Hold the hype: Darvish's debut disappoints

April, 10, 2012
4/10/12
12:20
AM ET

We'll have to wait another five days before Yu Darvish's impending superstardom explodes across the airwaves and cyberspace. Or maybe 10 days. Or, more likely, a month ... two months ... whatever it takes.

You see, in baseball, it's not so easy. You have to earn it. You want to be a sensation? Want to become the next Fidrych, the next Fernando, the next Nomo? The results come first. The hype follows. You aren't a creation; you have to create.

Darvish took the mound on a cloudy, 75-degree night in Arlington, Texas, for his first major league start. There was a buzz in the stadium, 42,000 strong in Ranger red and blue, ready to cheer on their half-Japanese, half-Iranian import, a pitcher Nolan Ryan determined was worth an investment of nearly $108 million.

But that's just money. That's no guarantee, either.

So a big ovation greeted Darvish and we anticipated his 95 mph heat, his nasty cutter, a slider, a curveball, heck maybe even a Gyroball or two. After all, we'd read the reports; he had, what, six, seven, eight different pitches? We expected to see a sensation.

But it doesn't work that way in baseball.

Darvish proceeded to stink up the joint.

He walked Chone Figgins on four pitches. He fell behind the first five batters. He gave up four hits, walked three guys (to a team that had drawn six walks in its first four games), threw a wild pitch, gave up four runs and threw 42 pitches as the Mariners batted around.

This wasn't Fernandomania. Worse: It was a reminder of Daisuke Matsuzaka, another one-time "best pitcher in Japan" who came to the States and disappointed with his incessant nibbling at the corners, high pitch counts and less-spirited-than-advertised fastball.

In truth, Darvish was a little unlucky that inning. Ichiro Suzuki blooped a single over third base and Miguel Olivo blooped a single just over Ian Kinsler. And with the bases loaded and one out, Scott Feldman warming up in the 'pen, he escaped the jam by striking out Brendan Ryan on three pitches and retiring Figgins on a grounder to third.

He fared much better after that, giving up another run in the second inning but pitching scoreless ball thereafter into the sixth, retiring 10 in a row at one point. In truth, he didn't really pitch any better. In the third, he fell behind four of the five batters, getting out of a two-on jam when Dustin Ackley lined out to short. He fell behind 2-0 and 3-0 to Ichiro and Justin Smoak in the fourth. In the sixth, Ron Washington gave him a chance to finish the inning after he had walked Ackley on five pitches, but Ichiro singled and Alexi Ogando had to clean up the mess.

Darvish's final line: 5.2 IP, 8 H, 5 R, 4 BB, 5 SO, 110 pitches, 59 strikes. He was credited with the win in the Rangers' 11-5 victory.

Considering this came against the majors' worst offensive team from the past two seasons, it wasn't impressive. Maybe it was nerves. Fair or not, however, Nolan Ryan didn't pay $108 million for a pitcher nervous about facing the Seattle Mariners in April, first game or not. He was all over the place, fastballs up and off the plate, offspeed stuff often down at the ankles. So, sure, maybe it was nerves. Or maybe, like Matsuzaka, he'll prove to be unwilling or unable to trust his stuff or pitch inside.

At this point, we just don't know. We won't know after his next start, this weekend against the Twins. We won't know for a while. In baseball, you have to justify your attention.

I happen to prefer it like this. Think about other sports. The most hyped player in the NFL this past season proved, in reality, to be nothing more than a backup quarterback, given away after the season for two low-round draft picks. Think of a hyped NBA prospect, such as John Wall. How's that working out for the Wizards?

Yes, we're seeing signs of this in baseball. Bryce Harper graced the cover of Sports Illustrated while still in high school. The expectations on him will be enormous and nearly impossible to live up to.

So maybe Darvish's debut is a good thing. We still have an empty canvas in front of us. It's up to him to paint the picture.

PHOTO OF THE DAY
Philly PhanaticDrew Hallowell/Getty ImagesYou know the Phanatic would rather be in Philadelphia on Opening Day.

David Schoenfield | email

SweetSpot blogger

SPONSORED HEADLINES

Comments

You must be signed in to post a comment

Already have an account?