First Pitch: Freddy Garcia's trade value
March, 23, 2012
3/23/12
7:00
AM ET
By
Andrew Marchand | ESPNNewYork.com
If the Yankees were to look to trade Freddy Garcia, it would be to clear him out of the logjam of the Super 7 rotation. It would have to be, because they aren't going to get anything of real value.
"They would not get a lot," an NL GM told ESPN New York.
It would seem that there would be a lot of teams that could use a guy who had a 3.62 ERA in the AL East last season, but the GM said he thinks most clubs view Garcia as a "depth guy." Plus, most teams don't have a $4 million salary slot available at this time of year.
One more factor to consider is since Garcia was signed as a free agent, he has the right to decline any trade until June.
Garcia is scheduled to return to the mound on Saturday for the first time since he hurt his hand a little more than a week ago. If I had to predict, I would say right now he would probably be the odd man out of the rotation. To me, it comes down to Garcia or Michael Pineda.
Pineda may one day be the No. 2 starter of the Yankees' dreams, but thus far he has had trouble with his fastball, his weight and the mass of the Yankee media. That said, while Brian Cashman and Joe Girardi have both brought up the possibility that Pineda could start the season at Triple-A, that is not why they got him.
(Cashman said Thursday he hasn't thought about it, but more likely he doesn't want to make it a bigger issue.)
In the end, as we have detailed here more than once, they could decide to start Pineda in the minors so he can be as ready for the big stage as possible, but more likely is in the rotation.
If they were pick Garcia for the rotation over Pineda, Phil Hughes or Ivan Nova, it would be because they know what Garcia is and they like it. As Girardi is prone to say, "Freddy is Freddy." They pretty much know what they are going to get with him. And, it seems, if they wanted to trade him they wouldn't wouldn't get much back for him.
UP NOW: Gordon Edes on Bobby Valentine being irked at Girardi for ending Thursday's Yankees-Red Sox game after nine innings.
ON DECK: Kieran Darcy will be in the clubhouse early this morning. At 1 p.m., Ivan Nova takes the ball and tries to close the door on any thoughts -- as minimal as they probably should be -- that he will not be in the rotation. The Yankees face the Twins. The game is on YES.
The big story of the day should be Derek Jeter's return to game-action after his calf injury sidelined him a week ago.
QUESTION OF THE DAY: Would you trade Freddy?
"They would not get a lot," an NL GM told ESPN New York.
It would seem that there would be a lot of teams that could use a guy who had a 3.62 ERA in the AL East last season, but the GM said he thinks most clubs view Garcia as a "depth guy." Plus, most teams don't have a $4 million salary slot available at this time of year.
One more factor to consider is since Garcia was signed as a free agent, he has the right to decline any trade until June.
Garcia is scheduled to return to the mound on Saturday for the first time since he hurt his hand a little more than a week ago. If I had to predict, I would say right now he would probably be the odd man out of the rotation. To me, it comes down to Garcia or Michael Pineda.
Pineda may one day be the No. 2 starter of the Yankees' dreams, but thus far he has had trouble with his fastball, his weight and the mass of the Yankee media. That said, while Brian Cashman and Joe Girardi have both brought up the possibility that Pineda could start the season at Triple-A, that is not why they got him.
(Cashman said Thursday he hasn't thought about it, but more likely he doesn't want to make it a bigger issue.)
In the end, as we have detailed here more than once, they could decide to start Pineda in the minors so he can be as ready for the big stage as possible, but more likely is in the rotation.
If they were pick Garcia for the rotation over Pineda, Phil Hughes or Ivan Nova, it would be because they know what Garcia is and they like it. As Girardi is prone to say, "Freddy is Freddy." They pretty much know what they are going to get with him. And, it seems, if they wanted to trade him they wouldn't wouldn't get much back for him.
UP NOW: Gordon Edes on Bobby Valentine being irked at Girardi for ending Thursday's Yankees-Red Sox game after nine innings.
ON DECK: Kieran Darcy will be in the clubhouse early this morning. At 1 p.m., Ivan Nova takes the ball and tries to close the door on any thoughts -- as minimal as they probably should be -- that he will not be in the rotation. The Yankees face the Twins. The game is on YES.
The big story of the day should be Derek Jeter's return to game-action after his calf injury sidelined him a week ago.
QUESTION OF THE DAY: Would you trade Freddy?

- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand
Teixeira hits for first time http://t.co/iyp1CKEcxv
48 minutes ago
- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand

- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand
Teixeira tweeted he took at-bats today.
about an hour ago
- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand

- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand
ICYMI: Q&A: Hal talks Cano, ticket prices, The Boss http://t.co/84IHyxZRdk
about 3 hours ago
- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
Quick hook on game = No quick hook for CC http://t.co/v9c0uOR3jZ
about 23 hours ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
Reid his lips: Jeter's the man http://t.co/XUdEY3Rujj
about 23 hours ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
Nothing official, but Aug. 19 likely makeup date for today's Yankees-Blue Jays rainout. Both teams off and begin 3-game series here next day
1 day ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
It's a washout http://t.co/kS4iT8szgv
1 day ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
Sabathia, Hughes, Kuroda to start in Baltimore; Nuno to be skipped due to today's rainout
1 day ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
Today's game is postponed; no makeup date scheduled yet
1 day ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand
RT @CAA_Baseball: With his 12th career multi-HR game, @RobinsonCano ties #Yankees franchise record for 2B held by HOFer Joe Gordon
1 day ago
- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
Today's lineup: granderson 8 cano 4 wells 7 Hafner dh Overbay 3 nix 5 Suzuki 9 brignac 6 Romine 2 Sabathia lhp
1 day ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand
First Pitch: Hal calls tickets 'affordable' http://t.co/cvPOepU61k
1 day ago
- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand

- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand
The irreplaceable Cano http://t.co/Q5LwkVsriM So says Joe Girardi
1 day ago
- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand

- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand
Classic A-Rod would get an inordinate amount of blame because of failure at end of games when he was big reason the moment was possible.
1 day ago
- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand

- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand
Very A-Rodish game by Carmelo: He was great enough to put himself in position to fail in the fourth.
1 day ago
- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand

- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand
Halapalooza http://t.co/84IHyxZRdk
1 day ago
- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand

- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand
Cano did not hit homer run No. 12 until game 65 in '12. This was game 43 of '13. #MVPCandidate
1 day ago
- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand

- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand
He finished with a career high 33
1 day ago
- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand

- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand
Cano did not hit homer run No. 12 until game 65. This was game 43. #MVPCandidate
1 day ago
- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand

- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand
Q&A: Hal talks Cano, ticket prices, The Boss http://t.co/84IHyxZRdk
1 day ago
- AndrewMarchand Andrew Marchand
TEAM LEADERS
| WINS LEADER | ||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
![]() |
Hiroki Kuroda
|
|||||||||||
| OTHER LEADERS | ||||||||||||
| BA | R. Cano | .295 | ||||||||||
| HR | R. Cano | 12 | ||||||||||
| RBI | R. Cano | 31 | ||||||||||
| R | R. Cano | 25 | ||||||||||
| OPS | R. Cano | .899 | ||||||||||
| ERA | H. Kuroda | 1.99 | ||||||||||
| SO | C. Sabathia | 54 | ||||||||||
- There are no games scheduled for today.





TWITTER

You must be signed in to post a comment