Print and Go Back SweetSpot [Print without images]

Thursday, June 10, 2010
Will the real CC Sabathia please stand up?

Yes, CC Sabathia beat the Orioles last night. No, Joel Sherman was not impressed.

If the Yankees are not worried, either they are not paying attention or they figure worrying won't help. Because Sabathia is clearly not the pitcher the Yankees thought they were getting when they signed him for $161 million. In the three seasons before the Yankees got Sabathia, his ERA+ was 146 and his strikeout-to-walk ratio was 4.5-to-1. Since then, his ERA+ is 120 and (more to the point) his strikeout-to-walk ratio is 2.8-to-1.

He's still both durable and effective; he's just not a perennial Cy Young candidate.

To find out what's ailing Sabathia, you would probably have to ask a (really good) scout. He's throwing as hard as ever. His fastball hasn't been an effective pitch this season, but there have been other seasons in which his fastball wasn't effective, and it didn't hurt him. In 2007 and '08, his best seasons, his best pitches were his slider and his changeup; last season his slider was just decent; this year neither pitch has been particularly good (all this "analysis" derived from these pitch values.)

My best guess is that some of this is your basic regression, and some is your basic fatigue that happens to lots of pitchers. How many hurlers burn brightly for a few seasons in their 20s, only to fade in their late 20s and early 30s? And how many times have teams been burned by six-, seven- and eight-year contracts in the last 35 years?