WEEK 1 | WEEK 2 | WEEK 3 | WEEK 4 | WEEK 5 | WEEK 6 | WEEK 7 | WEEK 8 | WEEK 9 | WEEK 10 | WEEK 11 | WEEK 12 | WEEK 13 | WEEK 14 | WEEK 15 | WEEK 16

1. SAM BRADFORD

Quarterback | St. Louis Rams ... Next Game: 1/2 at SEA

Bradford completed 71 percent of his passes for 292 yards in leading the Rams past the 49ers in a game that allowed St. Louis to control its playoff destiny in Week 17. Bradford had gone three games without a touchdown pass. There were times Sunday when the offense wasn't moving. The Rams generally stayed conservative, but Bradford still made big plays, including a 46-yard strike to Danario Alexander and a 41-yarder to Brandon Gibson. Bradford's scrambling 3-yard scoring pass to Laurent Robinson was vintage Bradford (if there can be such a thing at this stage of his career). He used his athleticism to outrun defenders before throwing back across his body with accuracy. Another strong game from Bradford could leave the Rams with an 8-8 record and the NFC West title.

Week 16 vs. SF (W, 25-17)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
28	37	292	75.7	46	1	0	107.0

2. MATT HASSELBECK

Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks ... Next Game: 1/2 vs. STL

The Seahawks were operating efficiently before Hasselbeck suffered a hip injury during the 1-yard scoring run that gave Seattle a 7-0 lead. Hasselbeck did not return. He completed 3 of 4 passes for 24 yards before suffering the injury. The trending arrow for Hasselbeck points sideways because he didn't play long enough to improve his standing, and the injury clouds his future. Hasselbeck will not practice during the week, coach Pete Carroll said, and the quarterback might not play against the Rams. Hasselbeck appeared on his way to an improved performance Sunday. He needed one, too, but the injury prevented that from happening. It's possible Hasselbeck has taken his last snap as a Seahawk.

Week 16 at TB (L, 38-15)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
3	4	24	75.0	9	0	0	89.6

3. ALEX SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 1/2 vs. ARI

Smith was reasonably efficient for the 49ers amid difficult circumstances. He took no snaps with the No.1 offense during the week and came into the game when the Rams had control. The 49ers needed more from Smith. The quarterback lost a fumble during a sack on third-and-9 from the Rams' 42 with 2:27 remaining and the 49ers down by eight. Smith's contract expires after the season. The 49ers will have new leadership by then and that leadership will likely want to start fresh at the position, and for good reason.

Week 16 at STL (L, 25-17)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
10	15	120	66.7	33	0	0	91.0

4. TROY SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 1/2 vs. ARI

Like quite a few backup quarterbacks, Troy Smith's play deteriorated the longer he was on the field. The 49ers won his first two starts, then lost three of his next four. No one bothered to ask Mike Singletary which quarterback would start the 49ers' game against Arizona in Week 17. Interim coach Jim Tomsula will make that call. San Francisco can no longer qualify for the playoffs. Troy Smith and Alex Smith have already shown what they can and cannot do. Might this be the week to sign Nate Davis from the practice squad and see what happens?

Week 16 at STL (L, 25-17)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
7	19	153	36.8	60	1	1	62.0

5. JOHN SKELTON

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 1/2 at SF

The Cardinals' offense sputtered along for much of the game Saturday night before Skelton led Arizona on the drive to the winning field goal. His 26-yard pass to Larry Fitzgerald on fourth-and-15 was the offensive play of the game for Arizona. Skelton followed up with a 19-yarder for Max Komar to set up Jay Feely's winning field goal. The finish outweighed the overall body of work for Skelton, who completed only 11 of 25 passes overall. Skelton might have shown enough to factor into the Cardinals' plans as the No. 2 quarterback next season.

Week 16 vs. DAL (W, 27-26)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
11	25	183	44.0	74	1	0	82.6

6. CHARLIE WHITEHURST

Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks ... Next Game: 1/2 vs. STL

Whitehurst provided an upgrade from Hasselbeck against Atlanta last week, in my view, but he struggled in relief against Tampa Bay. Taking over a lost cause in the second half of a home game might be easier for an inexperienced quarterback than playing nearly a full game on the road without getting first-team reps during the week. Whitehurst could get the start against the Rams. An impressive performance in victory would help change negative perceptions.

Week 16 at TB (L, 38-15)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
11	18	66	61.1	14	0	0	68.3

7. DEREK ANDERSON

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 1/2 at SF

Anderson has yet to play since doctors diagnosed a concussion following the Cardinals' game against St. Louis in Week 13. Arizona has no reason to set aside playing time for Anderson at this point. Starting Skelton in Week 17 makes the most sense.

Week 16 vs. DAL (W, 27-26)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

8. DAVID CARR

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 1/2 vs. ARI

Carr has not played since Week 7.

Week 16 at STL (L, 25-17)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

WEEK 1 | WEEK 2 | WEEK 3 | WEEK 4 | WEEK 5 | WEEK 6 | WEEK 7 | WEEK 8 | WEEK 9 | WEEK 10 | WEEK 11 | WEEK 12 | WEEK 13 | WEEK 14 | WEEK 15 | WEEK 16

1. SAM BRADFORD

Quarterback | St. Louis Rams ... Next Game: 12/26 vs. SF

The Rams rookie has no TDs with five INTs over his last three games after putting up 11 TDs and one INT from Weeks 6-12. Bradford has absorbed significant punishment over the past three games. Arizona's Adrian Wilson hit him hard two weeks ago, tweaking Bradford's ankle. New Orleans repeatedly hit Bradford hard and awkwardly last week. The Chiefs' Tamba Hali and others took their turns Sunday. The season remains a success for Bradford by just about every rookie measure, but he's struggling some as the season comes to a close.

Week 15 vs. KC (L, 27-13)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
21	43	181	48.8	25	0	2	40.9

2. ALEX SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 12/26 at STL

The 49ers were horrible against San Diego on Thursday night. Smith was part of the problem. His performance was not entirely irredeemable, however. Smith appeared to score a momentum-generating rushing TD early in the game, but officials overturned the call on replay. Smith remains in the No. 2 spot on this list because none of the other candidates has played well enough to overtake him. Smith also avoided interceptions against the Chargers until throwing one on a fourth-down desperation play late in the game. His performance against Seattle in Week 14 stands as the most productive by an NFC West quarterback in some time.

Week 15 at SD (L, 34-7)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
19	29	165	65.5	36	0	1	66.0

3. MATT HASSELBECK

Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks ... Next Game: 12/26 at TB

Three third-quarter turnovers led the Seahawks to replace Hasselbeck with backup Charlie Whitehurst. Coach Pete Carroll declined to say whether Whitehurst would remain the starter beyond Sunday. Either way, Hasselbeck is clearly declining. He has 17 INTs for the second season in a row. Hasselbeck would have to throw five TD passes without an INT to match his disappointing totals from last season. This is the second week in a row Hasselbeck has ranked lower than Alex Smith. That is telling.

Week 15 vs. ATL (L, 34-18)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
10	17	71	58.8	17	0	2	28.9

4. TROY SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 12/26 at STL

Coach Mike Singletary said he considered making a quarterback change during the 49ers' 34-7 defeat at San Diego. Switching from Alex Smith back to Troy Smith after less than one game wasn't going to change anything, most likely. But if Alex Smith struggles at St. Louis in Week 16, Singletary might be inclined to give Troy Smith another try. Troy Smith did light up the Rams' secondary when the teams played earlier this season. His production plateaued in subsequent weeks, however.

Week 15 at SD (L, 34-7)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

5. CHARLIE WHITEHURST

Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks ... Next Game: 12/26 at TB

Whitehurst is trending upward because he finally got back on the field and he provided an upgrade at the position by protecting the football against Atlanta. Whitehurst showed off his mobility by scrambling for a TD. His strong arm also was apparent. The Seahawks haven't announced their starter for Week 16, but this seems like a good time to give Whitehurst a shot. Hasselbeck has committed too many turnovers recently to keep the job. If Whitehurst struggles, the team could always go back to Hasselbeck. But if the team sticks with Hasselbeck heading into Week 16, how in the world can Whitehurst ever be considered a viable alternative in Seattle?

Week 15 vs. ATL (L, 34-18)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
8	16	83	50.0	31	0	0	65.4

6. JOHN SKELTON

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 12/25 vs. DAL

The Cardinals' passing game is largely a mess and a rookie passer such as Skelton isn't going to fix the problems. Skelton missed open receivers Sunday against Carolina. He threw a costly interception. Dropped passes also continued to plague the Cardinals' offense. This has become a lost season for Arizona, but at least Skelton is getting some work. He seems to be holding up reasonably well under the circumstances. He should be better for the experience.

Week 15 at CAR (L, 19-12)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
17	33	196	51.5	41	0	1	57.1

7. DEREK ANDERSON

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 12/25 vs. DAL

Concussion-related symptoms have sidelined Anderson for the past two games. The Cardinals have little incentive to get Anderson back onto the field anyway. They're out of the playoff race and there's little evidence Anderson gives them a significantly better chance to win. Anderson has probably taken his last snap for the Cardinals.

Week 15 at CAR (L, 19-12)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

8. DAVID CARR

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 12/26 at STL

The 49ers' decision to sign Carr makes little sense in retrospect. Of course, the team has lost its general manager and fired its offensive coordinator since adding Carr and sending Shaun Hill to Detroit via trade. It's an upset if Carr throws another pass for the 49ers this season, and perhaps ever.

Week 15 at SD (L, 34-7)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

WEEK 1 | WEEK 2 | WEEK 3 | WEEK 4 | WEEK 5 | WEEK 6 | WEEK 7 | WEEK 8 | WEEK 9 | WEEK 10 | WEEK 11 | WEEK 12 | WEEK 13 | WEEK 14 | WEEK 15 | WEEK 16

1. SAM BRADFORD

Quarterback | St. Louis Rams ... Next Game: 12/19 vs. KC

The rookie gets some slack following a rough performance on the road against the defending Super Bowl champs. Bradford's leadership shined through when he tracked down Saints safety Roman Harper following an ultimately disallowed 82-yard fumble return. His 32-yard strike to Laurent Robinson on fourth-and-18 set up Bradford's fourth-and-1 scoring run late in the game. The outcome was decided, but how the Rams finished the game mattered. Bradford wasn't reckless with the football even though New Orleans picked him off twice. This was a rough day, but not a discouraging one.

Week 14 at NO (L, 31-13)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
18	32	231	56.3	32	0	2	53.0

2. ALEX SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 12/16 at SD

A single performance should not be enough for Smith to move past a veteran as accomplished as Seattle's Matt Hasselbeck. Smith also has better stats for the season. He has the same number of TD passes and six fewer INTs. Smith could easily fall back down the list with a rocky showing against San Diego on Thursday night. His three-TD, mistake-free performance in Week 14 was exactly what the 49ers needed from him. San Francisco has now converted 28 of 59 times on third down in the last four full games Smith has played. The figure was 18 of 61 for the five games he missed.

Week 14 vs. SEA (W, 40-21)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
17	27	255	63.0	62	3	0	130.9

3. MATT HASSELBECK

Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks ... Next Game: 12/19 vs. ATL

Two TD passes and six INTs in two December games have knocked down Hasselbeck. He has eight picks in the Seahawks' last three games. It's looking more like receiver Mike Williams was the one making Hasselbeck look good, and less the other way around. That's a problem for Seattle given Williams' recurring injury problems. Hasselbeck has fought through his own physical issues, including a broken left wrist. He needs to fight through the mental side more effectively. A quarterback with his experience shouldn't fall apart the way Hasselbeck did while suffering five turnovers Sunday.

Week 14 at SF (L, 40-21)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
27	42	285	64.3	43	2	4	60.2

4. TROY SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 12/16 at SD

Alex Smith's strong performance against the Seahawks could make it tough for Troy Smith to get back on the field this season, barring injury. Tight end Vernon Davis couched his praise for Alex Smith by saying he had nothing against Troy Smith. Still, the message was clear. Davis: "Oh, he will remain the starter. I'm sure. I believe in that. Not saying anything bad about Troy Smith. I'm happy to have both of those guys. Whoever is playing is going to be good. You had better believe that. But I look forward to the next three games with Alex Smith at quarterback."

Week 14 vs. SEA (W, 40-21)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

5. JOHN SKELTON

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 12/19 at CAR

The Cardinals rookie made it through his first NFL start without suffering a turnover. Skelton even recovered a fumble after thumb issues contributed to a couple bad snaps from center Lyle Sendlein. Like Max Hall, who fell off this rankings list when Arizona placed him on injured reserve, Skelton managed to win his first start with the team despite throwing no touchdown passes. Coach Ken Whisenhunt waited until Monday before naming Skelton the starter for Week 15, even if Anderson is healthy.

Week 14 vs. DEN (W, 43-13)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
15	37	146	40.5	25	0	0	52.3

6. CHARLIE WHITEHURST

Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks ... Next Game: 12/19 vs. ATL

Hasselbeck tossed four picks and the Seahawks were getting blown out, but coach Pete Carroll did not turn to Whitehurst. Carroll: "I didn't get Charlie warmed up. It was my fault for not getting him warmed up to get a couple series so he can play some. Matt was seeing things well. He knew what was going on. He was clear about the mistakes that were made." Getting Whitehurst into the game was obviously an afterthought for Carroll. That probably isn't a great sign. Whitehurst's opportunity could come soon enough if Hasselbeck keeps struggling.

Week 14 at SF (L, 40-21)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

7. DEREK ANDERSON

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 12/19 at CAR

A concussion prevented Anderson from factoring into the Cardinals' quarterback decision against Denver. Getting cleared this week could make Anderson available, but Whisenhunt said Skelton would start anyway.

Week 14 vs. DEN (W, 43-13)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

8. DAVID CARR

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 12/16 at SD

The 49ers have no plans to get Carr onto the field in any capacity.

Week 14 vs. SEA (W, 40-21)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

WEEK 1 | WEEK 2 | WEEK 3 | WEEK 4 | WEEK 5 | WEEK 6 | WEEK 7 | WEEK 8 | WEEK 9 | WEEK 10 | WEEK 11 | WEEK 12 | WEEK 13 | WEEK 14 | WEEK 15 | WEEK 16

1. SAM BRADFORD

Quarterback | St. Louis Rams ... Next Game: 12/12 at NO

The Rams quarterback has struggled somewhat mysteriously on first down this season. The trend continued against the Cardinals. Bradford also lacked consistency on third down, a departure from form. The plays he did make on third down helped to define a gritty performance. Bradford showed toughness and resolve. It's news now when he throws an interception. Bradford blamed poor mechanics for the ball that sailed on him Sunday. Bradford continued to own second down, completing 8 of 9 passes for 72 yards and a 100.0 rating (in line with his 100.6 second-down rating for the season).

Week 13 at ARI (W, 19-6)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
18	29	187	62.1	26	0	1	66.3

2. MATT HASSELBECK

Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks ... Next Game: 12/12 at SF

The numbers were not pretty against Carolina, but Hasselbeck gets some slack for battling through difficult circumstances. His top two receivers, Mike Williams and Ben Obomanu, suffered injuries early in the game. Williams left during the first possession. Obomanu lasted until the second quarter. Neither returned. Tight end John Carlson wasn't even active. That left Hasselbeck with three wideouts -- Deon Butler, Brandon Stokley and Golden Tate -- for most of the game. He averaged a healthy 7.7 yards per attempt, but two picks knocked down his rating into the low 50s. Seattle converted five times in 10 chances on third down.

Week 13 vs. CAR (W, 31-14)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
17	30	229	56.7	36	0	2	53.3

3. ALEX SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 12/12 vs. SEA

Smith didn't even play Sunday, but his relative success in the red zone seemed appealing after watching the 49ers struggle badly in that area during their defeat at Green Bay. Smith has eight TDs and no INTs with a 124.4 rating in the red zone this season. Current 49ers starter Troy Smith hasn't fared as well in that area of the field. Troy Smith has made more big plays, bypassing the red zone altogether, but his inefficiency comes at a price.

Week 13 at GB (L, 34-16)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

4. TROY SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 12/12 vs. SEA

Good NFL quarterbacks generally complete at least 60 percent of their passes these days. Troy Smith completed 40 percent against the Packers. He did connect on a few big plays, notably a 66-yard TD strike to Vernon Davis. The big-play ability is what separates Troy Smith from Alex Smith at this point. The 49ers were becoming more efficient on third down when Alex Smith was the quarterback, however. San Francisco converted 21 of 42 (.500) third-down chances in the final three full games Alex Smith played before suffering a shoulder injury. The team has converted 18 of 61 chances (.295) in five full games with Troy Smith.

Week 13 at GB (L, 34-16)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
10	25	194	40.0	66	1	1	64.4

5. CHARLIE WHITEHURST

Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks ... Next Game: 12/12 at SF

For a minute it appeared Whitehurst might get into the game Sunday. Hasselbeck appeared shaken after planting awkwardly. In the end, another week passed without Whitehurst making an impact. It's looking like Whitehurst will not see the field in a meaningful capacity this season unless Hasselbeck suffers an injury.

Week 13 vs. CAR (W, 31-14)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

6. DAVID CARR

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 12/12 vs. SEA

Carr isn't moving up in the rankings. Quarterbacks around him are moving down.

Week 13 at GB (L, 34-16)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

7. DEREK ANDERSON

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 12/12 vs. DEN

Anderson struggled against the Rams and ultimately left the game amid concerns he might have suffered a concussion. The Cardinals' problems on offense go far beyond the QB position. The line isn't protecting very well or very consistently, at least. Receivers are dropping too many passes. Anderson hasn't been good enough to transcend those difficulties.

Week 13 vs. STL (L, 19-6)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
7	20	93	35.0	26	0	1	29.8

8. JOHN SKELTON

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 12/12 vs. DEN

The rookie had taken only eight practice reps during the week and he had no idea he would find his way into an NFL game for the first time. The Cardinals had to like the 22-yard pass Skelton completed to Steve Breaston on third-and-16. Skelton showed decent arm strength. Arizona will be reluctant to start him against Denver -- or against anyone, for that matter -- but what are the choices at this point?

Week 13 vs. STL (L, 19-6)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
3	6	45	50.0	22	0	0	75.0

9. MAX HALL

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 12/12 vs. DEN

Hall crammed two sacks, one interception, one fumble and a dislocated non-throwing shoulder into five snaps Sunday. It's not his fault the Cardinals thought he could win games for them this season. Still, the team's decision to name Hall its No. 2 quarterback and eventually its starter stands as one of the worst quarterback miscalculations I can recall.

Week 13 vs. STL (L, 19-6)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
1	3	10	33.3	10	0	1	4.2

WEEK 1 | WEEK 2 | WEEK 3 | WEEK 4 | WEEK 5 | WEEK 6 | WEEK 7 | WEEK 8 | WEEK 9 | WEEK 10 | WEEK 11 | WEEK 12 | WEEK 13 | WEEK 14 | WEEK 15 | WEEK 16

1. SAM BRADFORD

Quarterback | St. Louis Rams ... Next Game: 12/5 at ARI

Bradford became the first rookie quarterback in NFL history to pass for at least 300 yards and three touchdowns with no interceptions during a road victory. He has the Rams in first place after 11 games and heading to Arizona with confidence. His 17 TD passes rank second to Dan Marino's 20 in 1983 among rookies through 11 games (Marino started 11 games that season, finishing with 20 TDs and six INTs). The scouts I spoke with Sunday and Monday said they envisioned Bradford dominating the NFC West for years to come. Bradford has 11 TDs and one INT since top receiver Mark Clayton landed on injured reserve after Week 5. He'll have to get by without tight end Michael Hoomanawanui now.

Week 12 at DEN (W, 36-33)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
22	37	308	59.5	45	3	0	113.3

2. MATT HASSELBECK

Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks ... Next Game: 12/5 vs. CAR

Hasselbeck wasn't the problem during Seattle's discouraging 42-24 defeat to Kansas City in Week 13. The veteran passer could not overcome Mike Williams' absence and the Seahawks' utter lack of a running game. Hasselbeck appears to be holding up reasonably well from a physical standpoint. The team has rested his arm throughout the season, a smart move that Hasselbeck has welcomed. Hasselbeck's ability to sustain drives appears to hinge upon Williams' availability. He could use more from receiver Deon Butler, who struggled Sunday. Hasselbeck's rapport with Ben Obomanu continues to improve.

Week 12 vs. KC (L, 42-24)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
20	37	282	54.1	87	2	2	74.4

3. TROY SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 12/5 at GB

Smith threw a 38-yard TD strike to Michael Crabtree when the 49ers wanted to strike aggressively following a Cardinals turnover Monday night. That was all the scoring San Francisco needed. The 49ers didn't ask much from Smith during their run-oriented victory. They'll probably need more from him over the remaining five games after losing Frank Gore to a fractured hip. The success San Francisco enjoyed on the ground against Arizona came against a porous Cardinals defense, after all. Smith has a 3-1 starting record since taking over the position. That has to count for something.

Week 12 at ARI (W, 27-6)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
11	23	129	47.8	38	1	1	61.7

4. ALEX SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 12/5 at GB

It's strange seeing Alex Smith walk onto the field as a team captain during the pregame coin tosses. He's the 49ers' forgotten man, but his captaincy has not lapsed. Smith was better last season when he took over for Shaun Hill and expectations were low. He posted a 1-6 starting record this season (down from 5-5 in 2009) and will have a hard time getting onto the field again as long as the 49ers remain on their current course.

Week 12 at ARI (W, 27-6)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

5. DEREK ANDERSON

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 12/5 vs. STL

Anderson has proven ill-equipped to lead the Cardinals' offense this season. He showed an alarming lack of poise amid repetitive questioning following the Cardinals' embarrassing defeat Monday night. If Anderson cannot handle a few questions he found annoying, how can anyone expect him to handle critical situations on the field? The Cardinals will have to consider giving Max Hall another shot at this rate.

Week 12 vs. SF (L, 27-6)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
16	35	196	45.7	43	0	1	51.6

6. CHARLIE WHITEHURST

Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks ... Next Game: 12/5 vs. CAR

Most questions I receive regarding the Seahawks' quarterback situation assume Whitehurst has already proved he's not the answer beyond this season. I'm not so sure we've seen enough from Whitehurst to make that determination. We also haven't seen enough from him for the Seahawks to count on Whitehurst as more than a potential competitor at the position.

Week 12 vs. KC (L, 42-24)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

7. MAX HALL

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 12/5 vs. STL

The arrow for Hall points up only because Anderson's stock is falling. The Cardinals have lost six in a row. At some point, they might as well check out Hall or even fellow rookie John Skelton. This season is looking like a washout from a team standpoint.

Week 12 vs. SF (L, 27-6)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

8. DAVID CARR

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 12/5 at GB

Alex Smith's return to health following a shoulder injury makes it highly unlikely Carr will find his way onto the field again as a member of the 49ers.

Week 12 at ARI (W, 27-6)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

WEEK 1 | WEEK 2 | WEEK 3 | WEEK 4 | WEEK 5 | WEEK 6 | WEEK 7 | WEEK 8 | WEEK 9 | WEEK 10 | WEEK 11 | WEEK 12 | WEEK 13 | WEEK 14 | WEEK 15 | WEEK 16

1. MATT HASSELBECK

Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks ... Next Game: 11/28 vs. KC

The past two games have served notice that Hasselbeck can still play at a Pro Bowl level. Hasselbeck has completed 69.2 percent of his passes for 699 yards, two TDs, no INTs and a 105.7 rating in back-to-back games against Arizona and New Orleans. He has taken only one sack in those games. The recent push has left Hasselbeck with more TDs than INTs on the season for the first time since Week 1. Coach Pete Carroll and staff are showing more trust in Hasselbeck, turning him loose after several weeks of more conservative play. Hasselbeck has responded. He has triple-digit passer ratings in consecutive games for the first time since 2005.

Week 11 at NO (L, 34-19)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
32	44	366	72.7	68	1	0	104.9

2. SAM BRADFORD

Quarterback | St. Louis Rams ... Next Game: 11/28 at DEN

Bradford set a rookie record for most pass attempts without an INT before the Atlanta Falcons picked him off Sunday. He has eight TDs and one INT over his past five games. He made it through the Atlanta game without taking a sack, something he had not done in any of his previous nine starts. The Rams have lost three of four following a 3-3 start, however. Bradford is averaging only 5.7 YPA, a reflection of the limitations in the Rams' offense. The team needs to upgrade Bradford's weapons during the offseason to help the QB take the next step.

Week 11 vs. ATL (L, 34-17)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
27	42	233	64.3	25	2	1	84.7

3. TROY SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 11/29 at ARI

What happened to the bold downfield passer we saw in the 49ers' previous two games? Smith had problems against Tampa Bay when one-on-one matchups failed to materialize the way they had previously. His protection also faltered. The game plan seemed more conservative. The running game disappeared. Smith threw an INT for the first time this season. San Francisco now faces four of its next five games on the road. Coach Mike Singletary has not committed to Smith as his starter. A matchup against Arizona's defense could help Smith bounce back.

Week 11 vs. TB (L, 21-0)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
16	31	148	51.6	23	0	1	51.5

4. ALEX SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 11/29 at ARI

Alex Smith had three TDs and no INTs in his final two games before suffering a shoulder injury. He failed to complete even half his passes in either game, however, and the passing game had issues. His injured left shoulder has healed enough for the 49ers to consider making him their starter again. The 49ers will have to decide whether the Bucs exposed Troy Smith in a manner that warrants another QB change in San Francisco. The fact that Singletary will not commit to Troy Smith has Alex Smith's stock trending up, if only slightly.

Week 11 vs. TB (L, 21-0)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

5. DEREK ANDERSON

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 11/29 vs. SF

Anderson has generally cut down on turnovers since taking over the job during the Tampa Bay game in Week 8. The Cardinals have scored fewer points each week during that time, however. They aren't getting the return TDs that had pumped up their scoring and masked (from afar) issues that continue to linger on offense. Anderson has 796 yards, three TDs and one INT in his past two games. He has also taken 13 sacks in those games. Anderson simply doesn't deliver the ball accurately enough for the offense to sustain drives. Dropped passes hurt him Sunday.

Week 11 at KC (L, 31-13)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
25	46	295	54.3	27	1	0	81.3

6. CHARLIE WHITEHURST

Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks ... Next Game: 11/28 vs. KC

Hasselbeck's re-emergence over the past couple games has more clearly defined the QB situation in Seattle. Whitehurst did not help himself by missing throws against the New York Giants and tossing an INT in relief against the Cardinals. He made some good throws in the Arizona game, but if Hasselbeck keeps playing well and Seattle remains atop the NFC West, the Seahawks might not see Whitehurst again this season.

Week 11 at NO (L, 34-19)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
4	6	53	66.7	22	0	1	54.9

7. MAX HALL

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 11/29 vs. SF

The Cardinals are 0-4 in the last four games Anderson has started. They have lost five in a row overall in falling to 3-7 on the season. The more the Cardinals lose, the more incentive coach Ken Whisenhunt will have to give Hall another chance. Arizona remains only two games out of the NFC West race for now, however, so if Whisenhunt thinks Anderson gives the team its best chance at winning, there's no reason to make a QB change.

Week 11 at KC (L, 31-13)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

8. DAVID CARR

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 11/29 at ARI

Carr's career with the 49ers peaked when fans at Candlestick Park chanted his name during the Philadelphia game. Singletary sent Carr into the huddle, only to change his mind when players pleaded with him to stick with Alex Smith. No one is chanting for Carr now even though Troy Smith is coming off a rough game and Alex Smith has a 1-6 starting record this season.

Week 11 vs. TB (L, 21-20)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

WEEK 1 | WEEK 2 | WEEK 3 | WEEK 4 | WEEK 5 | WEEK 6 | WEEK 7 | WEEK 8 | WEEK 9 | WEEK 10 | WEEK 11 | WEEK 12 | WEEK 13 | WEEK 14 | WEEK 15 | WEEK 16

1. MATT HASSELBECK

Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks ... Next Game: 11/21 at NO

The Seahawks' veteran passer provided the leadership, toughness and passing his team needed to win at University of Phoenix Stadium for the first time. Hasselbeck's run as Seahawks quarterback appeared tenuous after he suffered eight sacks and a concussion at Oakland. But with Charlie Whitehurst throwing an interception in relief and Hasselbeck lighting up the Cardinals' secondary in Week 10, there's no question which quarterback gives Seattle its best chance at victory. The big question entering Week 11 is whether an injured left wrist will prevent Hasselbeck from playing or remaining effective when Seattle visits New Orleans.

Week 10 at Arizona (W, 36-18)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
22	34	333	64.7	63	1	0	106.6

2. SAM BRADFORD

Quarterback | St. Louis Rams ... Next Game: 11/21 vs. ATL

The Rams fell to 0-4 on the road even though Bradford put together what easily could have stood as a defining drive late in regulation. Tight end Daniel Fells dropped a pass similar to the one he caught for a touchdown against Carolina in the Rams' previous game. He might have scored on this one, too. Instead, the Rams had to settle for the tying field goal. Bradford completed better than 70 percent of his passes despite playing much of the game without his starting left tackle. He missed a couple throws, including when a wide-open Danny Amendola was running down the middle of the field. Bradford's pass sailed just long, depriving the Rams of a touchdown.

Week 10 at San Francisco (L, 23-20)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
30	42	251	71.4	25	1	0	94.4

3. TROY SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 11/21 vs. TB

The 49ers' new quarterback has completed 17 of 20 passes for 357 yards on first down this season. He owns a 2-0 starting record and has suffered no turnovers. The 49ers previously were turning over the ball too frequently. Smith has a strong feel for the game and situations. Teammates are responding to his aggressive mindset. Smith has clearly provided an adrenaline rush for the 49ers. The question now becomes whether Smith can perform consistently enough for the 49ers to keep winning. San Francisco went 0-for-11 on third down against the Rams. Smith has had success on early downs in part because opponents knew the 49ers might lean even more heavily on the run with a new quarterback.

Week 10 vs. St. Louis (W, 23-20)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
17	28	356	60.7	65	1	0	116.7

4. ALEX SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 11/21 vs. TB

Coach Mike Singletary has not yet named his starting quarterback for the 49ers' Week 11 game against Tampa Bay at Candlestick Park. Troy Smith seemingly has to be the choice. If Singletary handles the situation well, the switch to Troy Smith doesn't have to obliterate Alex Smith as an option at some point in the future. The team could always go back to Alex Smith if Troy Smith struggled. For now, however, Alex Smith appears to be on the outside.

Week 10 vs. St. Louis (W, 23-20)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

5. DEREK ANDERSON

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 11/21 at KC

The Cardinals started quickly on offense against Seattle and Anderson played a role. Arizona finally scored an opening-drive touchdown. The longer Anderson is on the field, however, the more his shortcomings become apparent. He needs strong support from the Cardinals' defense and running game. The defense was horrible Sunday. The running game was limited via injuries and game situations. The Cardinals still had a shot until Seattle's Aaron Curry sacked Anderson and forced a fumble, which the Seahawks recovered. There's no sense in making a quarterback change in Arizona after this game, but if the Cardinals keep losing, that will change.

Week 10 vs. Seattle (L, 36-18)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
23	45	322	51.1	36	1	1	72.6

6. CHARLIE WHITEHURST

Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks ... Next Game: 11/21 at NO

The Seahawks' confidence in Whitehurst can't be particularly high after shaky showings in back-to-back weeks. Whitehurst tossed an interception and led a drive to a field goal when subbing for an injured Hasselbeck in the third quarter Sunday. Hasselbeck had conducted target practice against Arizona's secondary. It's important to remember that Whitehurst has hardly played in the NFL. Whether starting or coming off the bench unexpectedly in relief, these are new situations for Whitehurst. So far, he hasn't produced well enough.

Week 10 at Arizona (W, 36-18)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
4	6	53	66.7	22	0	1	54.9

7. DAVID CARR

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 11/21 vs. TB

The 49ers have gone out of their way to avoid playing Carr, who appears to be entering the second half of his only season with the team.

Week 10 vs. St. Louis (W, 23-20)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

8. MAX HALL

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 11/21 at KC

Giving Hall late-season reps could make sense if the Cardinals keep losing. For now, however, Anderson appears to provide the best option.

Week 10 vs. Seattle (L, 36-18)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

WEEK 1 | WEEK 2 | WEEK 3 | WEEK 4 | WEEK 5 | WEEK 6 | WEEK 7 | WEEK 8 | WEEK 9 | WEEK 10 | WEEK 11 | WEEK 12 | WEEK 13 | WEEK 14 | WEEK 15 | WEEK 16

1. SAM BRADFORD

Quarterback | St. Louis Rams ... Next Game: 11/14 at SF

The Rams' rookie leader has exceeded reasonable expectations on nearly all fronts except one. He has not led the Rams to victory on the road. That must change for St. Louis to avoid another losing season. The team faces some good QBs on the road in the second half of the season (Kyle Orton, Drew Brees), so it will not be easy. But Bradford is gaining momentum lately with five TDs and no INTs in his past three games.

Week 8 vs. Carolina (W, 20-10)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
25	32	191	78.1	33	2	0	112.4

2. MATT HASSELBECK

Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks ... Next Game: 11/14 at ARI

Twenty-five quarterbacks have more TD passes than Hasselbeck this season. From 2003 through 2007 and even last season, Hasselbeck reached his current TD total no later than Week 5. The totals aren't likely to spike while the Seahawks continue to embrace a conservative approach on offense. Hasselbeck has only one INT and a 2-1 record in his past three starts, so the approach has worked to an extent. The Seahawks expect Hasselbeck to return against Arizona in Week 10. The QB has three TDs and six INTs in his last four games against the Cardinals, however.

Week 9 vs. N.Y. Giants (L, 41-7)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

3. TROY SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 11/14 vs. STL

One game isn't much to go on, but the 49ers aren't complaining about the results. Smith helped them to a badly needed victory over Denver and he's the favorite to start against the Rams in Week 10. Smith needs to improve his efficiency on third down, where his rating was only 70.4 against the Broncos (compared to 113.2 on first down and 139.1 on second down). Getting Vernon Davis back from injury should help.

Week 8 vs. Denver (W, 24-16)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
12	19	196	63.2	38	1	0	115.2

4. ALEX SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 11/14 vs. STL

Smith posted his three highest single-game passer ratings of the season before suffering a sprained left shoulder. The passing game was appearing disjointed, however. Smith failed to complete even half his passes in his two most recent starts. Coach Mike Singletary sounds inclined to leave Troy Smith in the lineup for another week. It's a critical time for Alex Smith. He needs a strong finish.

Week 8 vs. Denver (W, 24-16)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

5. DEREK ANDERSON

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 11/14 vs. SEA

Anderson played a turnover-free game against Minnesota, putting the Cardinals in position to pull off an upset. This game marked an improvement for Anderson on that basis alone. He'll move up the list with a similar showing against Seattle in Week 10. Anderson posted a 91.7 passer rating against Minnesota, his highest in a game since the 2008 season.

Week 9 at Minnesota (L, 27-24)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
15	26	179	57.7	30	1	0	91.7

6. CHARLIE WHITEHURST

Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks ... Next Game: 11/14 at ARI

The Seahawks used two or more tight ends on about two-thirds of their offensive snaps against the New York Giants, a stunning figure for a team that fell behind 35-0 in the first half. The approach helped Whitehurst play a full game without getting sacked, a huge upset. But the offense wasn't dynamic at all. Whitehurst, for his part, missed receivers too frequently, notably on a third-and-1 trick play that could have given Seattle momentum.

Week 9 vs. N.Y. Giants (L, 41-7)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
12	23	113	52.2	36	1	2	44.3

7. DAVID CARR

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 11/14 vs. STL

Carr was quite efficient in relief for the Giants last season, but the 49ers have showed virtually no faith in him. They gave Carr only a brief opportunity to change their minds, but Carr only reinforced their feelings about him with a late INT against Carolina.

Week 8 vs. Denver (W, 24-16)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

8. MAX HALL

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 11/14 vs. SEA

Ron Jaworski's stinging criticisms of Hall appear well founded, although plenty of eventually productive QBs struggled early in their careers. Jaworski became a Pro Bowler after beginning his career with one TD and eight INTs. There's still time for Hall, but the Cardinals need to stick with Anderson for now.

Week 9 at Minnesota (L, 27-24)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

WEEK 1 | WEEK 2 | WEEK 3 | WEEK 4 | WEEK 5 | WEEK 6 | WEEK 7 | WEEK 8 | WEEK 9 | WEEK 10 | WEEK 11 | WEEK 12 | WEEK 13 | WEEK 14 | WEEK 15 | WEEK 16

1. SAM BRADFORD

Quarterback | St. Louis Rams ... Next Game: 11/14 at SF

The Rams rookie has five TD passes without an INT in his past three games. He has 11 TD passes in his first eight NFL games, matching Ben Roethlisberger, Peyton Manning and Dan Marino for the most since the AFL-NFL merger in 1970, according to ESPN Stats & Information. Bradford has six TDs, zero INTs and a 101.2 rating on third down this season. He set a career high against Carolina by completing 78.1 percent of his passes.

Week 8 vs. Carolina (W, 20-10)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
25	32	191	78.1	33	2	0	112.4

2. MATT HASSELBECK

Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks ... Next Game: 11/7 vs. NYG

Eight sacks and a 13-for-32 passing performance against Oakland dragged down Hasselbeck's standing. He won't miss Oakland if this was his last start there. The Seahawks have converted twice in 27 third-down chances at Oakland in Hasselbeck's past two starts there, the previous one coming in 2002. Hasselbeck needs left tackle Russell Okung back in the lineup.

Week 8 at Oakland (L, 33-3)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
13	32	160	40.6	35	0	1	43.8

3. TROY SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 11/14 vs. STL

So far, so good for the 49ers' new starter. Smith averaged 10.3 yards per attempt with one TD rushing and one TD passing. He made timely plays and avoided turnovers. The 49ers have a bye week and that should help Smith settle into the starting job. Coach Mike Singletary wouldn't name his starter for Week 10, but can the team really afford to go backward?

Week 8 vs. Denver (W, 24-16)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
12	19	196	63.2	38	1	0	115.2

4. ALEX SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 11/14 vs. STL

The 49ers expect Alex Smith's left shoulder to recover in time for him to be cleared for the team's game against St. Louis following the bye. There's no reason to rush him back into the lineup after Troy Smith helped lead a 21-point fourth quarter to beat Denver, however.

Week 8 vs. Denver (W, 24-16)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

5. DEREK ANDERSON

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 11/7 at MIN

Anderson provided an upgrade in relief for the second game in a row. Then as now, the longer he was on the field, the worse the results. Anderson tossed a pair of first-down INTs in the final 5:08 of a close game, killer turnovers that showed, again, how little the Cardinals can trust him to protect the football.

Week 8 vs. Tampa Bay (L, 38-35)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
16	24	234	66.7	37	1	2	77.4

6. DAVID CARR

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 11/14 vs. STL

Carr did not play in Week 8 and he probably won't play for the 49ers unless an injury forces him onto the field. The INT he threw late in the Carolina game made the 49ers' decision to play Troy Smith an easier one.

Week 8 vs. Denver (W, 24-16)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0

7. MAX HALL

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 11/7 at MIN

The Bucs returned two of his INTs for touchdowns to take a 21-14 lead with 6:33 left in the second quarter. The Cardinals had seen enough at that point. They benched Hall, went with Anderson and outscored the Bucs by four points the rest of the way. Coach Ken Whisenhunt did not immediately name a starter for Week 9, but it's tough to envision the team having much confidence in Hall.

Week 8 vs. Tampa Bay (L, 38-35)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
8	16	71	50.0	17	1	2	43.5

WEEK 1 | WEEK 2 | WEEK 3 | WEEK 4 | WEEK 5 | WEEK 6 | WEEK 7 | WEEK 8 | WEEK 9 | WEEK 10 | WEEK 11 | WEEK 12 | WEEK 13 | WEEK 14 | WEEK 15 | WEEK 16

1. MATT HASSELBECK

Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks ... Next Game: 10/31 at OAK

Hasselbeck has gone back-to-back weeks without an interception for the first time since Weeks 12 and 13 last season. He's developing a strong rapport with receiver Mike Williams, particularly on third down. Hasselbeck has completed all nine third-down attempts to Williams in the Seahawks' past two games, converting eight first downs. Seattle scored only one TD in seven red zone possessions Sunday, however, and there were times when Hasselbeck invited sacks by holding the ball too long. He faces a potentially difficult matchup against Nnamdi Asomugha and the Oakland Raiders' defense in Week 8.

Week 7 vs. Arizona (W, 22-10)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
20	38	192	52.6	26	1	0	75.8

2. SAM BRADFORD

Quarterback | St. Louis Rams ... Next Game: 10/31 vs. CAR

Bradford posted his highest passer rating of the season Sunday even though this wasn't his best game. Bradford appeared less accurate than usual, completing only half of his passes for 126 yards. But the offense started quickly, jumping out to a 17-3 lead in the first half. Bradford avoided throwing an interception for the second week in a row and the second time in his career (although he did lose a fumble). Turnover avoidance can be half the battle even for veteran quarterbacks. Injuries at receiver could be catching up to Bradford. Returning home to face Carolina in Week 8 should give him a chance to bounce back.

Week 7 at Tampa Bay (L, 18-17)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
13	26	126	50.0	19	2	0	89.6

3. ALEX SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 10/31 vs. DEN

Smith started quickly against the Panthers, continuing a recent trend. But the offense stagnated and Smith appeared completely out of rhythm before an injured left shoulder knocked him from the game. The injury, Smith's season-long performance and the 49ers' 1-6 record are making this look like the quarterback's final season with the organization. The 49ers have not yet said how long Smith might miss while recovering from the injury, however.

Week 7 at Carolina (L, 23-20)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
9	19	129	47.4	53	1	0	87.4

4. DEREK ANDERSON

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 10/31 vs. TB

The Cardinals' offense perked up and drove toward its first touchdown since Sept. 26 when Anderson entered the game Sunday against Seattle. Anderson completed his first four passes for 67 yards. He then completed 4 of 13 passes for 29 yards during the rest of the game. The performance wasn't good enough for coach Ken Whisenhunt to name Anderson his starter against the Bucs in Week 8.

Week 7 at Seattle (L, 22-10)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
8	17	96	47.1	29	0	0	64.8

5. DAVID CARR

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 10/31 vs. DEN

The 49ers weren't asking for much from Carr when they put him into a 10-10 game early in the second half. They leaned heavily on Frank Gore, as expected, and happily accepted the defensive TD that gave them a 20-13 lead with 12:52 remaining in the fourth quarter. But when the 49ers needed a few passes to sustain drives, Carr was unable to deliver. The interception he threw on second-and-14 with 1:14 remaining put the Panthers in position to win the game.

Week 7 at Carolina (L, 23-20)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
5	13	67	38.5	22	0	1	23.6

6. MAX HALL

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 10/31 vs. TB

Hall struggled against the Seahawks and has yet to produce a touchdown drive in two starts. Hall lacks size and it appeared as though wet conditions made it tougher for him to throw the football with accuracy. Hall has taken a pounding this season, leaving both starts with injuries. He returned against New Orleans, but not against Seattle. Whisenhunt is sticking with Hall as his starter and Hall will presumably fare better at home in Week 8.

Week 7 at Seattle (L, 22-10)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
4	16	36	25.0	15	0	1	13.5

WEEK 1 | WEEK 2 | WEEK 3 | WEEK 4 | WEEK 5 | WEEK 6 | WEEK 7 | WEEK 8 | WEEK 9 | WEEK 10 | WEEK 11 | WEEK 12 | WEEK 13 | WEEK 14 | WEEK 15 | WEEK 16

1. MATT HASSELBECK

Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks ... Next Game: 10/24 vs. ARI

Hasselbeck remains in the top spot after becoming the first NFC West quarterback this season to lead his team to victory against a non-division opponent on the road. Hasselbeck appeared more comfortable than he has all season. This was his first game without a sack since the 2009 opener against St. Louis. He pushed the offensive tempo and threw confidently, particularly to receiver Mike Williams. Hasselbeck threw no interceptions after tossing at least one in eight consecutive games dating to last season. He had a legitimate shot at a 300-yard passing day until tight end John Carlson dropped a third-quarter pass for what would have been a big gain. This performance ended for now any thoughts about a quarterback change in Seattle. Hasselbeck looked like the man Sunday.

Week 6 at Chicago (W, 23-20)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
25	40	242	62.5	24	1	0	87.7

2. SAM BRADFORD

Quarterback | St. Louis Rams ... Next Game: 10/24 at TB

Bradford went without an interception for the first time in six NFL starts, posting a season-high 87.8 rating in a victory the Rams badly needed. Bradford continues to show good toughness, durability and leadership. He has overcome significant personnel losses (Donnie Avery, Mark Clayton). Bradford might have padded his stats some if the Rams had gone with a more aggressive game plan after building a double-digit lead in the first half. Then again, he's a rookie and might have turned over the ball, too. The bottom line, though, was that Bradford played well enough early for the Rams to take control and play the second half on their terms. One other thing: Bradford is 3-3 as an NFL starter for a team that had a 3-33 record in its previous 36 games.

Week 6 vs. San Diego (W, 20-17)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
18	31	198	58.1	38	1	0	87.8

3. ALEX SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 10/24 at CAR

Let's not focus too much on the aesthetics of the 49ers' 17-9 victory over the Raiders in Week 6. Smith tossed two touchdown passes, including a 32-yarder to Michael Crabtree when the 49ers absolutely needed a play along those lines. Smith went without an interception for the first time this season. For as much as the 49ers wanted Smith and the offense to take a significant step forward this season, turnover avoidance stood as the top priority following a 0-5 start. For reference, consider that Smith tossed no interceptions in four of the 49ers' final six games last season. The team went 4-2 over that stretch. The 49ers are now 1-0 this season when Smith avoids turnovers. And with 0-5 Carolina on the schedule next week, turnover avoidance should remain the priority. Sometimes teams must learn not to lose before they learn how to win.

Week 6 vs. Oakland (W, 17-9)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
16	33	196	48.5	35	2	0	87.4

4. MAX HALL

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 10/24 at SEA

Hall lost ground in the rankings during a Cardinals bye week that saw every other quarterback in the division win his game without throwing an interception. Hall faces the toughest challenge of any NFC West quarterback in Week 7 when he visits Qwest Field for the first time as a professional. At least there's a good chance receivers Steve Breaston and Early Doucet will return from injuries.

Week 5 vs. New Orleans (W, 30-20)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
17	27	168	63.0	26	0	1	65.0

WEEK 1 | WEEK 2 | WEEK 3 | WEEK 4 | WEEK 5 | WEEK 6 | WEEK 7 | WEEK 8 | WEEK 9 | WEEK 10 | WEEK 11 | WEEK 12 | WEEK 13 | WEEK 14 | WEEK 15 | WEEK 16

1. MATT HASSELBECK

Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks ... Next Game: 10/17 at CHI

The bye week made Hasselbeck the top-rated quarterback in the division by default. Seattle's veteran passer could be nearing a crossroads, however. Another performance like the one he provided during a 20-3 defeat at St. Louis before the bye seems entirely plausible heading onto the road against a 4-1 Chicago Bears team featuring Julius Peppers rushing off the edge. If that happens, no one should be surprised to see the Seahawks give Charlie Whitehurst a shot at the job. But if Marshawn Lynch and a healthier offensive line restore balance to the offense, Hasselbeck can hold onto his job and, perhaps, the top spot in these weekly rankings.

Week 4 at St. Louis (L, 20-3)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
20	36	191	55.6	36	0	1	58.9

2. SAM BRADFORD

Quarterback | St. Louis Rams ... Next Game: 10/17 vs. SD

The No. 1 overall draft choice played like a rookie following a two-week stretch when he more closely resembled a seasoned veteran. He posted a season-low 46.1 rating during the Rams' 44-6 defeat at Detroit. Losing top receiver Mark Clayton barely a month after losing previous top receiver Donnie Avery puts Bradford in a tough spot. The team needs rookie tight end Mike Hoomanawanui to pick up where he left off before suffering a severe high-ankle sprain. At least the Rams remain reasonably healthy on their offensive line, and Steven Jackson has fought through a groin injury pretty well. The injuries at receiver will still come at a price, however. Brandon Gibson and Mardy Gilyard must pick up the pace.

Week 5 at Detroit (L, 44-6)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
23	45	215	51.1	30	0	2	46.1

3. MAX HALL

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 10/24 at SEA

The Cardinals probably put too much faith in Hall against New Orleans. They spread the field, emptied the backfield and put the ball in the rookie's hands during critical third-down situations when running the ball arguably made more sense from a time-management standpoint. Hall responded by playing aggressively and fearlessly. Maybe a little too fearlessly. But the Cardinals emerged with a victory they needed badly heading into their bye week. Teammates said they responded to Hall's confidence and energy. That and the win were enough for Hall to take the third spot in the rankings this week.

Week 5 vs. New Orleans (W, 30-20)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
17	27	168	63.0	26	0	1	65.0

4. ALEX SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 10/17 vs. OAK

Smith has sometimes been at his best very early in games and then once games appear to have slipped away in the fourth quarter. He hasn't been good enough during those moments when games swing one way or another. Take Sunday night. The 49ers trailed the Eagles, 17-10, early in the fourth quarter. A good quarterback leads his team down the field to tie the game. Not Smith. The Eagles flustered him, chased him down, forced a fumble and returned the ball for a back-breaking touchdown. Only then did Smith come alive. His team trailed by two touchdowns by then. Smith did just enough to make it look like he's on the verge of great things. There's nothing great about an 0-5 record, however.

Week 5 vs. Philadelphia (L, 27-24)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
25	39	309	64.1	36	3	2	92.8

5. DEREK ANDERSON

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 10/24 at Seattle

Anderson finished the first half Sunday after the Saints shook up Hall with a hard hit. Not much new here.

Week 5 vs. New Orleans (W, 30-20)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
1	2	6	50.0	6	0	0	56.3

6. DAVID CARR

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 10/17 vs. OAK

The 49ers must have zero faith in Carr to stick with Smith exclusively to this point in the season. But if the 49ers do not beat Oakland, Carr has to get the call, right?

Week 5 vs. Philadelphia (L, 27-24)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0	0.0

WEEK 1 | WEEK 2 | WEEK 3 | WEEK 4 | WEEK 5 | WEEK 6 | WEEK 7 | WEEK 8 | WEEK 9 | WEEK 10 | WEEK 11 | WEEK 12 | WEEK 13 | WEEK 14 | WEEK 15 | WEEK 16

1. SAM BRADFORD

Quarterback | St. Louis Rams ... Next Game: 10/10 at DET

Peyton Manning had three TDs, 11 INTs and a 0-4 record in his first four regular-season games. He also took 11 sacks. Bradford has six TDs, six INTs and a 2-2 record with 10 sacks. Both joined the worst teams in the league. Bradford is faring better through four games and well enough to take over the No. 1 spot in my weekly divisional rankings. The bar is not particularly high in the NFC West right now, but Bradford's poise and command are more impressive than his stats to this point. The Rams believe in him.

Week 4 vs. Seattle (W, 20-3)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
23	41	289	56.1	49	2	1	84.3

2. MATT HASSELBECK

Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks ... Next Game: 10/17 at CHI

Seattle's veteran quarterback has thrown more TDs than INTs in a game just once this season and twice in his past 13 games dating to last season. Coach Pete Carroll committed to Hasselbeck as his starter following the Seahawks' 20-3 defeat at St. Louis in Week 4. The bye should give Seattle a chance to get its offensive line in place and begin evolving into a more aggressive team offensively. Hasselbeck doesn't deal with uncertainty particularly well, in my opinion, and there's lots of uncertainty for him right now -- constantly changing personnel, a new offense, new coaches, Charlie Whitehurst's presence and no contract for Hasselbeck beyond this season.

Week 4 at St. Louis (L, 20-3)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
20	36	191	55.6	36	0	1	58.9

3. ALEX SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 10/10 vs. PHI

The fourth-quarter drive he led against New Orleans and the 49ers' opening TD drive against Atlanta in Week 4 let Smith hold onto the third spot despite a 0-4 starting record this season. Let's face it, though: Ranking third among quarterbacks in this division isn't good enough. The 49ers have only one legitimate TD drive to show for their losses to Seattle, Kansas City and Atlanta. Smith's job appears safe because the 49ers do not have an alternative they consider ready or viable, and the team remains only two games back in the division after playing three of its first four games on the road. Smith must improve now that the schedule becomes more favorable.

Week 4 at Atlanta (L, 16-14)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
21	32	188	65.6	19	1	2	65.6

4. DEREK ANDERSON

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 10/10 vs. NO

Larry Fitzgerald rode to Anderson's defense after the Cardinals benched their quarterback against San Diego. Anderson could use that kind of protection from his offensive line, too. Fitzgerald is right when he says Anderson is not solely to blame for the Cardinals' problems on offense, but it's also fair to say Anderson hasn't been part of the solution, either. He has struggled throwing to a depleted cast of receivers. His accuracy remains a weakness.

Week 4 at San Diego (L, 41-10)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
7	14	64	50.0	16	0	2	23.2

5. MAX HALL

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 10/10 vs. NO

The undrafted rookie took six sacks after replacing Anderson, but at least he avoided interceptions. Whether or not Hall gets the start against New Orleans in Week 5, it's clear he's going to start at some point this season. Somewhat amazingly, that might not prevent the Cardinals from competing within the division. It could actually help if Hall develops quickly, the Cardinals get healthy at receiver and Beanie Wells emerges as expected.

Week 4 at San Diego (L, 41-10)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
8	14	82	57.1	24	0	0	74.1

WEEK 1 | WEEK 2 | WEEK 3 | WEEK 4 | WEEK 5 | WEEK 6 | WEEK 7 | WEEK 8 | WEEK 9 | WEEK 10 | WEEK 11 | WEEK 12 | WEEK 13 | WEEK 14 | WEEK 15 | WEEK 16

1. MATT HASSELBECK

Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks ... Next Game: 10/3 at STL

The Seahawks' passing game remains somewhat out of sync, especially as the team shuffles players through the skill-position spots within its base personnel. Hasselbeck still leads NFC West starters in yards per pass attempt. He's completing a healthy percentage overall. The Seahawks are giving Hasselbeck a chance with better-than-expected pass protection and game plans that move Hasselbeck away from pressure. The struggles from the base offense stand out when looking at Hasselbeck's passer ratings by down: 55.8 on first, 76.4 on second and 106.3 on third.

Week 3 vs. San Diego (W, 27-20)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
19	32	220	59.4	41	1	1	77.6

2. SAM BRADFORD

Quarterback | St. Louis Rams ... Next Game: 10/3 vs. SEA

Bradford can assume the top spot on this list if he can outplay Hasselbeck and lead the Rams to victory against Seattle in Week 4. Both quarterbacks have four touchdown passes and five interceptions this season. Bradford has zero touchdowns, four interceptions and a 28.3 rating on first down. He has three touchdowns, no interceptions and a 106.8 rating on second down. Teams can be less predictable on second down, when coordinators have more flexibility with their play calling. Perhaps that accounts for the difference. Bradford appears comfortable when the Rams run a faster-paced offense. Two-minute situations seem to suit him.

Week 3 vs. Washington (W, 30-16)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
23	37	235	62.2	30	1	1	78.1

3. DEREK ANDERSON

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 10/3 at SD

Anderson has been streaky, to say the least. He's been at his best deep in the red zone, completing 3 of 4 passes with two touchdowns and no interceptions from inside the opponents' 10-yard line. Still, it's fair to say the Cardinals are 2-1 in spite of their quarterback play, not because of it. Anderson shows admirable toughness. He's also tough to watch when he misses receivers. Anderson is completing 52 percent of his passes overall. Only Bruce Gradkowski, Jimmy Clausen and Matt Moore are completing a lower percentage among quarterbacks with at least 14 attempts per game this season.

Week 3 vs. Oakland (W, 24-23)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
12	26	122	46.2	25	2	1	69.7

4. ALEX SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 10/3 at ATL

Smith has thrown three of his five interceptions on third down. He failed to build upon the tying drive he led against New Orleans a week ago. The 49ers have problems beyond Smith right now, but it's tougher to say Smith is part of the solution after a 0-3 start and two horrid road performances. Smith probably remains the 49ers' best option after the team traded away Shaun Hill. But if NFL teams had to choose their starters for Week 4 from the current starters in the division, I don't think Smith would generate much momentum. The 49ers have converted only five times in 32 third-down chances on the road.

Week 3 at Kansas City (L, 31-10)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
23	42	232	54.8	41	1	1	68.8

WEEK 1 | WEEK 2 | WEEK 3 | WEEK 4 | WEEK 5 | WEEK 6 | WEEK 7 | WEEK 8 | WEEK 9 | WEEK 10 | WEEK 11 | WEEK 12 | WEEK 13 | WEEK 14 | WEEK 15 | WEEK 16

1. MATT HASSELBECK

Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks ... Next Game: 9/26 vs. SD

Hasselbeck is the only quarterback in the division with an impressive victory on his résumé this season, so he holds the top spot. But that might not last with another game like the one Hasselbeck played at Denver. This marked the third time in his last five starts (dating to last season) that Hasselbeck tossed at least three interceptions. His rating through two weeks is now lower than it was last season.

Week 2 vs. Denver (L, 31-14)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
20	35	233	57.1	52	1	3	51.3

2. ALEX SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 9/26 at KC

Smith is the only NFC West quarterback to lead the tying or go-ahead drive in the final two minutes of a fourth quarter this season. He played well enough late in the 49ers' 25-22 defeat Monday night to nudge past Bradford for the second spot at this point in the season. Smith scrambled effectively, stared down blitzers, found open receivers and commanded the offense effectively with the game on the line. He held up his end against a championship opponent.

Week 2 vs. New Orleans (L, 25-22)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
23	32	275	71.9	41	1	2	82.2

3. SAM BRADFORD

Quarterback | St. Louis Rams ... Next Game: 9/26 vs. WAS

Bradford is the only quarterback in the division to keep his team close in each of the first two games of the season. He completed his first seven passes for 98 yards and a score against Oakland in Week 2. He also rallied the Rams with a 59-yard touchdown drive in the final four minutes.

Week 2 vs. Oakland (L, 16-14)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
14	25	167	56.0	36	2	1	86.6

4. DEREK ANDERSON

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 9/26 vs. OAK

The Cardinals failed to convert even once on third down during their 41-7 defeat to the Falcons. Anderson was not entirely or even mostly to blame for the overall performance, but neither was he good enough to keep the Cardinals more competitive. Arizona must protect him better.

Week 2 at Atlanta (L, 41-7)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
17	31	161	54.8	29	0	2	42.5

WEEK 1 | WEEK 2 | WEEK 3 | WEEK 4 | WEEK 5 | WEEK 6 | WEEK 7 | WEEK 8 | WEEK 9 | WEEK 10 | WEEK 11 | WEEK 12 | WEEK 13 | WEEK 14 | WEEK 15 | WEEK 16

1. MATT HASSELBECK

Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks ... Next Game: 9/19 at DEN

Let's take a break from talking about how age and injuries have derailed Hasselbeck's career. He stayed steady after an early pick and gave Seattle what the 49ers needed from their QB.

Week 1 vs. San Francisco (W, 31-6)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
18	23	170	78.3	35	2	1	108.3

2. SAM BRADFORD

Quarterback | St. Louis Rams ... Next Game: 9/19 at OAK

His passer rating suffered from two interceptions thrown in desperation, but there was much to like about Bradford's leadership Sunday. The Cardinals' veteran defense could not make him blink. Bradford recovered a fumble and made a tackle, too.

Week 1 vs. Arizona (L, 17-13)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
32	55	253	58.2	39	1	3	53.1

3. DEREK ANDERSON

Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals ... Next Game: 9/19 at ATL

Gritty leadership with the game on the line helped the Cardinals hold off the Rams, but there were also quite a few inaccurate throws. Anderson targeted Larry Fitzgerald 15 times, connecting on three.

Week 1 vs. St. Louis (W, 17-13)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
22	41	297	53.7	35	1	0	85.1

4. ALEX SMITH

Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers ... Next Game: 9/20 vs. NO

Smith could have used some help out there, particularly from receiver Michael Crabtree, but his leadership wasn't strong enough. The 49ers converted only once in 15 third-down plays and a lot of that is on the QB.

Week 1 vs. Seattle (L, 31-6)

CMP	ATT	YDS	CMP%	LNG	TD	INT	RAT
26	45	225	57.8	23	0	2	52.5