They should all play, but Ichiro should be in the lineup the least.
That is going on the assumption that Wells keeps hitting and doesn't revert to the scuffling player the Angels were eager to offload for nothing more than financial relief. On Wednesday, he hit another homer, his 10th, tying him for the team lead with Robinson Cano.
Greatest New York Comebacks
ESPN New York takes a look back at the greatest comebacks in New York history. Photo Gallery
I have been writing for a while about my doubts that a 39-year-old Ichiro is still a very productive player. He entered Wednesday as a .200 hitter against right-handed pitching in 85 at-bats. Of his 17 hits, two were homers and two were doubles, while the 13 others were singles. He had eight walks -- which is a lot for him -- so his on-base percentage was .269 or about 70 points lower than what might be reasonable to hope for at this stage in his career.
He went 0-for-4 on Wednesday night, dropping his overall average to .238. Even before the 0-for, his OPS against right-handers was .563.
Wells entered Wednesday with a .316 on-base percentage vs. righties, which isn't great, but is still superior to Ichiro. Prior to Wednesday's homer, he had six homers and an OPS of .805 against righties.
When lefties are on the mound, Wells will be either in the outfield or at DH. Why? Entering Wednesday, his OPS was .991 against southpaws.
Granderson is going to play because, despite all the strikeouts, he is a 40-plus homer guy thanks in large part to Yankee Stadium. The Yankees rightfully love Gardner's defense. But he still needs to prove himself with the bat. Overall, Gardner entered Wednesday with a .327 on-base percentage. That needs to be a bit higher.
I suspect Girardi will check his binder and come to the same conclusion I have. Of course he won't say it, but Ichiro will sit the most -- until further notice.