NFC West: Bucky Brooks

Draft theorizing carried the NFC West chat Wednesday. Potential scenarios are virtually endless in quantity. We considered a few of them and expanded the conversation.

Full chat transcript here. A few highlights below:

Adam from Rancho Santa Margarita, Calif., enjoyed the mock draft comparison, but he's not so sure the San Francisco 49ers will seriously consider a guard in the first round. He thinks adding to the defensive line or finding a speed player at receiver would carry move value.

Mike Sando: Thanks, Adam. I understand what the mock drafters are thinking. They are going with perceived needs because it's tougher to figure out value differentials for players drafted later in the first round. It's easy to give the 49ers a guard at that point in the draft. I agree with the thinking that a team should be able to develop a guard chosen later in the draft. It's OK to take a guard early if you're getting a special one, but harder to justify in other cases. The 49ers have a great defense already, but if they could find someone to project as an eventual Justin Smith successor, that would help the team. Bucky Brooks had that thought in mind in putting together his mock, which I linked to from the item you referenced.

D from Valley of the Sun thinks value would compel the Arizona Cardinals to select David DeCastro in the first round, if available. The team could move Adam Snyder to tackle, then draft a tackle in the third round, a pass-rusher in the fourth (think Sam Acho last year) and a receiver after that. Emphasizing the ground game would help Kevin Kolb this season, in his view.

Mike Sando: You've thought through the scenario well, I would say. That is a less-than-ideal scenario, however. The team already spent big for left guard Daryn Colledge in free agency. Investing a first-round choice in a right guard just doesn't seem like the preferred path philosophically. Beanie Wells and Ryan Williams need to stay healthy, first and foremost. Wells had 1,000 yards last season despite not being healthy much of the time. The thought of Snyder at right tackle isn't appealing, either. Jeremy Bridges might be a better starting option there.

Corey from Washington, D.C., proposes the following scenario: Ryan Tannehill slips past Cleveland at No. 4; Seattle trades up with Miami to take Quinton Coples at No. 8; and the Dolphins select Tannehill at No. 12, a position Corey deemed "more respectable" for the Texas A&M quarterback. "For the record, I have a hard time buying Kansas City passingon Luke Kuechly to get a raw QB, which I factored in," he added.

Mike Sando: I question whether the Dolphins would have the patience to try such a move. They're likely desperate for a quarterback. Can they really afford to get cute if they think Tannehill is their guy? I don't see how they could do that, given the risk of losing the player.

Roland from Winnipeg notes that three of the 14 mock drafts cited had the St. Louis Rams passing on Justin Blackmon for Fletcher Cox. He likes the thinking because he sees quality receivers available later, but he wonders whether the Rams have a great enough need at defensive tackle to justify the decision.

Mike Sando: The Rams are starting over in a lot of areas, but especially at defensive tackle. They flushed out Fred Robbins and are starting almost from scratch there. The thinking on Fletcher Cox would reflect Jeff Fisher's general belief that you build with a strong running game and strong defense. Yes, you need playmakers too, but the first priority is to take pressure off the QB by running the ball, perhaps diminishing the need to build right away with a receiver taken sixth overall, especially if that receiver isn't as appealing as some of the other receivers taken very early in drafts. Cox would then be a value selection.

Thanks for keeping the conversation going. The NFC West chat will return to its usual Thursday schedule next week.

Enjoy your Wednesday night.

Posted by ESPN.com's Mike Sando

John Crumpacker of the San Francisco Chronicle outlines issues facing the 49ers with nearly six months left until the regular season. The quarterback situation is one of them, again.

Matt Maiocco of the Santa Rosa Press-Democrat takes a quick look at the 49ers' first offseason practices. 

Also from Maiocco: He profiles new 49ers offensive coordinator Jimmy Raye. Maiocco: "During his Michigan State career, from 1965 to '67, Raye was the only black quarterback starting at the NCAA Division I level. He played a central role [in] one of the most memorable games in college history. Michigan State and Notre Dame entered their late-season 1966 game with unbeaten records. Notre Dame was ranked No. 1, while Michigan State was No. 2. The game ended in controversy as Notre Dame coach Ara Paraseghian elected to run out the clock and settle for a 10-10 tie rather than go for the win in the closing minutes. The teams shared the national championship."

Dan Brown of the San Jose Mercury News profiles the 49ers' quarterbacks. Brown: "Assuming he has recovered from his second shoulder surgery, [Alex] Smith still possesses the best raw tools among 49ers passers. His confidence was shaken by an ill-fated pairing with coach Mike Nolan, but Smith is young enough to rebound."

Matt Barrows of the Sacramento Bee previews the 49ers' practices. Free safety Mark Roman plans to pursue a potential trade until June. At that point, he would report to the 49ers.

Bill Coats of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch says Rams general manager Billy Devaney was impressed by Eugene Monroe's pro day. The team is also working toward agreements with Billy Bajema and Gus Frerotte.

VanRam of Turf Show Times runs through some Rams-related notes. VanRam: "The Rams have requested a private workout with Penn State WR Derrick Williams. Williams is likely a second round pick, and an intriguing player for the new offense. According to this scouting report from Mocking the Draft, Williams has great after-the-catch ability and intelligence, two features which could be real assets in a system that gives the WRs a little range."

Jason Cole of Yahoo! Sports checks in with former Rams and 49ers offensive coordinator Mike Martz for a look at the 2006 quarterback draft class. Martz on Matt Leinart: "There is a maturation process you have to go through as a quarterback. He's lucky that he's on a good team where he hasn't had to play a lot yet and he's had Kurt to watch and learn from. That can be really valuable for a quarterback. Eventually, he'll have to go in there and get beat up a little and succeed under duress."

Darren Urban of azcardinals.com says Anthony Becht is the latest tight end to compete for a job in Arizona. Urban: "Becht, 6-foot-5 and 280 pounds, had just six catches last season but played in all 16 games for the eighth season in a row. His teams have had seven 1,000-yard rushers in his nine NFL seasons and Becht has 178 career receptions for 1,450 yards."

Doug Farrar of Field Gulls, in linking to a photo of Seahawks general mananger Tim Ruskell at Matthew Stafford's pro day, hopes the team finds someone better than David Greene. Ouch.

John Morgan of Field Gulls sizes up Ruskell's draft priorities. He notes that Ruskell, while with Seattle, has drafted only one player, a long-snapper, from a non-BCS school.

Michael Steffes of Seahawk Addicts links to Bucky Brooks' SI.com story suggesting the Seahawks are poised for a big turnaround in 2009. He thinks new offensive coordinator Greg Knapp has the right pieces for his offense. Brooks: "With [Julius] Jones and T.J. Duckett in the fold, Knapp inherits a pair of runners who should thrive in this scheme. Jones, who had two 100-yard games last season, is a decisive runner who is most effective running between the tackles. Though his season was viewed as a disappointment, the six-year pro averaged a respectable 4.4 yards per carry and didn't receive nearly enough touches [he only averaged 10.5 rushing attempts a game in 2008] to determine if he could cut it as a feature back."

Also from Steffes hopes this is the draft Seattle uses to revamp its offense. Steffes: "They found a great young tight end last year, but just about every other position could use some youth."

SPONSORED HEADLINES

NFC WEST SCOREBOARD

Sunday, 1/25