Pac-12 coach was off on David Shaw

August, 10, 2012
It takes a big man to admit when you're wrong -- even if you do it anonymously. And that was the case with one Pac-12 coach who said he was 180-degrees off on Stanford head coach David Shaw.

Athlon Sports did an anonymous survey of Pac-12 coaches talking about each other's teams. It's not exactly "Real Housewives" cattiness. There are actually some really interesting and thought-provoking takes. Anonymity usually provides a good opportunity for honesty.

Here's an excerpt of what one coach had to say about Shaw.
I have to admit I was wrong about David Shaw. I thought with him replacing Jim Harbaugh, the Cardinal would lose their toughness and personality and would flounder last season. Even with Andrew Luck at quarterback, I just didn’t think they could be as good as they were with Harbaugh. Well, I’m officially an idiot. Shaw did a tremendous job leading Stanford to an 11-win season and it should have been 12. There’s no way they should have lost to Oklahoma State in the Fiesta Bowl. This year, though, I’m afraid Stanford will take a little dip. Of course, it’s got nothing to do with Shaw, but having to replace Andrew Luck will not be easy.

Not exactly going out on a limb predicting some drop-off for the Cardinal in 2012. I think most people are thinking between eight and nine wins and a decent bowl game for Stanford. As with any bell curve, you have the folks who think Stanford is bound for a third-straight BCS bowl game and those who think being bowl eligibility will be a struggle.

Who knows? Maybe they run the table. Shaw has proved at least one person wrong before ...



You must be signed in to post a comment

Already have an account?

David Shaw Talks Stanford Signing Day
Stanford coach David Shaw joins ESPN's Matt Schick to discuss the Cardinal's 2015 recruiting class and its top positional needs heading into the spring.