- Dan Graziano, ESPN Staff Writer
- 0 Shares
Mel Kiper Jr. and Todd McShay both have new mock drafts out Tuesday. Both are Insider, so I can't fill you in on all of the juicy details, but I can tell you who they're picking for the New York Giants and give you some of my thoughts on it if you like. That work? Mkay, great. Here goes.
Mel's mock has the Giants taking Pittsburgh defensive tackle Aaron Donald at No. 12 overall. This is with North Carolina tight end Eric Ebron and Notre Dame offensive lineman Zack Martin still on the board. You know me, if I'm picking for the Giants here, I'm taking the offensive lineman. But I have no issue with a defensive lineman, especially one as fearsome as Donald, who could add instant depth to the defensive tackle rotation and likely flourish as a long-term starter on the interior of the Giants' defensive line. Having let Linval Joseph leave in one of the free-agent moves I still struggle to understand, the Giants could use an infusion of talented youth in there, and Donald would be a fun pick. We'd go to bed next Thursday writing that they need to address offensive line in the Friday night portion of the draft, but they likely can do that.
In Todd's mock, Donald and Martin are still on the board at 12, though Ebron is not and neither is Mike Evans. Todd gives the Giants LSU wide receiver Odell Beckham Jr., who could conceivably team with fellow former LSU wide receiver Rueben Randle to round out the Giants' wide receiver corps behind Victor Cruz. Beckham also would be a fun pick, and would make Giants fans feel better about the array of weapons for quarterback Eli Manning in the passing game. But I don't know if I love the pick at 12. I think the Giants' biggest big-picture problem is the erosion of top-end talent up front. I think you need a foundation piece if you're drafting in the first half of the first round. And I think they'd be better served looking at what Bill Polian calls "fat guys" -- lineman of either the offensive or defensive persuasion -- with this high a pick.
Just my opinion, though, and Mel's pick and Todd's pick both make sense on some level. The fact there's such a spread with regard to the Giants' best options in the first round indicates just how many spots on their roster still need long-term solutions.