Print and Go Back ESPN.com: SweetSpot [Print without images]

Monday, December 13, 2010
Hall of Famer Gillick famous for memory


I got Eddie Robinson's memoir in the mail recently, and I really enjoyed it and was going to recommend the book if you're looking for a Christmas gift ... only to discover that the book won't be released until February. (I was blessed with an advance copy.)

I should probably hold off until then, but it's like Leo Durocher said: "Save my pitcher for tomorrow? It might rain tomorrow."

Plus, Pat Gillick was just elected to the Hall of Fame, and it was Robinson who gave Gillick his first front-office job ...
Gillick had trouble staying healthy as a pitcher in the minors, and he had trouble throwing strikes. He turned 26 during the '63 season, had pitched some in Triple-A, and probably could have kept pitching if he'd wanted.

He seems to have made the right choice, as did Robinson in hiring Gillick.

That bit about Gillick's memory was echoed in Craig Wright's latest The Diamond Appraised column:
I can see Craig's point, but you sort of have to go with the Hall of Fame you've got, rather than the one you want. That doesn't mean you elect every first baseman who was as good as George Kelly, or every owner who meant as much to the game as Tom Yawkey.

The problem with drawing the line above Gillick is that you're essentially saying there hasn't been a baseball executive -- not including owners, commissioners, or union heads -- good enough to be in the Hall since George Weiss. And George Weiss died nearly 40 years ago.

And frankly, there's no danger of overpopulation. Not by general managers, anyway. I believe that Gillick's just the fifth. John Schuerholz will make six. And Schuerholz will be the last for quite some time.

Meanwhile, there are 20 managers in the Hall of Fame. Twenty managers, five general managers. Which, just in terms of their impact on the standings and world championships and the like, seems like an odd ratio.

Craig's argument would (I think) be that nobody goes to Cooperstown to see Gillick's plaque, or Yawkey's, or Morgan Bulkeley's, or Nestor Chylak's. Frankly, I can't help thinking maybe there should be a separate wing for those guys -- as opposed to the imaginary "wing" that holds the writers and broadcasters -- leaving the fancy room with all the plaques to just the players. (Oh, and I would make room for scouts in our new wing, too.)

In the absence of a new room, we should be exceptionally stingy about non-players. For me, though, Gillick makes the cut.


I really enjoyed Robinson's book. As most memoirs do, it suffers from a general lack of candor. It's not that Robinson's lying; rather, he pulls his punches because, understandably enough, he doesn't want to commit negative comments to posterity. He only takes the gloves off a few times, notably to criticize Lou Boudreau, his manager in Cleveland.

The book is full of nuggets, though, and my second complaint is that it's really not long enough. Robinson was in the game for 65 years, and all 65 years (plus a few more) are packed into 227 pages.

Minor quibbles. I liked the book so much that I'm going to be referencing it a few more times this week, highlighting passages that particularly caught my eye. For example, shortly after that passage above, Robinson -- and C. Paul Rogers III, his capable co-author -- write of Gillick, "He became one of the most successful and well respected general managers in the game. He won a World Series ring in 1993 as general manager of the Toronto Blue Jays ...and was the GM for the 2008 World Champion Philadelphia Phillies before retiring."

Robinson missed one, as Gillick's Blue Jays won the World Series in 1992, too. But you do get a sense, in the book, for just how much weight a World Series ring carries. In 1954, Robinson joined the Yankees, where Frankie Crosetti was the third-base coach. Crosetti, Robinson writes, "played shortstop for the Yankees for years until Phil Rizzuto took over. Then Cro, as we fondly called him, had stepped right into coaching third. There's no telling how many World Series rings Cro and Bill Dickey had between them ... Cro was always very much into the game, very intense. He also was a little on the tight side, and he wanted and expected World Series money every year."

Crosetti played for the Yankees from 1932 through 1946, served as player-coach (playing very rarely) in 1947 and '48, and was a full-time coach from 1949 through '68. How many World Series rings?

Seventeen.

And in those days, a player (or coach) could buy a nice house with his World Series share.

Is 17 rings the record? I don't know. Probably. It's really hard to figure, though, because it's not just players and coaches who get rings. Robinson picked up a couple of them as a player, and later grabbed three more while working as a non-exclusive scout for the Twins and the Reds. It's certainly possible that someone else associated with the Yankees in the 1950s and '60s later worked as an executive or scout with teams that won a bunch of World Series.

Still, 17 seems like a lot. On second thought, that probably is the record.