Santana's no Roger Craig
July, 19, 2010
7/19/10
11:00
AM ET
By Mark Simon | ESPNNewYork.com
Our colleague Jayson Stark sent a Tweet that rattled around my brain for a few hours Sunday evening.
It told how Johan Santana has made 12 starts this season in which he's pitched at least six innings and allowed one run or fewer (In researcher world, those fall under a larger umbrella, articulated in this piece by my colleagues on "Superior Starts")
Yet in those dozen starts, he has as many wins (six) as no-decisions.
As another blogger, Justin Norman, wrote elsewhere, that's absurd.
And while Norman looked into whether Santana is the unluckiest pitcher in baseball this season (and basically concluded he is), I'll look at it from another angle.
What is the context of Santana's season within Mets history?
Baseball-Reference.com's Play Index provides us with an easy means for taking a closer look, so we did so late last night, and here's what we found.
As noted previously, Santana has six no-decisions in those 12 starts (six or more innings, no runs/one run allowed).
Inspired by multiple works (by Bill James and others) who have toyed with the numbers on this subject, let's have a little fun with the numbers and call those no-decisions "Unlucky no-decisions."
Santana's six are the most "Unlucky no-decisions" a Mets pitcher has EVER had in a single-season.
However, Santana's fate could be worse. In those 12 starts, he's 6-0 with six no-decisions. So he does have six victories.
But take note that he hasn't personally had his record damaged (ie: suffered the loss) in any of those contests. There's some solace for him, albeit a mild amount.
Solely for the sake of this piece, let's invent a stat, and we'll call it "Gross Unlucky Score" or GUS for short.
If we make the presumption that it's twice as painful for a pitcher when he loses a start in which he pitches great (six-plus innings, zero/one runs) as when he gets a no-decision, we can create a formula easily.
GUS equals (Unlucky Losses*2) + No-Decisions.
Santana has a GUS of six, which as it turns out, is painful, but not historic ... not yet.
This is the 19th time in Mets history that a pitcher has had a GUS of six or greater. A lot of pitchers have had sixes. Mike Pelfrey was the most recent in 2008 (two losses, two no-decisions). Tom Glavine notched a six twice in a three-year span (2003 and 2005).
With one more no-decision in a start such as this, Santana moves into a more elite territory of unluckiness. Only four pitchers have posted a GUS of seven or greater and it hasn't been done since Pete Schourek (two losses, three no-decisions) scored a seven in 1992.
Two pitchers posted GUS'es of seven or greater in 1973. But Jon Matlack had six wins in games in which he allowed one run or fewer in six innings or more, and Tom Seaver had nine. Plus, both had a National League pennant to dull their pain.
But there is one pitcher whose GUS qualifies him as the Babe Ruth of unlucky Mets starters. It would take a herculean effort by Santana to catch Roger Craig's 1963 season.
Craig went 5-22 during a hapless season in which he lost 18 straight games in one stretch. He deserved a better fate.
Craig's GUS score was a 14 and it took a heck of an effort on his part, as well as a heck of a lot of futility, to reach that mark.
Craig made eight starts in 1963 in which he pitched at least six innings and allowed no runs or one run. He had two no-decisions and six losses.
So you know what that means. Of those eight great starts, how many did Craig win?
None of them.
It told how Johan Santana has made 12 starts this season in which he's pitched at least six innings and allowed one run or fewer (In researcher world, those fall under a larger umbrella, articulated in this piece by my colleagues on "Superior Starts")
Yet in those dozen starts, he has as many wins (six) as no-decisions.
As another blogger, Justin Norman, wrote elsewhere, that's absurd.
And while Norman looked into whether Santana is the unluckiest pitcher in baseball this season (and basically concluded he is), I'll look at it from another angle.
What is the context of Santana's season within Mets history?
Baseball-Reference.com's Play Index provides us with an easy means for taking a closer look, so we did so late last night, and here's what we found.
As noted previously, Santana has six no-decisions in those 12 starts (six or more innings, no runs/one run allowed).
Inspired by multiple works (by Bill James and others) who have toyed with the numbers on this subject, let's have a little fun with the numbers and call those no-decisions "Unlucky no-decisions."
Santana's six are the most "Unlucky no-decisions" a Mets pitcher has EVER had in a single-season.
However, Santana's fate could be worse. In those 12 starts, he's 6-0 with six no-decisions. So he does have six victories.
But take note that he hasn't personally had his record damaged (ie: suffered the loss) in any of those contests. There's some solace for him, albeit a mild amount.
Solely for the sake of this piece, let's invent a stat, and we'll call it "Gross Unlucky Score" or GUS for short.
If we make the presumption that it's twice as painful for a pitcher when he loses a start in which he pitches great (six-plus innings, zero/one runs) as when he gets a no-decision, we can create a formula easily.
GUS equals (Unlucky Losses*2) + No-Decisions.
Santana has a GUS of six, which as it turns out, is painful, but not historic ... not yet.
This is the 19th time in Mets history that a pitcher has had a GUS of six or greater. A lot of pitchers have had sixes. Mike Pelfrey was the most recent in 2008 (two losses, two no-decisions). Tom Glavine notched a six twice in a three-year span (2003 and 2005).
With one more no-decision in a start such as this, Santana moves into a more elite territory of unluckiness. Only four pitchers have posted a GUS of seven or greater and it hasn't been done since Pete Schourek (two losses, three no-decisions) scored a seven in 1992.
Two pitchers posted GUS'es of seven or greater in 1973. But Jon Matlack had six wins in games in which he allowed one run or fewer in six innings or more, and Tom Seaver had nine. Plus, both had a National League pennant to dull their pain.
But there is one pitcher whose GUS qualifies him as the Babe Ruth of unlucky Mets starters. It would take a herculean effort by Santana to catch Roger Craig's 1963 season.
Craig went 5-22 during a hapless season in which he lost 18 straight games in one stretch. He deserved a better fate.
Craig's GUS score was a 14 and it took a heck of an effort on his part, as well as a heck of a lot of futility, to reach that mark.
Craig made eight starts in 1963 in which he pitched at least six innings and allowed no runs or one run. He had two no-decisions and six losses.
So you know what that means. Of those eight great starts, how many did Craig win?
None of them.

- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin
Ike's woes continue with 4K night http://t.co/qXecw0sbPm #NYM #Mets
22 minutes ago
- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin

- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin
Collins explains lifting Hefner from gem http://t.co/3rJPdSQXCU #NYM #Mets
about an hour ago
- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin

- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin
Citi Field gates will open at 5:10 p.m. Saturday for fans. #mets #braves
about an hour ago
- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin

- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin
Suspended game may go untelevised http://t.co/PPVJmdIi1b #NYM #Mets
about an hour ago
- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin

- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin
Yes. come early. RT @MotheFo16: but does that mean people with tickets for tomorrow's game will be allowed in to watch rest of today's game?
about an hour ago
- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin

- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin
People with tickets for tonight's suspended #Mets game can redeem the ticket for any future date, including tomorrow.
about 2 hours ago
- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin

- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin
Terry Collins said Jeremy Hefner probably could have pitched seventh, but wanted to try to get him out on high note in position to win.
about 2 hours ago
- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin

- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin
How much longer can #Mets stick with Ike Davis? "I'm not sure," Terry Collins said.
about 2 hours ago
- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin

- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin
Terry on Ike: "I know it's wearing on him." Said Ike was in batting cage during rain delay working. #mets
about 2 hours ago
- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin

- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin
Terry said he'll start the suspended game with a reliever, not the scheduled starting pitcher.
about 2 hours ago
- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin

- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin
Terry Collins speaking now. Nothing apparently up that kept clubhouse closed. #mets
about 2 hours ago
- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin

- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin
SNY person explained Fox and SNY use same production truck. So it's not even clear two networks could carry Saturday.
about 2 hours ago
- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin

- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin
TV is going to be fascinating. Fox is supposed to do regular game at 7:15. No one may televise resumption hour earlier. #mets #braves
about 2 hours ago
- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin

- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin
Rapid Reaction: Braves 5, Mets 5 http://t.co/0RSn3oQVfb #NYM #Mets
about 2 hours ago
- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin

- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin
Minors 5.24.13: Plawecki 4 RBIs for Gnats http://t.co/NdL9qVXiu6 #NYM #Mets
about 2 hours ago
- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin

- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin
Rapid Reaction: #Mets 5, #Braves 5 (suspended): http://t.co/cYM7iFj0LW
about 2 hours ago
- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin

- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin
When it stops raining. // RT @StewDaddyG: When's the game restarting?
about 2 hours ago
- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin

- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin
Flores manning first base for Vegas http://t.co/tz3DybKcx3 #NYM #Mets
about 2 hours ago
- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin

- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin
Radar looks pretty good. #Mets-#Braves game will resume at some point: http://t.co/nPkNYhglsK
about 3 hours ago
- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin

- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin
Understated it earlier. Third 4 K game for Ike Davis this season. Matches franchise record for most times in a season. And it's only May.
about 3 hours ago
- AdamRubinESPN Adam Rubin




TWITTER

You must be signed in to post a comment