<
>

Should the Giants keep Mario Manningham?

ESPNNewYork.com's Jane McManus and Ohm Youngmisuk debate the future of wide receiver Mario Manningham with the New York Giants.

McManus: "The Giants have had a difficult time keeping their receiving corps healthy, and the replacement pieces haven't always lived up to the billing. Manningham is a reliable cog with big-game ability, and the Giants shouldn't discount that so easily."

Youngmisuk: "He is capable of making sensationally difficult catches, such as his NFC Championship Game touchdown catch in the fourth quarter against San Francisco and his 38-yard fourth-quarter catch against the Patriots that is now part of Giants Super Bowl lore. But Manningham also is capable of dropping balls and failing to haul in a touchdown pass, like he did against San Francisco during the regular season, and fading out of bounds on a deep route, like he did in the Super Bowl on the fourth-quarter drive before his big catch."