Browns have one major position to address
April, 15, 2014
By Pat McManamon | ESPN.com
USA Today Sports, Getty ImagesTeddy Bridgewater, Blake Bortles and Johnny Manziel are options the Cleveland Browns will consider with their top pick in May's NFL draft.And then there was one.
The Cleveland Browns' busy offseason leaves them having addressed the possible loss of Alex Mack (he stayed) and the departures of T.J. Ward and D'Qwell Jackson (Donte Whitner and Karlos Dansby). They added a running back (Ben Tate) and they added depth at several spots, including the offensive line (Paul McQuistan), receiver (Andrew Hawkins, Nate Burleson), tight end (Jim Dray) and cornerback (Isaiah Trufant).
On Monday, they even added the long-lost fullback, a guy the team did not give Rob Chudzinski a year ago. Chris Pressley is coming off a missed season due to ACL surgery so he is not a lock to make the team, but if he can give anything at all it’s more than the Browns had a year ago.
All this does is set the Browns up to draft the way they want to draft, not the way they have to.
"[GM] Ray [Farmer] talked about that process of just stabilizing, leveling the ship," coach Mike Pettine told the gathered media at the NFL owners meetings.
Which basically leaves one spot to address: quarterback.
Yes, Virginia, there will be a new quarterback in Cleveland before training camp.
The team must add a veteran before the “voluntary” minicamp the end of the month. They can’t go into camp with only two guys, especially because Brian Hoyer will probably be limited as he comes off knee surgery. Given that the market of veterans left are the Rex Grossmans of the world, the Browns also will add a quarterback in the draft.
When is the million-dollar question.
If it’s fourth overall, the choices remain the same three: Blake Bortles, Johnny Manziel or Teddy Bridgewater. If it’s later, there is a bundle from which to pick.
"That's the position that needs to be addressed," Pettine said. "But we're not locked into, 'We're drafting a starter.'"
Which is good to hear.
Because if the Browns draft a guy to start and they force him in too quickly they'll be following the wash-rinse-repeat cycle that has contributed to so many problems since 1999. The challenge comes in managing the situation.
Because if the team selects a quarterback with the fourth pick, Hoyer will find out quickly what it’s really like to play for his hometown team. Assuming he starts, the first time he has a two-interception, one-touchdown game in a 23-14 loss, the clamor will start from fans and media about the guy drafted fourth.
If it’s Manziel, that clamor will be loud and ornery.
If it’s Bortles, folks might be a little more patient because the word on him is he will need a year or two.
If it’s Bridgewater, it’s anyone’s guess.
Then if the young guy plays the negativity will continue if he struggles.
This negativity has affected Browns quarterbacks since '99 – all the way back to Tim Couch and Kelly Holcomb. It’s unrealistic to think it didn’t, because quarterback is a confidence position. He who hesitates is lost. It may sound like an easy excuse, except it affects a player’s psyche.
The spiral is almost natural. Young guy has to learn, to grow, but because he’s learning he makes mistakes, which leads to criticism, which he says he doesn’t hear but he does. Which leads to self-doubt, which leads to tentative play, which leads to more mistakes and more questions and clamor – and soon enough, the environment to succeed is damaged, which only exacerbates the issue.
There is the Bruce Arians argument, which says a team needs to pass-protect and run the ball to help a young quarterback, but if the guy can play he can play. But Bill Walsh, the great quarterback guru and leader of the San Francisco 49ers, once talked about protecting a young quarterback from a damaging environment. He talked almost emotionally, as if the damage to the player was almost permanent.
The word he used: traumatic.
The Browns have to be aware of this, and if they’re not they need only look at their history since their return. The good thing is whoever plays will have a much fuller deck than many of his predecessors. That’s the result of the offseason work.
But the Browns have saved the most important position for last.
How they handle it not only in the next two months but also through the entire 2014 season could have as much impact on the team as the selection itself.
1:00 PM ET Cleveland Atlanta 1:00 PM ET Tennessee Philadelphia 1:00 PM ET Detroit New England 1:00 PM ET Green Bay Minnesota 1:00 PM ET Jacksonville Indianapolis 1:00 PM ET Cincinnati Houston 1:00 PM ET New York Buffalo 1:00 PM ET Tampa Bay Chicago 4:05 PM ET Arizona Seattle 4:05 PM ET St. Louis San Diego 4:25 PM ET Miami Denver 4:25 PM ET Washington San Francisco 8:30 PM ET Dallas New York