk

- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk
Nicks' agent denies OTA absence was contract-related to Yahoo. But it gave us a glimpse of life without Nicks + Cruz http://t.co/lEcBVESuyr
about 10 hours ago
- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk

- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk
Sounds like Ramses Barden will be returning to the Giants. He's in the building now
about 10 hours ago
- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk

- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk
>> RT @JasonColeYahoo: This is a correction about Hakeem Nicks. I misunderstood my source. I apologize for the error: http://t.co/E97ArpqYv2
about 10 hours ago
- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk

- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk
Hynoski: “I am going to set my mind to being ready for the first game. They said that is not an unrealistic goal.”
about 11 hours ago
- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk

- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk
Giants update on Hynoski: Injury to MCL and chip fracture to lateral plateau. Hynoski will undergo surgery Friday
about 11 hours ago
- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk

- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk
Nothing solid yet on Henry Hynoski, who is still having his knee injury evaluated according to source.
about 11 hours ago
- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk

- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk
Giants go through OTA without Cruz and Nicks. Both receivers will need new deals soon http://t.co/lEcBVESuyr
about 12 hours ago
- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk

- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk
Jacquian working his way back from PCL injury http://t.co/0VqxHxGTZ7
about 12 hours ago
- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk

- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk
Candid Curry talks about disappointing career and what's driving him now http://t.co/UfmQR84iaN
about 12 hours ago
- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk

- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk
Jacquian Williams taking things easy with PCL injury http://t.co/0VqxHxGTZ7
1 day ago
- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk

- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk
Barden could re-sign with Giants http://t.co/ranxxcSkik
1 day ago
- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk





TWITTER


You must be signed in to post a comment