NFC North: Tyler Thigpen
Donovan McNabb as (expensive) insurance
I reacted forcefully Tuesday upon hearing news I honestly never expected. Never did I think the Minnesota Vikings would draft a quarterback No. 12 overall, declare him their Matt Ryan/Joe Flacco -- i.e., an instant starter on a veteran team -- and then acquire a veteran to start ahead of him just before training camp.
Geoff Burke/US PresswireDonovan McNabb -- a six-time Pro Bowl selection -- was traded for a 2012 sixth-round pick and a conditional sixth rounder in 2013.And after mulling it for most of Wednesday, I think that's exactly what the Vikings did. Their trade for Donovan McNabb, completed a short time ago, requires us to recalibrate how most of us view McNabb at this stage of his career. He will offer a professional presence during whatever time Ponder needs on the sideline, if any, but McNabb should in no way be viewed as the Vikings' unquestioned starter for the 2011 season.
If McNabb starts Sept. 11 against the San Diego Chargers, he'll become only the third post-merger quarterback in the past 41 seasons to be a Week 1 starter for three different teams in consecutive years. Yes, Donovan McNabb -- a six-time Pro Bowler -- is now a quintessential journeyman.
(Hat tip to ESPN's Keith Hawkins for digging out that Elias stat.)
Think about how this all played out. The Washington Redskins wanted no part of McNabb, even at a time when merely capable quarterback play is a much-valued commodity. The Redskins are prepared to start fellow journeyman John Beck, and the best deal they could find for McNabb is one that guarantees only a sixth-round draft pick.
It's also important to note that multiple media reports, including one by Jay Glazer of FoxSports.com, have the Vikings first pursuing free agent Tyler Thigpen for this role. Thigpen is a former Vikings draft pick. He's started 12 games in his career and fits the profile we've been discussing.
McNabb might be an upgrade over Thigpen as a short-term starter, but how he will accept Ponder's eventual ascension is anyone's guess and probably had something to do with the delay between the preliminary agreement and the deal's completion.
McNabb would need a career renaissance to fulfill the expectations I'm hearing from some of you. He'll have a much stronger set of skill players to work with than he did in Washington, but he'll also have a fraction of the time to learn the Vikings' offense and develop the chemistry necessary for this transition.
So I don't think this is a terrible move, especially if the Vikings first tried and failed to sign Thigpen. They needed to add a veteran quarterback one way or the other.
I just don't think it changes the franchise's big-picture dynamic. Ponder will start when he is ready and possibly sooner. If McNabb can buy the Vikings a few extra weeks or months, then bully for everyone.
If there is a downside, it's that the Vikings have added a layer of consternation to the eventual transition. Barring a McNabb injury, Ponder will get his first start after one of these scenarios:
- He beats out McNabb in training camp.
- McNabb struggles.
- McNabb plays well enough to keep the job but is cast aside anyway.
None of these scenarios would be painful if you substituted "Thigpen" for "McNabb." That's what we all need to get our heads around. The events of the past few days have told us this: In the summer of 2011, at least, Thigpen = McNabb.

Explaining Donovan McNabb's reticence
According to Schefter, some people in the McNabb camp became emotional Tuesday night because of the cool embrace the Vikings extended. They were concerned about reports the Vikings had first pursued free agent Tyler Thigpen as well as the Vikings' insistence that he dramatically reduce his contract terms.
Thigpen is the quarterback I thought the Vikings might pair with rookie Christian Ponder, but Thigpen smartly agreed to terms with the Buffalo Bills, where he will have a chance to win a long-term starting job.
Ultimately, the deal is expected to happen. The Redskins will get a sixth-round draft pick in 2012 and possibly a conditional pick as well. Stay tuned.
Scramble'11: Readying Christian Ponder
Chuck Cook/US PresswireChristian Ponder is the Vikings long-term solution at quarterback, and possibly their short-term solution as well.I don't see it, never have seen it and won't see it until it hits me upside the head in a surprise. My sense is the Vikings drafted Ponder at No. 12 overall with the full expectation that he would be their immediate starter. He won't come to training camp completely cold, having studied a version of their new playbook for the past three months. There is no way he will be totally up to speed when the regular season begins, but would it be worth a draft pick to acquire the shortest of short-term starters?
My answer is no, and nothing team officials said during a news conference Monday suggested otherwise. I do think the Vikings will sign a veteran, but it will be someone to provide insurance against an unexpected hurdle in Ponder's development. I don't know who that person is, but I think it's much more likely to be someone of the Tyler Thigpen variety than Orton or McNabb.
Vice president of player personnel Rick Spielman alluded to that scenario Monday. He acknowledged the Vikings have discussed every possible scenario but added: "I know we've talked about making sure the veteran quarterback will be the right fit, too. Not only for us to potentially win ballgames if we go down that route, but also the right fit in the room for Ponder and Joe Webb and Rhett Bomar."
Coach Leslie Frazier wouldn't rule out any possibility, but we know Ponder will be his quarterback in the long term. I have no doubt he wants Ponder as his quarterback in the short term as well.
"We're going to try to do what's best for the Vikings and what's best for our roster," Frazier said. "But I wouldn't put it past us to open the season with a young quarterback if that's the case."
As the muckety-muck of an unprecedented lockout transitions into the NFL's new free-agent template, we still must guard against being led astray by teams who don't want their competitors to get a preview of their game plan. If the Vikings were preparing an offer for Orton or McNabb, they wouldn't have jumped up and said so Monday.
But I'll go on record now and suggest it would be a mistake to invest the assets necessary, be it draft picks or salary cap space or both, to bring in a veteran starter. Frazier is building his offense around tailback Adrian Peterson and can employ an array of playmakers in the passing game, even if free agent Sidney Rice signs elsewhere. That kind of team can and should support a rookie quarterback, lost offseason or otherwise.
Bears hoping to add Joe Webb to their list
AP Photo/Paul Sancya"'Monday Night Football,' you can't get better than that," said Joe Webb of his probable first start. To put it bluntly, does it matter? Whoever takes the Minnesota Vikings' first snap will be the fourth backup quarterback the Bears have faced this season. Smith's team has won all three previous games, allowing a total of 26 points and limiting the passers to an average of 142 yards per game.
ESPNChicago.com's Jon Greenberg suggested the "Bears are getting another break in a season full of fortune." Indeed, they appear to be living the kind of charmed existence necessary for most division winners in this era of NFL parity.
And let's be clear: The Bears won't simply be facing a backup quarterback at TCF Bank Stadium. The Vikings' starter will be a pull-the-ripcord-emergency replacement for Brett Favre and Tarvaris Jackson, both of whom suffered significant injuries in consecutive weeks.
The Vikings announced Saturday they will start Joe Webb -- a sixth-round draft choice once projected as a receiver and whose future position remains unclear. His backup will be journeyman Patrick Ramsey, whose first practice with the team was Thursday.
Webb's ascendance should please fans of both teams. For the Vikings, he represents the excitement of the unknown at the end of a deeply disappointing season. The Bears have remained publicly respectful of Webb, but surely they know he is the rawest quarterback they have faced this season and one who will start only through unique circumstances.
If common sense had prevailed in the spring, Webb would be into his 15th week as a receiver/kick returner/Wildcat quarterback. That was the original vision after Senior Bowl coaches switched him from quarterback to receiver in January. Webb, in fact, gained some national buzz after the emergence of a YouTube video that showed him jumping over seven stacked drill bags.
Nick Laham/Getty ImagesIt will be Joe Webb (14), not Brett Favre, who starts for the Vikings on Monday night.Is he a quarterback because of his skills or as the result of a Machiavellian sideshow? I'm not sure. Regardless, Webb has appeared permanently amused ever since. As in: Not even I can believe I'm a quarterback on a National Football League roster. Watching him practice and interact with teammates has been at once charming and frightening.
"I really like his attitude," offensive coordinator Darrell Bevell said. "He's got great confidence in his ability. He's kind of an unflappable guy. He does come across like he doesn't know what he doesn't know [and doesn't know] what he's getting himself into. He just really does believe in his ability and that he can make plays in the field."
We'll find out Monday night if that confidence is justified or borne from blissful ignorance. Frankly, it could be either. Webb had the kind of training camp that made you cringe at times and raise an eyebrow at others. He'd throw a 6-yard duck followed by a 50-yard rope. He tantalized late-game preseason observers with a 48-yard touchdown run against the San Francisco 49ers and, as expected, helped nudge Rosenfels off the roster in September.
Considering Favre's 18-year streak of consecutive starts, the decision carried little weight at the time. But now Webb is set to make his first NFL start on "Monday Night Football" against a defense that ranks fifth in the NFL with 26 takeaways. Oh, and the game-time temperature is expected to be around 20 degrees -- or about 20 degrees lower than the coldest game he said he ever started at Alabama-Birmingham.
"I mean, it's a great opportunity. "Monday Night Football," you can't get better than that," Webb said. "You've been dreaming that ever since you've been a little kid. Watching the game ever since you've been a little kid and now I'm probably going to be a part of it. [I'd] love to take advantage of it."
Webb has carried himself as a happy-go-lucky interloper in an NFL locker room. Monday night, he'll have a chance to demonstrate he belongs on the big stage.
"Joe, he is a character," Bevell said. "He's got great personality. The guys like him. The players around him feed off his energy. But he has great confidence, and I don't think he has any doubt about stepping in the huddle, calling plays, doing what we're asking him to do. ... As long as he's working within the offense, who can't believe in him?"
Here's the better question: If the Bears took care of business against Jimmy Clausen, Tyler Thigpen and Drew Stanton, shouldn't they do the same against Joe Webb? Who can't believe that?
- I got a number of angry responses Thursday night after sending out an innocent tweet about the Bears' defensive resurgence. @packerinsider wrote: "the bears really did a good job shutting down the QB-less, OL-less, Brandon Marshall-less, Wildcat-less Dolphins offense." To the extent that the Dolphins' offensive approach was baffling, I agree. Why they felt compelled to put the game in quarterback Tyler Thigpen's hands, while ignoring tailbacks Ronnie Brown and Ricky Williams, was beyond me. (In fact, the seven combined carries by Miami running backs was tied for the lowest full-game total in Dolphins history, according to the Elias Sports Bureau.) But I don't think that decision should diminish the Bears' performance. The Dolphins might have shied away from the run based on pregame scouting of the Bears' run defense, which is now allowing the second-lowest average yards per game (78.0) in the NFL. And in this league, especially this year, teams deserve credit for doing what they should do. It doesn't always happen that way.
- The Bears' six-sack performance resulted from another instance of defensive coordinator Rod Marinelli largely relying on a base number of pass-rushers. According to ESPN Stats & Information, five of six sacks came on plays where Marinelli had four men rushing the passer. At times, that four-man rush included a "zone blitz" in which a defensive lineman dropped into coverage while a linebacker rushed the passer. But overall, the Bears dominated the Dolphins' injury-plagued offensive lineman. Defensive end Julius Peppers tore up left tackle Jake Long, who was playing with a torn labrum in his shoulder. Ultimately, Marinelli sent an extra rusher on only 18 percent of the Dolphins' pass plays.
- The Bears limited the Dolphins to one third-down conversion in 11 opportunities, bringing the Bears' two-game total to two of 20 in that department. I know that the most important defensive statistic is points allowed. But the reason the Bears are allowing the fewest points per game in the NFL (14.6) is that they are stopping opponents' drives at such a high rate. Only one team, the New York Giants, has a lower third-down conversion rate (29 percent) this season than the Bears (31). It doesn't matter how many yards you give up. Your opponent can't score enough points to win if it is punting or attempting field goals.
Kevin SeifertThe Bears enter the examination room on the heels of their 16-0 shutout of the Dolphins.What's gotten into offensive coordinator Mike Martz? Matt Forte's game-sealing touchdown run in the third quarter was the Bears' 29th running play of the game. To that point, they had thrown 21 passes. As we discussed in our pregame post, the Bears need balance from their offense even if they're not always getting equal production. In the Bears' three games since the bye, all victories, Forte and backup Chester Taylor have combined for an average of more than 30 carries per game. That's a significant adjustment from Martz, who would throw two passes per play if he could. Martz also smartly moved away from one of his favorite passes, the screen, when the Dolphins demonstrated why they are the NFL's best defense against them. As it was, quarterback Jay Cutler has to throw the ball away on two of the three screens I logged.
BBAO: Brad Childress contract details
ESPN.com senior writer John Clayton turned up an interesting nugget in his weekly "First and 10" column. According to Clayton, the contract of Minnesota Vikings coach Brad Childress is guaranteed for significantly less money than we thought.
The contract Childress signed last year was advertised as extending through the 2013 season. In fact, the final year is a team option. That means the guaranteed portion of the deal ends after 2012. Clayton reported that Childress is due a total of $6.6 million over those two seasons.
Looked at another way, the buyout on Childress’ deal is about 42 percent of what the Vikings are paying quarterback Brett Favre this season. That total is nothing to sneeze at, but it’s much less than the $12 million previously reported. The revised figures are something to keep an eye on moving forward.
Continuing around the NFC North:
- Brian Murphy of the St. Paul Pioneer Press: "Jared Allen's calf-roping sack celebration symbolized the Vikings' dominant defense when the fan favorite pass rusher used to stalk quarterbacks. These days, Minnesota's sagging defense is best characterized by images of players with their hands on their hips, heads hanging in dejection after yielding another first down to an offense on the march."
- Tom Pelissero of 1500ESPN.com considers the Sidney Rice situation in the context of the Vikings' big-picture roster dilemma.
- The Vikings have already surpassed their 2009 season total in turnovers, notes Chip Scoggins of the Star Tribune.
- Here's what Chicago Bears coach Lovie Smith said after a 16-0 victory over the Miami Dolphins, via David Haugh of the Chicago Tribune: "We wanted to put the pressure on that second-place team behind us."
- The Bears have found a familiar recipe for success, writes Melissa Isaacson of ESPNChicago.com.
- It's only fair to point out the Bears had a few things going for them Thursday night, writes Rick Morrissey of the Chicago Sun-Times. Among them: The Dolphins started No. 3 quarterback Tyler Thigpen.
- Jeff Dickerson of ESPNChicago.com chronicles defensive end Julius Peppers' three-sack game.
- The Bears are continuing to improve offensively, writes Michael C. Wright of ESPNChicago.com.
- The Detroit Lions have a tough matchup Sunday against the Dallas Cowboys' big wide receivers, writes Carlos Monarrez of the Detroit Free Press.
- How much patience should Lions fans have with this team? That's what John Niyo of the Detroit News is asking.
- The Packers are excited about using rookie Sam Shields as a kick returner, writes Tom Silverstein of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel.
- Although place-kicker Mason Crosby's conversion rate has dropped in each of his four seasons, the Packers' support of him has never wavered. Mike Vandermause of the Green Bay Press-Gazette has more.
- Packers nose tackle B.J. Raji has quietly made a big impact this season, according to Jason Wilde of ESPNMilwaukee.com.
Rapid Reaction: Bears 16, Dolphins 0

Here are a few quick thoughts from the Bears’ third straight victory:
What it means: Like the Green Bay Packers, the Bears are also on a three-game winning streak. But the Bears continue to lead an NFC North race that is down to just two teams. Chicago’s victory over the Dolphins raises the stakes for the Packers, who face division rival Minnesota on Sunday needing to keep pace with the Bears.
Sackfest: Led by Julius Peppers, the Bears racked up a season-high six sacks Thursday night against a depleted Dolphins offensive line competing with a backup quarterback in third-stringer Tyler Thigpen.
Peppers finished with three sacks, and Israel Idonije, Brian Urlacher and Henry Melton registered one sack apiece.
Playing with an injured shoulder, Miami left tackle Jake Long surprisingly held his own for a half against Peppers, who seemed poised to have a breakout performance against the Dolphins. Peppers registered his first sack since Oct. 3. Peppers dropped Thigpen for a 1-yard loss with 1:25 left in the first half, in addition to batting down a pass. Two of Peppers’ sacks came in the first half, and he tacked on another sack in the fourth quarter.
Miami’s offensive line, meanwhile, was further banged up in the first quarter when backup center Cory Procter -- subbing for starter Joe Berger -- left the game with a knee injury. The Dolphins slid over guard Richie Incognito to fill in for Procter.
About time: Running back Matt Forte rushed for 97 yards. He has reached the century mark just twice all season.
Melton contributing: Considered almost an afterthought in the club’s plans on defense heading into the season, Melton seems to be making meaningful contributions in the defensive line rotation. He registered his second sack in two outings Thursday night.
Melton, a second-year player, has had at least two tackles in four of his past five games, and has been on the active roster every week. As a rookie last year, Melton was placed on the injured reserve before the regular season even started.
Law of threes: The Dolphins had their third center (Incognito) hiking the ball to the No. 3 quarterback (Thigpen). The Bears, meanwhile, seemed able to score solely in increments of three, taking a 9-0 lead in the third quarter on three field goals from Robbie Gould.
Taking it further, three different players -- Melton, Peppers, and Idonije -- were responsible for the Bears’ first three sacks, which also occurred within the first three quarters. The club didn’t post another sack until the fourth quarter.
What’s next: A week from Sunday the Bears will host a potent Philadelphia Eagles squad that stomped the Washington Redskins on "Monday Night Football" behind a phenomenal effort by quarterback Michael Vick. Chicago’s defense has been consistent all season, but it faces by far its biggest test in containing the red-hot quarterback.
Five things to watch: Bears at Dolphins
1. One for the record books? A victory would give the Bears their 700th regular-season victory in team history, the first franchise to reach that milestone. (The Green Bay Packers are next on the list with 660 franchise victories.) There would be something karmic about doing it in Miami, the site of their only loss of the 1985 season and also where they lost Super Bowl XLI.

2. Miami's run game. With No. 3 quarterback Tyler Thigpen making his first start in two years, the Dolphins figure to rely heavily on running backs Ronnie Brown and Ricky Williams. The Bears have been vulnerable to long runs this season, having given up an NFL-high 11 runs of 20 or more yards. But the Dolphins have broken only three runs of 20 or more yards, tied for fifth-worst in the NFL. As good as Brown and Williams are at grinding out tough yards, they might not be equipped to capitalize on the Bears' vulnerability against breakaway threats.
3. Wounded prey. Dolphins left tackle Jake Long is listed as questionable because of a shoulder injury. He's expected to play, but you would think the Bears will put defensive end Julius Peppers in position to test Long's agility at the outset. Thigpen is relatively mobile, but there is nothing worse than starting a game with concerns about whether your left tackle has all of his faculties. Thigpen, by the way, is an aggressive downfield thrower who will have to guard against the trap of the Cover 2 defense. The Bears have given up an NFL-low three passes of 30 or more yards this season. Thigpen will need the patience of a veteran to avoid throwing downfield interceptions.
4. Run-pass ratio. Including quarterback scrambles, the Bears have run the ball more than they have passed in each of their past three victories. It's hard to imagine them winning Thursday night if that ratio is reversed. The Dolphins have the NFL's sixth-ranked pass defense, holding opponents to a 58.4 completion percentage and a bit more than 200 yards per game. They also have 23 sacks. Quarterback Jay Cutler got much better protection last week against the Minnesota Vikings, but the Bears shouldn't push it.
5. Night fright. Strange things happen to Cutler at night. Last season, he threw five interceptions in one night game, four in another and a total of 13 interceptions in five. On a Sunday night earlier this year, he was sacked nine times in the first half by the New York Giants before departing with a concussion. Thursday night, Cutler could be without one of his favorite crutches. According to ESPN Stats & Information, Cutler has thrown the second-most screen passes (31) in the NFL this season. But the Dolphins' defense has been especially adept at stopping those plays. Opponents are completing just 55 percent of screen attempts against them, by far the lowest mark in the NFL. The Washington Redskins rank second at 71 percent. We'll see if Cutler can get through a night game without one of his favorite plays.
BBAO: Another Tyler Thigpen appearance
You're on the right track if the name "Tyler Thigpen" rings a bell. The quarterback expected to start Thursday night against the Chicago Bears was a seventh-round draft pick of the Minnesota Vikings in 2007. (It always goes back to the Vikings, doesn't it?)
The Vikings liked Thigpen and wanted to develop him as a long-term project. But they weren't willing to create a roster spot to do it, and instead tried to slip him through waivers and place him on the practice squad. (The backup quarterbacks they kept instead, Brooks Bollinger and Kelly Holcomb, are long gone.) The Kansas City Chiefs claimed Thigpen largely because he impressed them during a joint training camp practice, and he had an impressive stretch of 11 starts during the 2008 season. The Chiefs traded him to the Miami Dolphins in 2009.
Jeff Darlington of the Miami Herald chronicles Thigpen's journey. Bears fans might be rejoicing in facing the Dolphins' No. 3 quarterback, but rest assured he has more experience and skill than the players that fill that job for many teams.
- Lori Nickel of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel asks whether the Green Bay Packers will get any help from their new running back depth.
- Once and current Packers tight end/linebacker Spencer Havner didn't burn any bridges after being waived this summer, notes Mike Vandermause of the Green Bay Press-Gazette.
- The Detroit Lions' run blocking has been suspect this season, writes Chris McCosky of the Detroit News.
- On Sunday, the Lions will face ex-teammates Jon Kitna and Roy Williams, who now play for the Dallas Cowboys. Carlos Monarrez of the Detroit Free Press has more.
- The Lions have the worst record in NFL history for any team that has outscored its opponents at this point in the season, Michael David Smith writes in the Wall Street Journal.
- The short week left the Bears practicing on Tuesday. All players participated on at least a limited basis and should be available for Thursday night's game against Miami, according to Jeff Dickerson of ESPNChicago.com.
- Bears quarterback Jay Cutler is using his mobility to his advantage lately, writes Dan Pompei of the Chicago Tribune.
- The Bears' offense is improving, according to Mike Mulligan of the Chicago Sun-Times.
- The Star Tribune considers the possibility that Minnesota Vikings receiver Sidney Rice will opt out of playing at all this season because of a hip injury and concerns about how his value could be impacted on the free-agent market.
- Tom Powers of the St. Paul Pioneer Press writes that Vikings owner Zygi Wilf needs to hire a "football czar" to straighten out his team.
- The Pioneer Press: "Vikings defensive tackles Kevin Williams and Pat Williams today will ask the Minnesota Court of Appeals to permanently block the NFL from suspending them four games because the league violated state drug-testing laws when it tried to punish them in 2008."
» Draft Watch: Biggest needs (2/17) | Busts/gems (2/24) | Schemes, themes (3/3) | Recent history (3/10) | Needs revisited (3/17) | Under-the-radar needs (3/26) | History in that spot (3/31) | Draft approach (4/7) | Decision-makers (4/14) | Dream scenario/Plan B (4/21)
Each Wednesday leading up to the NFL draft (April 22-24), the ESPN.com blog network will take a division-by-division look at key aspects of the draft. Today's topic: Biggest needs revisited.
Chicago Bears
Last month: The Bears started five different safety combinations last season and have a pressing need for a ball-hawking free safety. Al Afalava could fit as a strong safety, but the Bears don't seem to trust any of their incumbent safeties in deep coverage. The Tampa 2 scheme doesn't always put safeties in position to make big plays, but the Bears' free safety has too often been a liability. Chicago could also use depth at defensive end after the death of Gaines Adams and the expected departure of Adewale Ogunleye.
Now: The Bears have addressed some of the needs we first identified last month via the free-agent market, signing defensive end Julius Peppers to replace Ogunleye and Chester Taylor to provide premium depth in the backfield. But both safety positions remain noticeably untouched. There have been some suggestions that the Bears pursue St. Louis safety O.J. Atogwe, a restricted free agent who would require no compensation to pry from the Rams. Barring a run at him, safety ranks with offensive line as the Bears' top needs with the draft looming in five weeks.
Detroit Lions
Last month: Depth is an issue at most positions, but none moreso than in the Lions' interior offensive and defensive lines. They are in position to draft an elite defensive tackle with their No. 2 overall pick, be it Oklahoma's Gerald McCoy or Nebraska's Ndamukong Suh. They also will be scouring the nation for candidates to play both guard positions alongside center Dominic Raiola. A receiver to steal some coverage from Calvin Johnson should be a priority after the middling performance of free-agent acquisition Bryant Johnson last season. There could also be a need at tight end, where starter Brandon Pettigrew is recovering from a torn anterior cruciate ligament and his two backups -- Casey Fitzsimmons and Will Heller -- are eligible for unrestricted free agency.
Now: The Lions have addressed the interior of their defensive line, acquiring defensive tackle Corey Williams from Cleveland and hosting defensive tackle/end Anthony Hargrove, a restricted free agent, on a visit. Veteran guard Chester Pitts is scheduled for a visit, but the left guard position might ultimately be filled through the draft. It's also not out of the question that the Lions target Oklahoma State left tackle Russell Okung with the No. 2 overall pick. The Lions have addressed their No. 2 receiver position with free agent Nate Burleson and re-signed Heller, two other areas of need we discussed.
Green Bay Packers
Last month: Both of the Packers' starting offensive tackles, Chad Clifton and Mark Tauscher, are pending unrestricted free agents. At 34 and 33, respectively, neither player has a long career ahead of him. The Packers might have addressed one of the positions by drafting T.J. Lang last year, but they could use additional depth and options considering both positions must soon be turned over. Injuries last season revealed a need for depth in the defensive backfield, especially at cornerback, and the Packers also need to determine whether they will replace outside linebacker Aaron Kampman.
Now: Clifton and Tauscher have both re-signed, but finding a left tackle of the future remains one of the Packers' top priorities as the draft approaches. Clifton signed a three-year deal, but it's not clear how long he will play. As per their philosophy, the Packers haven't addressed any needs by signing free agents from other teams. They'll target their remaining need positions in the draft. In addition to left tackle, that positional list should also include outside linebacker and cornerback.
Minnesota Vikings
Last month: Whether or not quarterback Brett Favre returns in 2010, the Vikings must establish a succession plan at the position. They've drafted three quarterbacks in the past four years, but among that list -- Tarvaris Jackson, Tyler Thigpen and John David Booty -- none are signed for 2010. There's no reason to believe the Vikings consider Sage Rosenfels a long-term solution, so drafting a quarterback would seem to be among their highest priorities. Another area of need is at cornerback, where starter Cedric Griffin is recovering from a torn anterior cruciate ligament and nickelback Benny Sapp is a pending unrestricted free agent.
Now: The Vikings re-signed Sapp to give them an alternative if Griffin isn't ready to start the season, but cornerback could still be a high priority in the draft. The loss of Taylor makes depth at running back an issue, but that is one position where it makes sense to go young. As draft boards begin to shape up, it will be interesting to see if the Vikings get an opportunity to fill their need for a long-term quarterback answer. Will there be anyone of that description available with the No. 30 overall pick? That debate remains unsettled.
» Draft Watch: Biggest needs (2/17) | Busts/gems (2/24) | Schemes, themes (3/3) | Recent history (3/10) | Needs revisited (3/17) | Under-the-radar needs (3/26) | History in that spot (3/31) | Draft approach (4/7) | Decision-makers (4/14) | Dream scenario/Plan B (4/21)
Each Wednesday leading up to the NFL draft (April 22-24), the ESPN.com blog network will take a division-by-division look at key aspects of the draft. Today's topic: Recent history.
Chicago Bears
The Bears have been unable to add fresh blood to their pass rush, striking out on defensive end Dan Bazuin in 2007 and getting nothing so far from defensive end/tackle Jarron Gilbert (2009). That void, along with a lack of first- or second-round picks this year, left the Bears no choice but to pursue free agent Julius Peppers. The Bears have also drafted seven defensive backs over the past three years, and only one of them -- cornerback Zack Bowman -- figures as a lock to contribute in 2010. Those failures have left the Bears still looking to fill perhaps both safety positions this offseason. That's one position where you can find a starter in the later rounds, and it almost assuredly will be a focus for the Bears next month.
Detroit Lions
About the only position the Lions have placed on the backburner is quarterback, thanks to their decision to draft Matthew Stafford last year. Although Stafford hasn't yet proved he is the Lions' long-term answer, the money he received as the No. 1 pick all but guarantees he will be their starter for the next few years at least. Otherwise, well-known recent failures have left the Lions scrambling to fortify nearly every other position. Given the frequency with which they have drafted first-round receivers, they never should have needed to sign free agents Bryant Johnson and Nate Burleson in successive years. The failure of defensive linemen Cliff Avril, Andre Fluellen and Ikaika Alama-Francis to provide impact has necessitated a 2010 overhaul that should continue with a defensive tackle coming with the No. 2 overall pick of the draft.
Green Bay Packers
The Packers' biggest problem is that several years of above-average drafting has left them with a lineup of restricted free agents who have established themselves as starters and are ready for their second contracts. In this draft, the Packers shouldn't need to focus on safety, thanks to incumbents Nick Collins and Atari Bigby. They are in pretty good shape at receiver with former draft choices Jordy Nelson and James Jones backing up Greg Jennings and Donald Driver. Tight end Jermichael Finley's emergence makes his position a secondary priority. Injuries to former second-round pick Pat Lee has made cornerback a priority, and the inability to draft a successor at left tackle forced the Packers to re-sign Chad Clifton last week.
Minnesota Vikings
The Vikings head into the 2010 draft with quarterback at the top of their need list in part because they haven't been able to develop former second-round pick Tarvaris Jackson into a long-term starter. They also parted ways with second-day draft picks Tyler Thigpen and John David Booty. But beyond that position, however, focused drafting has left the Vikings able to draft the best available player with most of their picks this year. Although he is still developing, former second-round pick Tyrell Johnson is a starter. The same goes for former sixth-round pick John Sullivan at center and former second-round pick Phil Loadholt at right tackle.
Each Wednesday leading up to the NFL draft (April 22-24), the ESPN.com blog network will take a division-by-division look at key aspects of the draft. Today's topic: biggest team needs.
Chicago Bears
The Bears started five different safety combinations last season and have a pressing need for a ball-hawking free safety. Al Afalava could fit as a strong safety, but the Bears don't seem to trust any of their incumbent safeties in deep coverage. The Tampa-2 scheme doesn't always put safeties in position to make big plays, but the Bears' free safety has too often been a liability. Chicago could also use depth at defensive end after the death of Gaines Adams and the expected departure of Adewale Ogunleye.
Detroit Lions
Depth is an issue at most positions, but none moreso than in the Lions' interior offensive and defensive lines. They are in position to draft an elite defensive tackle with their No. 2 overall pick, be it Oklahoma's Gerald McCoy or Nebraska's Ndamukong Suh. They also will be scouring the nation for candidates to play both guard positions alongside center Dominic Raiola. A receiver to steal some coverage from Calvin Johnson should be a priority after the middling performance of free agent acquisition Bryant Johnson last season. There could also be a need at tight end, where starter Brandon Pettigrew is recovering from a torn anterior cruciate ligament and his two backups -- Casey FitzSimmons and Will Heller -- are eligible for unrestricted free agency.
Green Bay Packers
Both of the Packers' starting offensive tackles, Chad Clifton and Mark Tauscher, are pending unrestricted free agents. At 34 and 33, respectively, neither player has a long career ahead of him. The Packers might have addressed one of the positions by drafting T.J. Lang last year, but they could use additional depth and options considering both positions must soon be turned over. Injuries last season revealed a need for depth in the defensive backfield, especially at cornerback, and the Packers also need to determine whether they will replace outside linebacker Aaron Kampman.
Minnesota Vikings
Whether or not quarterback Brett Favre returns in 2010, the Vikings must establish a succession plan at the position. They've drafted three quarterbacks in the past four years, but among that list -- Tarvaris Jackson, Tyler Thigpen and John David Booty -- none are signed for 2010. There's no reason to believe the Vikings consider Sage Rosenfels a long-term solution, so drafting a quarterback would seem to be among their highest priorities. Another area of need is at cornerback, where starter Cedric Griffin is recovering from a torn anterior cruciate ligament and nickel back Benny Sapp is a pending unrestricted free agent.Why Booty is practice-squad eligible
A number of you questioned Monday's assertion that Minnesota quarterback John David Booty is eligible for the practice squad. After all, there are a number of places in cyberspace that note practice squad players must have less than one accrued year of NFL experience. Booty, the Vikings' No. 3 quarterback last season, was credited with a year of experience last season and is officially entering his second year in the league.
But after checking with people who would know -- and consulting the official version of the NFL's collective bargaining agreement -- I can tell you that Booty is, in fact, eligible for the practice squad this season.
The short version of the explanation is that the CBA allows for two possibilities in eligibility. (You can check Article XXXIV, Section 4(a) if you're interested in the exact language.)
Less than one accrued season is one marker for eligibility. But a player with one accrued season can be eligible if he was active for fewer than nine regular-season games during that season. Technically, Booty was active for only one game last year and was on the game-day inactive list for the other 15 as the Vikings' No. 3 quarterback.
After seeing this passage in the CBA, I confirmed Booty falls under this category. It's relatively rare but does exist.
With all of that said, I have no idea if the Vikings will try to sneak Booty onto the practice squad. Doing so requires a player to pass through waivers, meaning he could be claimed by another team before the Vikings have a chance to sign him to the practice squad. Minnesota lost quarterback Tyler Thigpen that way in 2007 when Kansas City claimed him.
All this really means is the Vikings have the option to attempt the maneuver if they want. It would allow them to keep backups Tarvaris Jackson and Sage Rosenfels on their active roster while continuing to develop Booty. Will it happen? We'll know in a few weeks.
Meanwhile, watch the video below to find out why Minnesota defensive end Jared Allen believes he could be one of Brett Favre's top targets.
It's over for K.C./Minnesota joint practices
EDEN PRARIE, Minn. -- Those of you who build your summer schedule around the annual Minnesota/Kansas City training camp practice will have to find another August anchor.
Vikings coach Brad Childress confirmed Thursday that the teams won't practice together in 2009. New Chiefs general manager Scott Pioli actually informed Childress of the decision during the February scouting combine. It's unlikely the Vikings will find another practice partner for this summer.
"And that is OK," Childress said. "[Kansas City] just happened to be convenient because they were close. We are fine working with ourselves."
I'm guessing you'll be OK with it, too. The drama between the two teams has petered out since the middle of the decade, when you needed two hands to count the number of fights in each practice. My personal favorite came in 2004, when former wrestler Brock Lesnar -- trying out as a defensive tackle -- started pinning Chiefs offensive linemen to the ground. (It seemed Lesnar didn't realize it would be hard to make a tackle if he was more worried about slamming guards, but that's for another day.)
Three years later, the Chiefs became enamored while watching a rookie quarterback throw the ball. The next month, ex-Kansas City general manager Carl Peterson claimed quarterback Tyler Thigpen when the Vikings tried sneaking him through waivers and on to the practice squad.
By my count, the NFC North is one of two divisions without a single "Wildcat" snap this season. And, as you no doubt know by now, the Wildcat offense -- where a non-quarterback takes a shotgun snap -- is all the rage in the NFL this season.
(The AFC South is the other holdout.)
(Thanks to a couple readers who pointed out that I should have typed "AFC South" instead of "NFC South" in the original version of this post.)
![]() | |
| AP Photo/Charles Rex Arbogast | |
| The Bears have hinted at having some "Wildcat"-type plays featuring the ever-dangerous Devin Hester. |
But there are still seven games remaining, and you never know when one of our Black and Blue teams might get fancy. So let's have a little fun and take a look at the possibilities. In alphabetical order, as always:
Chicago: Offensive coordinator Ron Turner has hinted the Bears have practiced the formation using receiver/kick returner Devin Hester as the "quarterback." Chicago fans are no doubt salivating over that possibility. Can you imagine Hester running an option play? Or simply treading water in the backfield until he spots an opening, as he has done on many of his touchdown returns? Another possibility is receiver Rashied Davis, who is a pretty good open-field runner as well.
Detroit: I'm sure Lions fans would love to see receiver Calvin Johnson line up as the quarterback and put his open-field abilities to the test. But doing so would eliminate pressure to defend against a long pass in that formation. I like the idea of lining up tailback Kevin Smith and having him take off in the same direction as Johnson's route. Smith would get the option of either turning the corner or throwing Johnson's way. It might get a few yards -- or at least sell a few tickets.
Green Bay: If nothing else, a direct snap to tailback Ryan Grant might jump-start the Packers' stagnant running game. And if Kansas City's Tyler Thigpen can run a deep touchdown route out of the Wildcat, so can the Packers' Aaron Rodgers. But to put the maximum pressure on a defense, Green Bay would probably need to put one of their starting receivers, Donald Driver and Greg Jennings, in the backfield. Both are good open-field runners. I can envision Driver motoring around the edge of a surprised defense.
Minnesota: Coach Brad Childress' commitment to the fundamentals of his offense makes the Vikings one of the unlikeliest teams to run the Wildcat. But they have some intriguing personnel for the job, starting with tailback Adrian Peterson. I have no idea if he can throw the ball -- unlike many players, Peterson doesn't toss the ball around during practice -- but a few direct snaps could put a defense on its heel. Tailback Chester Taylor has shown decent touch on a few trick plays, and receiver Sidney Rice proved to have a gun on two option passes last season.



