Niners get great value, plus risk, in Crabtree

April, 25, 2009
Apr 25
5:23
PM ET
Print
By Mike Sando

Posted by ESPN.com's Mike Sando

The 49ers had to like where they were sitting at No. 10 once the Jaguars selected Virginia tackle Eugene Monroe at No. 8. At that point, the 49ers knew Texas Tech receiver Michael Crabtree, Mississippi tackle Michael Oher or Boston College defensive tackle B.J. Raji would fall to them in the 10th slot.

Raji went to the Packers at No. 9. That left Crabtree available to the 49ers somewhat unexpectedly. The suspense was building. Would 49ers general manager Scot McCloughan take the most talented player available, even though McCloughan's teams had drafted only one receiver among the top 55 overall choices during his 15-year personnel career?

The ultimate decision to select Crabtree over Oher and the other available players allowed the 49ers to maximize the value of that choice. This pick was an easy one from a value standpoint. Crabtree is arguably among the three most talented prospects in the draft. The 49ers landed him in the 10th spot. Crabtree comes to them with much to prove. He'll need to mature. The fatherly role Mike Singletary likes to play will apply here.

This is a relatively high-risk choice. However, the 49ers had a need. Crabtree was certainly talented enough to warrant a top-10 selection. That makes this a good pick for the 49ers, even with the risk.

Draft Rd. Pick McCloughan's Team Receiver
College Conference
2001
1 9 Seahawks
Koren Robinson NC St.
ACC
2009
1 10
49ers
Michael Crabtree
Texas Tech
Big 12
1996
2 56 Packers Derrick Mayes
Notre Dame
Independent
2007
3 76 49ers Jason Hill
Wash. St. Pac-10
2000 3 80
Seahawks Darrell Jackson
Florida
SEC
1999
3 82 Seahawks Karsten Bailey
Auburn SEC
2006 3 84
49ers Brandon Williams
Wisconsin
Big Ten
1995 3 90
Packers Antonio Freeman
Virginia Tech
ACC
2001
5 140 Seahawks Alex Bannister
E.Kentucky
Ohio Valley (I-AA)
1994
5 146 Packer Terry Mickens Florida A&M
MEAC (I-AA)
1998
5 150 Packers Corey Bradford
Jackson St.
SWAC (I-AA)
2004
5 157 Seahawks D.J. Hackett
Colorado Big 12
1994
6 169 Packers Jay Kearney
W.Virginia
Big East
1995
6
173 Packers Charlie Simmons
Georgia Tech
ACC
2008
6 174 49ers Josh Morgan
Virginia Tech ACC
2005
5 174 49ers Rasheed Marshall
W.Virginia
Big East
2000
6 175 Seahawks James Williams
Marshall
C-USA
1994
6
181 Packers Bill Schroeder
Wisc.-LaCrosse WIAC (II)
1999
7 213 Packers Donald Driver
Alcorn ST.
SWAC (I-AA)
1997
7 213 Packers Chris Miller
USC
Pac-10
2005
7 223 49ers Marcus Maxwell
Oregon
Pac-10
2003
7 224 Seahawks Taco Wallace
Kansas St.
Big 12

Sort comments by: Most Recent | First Posted