Create your own Negro League all-stars
July, 25, 2012
7/25/12
9:00
AM ET
By Hilary Goldstein | Special to ESPN.com
AP PhotoDid the great Jackie Robinson make our Negro League All-Star team in "MLB 12: The Show"?Using the create-a-player option in "MLB 12: The Show," we've crafted the core ratings for a solid starting lineup of Negro Leagues all-stars.
It should be noted that stats for Negro Leagues players weren't tracked with the veracity of MLB players. In many cases, we did our best to estimate some stats, such as a player’s ability to stay healthy based solely on the longevity of his career.
Below are ratings to build your own starting lineup of Negro Leagues stars. We also simulated some games to see how these legends of the diamond would stand up in today's modern game.
• The lineup card
1. Cool Papa Bell | OF
By all accounts, James "Cool Papa" Bell was the fastest human being to ever live. His quickness is legendary and he's considered one of the best defensive center fielders of all time.
[+] Enlarge
AP Photo/HMB
AP Photo/HMBBats/Throws: S/L
RT Contact: 88
LT Contact: 80
RT Power: 35
LT Power: 31
Bunt: 76
Drag Bunt: 71
Plate Vision: 70
Plate Discipline: 74
Clutch: 70
Durability: 98
Speed: 99
Arm Strength: 80
Arm Accuracy: 88
Reaction: 94
Fielding: 99
Blocking: 0
BR Ability: 92
BR Aggressiveness: 86
2. Pop Lloyd | SS
Likened to the Honus Wagner of the Negro Leagues, Lloyd regularly batted better than .400 and was an aggressive baserunner.
[+] Enlarge
Diamond Images/Getty Images
Diamond Images/Getty ImagesBats/Throws: L/R
RT Contact: 92
LT Contact: 87
RT Power: 30
LT Power: 26
Bunt: 82
Drag Bunt: 71
Plate Vision: 90
Plate Discipline: 96
Clutch: 80
Durability: 97
Speed: 84
Arm Strength: 70
Arm Accuracy: 83
Reaction: 80
Fielding: 81
Blocking: 0
BR Ability: 87
BR Aggressiveness: 92
3. Buck Leonard | 1B
The perfect combination of batting average and power, Leonard was one of the Negro Leagues' most consistent hitters.
[+] Enlarge
AP Photo/ Dave Pickoff
AP Photo/ Dave PickoffBats/Throws: L/L
RT Contact: 77
LT Contact: 74
RT Power: 78
LT Power: 70
Bunt: 40
Drag Bunt: 16
Plate Vision: 86
Plate Discipline: 85
Clutch: 88
Durability: 90
Speed: 65
Arm Strength: 65
Arm Accuracy: 76
Reaction: 75
Fielding: 74
Blocking: 0
BR Ability: 63
BR Aggressiveness: 40
4. Josh Gibson | C
The Babe Ruth of the Negro Leagues, Gibson was the most imposing hitter of his era, tallying up nearly 800 homers in his career.
[+] Enlarge
AP Photo/FileCatcher Josh Gibson was one of the greatest sluggers in baseball, period.
AP Photo/FileCatcher Josh Gibson was one of the greatest sluggers in baseball, period.Bats/Throws: R/R
RT Contact: 83
LT Contact: 84
RT Power: 88
LT Power: 99
Bunt: 42
Drag Bunt: 5
Plate Vision: 92
Plate Discipline: 96
Clutch: 99
Durability: 90
Speed: 40
Arm Strength: 84
Arm Accuracy: 85
Reaction: 50
Fielding: 63
Blocking: 78
BR Ability: 48
BR Aggressiveness: 15
5. Oscar Charleston | OF
One of the first five-tool players, Charleston had it all. Though he is a natural center fielder (as are all the outfielders in our starting lineup), he can also play first base.
Modern Equivalent: Matt Kemp
[+] Enlarge
AP Photo
AP PhotoRT Contact: 86. LT Contact: 80.
RT Power: 70. LT Power: 61.
Bunt: 55. Drag Bunt: 30.
Plate Vision: 85. Plate Discipline: 88.
Clutch: 77
Durability: 86
Speed: 82
Arm Strength: 73
Arm Accuracy: 86
Reaction: 90
Fielding: 90
Blocking: 0
BR Ability: 84
BR Aggressiveness: 80
6. Pete Hill | OF
A line-drive hitter, Hill had impeccable bat control and would foul off pitch after pitch until he found one he liked.
[+] Enlarge
Getty Images
Getty ImagesBats/Throws: L/R
RT Contact: 88
LT Contact: 81
RT Power: 27
LT Power: 25
Bunt: 73
Drag Bunt: 58
Plate Vision: 90
Plate Discipline: 92
Clutch: 65
Durability: 95
Speed: 80
Arm Strength: 87
Arm Accuracy: 83
Reaction: 80
Fielding: 84
Blocking: 0
BR Ability: 70
BR Aggressiveness: 70
7. Ray Dandridge | 3B
The best defensive third baseman of the Negro Leagues, Dandridge comes with MVP credentials and a talent for hitting to all fields.
[+] Enlarge
Mark Rucker/Transcendental Graphics/Getty Images
Mark Rucker/Transcendental Graphics/Getty ImagesBats/Throws: R/R
RT Contact: 74
LT Contact: 80
RT Power: 38
LT Power: 42
Bunt: 70
Drag Bunt: 35
Plate Vision: 80
Plate Discipline: 83
Clutch: 70
Durability: 88
Speed: 60
Arm Strength: 93
Arm Accuracy: 90
Reaction: 90
Fielding: 91
Blocking: 0
BR Ability: 70
BR Aggressiveness: 40
8. Sammy Hughes | 2B
The only member of our roster not yet in the Hall of Fame, Hughes could turn the double play like nobody's business. He was a solid contact hitter to boot.
Modern Equivalent: Dustin Pedroia
[+] Enlarge
Mark Rucker/Transcendental Graphics, Getty Images
Mark Rucker/Transcendental Graphics, Getty ImagesRT Contact: 72. LT Contact: 76.
RT Power: 27. LT Power: 35.
Bunt: 90. Drag Bunt: 66.
Plate Vision: 75
Plate Discipline: 84
Clutch: 50
Durability: 90
Speed: 73
Arm Strength: 79
Arm Accuracy: 88
Reaction: 90
Fielding: 91
Blocking: 0
BR Ability: 74
BR Aggressiveness: 70
9. "Smokey" Joe Williams | P
Alongside Satchel Paige, Williams is not only considered one of the best Negro Leagues pitchers, but one of the greatest of all time.
Modern Equivalent: Stephen Strasburg
[+] Enlarge
Mark Rucker/Transcendental Graphics/Getty ImagesSatchel Paige might be more famous, but Smokey Joe Williams might have been a better pitcher.
Mark Rucker/Transcendental Graphics/Getty ImagesSatchel Paige might be more famous, but Smokey Joe Williams might have been a better pitcher.Stamina: 90. Pitching Clutch: 80
H/9: 80. HR/9: 90. K/9: 92. BB/9: 86
Bunt: 45
Drag Bunt: 20
Plate Vision: 40
Plate Discipline: 50
Clutch: 10
Durability: 90
Speed: 40
Arm Strength: 80
Arm Accuracy: 75
Reaction: 60
Fielding: 40
Blocking: 30
BR Ability: 40
BR Aggressiveness: 20
Pitch Type: 4-Seam Fastball: Velocity: 91. Control: 90. Break: 45
Pitch Type: Running Fastball: Velocity: 86. Control: 88. Break: 65.
Pitch Type: Changeup: Velocity: 74. Control: 92. Break: 61.
• The Negro Leagues All-Stars vs. The New York Yankees
Unfortunately, there is no create-a-team option in "MLB 12: The Show." This means the starting roster for the Negro Leagues All-Stars needs to replace a current major league starting nine. We chose the Los Angeles Dodgers in honor of Jackie Robinson, the first Negro Leagues star to play in the bigs. And what better way to test the quality of these all-stars than against the Yankees' current roster?
Final score: Dodgers 9, Yankees 2
C.C. Sabathia may be one of the best pitchers in the modern era, but he had no answers for the sure bats of the new L.A. Dodgers. Gibson was the player of the game, belting two homers and driving in five runs. But it was Leonard who proved the toughest out, going 4-for-5 with one RBI.
Yes, the fastest man to ever lace up cleats, Cool Papa Bell, got on base once and made the most of it, getting an easy steal of third before scoring on a Leonard double.
Sabathia lasted just five innings and gave up five earned runs in his time on the mound.
Smokey Joe Williams didn't have his best stuff, but then few do against the Yankees' potent lineup. In true old-school style, he went the full nine innings, giving up a run on each of Curtis Granderson's doubles. A-Rod took a nod, with two K's and a couple of weak fly balls.
It looked like easy work for the Negro Leagues version of the Dodgers. But as we simmed a full seven-game series, things evened out. The Dodgers won the series 4-2, with no team winning by more than two runs following the opening-game rout.
Want to Learn More? Three sources proved invaluable in creating this article. They also are great resources for learning more about the Negro Leagues. They are "Baseball's Other All-Stars" by William F. McNeil, "Only the Ball Was White" by Robert Peterson, and the National Baseball Hall of Fame site.

- EAMaddenNFL EA SPORTS Madden NFL
Discover #EASPORTSIGNITE, the engine that powers #MaddenNext25: http://t.co/ifLYFkdfBr
3 minutes ago
- EAMaddenNFL EA SPORTS Madden NFL

- EAMaddenNFL EA SPORTS Madden NFL
#Think like a pro. #Play like a pro. The future of #Madden25 is coming: http://t.co/nLD9ty6EsR #EASPORTSIGNITE #MaddenNext25
4 minutes ago
- EAMaddenNFL EA SPORTS Madden NFL

- EASPORTS EA SPORTS
See the next-gen games in development. https://t.co/6rqORLJA8s Discover #EASPORTSIGNITE: http://t.co/yVTyRW0WF1 #XboxOne #XboxReveal
about an hour ago
- EASPORTS EA SPORTS

- EAMaddenNFL EA SPORTS Madden NFL
:( "RT @SportsCenter: BREAKING: Bears MLB Brian Urlacher has announced his retirement. Urlacher played 13 NFL seasons, all in Chicago."
about an hour ago
- EAMaddenNFL EA SPORTS Madden NFL

- WWEgames WWE 2K
RT @aubreysitterson: Some of our eager #WWE2K14 playtesters, gearing up for action! http://t.co/ivFfqtaEg4
about an hour ago
- WWEgames WWE 2K

- EAMaddenNFL EA SPORTS Madden NFL
BREAKING: Charles Woodson has signed with the @RAIDERS, according to reports. Is this a good fit for C-Woods?
about an hour ago
- EAMaddenNFL EA SPORTS Madden NFL

- EAMaddenNFL EA SPORTS Madden NFL
RT @marotzSwagg: @EAMaddenNFL can't wait for new Madden to come out!!! Connected Franchise! All new running and DEFENSE! #Madden25
about an hour ago
- EAMaddenNFL EA SPORTS Madden NFL

- EAMaddenNFL EA SPORTS Madden NFL
RT @EASPORTS_MUT: New community TotW is now live. Thanks to @ERockMUT for his Birdgang squad
about an hour ago
- EAMaddenNFL EA SPORTS Madden NFL

- WWEgames WWE 2K
Everything is set and waiting for our #WWE2K14 playtesters! http://t.co/rHVD77eYrR
about an hour ago
- WWEgames WWE 2K

- EAMaddenNFL EA SPORTS Madden NFL
>:) "RT @DJMikeyMikey24: @EAMaddenNFL whatcha tryna do make people miss out on work? LOL just kiddin"
about 2 hours ago
- EAMaddenNFL EA SPORTS Madden NFL

- EAMaddenNFL EA SPORTS Madden NFL
Have you had a chance to check out our #Madden25 Connected Franchise reveal? You might want to take off work 8.27.13: http://t.co/Vv5bBuKR2G
about 2 hours ago
- EAMaddenNFL EA SPORTS Madden NFL

- Ronnie2K Ronnie 2K 2K13
Do the Spurs just get bored sometimes and say "Hey we need some drama."?
about 12 hours ago
- Ronnie2K Ronnie 2K 2K13

- WWEgames WWE 2K
RT @jim784m: Landed in Cali! Playtesting @WWEGames' #2K14 tomorrow. Excited? :D Yep!
about 14 hours ago
- WWEgames WWE 2K

- Ronnie2K Ronnie 2K 2K13
We are champions #SFGiants @sfgiants http://t.co/lgoQXDIw5Y
about 14 hours ago
- Ronnie2K Ronnie 2K 2K13

- EAMaddenNFL EA SPORTS Madden NFL
Wait till you see more at #E3! RT “@Football6335: @EAMaddenNFL IT LOOKS SWEET!! AMAZING GRAPHICS”
about 15 hours ago
- EAMaddenNFL EA SPORTS Madden NFL

- EASPORTS EA SPORTS
In case you missed the #EASPORTSIGNITE Trailer from today's #XboxReveal, check it out here: http://t.co/jGR19CNGdP
about 16 hours ago
- EASPORTS EA SPORTS

- EAMaddenNFL EA SPORTS Madden NFL
If you're curious about the #EASPORTSIGNITE technology powering #MaddenNext25, go here for all the juicy deets: http://t.co/jzoqHdpM7V
about 17 hours ago
- EAMaddenNFL EA SPORTS Madden NFL

- EAMaddenNFL EA SPORTS Madden NFL
In case you missed the #EASPORTSIGNITE Trailer from today's #XboxReveal, check it out here: http://t.co/NhxOVnMFbx #MaddenNext25
about 17 hours ago
- EAMaddenNFL EA SPORTS Madden NFL

- EAMaddenNFL EA SPORTS Madden NFL
RT @ctgaming7: @EAMaddenNFL Madden 25 looks so awesome! #cantwait #runfree
about 18 hours ago
- EAMaddenNFL EA SPORTS Madden NFL

- EASPORTS EA SPORTS
Discover EA SPORTS IGNITE: http://t.co/xYP0CzqRNH #EASPORTSIGNITE #XboxOne #XboxReveal
about 18 hours ago
- EASPORTS EA SPORTS
ESPN ARCADE
- Return Man 2
- The sequel to our most popular game is here. How's your return?
- Wide Out
- Run timed routes, beat DB's to the end zone and score.
- Electric QB
- Hit your receivers, dodge defenders and rack up TDs.






VIDEO GAMES ON TWITTER
You must be signed in to post a comment