Readers were quick to bring up Belichick's role in the Spygate video-taping scandal, the way he left the New York Jets by scrawling his resignation on a napkin and the way he ran for the tunnel before the end of Super Bowl XLII. Or maybe he's disliked because he has won for a decade.
Parcells is a gruff, larger-than-life character who has worked for every AFC East club but the Buffalo Bills. He has influenced the division for decades, most recently as the Miami Dolphins' reclusive football ops director.
Or maybe you'd like to vote for unashamedly outspoken Jets head coach Rex Ryan.
Perhaps you're more the type to root against quarterbacks. In that case, the top candidate is Patriots leading man Tom Brady, who already has everything but seemingly could drop by your house and take whatever he wants if he were in the mood.
Jets quarterback Mark Sanchez is another one who seems to drive fans bananas. Many believe he's overrated and a little too glamorous for a kid who hasn't accomplished much.