First pitch: Who should fifth starter be?
July, 19, 2012
7/19/12
7:00
AM ET
By Mike Mazzeo | ESPNNewYork.com
Freddy Garcia, Thursday night’s starter in Oakland, has compiled a 7.34 ERA in seven starts this season.
So does that give you confidence that Garcia can deliver in Andy Pettitte’s absence until Sept. 1, when Pettitte hopes to return to the rotation?
Garcia, 35, has to get by with guts and guile these days, no longer relying on the mid-90s fastball he one possessed.
“The Chief” has pitched to a 3.18 ERA in his last three outings, but can he sustain that type of consistency?
Perhaps the Yankees would be better served inserting a young starter such as David Phelps, who they recently promoted, as a stopgap until Pettitte returns.
Garcia? Phelps? Maybe GM Brian Cashman should make a trade? Let us know who you think should pitch in the No. 5 spot in the rotation for the next six weeks.
UP NOW: Wallace Matthews has a column on the Yankees becoming a machine. Seriously. They look like a juggernaut right now. I have blogs on Hiroki Kuroda, A-Rod and Mark Teixeira. Katie Sharp will be bringing you her latest edition of Yankeemetrics in the A.M. as well.
ON DECK: The Yankees open up a seven-day, seven-game West Coast roadtrip against the A’s.
So does that give you confidence that Garcia can deliver in Andy Pettitte’s absence until Sept. 1, when Pettitte hopes to return to the rotation?
Garcia, 35, has to get by with guts and guile these days, no longer relying on the mid-90s fastball he one possessed.
“The Chief” has pitched to a 3.18 ERA in his last three outings, but can he sustain that type of consistency?
Perhaps the Yankees would be better served inserting a young starter such as David Phelps, who they recently promoted, as a stopgap until Pettitte returns.
Garcia? Phelps? Maybe GM Brian Cashman should make a trade? Let us know who you think should pitch in the No. 5 spot in the rotation for the next six weeks.
UP NOW: Wallace Matthews has a column on the Yankees becoming a machine. Seriously. They look like a juggernaut right now. I have blogs on Hiroki Kuroda, A-Rod and Mark Teixeira. Katie Sharp will be bringing you her latest edition of Yankeemetrics in the A.M. as well.
ON DECK: The Yankees open up a seven-day, seven-game West Coast roadtrip against the A’s.

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
RT @MattEhalt: Universe might explode: Mariano vs. Puig in the 9th.
about an hour ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
Ninth-inning main event coming up: Mo vs. Puig
about an hour ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
With Yanks up 6-2, Claiborne now on to pitch the eighth, Brignac in to play SS, Nix moves to 3d, Adams to bench
about an hour ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
Biggest laugh line of the day: "Today's paid attendance, 40,604"
about an hour ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
Clutch strikeout for Kelley to end the inning. Yanks up 3-2 after 6-1/2
about 2 hours ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
Kuroda fell behind Hairston 3-0, paid for it with RBI single, Yankes lead cut to 3-2, Kuroda out of game, Kelley in
about 2 hours ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
Moment of truth for Kuroda: runners at the corners, two out, PH Hairston up for Dodgers in 7th
about 2 hours ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
Say what? Puig on Cano http://t.co/kIa1tPo6vi
about 2 hours ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
Cano probably would have been good catching hot rivets on a skyscraper in a previous life
about 2 hours ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
Cano is ridiculous, Chapter 2,473
about 2 hours ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
I like this one: Harvey threatened to beat up Rauch http://t.co/n961ZIpnzM
about 2 hours ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
helping my boy Adam in his quest: Farm report: Gavin follows Garin's path http://t.co/G9tTsFmQ4z
about 2 hours ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
Just trying to help Adam: Is Chipper a closet Mets fan? http://t.co/xPUqPWBUrU
about 2 hours ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
RT @TikiBarber: Rest In Peace Dave Jennings...
about 3 hours ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
Hot Button: See you in October? http://t.co/DEEhIFWenP
about 3 hours ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
David Adams first career sac bunt comes before David Adams' first career walk
about 3 hours ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
Meanwhile, poor Thomas Neal doesn';t even get a picture on the scoreboard, just a generic Yankees logo
about 3 hours ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
There's either many more Dodgers fans here for Game 1 or a houseful of Donnie Baseball fans. Just got a big ovation when shown on big screen
about 3 hours ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
Yanks mum on A-Rod http://t.co/78MCUHwhQj
about 4 hours ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews

- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
Yankees add OF Martinez from Astros http://t.co/lmdFqAn0ta
about 4 hours ago
- ESPNNYYankees wallace matthews
TEAM LEADERS
| BA LEADER | ||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
![]() |
Brett Gardner
|
|||||||||||
| OTHER LEADERS | ||||||||||||
| HR | R. Cano | 16 | ||||||||||
| RBI | R. Cano | 42 | ||||||||||
| R | B. Gardner | 39 | ||||||||||
| OPS | R. Cano | .861 | ||||||||||
| W | H. Kuroda | 7 | ||||||||||
| ERA | H. Kuroda | 2.78 | ||||||||||
| SO | C. Sabathia | 89 | ||||||||||




TWITTER


You must be signed in to post a comment