Print and Go Back ESPN.com: NFC East [Print without images]

Tuesday, February 28, 2012
Should the Giants keep Mario Manningham?

By ESPN.com staff

ESPNNewYork.com's Jane McManus and Ohm Youngmisuk debate the future of wide receiver Mario Manningham with the New York Giants.

McManus: "The Giants have had a difficult time keeping their receiving corps healthy, and the replacement pieces haven't always lived up to the billing. Manningham is a reliable cog with big-game ability, and the Giants shouldn't discount that so easily."

Youngmisuk: "He is capable of making sensationally difficult catches, such as his NFC Championship Game touchdown catch in the fourth quarter against San Francisco and his 38-yard fourth-quarter catch against the Patriots that is now part of Giants Super Bowl lore. But Manningham also is capable of dropping balls and failing to haul in a touchdown pass, like he did against San Francisco during the regular season, and fading out of bounds on a deep route, like he did in the Super Bowl on the fourth-quarter drive before his big catch."