Power rankings: How the voters voted

October, 6, 2009
10/06/09
1:00
PM ET

Posted by ESPN.com's Mike Sando
Rank Team Mike Sando John Clayton Paul Kuharsky Jeff Chadiha
1 IND 1 1 2 3
2 NYG 3 3 1 1
3 MIN 2 2 4 4
4 NO 4 4 3 2
5 NYJ 5 6 5 5
6 NE 6 7 6 6
7 BAL 7 8 7 7
8 DEN 8 5 10 8
9 ATL 10 9 8 12
10 PHI 9 10 12 11
11 CIN 11 11 13 9
12 SF 14 14 9 10
13 GB 12 15 11 15
14 CHI 13 13 14 13
15 PIT 15 12 15 14
16 SD 16 16 16 16
17 DAL 20 17 17 17
18 JAC 18 19 19 19
19 ARI 17 18 18 23
20 HOU 19 20 20 18
21 MIA 21 22 22 21
22 WAS 27 21 21 20
23 BUF 22 24 24 22
24 SEA 25 23 23 24
25 TEN 23 25 25 25
26 CAR 24 26 26 26
27 DET 26 28 27 27
28 OAK 28 27 28 28
29 CLE 29 29 31 29
30 KC 30 30 29 31
31 TB 31 31 30 30
32 STL 32 32 32 32


The Colts narrowly beat out the Giants for the top spot in ESPN.com's NFL Power Rankings for Week 5.

Those favoring the Giants can blame the Vikings, who moved into the No. 2 spot on two ballots following their victory over the Packers on "Monday Night Football."

The Vikings' late push left the Giants third on my ballot and John Clayton's ballot, enough to move the Colts into the No. 1 spot. The Ravens fell six spots to No. 7 overall following their Week 4 defeat at New England. The relatively large fall after only one defeat -- on the road, no less -- suggested panelists weren't necessarily sold on Baltimore as the top team.

The Giants have ranked higher than any team on average -- 2.7 overall -- since the 2009 power rankings debuted in May.

A look inside the rankings ...

Rising: The Broncos jumped five spots to No. 8, the largest gain from Week 4. The Jaguars and Redskins jumped four spots apiece. The 49ers and Dolphins moved up three. The Vikings rose two places. The Colts, Giants, Jets, Patriots, Steelers and Lions rose one spot apiece.

Falling: The Titans plummeted seven spots, the largest fall from Week 4. The Ravens fell six places to No. 7. The Chargers dropped four spots, the Packers three and the Bills two. The Raiders, Panthers, Seahawks, Eagles and Falcons each dropped one spot.

Unchanged: Rankings for the Saints, Bengals, Bears, Cowboys, Cardinals, Texans, Browns, Chiefs, Bucs and Rams remained unchanged.

Deadlocked: We broke one tie this week. Green Bay prevailed over Chicago for the 13th spot based on head-to-head results in Week 1.

Groupthink: Three panelists ranked the Jets fifth, the Patriots sixth and the Ravens seventh. All four panelists ranked the Chargers 16th. Three ranked the Cowboys 17th. Three ranked the Jaguars 19th. Three ranked the Titans 25th and the Panthers 26th. All four ranked the Rams 32nd.

Agree to disagree: For the second week in a row, the Redskins generated the widest gap -- seven spots -- between highest and lowest votes. Six other teams generated disparities of at least four spots:
  • Redskins (7): Chadiha ranked them 20th, higher than any voter ranked them. Sando ranked them 27th, lower than any voter ranked them.
  • Cardinals (6): Sando 17th, Chadiha 23rd.
  • Broncos (5): Clayton fifth, Kuharsky 10th.
  • 49ers (5): Kuharsky ninth, Sando and Clayton 14th.
  • Falcons (4): Kuharsky eighth, Chadiha 12th.
  • Bengals (4): Chadiha ninth, Kuharsky 13th.
  • Packers (4): Kuharsky 11th, Clayton and Chadiha 15th.
Power rankings histories: We now offer colorful layered graphs showing where each NFL team has ranked every week since the 2002 season.

Ranking the divisions: NFC East teams ranked 13.1 on average, slightly up from last week and still higher than any other division's teams. NFC West remained below AFC West teams as the lowest-ranked division on average. The chart below shows how each voter ranked each division on average. Highest votes in red. Lowest votes in blue.

Breakdown By Division
Voter AFC
East
AFC
North
AFC
South
AFC
West
NFC
East
NFC
North
NFC
South
NFC
West
Mike Sando 13.5 15.5 15.25 20.5 14.75 13.25 17.25 22
John Clayton 14.75 15 16.25 19.5 12.75 14.5 17.5 21.75
Paul Kuharsky 14.25 16.5 16.5 20.75 12.75 14 16.75 20.5
Jeff Chadiha 13.5 14.75 16.25 20.75 12.25 14.75 17.5 22.25
Average 14.0 15.4 16.1 20.4 13.1 14.1 17.3 21.6
Rank 2 4 5 7 1 3 6 8


A voter-by-voter look at changes of at least four spots since the Week 4 rankings:

Sando: Broncos (+8), Ravens (-6)

Clayton: Broncos (+6), Texans (+4), Dolphins (+4), Cowboys (-4), Packers (-5), Ravens (-7), Titans (-7)

Kuharsky: Broncos (+7), Jaguars (+5), Redskins (+5), Ravens (-5), Titans (-6), Chargers (-7)

Chadiha: Redskins (+8), Jaguars (+6), 49ers (+5), Bears (+4), Texans (+4), Packers (-5), Ravens (-6), Panthers (-7), Titans (-7)

For download: An Excel file -- available here or here -- showing how each voter voted this week and in past weeks.

The file includes a "powerflaws" sheet pointing out potential flaws in voters' thinking by showing how many higher-ranked opponents each team has defeated. For example, the Jaguars rank one spot ahead of the Cardinals even though Arizona won in Jacksonville.

A quick primer on the "powerflaws" sheet:
  • Column Y features team rankings.
  • Column Z shows how many times a team has defeated higher-ranked teams.
  • Change the rankings in column Y as you see fit.
  • Re-sort column Y in ascending order (1 to 32) using the standard Excel pull-down menu atop the column.
  • The information in column Z, which reflects potential ranking errors, will change (with the adjusted total highlighted in yellow atop the column).
  • The lower the figure in that yellow box, the fewer conflicts.

SPONSORED HEADLINES

Comments

You must be signed in to post a comment

Already have an account?

Insider