Tuesday, July 3, 2012
AFC South training camp battles
By Paul Kuharsky
» AFC camp battles: West | North | South | East » NFC: West | North | South | East
An early look at the biggest training camp position battles:
Right tackle: Rashad Butler versus Derek Newton
Right guard: Antoine Caldwell versus Brandon Brooks
The Texans are reshaping the right side of their offensive line after releasing right tackle Eric Winston to save money and watching right guard Mike Brisiel take a free-agent deal with the Oakland Raiders.
Butler and Caldwell have experience in the system and go into training camp as favorites to win the starting jobs. But it won’t be a giant upset if one of them loses out to the promising kid in position to make a push. The team is high on Newton, who appeared in 14 games as a rookie in 2011, and Brooks, a third-round pick who was listed at 343 pounds when he was drafted and would be the team’s biggest lineman even if he slims down. We won't see Newton and Brooks as starters, but we could see one of them pull an upset.
Cornerback: Kevin Thomas versus all comers at left cornerback
The secondary is the Colts’ biggest issue, and depth beyond starting right cornerback Jerraud Powers is very questionable at corner. Thomas lined up as the second starter during spring and summer work. But the team did a lot to give itself other options for that slot as well as nickel and dime.
The Colts traded for Cassius Vaughn, claimed Korey Lindsey off waivers and signed free agent Justin King, previously of St. Louis. Those three plus holdovers Chris Rucker, Terrence Johnson and Brandon King will look to earn roles during training camp. The team could continue to seek help at corner, too.
Cornerback: Rashean Mathis vs. Aaron Ross
While Derek Cox will man right cornerback, veterans Mathis and Ross will compete for the starting job on the left side.
Mathis is a true pro who’s been a good leader for the Jaguars for nine seasons. He’s made great progress in a comeback from a shredded knee suffered in November. Ross was part of two Super Bowl-winning teams with the New York Giants and will also offer leadership. The guy who doesn’t get the starting job will still be an important player on defense, lining up in the slot in the nickel package.
Quarterback: Matt Hasselbeck versus Jake Locker
It’s experience versus potential in what will be one of the most watched training camp battles in the NFL. Don’t believe Hasselbeck can’t lose the job. Coach Mike Munchak wouldn’t be setting it up as a competition for show.
To me, the question is whether Locker can be accurate enough to make his mobility too appealing to pass up. If so, he’s got a chance. If not, then Hasselbeck should retain the job. In the long run, it would be far easier to pull Hasselbeck along the way than it would be to take Locker out of the lineup. That could be a factor in what the Titans say will likely boil down to a gut feeling on whom they are better off with under center.