Positional analysis: Wide receivers

January, 19, 2012
Jan 19
5:00
AM ET
This is the third part in a nine-part review of the 2011 season, a position-by-position analysis:

Position: Wide receivers

Overall grade (on a scale of 1 to 10): 6.0

Depth chart: Santonio Holmes (16 starts/1,027 plays), Plaxico Burress (13/889), Jeremy Kerley (1/320), Patrick Turner (1/193), Derrick Mason (0/169), Eron Riley (0/3), Logan Payne (injured).

2011 headline: Receivers Flunk Chemistry 101.

Gold star: N/A

Disappointing: Holmes.

Stat check: Holmes has gone 25 straight games (counting playoffs) without reaching 100 receiving yards.

Analysis: The Jets thought they pulled off a coup by re-signing Holmes and adding Burress and Mason, and dumping Braylon Edwards, Jerricho Cotchery and Brad Smith. Man, were they wrong. This was a classic case of a front office overlooking the importance of intangibles. Burress had zero chemistry with QB Mark Sanchez, and Holmes regressed in terms of his rapport with Sanchez. It was ugly.

Holmes (51 catches/102 targets) and Burress (45/97) ranked among the worst in the league in completion percentage. It's hard to believe, but neither receiver managed a reception longer than 38 yards. You knew it would be rough for Burress, coming off a two-year prison sentence, but Holmes? Very strange. One opposing scout said Holmes lack his usual explosiveness. In fact, he had only eight receptions of 20+ yards and he averaged only 3.8 YAC. The Jets paid him like a franchise receiver ($9 million per year), but he was anything but -- although he was victimized by a lack of creativity in the passing game. How many slants can one team run?

Burress filled the void for a red-zone receiver, finishing with seven TDs inside the 20 (tied for seventh in the league). He used his 6-foot-5 frame to dominate in tight quarters, just like everyone figured. But between the 20s, he was a non-factor, unable to separate because of his diminished speed. By the final month, Burress was out of gas, managing only eight catches in the last four games.

Mason (13/21) was a waste of time and money; he should've retired after last season. Kerley (29/46) did an admirable job in his place, showing sure hands and short-area quickness. It's difficult for a rookie to handle the slot position, and Kerley did quite well. Some close to the team believe he should've had more playing time down the stretch, replacing Burress. Turner (8/15) flashed as a blocker and made a couple of big catches.

2012 free agents: Burress (UFA), Turner (RFA).

On the bubble: Holmes.

Note: Play counts, which include penalties, are from Pro Football Focus.
Rich Cimini, longtime Jets beat writer for the New York Daily News and a Syracuse graduate, covers Gang Green for ESPNNewYork.com.
Follow Rich on Twitter

ESPN Conversations


You must be signed in to post a comment

Already have an account?

  • janesports Jane McManus
    Northwestern will face Syracuse in the NCAA women's lacrosse final on Sunday after beating Maryland 9-7 tonight in a semi.
    about 2 hours ago     
  • janesports Jane McManus
    For Florida women's lacrosse, winning goal was waived off due to illegal stick depth with :09 left in OT. Then Syra scored in sudden death.
    about 6 hours ago     
  • janesports Jane McManus
    No. 4 Syracuse women's lacrosse rebounded from 12-5 halftime deficit to beat No. 1 Florida 14-13 in sudden death OT. Just wow. NCAA semis.
    about 6 hours ago     
  • RichCimini Rich Cimini
    Q & A with Mark Sanchez: We interrupt Tebow-mania to bring you the Jets' starting quarterback, Mark Sanchez... http://t.co/wW1J76q1 #nyj
    about 7 hours ago     
  • janesports Jane McManus
    Here in Stony Brook, Florida frosh Shannon Gilroy of Northport is putting together heck of a homecoming. 4G already, up 10-4 over Syracuse.
    about 7 hours ago     
  • janesports Jane McManus
    Can we do it again tonight? RT @JeanGreasy Felt like a big family at that venue tonight. That's pretty good. pretty...pretty...pretty good.
    about 7 hours ago     
  • janesports Jane McManus
    Former Jet Trevor Pryce with solid NYT piece on tennis. If writing doesn't work out for me, perhaps I'll be an NFL DE. http://t.co/6wR7yf2C
    about 8 hours ago     
  • janesports Jane McManus
    Women's NCAA lacrosse semis about to startin Stony Brook. Can you believe Fla is top seed when 3 years ago it started program from scratch?
    about 9 hours ago     
  • RichCimini Rich Cimini
    Since Jets don't want 'Hard Knocks' ...: ... the folks at NFL Live would love to take their place. http://t.co/yncXxuDk #nyj
    about 9 hours ago     
  • janesports Jane McManus
    Just heard Nas song about his daughter growing up. So nice to hear a different slice of femininity discussed on commercial radio.
    about 12 hours ago     
  • janesports Jane McManus
    Gimme a C-O-R-P-O-R-A-T-E and a L-A-W! RT @adbrandt Enduring winner in NFL-NFLPA relationship: billable hours.
    about 14 hours ago     
  • janesports Jane McManus
    #Jets ST coordinator Mike Westhoff recovering from surgery to repair broken rod in leg. Should be back by camp. http://t.co/MAGLuibJ #NFL
    about 17 hours ago     
  • janesports Jane McManus
    Last night at Drom, @JeanGreasy played some new and some old stuff, including this one: http://t.co/twYsgVqm Thx for the intro, Twitter!
    about 17 hours ago     
  • janesports Jane McManus
    Just saw @JeanGreasy kill it at Drom in NYC. Even better live than on Twitter. She is real after all.
    1 day ago     
  • RichCimini Rich Cimini
    Quick take on QBs, Hill's vertical speed, etc.: Observations on OTA No. 3 (the first session open to the me... http://t.co/f6D5vhda #nyj
    1 day ago     
  • RichCimini Rich Cimini
    'Te-bow! Te-bow! Te-bow!': When Tim Tebow walked into the locker room Thursday, with a crowd of reporters a... http://t.co/wejdJAcm #nyj
    1 day ago     
  • RichCimini Rich Cimini
    Tebow backs 'Tebowing' HS student: Tim Tebow said he was vaguely familiar with the story of Chuck Shriner, ... http://t.co/cYpjmtk8 #nyj
    1 day ago     
  • RichCimini Rich Cimini
    Missing: Holmes, Cromartie and Landry: WR Santonio Holmes, CB Antonio Cromartie and S LaRon Landry didn't p... http://t.co/OBOhoNeI #nyj
    1 day ago     
  • RichCimini Rich Cimini
    #Jets STC Mike Westhoff, one tough dude, said he needed surgery because his metal femur broke in half. http://t.co/A8aXppJT
    1 day ago     
  • janesports Jane McManus
    Lawrence Taylor's reaction when he learned Charlie Sheen may have had the winning bid on his Super Bowl ring? http://t.co/QRGwtpv1 #NFL
    1 day ago     

TEAM LEADERS

PASSING
Mark Sanchez
ATT COMP YDS TD
543 308 3474 26
RUSHINGCARYDSAVGTD
S. Greene 253 1054 4.2 6
L. Tomlinson 75 280 3.7 1
RECEIVINGRECYDSAVGTD
D. Keller 65 815 12.5 5
S. Holmes 51 654 12.8 8

NEW YORK CALENDAR

  •    There are no games scheduled for today.
  •    There are no games scheduled for today.
  •    There are no games scheduled for today.
  •    There are no games scheduled for today.
  •    There are no games scheduled for today.