Our recruiting folks at ESPN have gone back and re-visited the 2008 signing class and assessed how the marquee prospects in that class fared in college.
It’s one of my favorite exercises, because it’s a reminder that recruiting is anything but an exact science, and that evaluating recruiting classes and prospects on signing day is a dicey proposition.
Everybody is trying to recruit great players, but what matters is what you do with those players once you get them on your campus.
Of the 25 top prospects in the 2008 class, seven signed with SEC schools.
No. 2 on that list was Julio Jones. No. 5 was A.J. Green, and No. 8 was Patrick Peterson.
I’d say the analysts got those three right. They were all great players who earned numerous awards and accolades, and all three were taken among the top six picks in last year’s NFL draft.
All four were ranked among the top 25 prospects in the nation by ESPN in 2008, but for varying reasons, they never flourished in college.
Hill, a safety who signed with Florida out of West Orange, N.J., was the No. 3 overall prospect in 2008. He had a promising freshman season, but struggled with consistency his next two seasons. He declared early for the NFL draft and wasn’t selected, and wound up playing in the Arena Football League.
Finley, another safety who signed with Florida out of Auburn, Ala., was No. 10. He was sidetracked by injuries and off-the-field issues during his career and announced that he was transferring to North Alabama.
Aghayere, a defensive end who signed with LSU out of Garland, Texas, was No. 14. He’s a rising senior, but has played mostly in a reserve role for the Tigers. He didn’t make any starts this season and finished with three total tackles.
Scott, an athlete who signed with Alabama out of Prichard, Ala., was No. 19. He moved from running back to cornerback after arriving at Alabama, but wound up transferring and played at South Alabama this past season.
Florida signed an SEC-high six players in 2008 that were ranked among the top 55 prospects nationally. The Gators signed 10 players who were ESPNU 150 prospects.
It’s a haul that looked terrific at the time, but four seasons later, the Gators lost six football games and didn’t beat anybody in 2011 (in the FBS ranks) that finished with a winning record.
There’s also the flip side.
Alabama’s 2008 class was ranked No. 3 by ESPN, and it’s a class that was the driving force behind the Crimson Tide’s dizzying run the past few years, which includes two national championships.
So, again, there are always hits and misses in recruiting, and those players who miss sometimes do so for reasons that go well beyond football ability. What’s more, classes that look like a million dollars on signing day don’t always look so good three and four years later.
Just something to remember with national signing day approaching.
Here’s a look at the remaining ESPNU 150 prospects in 2008 who signed with SEC schools:
No. 30: DE Courtney Upshaw (Alabama)
No. 31: CB Janoris Jenkins (Florida)
No. 33: OT Tyler Love (Alabama)
No. 35: RB Richard Samuel (Georgia)
No. 37: DT Omar Hunter (Florida)
No. 41: ATH Joe Adams (Arkansas)
No. 43: DE William Green (Florida)
No. 45: DT DeAngelo Tyson (Georgia)
No. 50: RB Carlton Thomson (Georgia)
No. 51: WR Chris Tolliver (LSU)
No. 54: CB Charles Whitlock (South Carolina)
No. 55: ATH Jeff Demps (Florida)
No. 70: S Karnell Hatcher (LSU)
No. 76: RB De’Anthony Curtis (Arkansas)
No. 80: OLB Lerentee McCray (Florida)
No. 81: QB Tyler Wilson (Arkansas)
No. 87: WR Rod Wilks (Tennessee)
No. 93: ATH Charles Mitchell (Mississippi State)
No. 99: OLB Jerrell Harris (Alabama)
No. 108: RB Mark Ingram (Alabama)
No. 121: OT Matt Patchan (Florida)
No. 131: DE Toby Jackson (Georgia)
No. 132: OG A.J. Harmon (Georgia)
No. 133: ILB Brendan Beal (Florida)
No. 136: CB Neiko Thorpe (Auburn)
No. 140: C Ben Jones (Georgia)
No. 142: CB Jeremy Brown (Florida)
No. 144: ATH Chris Jackson (Alabama)
No. 146: WR Tavarres King (Georgia)
No. 147: RB Eric Smith (Auburn)