TrueHoop: Lebron James
Special to ESPN.com
Kyrie Irving was the rebound for a spurned sports town.
As impossible as it might have been, it was on the then-19-year-old to bring the Cleveland Cavaliers out of the grieving process after LeBron James left for Miami.
To his credit, Irving played that role well. He demanded attention right from the start, his brilliance with the ball forcing you to live in the moment, not the past. Though the sample size was only 11 games at Duke, he played almost exactly as most predicted -- an average athlete with an unreal handle and smoothness around the rim. Though James' shadow still lingered, Irving was a budding superstar Cleveland could really grow with.
But that process was quickly accelerated. General manager Chris Grant, perhaps mandated to live up to owner Dan Gilbert's guarantee to beat James to a title, made multiple win-now moves and routinely tried to outsmart the draft process.
In large part because of that, the perception of Irving became complicated when the "next level" to his game never came. Some of the shine wore off as time went on and the losses continued to pile up, and it didn't help matters that Irving rarely looked engaged defensively or that his key percentages (true shooting, effective field goal, rebound and assist) all declined after his marvelous 2011-12 rookie of the year campaign.
But despite the hit in production and reputation, Irving provided post-James Cleveland with what fans needed: a pleasant distraction and, more important, a recruiting chip. Maybe James would have come home regardless, but Irving’s potential probably made that decision a little easier.
Up to this point, Irving has spent most of his professional career on an island. His best moments have come almost completely independent of his teammates, whether during All-Star Weekend or in isolation at the top of the key in the regular season.
Irving’s greatest strength is his ability to create for himself off the dribble, a skill he has been able to hone thanks to the ineptitude of his teammates and the stale offensive systems he has been in. Irving makes opposing big men in the pick-and-roll look like dancing puppets -- a quick in-and-out dribble makes limbs go limp, a crossover sends them flying comically in the wrong direction.
There have been negative side effects to the overreliance on those abilities, though, as Irving has developed into a sometimes reluctant distributor, content with taking the first shot that is available to him. Irving’s usage percentage was practically identical to Stephen Curry’s last season, but Curry’s 39.9 assist percentage was drastically higher than Irving's 31.6.
A lot of that has to do with the quality of teammates around Irving and the general lack of trust. Irving and Dion Waiters would reluctantly take turns trying to go 1-on-5 while the other stood around and watched -- the type of offense usually reserved for bad pickup basketball.
And if Irving wasn’t hitting, the Cavs were pretty much toast. He shot 47.9 percent from the field in the 28 wins he was a part of last season, but just 40.1 percent in 43 losses. His isolation scoring could give Cleveland a puncher’s chance, but his negative impact defensively and the lack of two-way talent around him made every game an uphill battle if he wasn't on fire from the field.
Could Irving have done more the past three years to help the bottom line? Absolutely. His defensive real plus/minus rating was 71st out of 82 eligible point guards last season, and at least some of the blame for his team’s lack of chemistry has to fall on him.
But it’s not that Irving is incapable of playing a complete game. Some of the league’s poorest defenders just don’t have the foot speed or the intelligence to be useful on that end, but that isn't the case here. There’s just very little consistency in terms of his effort and technique, as he’ll often lazily walk into perimeter closeouts or provide faux help and actually guard no one.
Some of that is understandable. Buzzing around the court defensively is much less appealing during meaningless games, which make up the majority of Irving's career as a pro thus far.
Scoring has taken clear priority, as it often tends to for a bad team’s most gifted player, and that has created some clear accountability issues. Your best player can be a below-average defender, but not an unwilling one. Irving and Cleveland were caught in a vicious cycle that we see swallow up some of the league’s most talented young players time and time again.
Wipe the slate clean. Locker-room tiffs, shabby defense, bad body language, empty stats. Forget it all.
Irving, just 22 years old, has received a fresh start. He has a new max contract, a new coach in David Blatt, a new pick-and-pop big man in Kevin Love, and the reigning Best Basketball Player on the Planet next to him in James.
The big question is how Irving will adapt to all of it. You would hope he knows better than Ricky Davis, who once famously said: "I thought LeBron James was just going to be another addition to help me score." The ball is going to be in Irving’s hands a lot less, whether he’s ready for that or not.
Some established habits may die hard, but if his ramped-up defensive efforts this summer with Team USA during the FIBA Basketball World Cup are any indicator, Irving is mentally prepared to redefine his game. His role will be more complicated and will fluctuate on a game-to-game basis, but James has a habit of making basketball much easier for everyone on his side.
Where we might see the biggest difference in Irving’s production is away from the ball. He shot just 35.3 percent on 3.3 spot-up attempts per game last season, according to NBA.com. But with defenders unable to stay glued to him because of the presence of James and Love, those numbers should improve. Gone are the days of hoping Alonzo Gee will find him open on a drive-and-kick; defenders will have to actually pick their poison now instead of staying glued to Irving.
It’s easy to get caught up in the minutiae of Irving’s play, but no point guard in the league is in a better position. After a temporary delay, Irving is right back on track to have the type of career befitting his immense talent.
D.J. Foster is a contributor to ESPN.com and the TrueHoop Network. Follow him @fosterdj. All stats via NBA.com, Basketball-Reference.com or ESPN.com unless otherwise noted.
But LeBron's surge in popularity is confined to certain demographics.
Hispanics supported LeBron to the tune of 13.5 percent during the 2013-14 season and now do so at 17.4 percent. Even though LeBron rejected a heavily Latino market in Miami, his homeward turn certainly didn't hurt him with Hispanics polled.
There wasn't much evidence of LeBron's move resonating with African-American NBA fans or younger NBA fans. LeBron was the favorite player for 28.1 percent of the African-American NBA fans polled during the 2013-14 season. Our latest figures show no "I'm coming home" impact in that demographic, with LeBron most recently registering as the favorite player for 27.8 percent of African-American fans.
In stark contrast, older fans wholly embraced LeBron's embrace of his old team. The 35-54 demographic went from 14.7 percent support to 18.4 percent. Fans over the age of 55 went from 11.7 percent to 16.6 percent. LeBron's summer bump was powered by fans over the age of 35.
There might be a connection between how LeBron's return was received and how inclined the fan receiving it is to root for a local team. Older fans are generally more likely to support the local squad. Last season, 57.5 percent of fans over the age of 55 said they support the team in their market. Only 39.1 percent of fans 12-17 said they support the in-market team. There's a similar contrast between white and African-American NBA fans, with 58 percent of white fans supporting the local team to 37 percent black fans pledging local allegiance.
In terms of reputation, leaving Miami has been the opposite of leaving Cleveland. When LeBron ditched the Cavs in 2010, his favorite rating sank from that 15.6 percent figure to 10.2 percent in his first season with the Heat. Spurning Cleveland meant a sudden loss in over a third of his fans. In stark contrast, breaking hearts in Miami has led to many new LeBron converts nationwide, especially among demographics that tend to root local.
It would appear that if you root for the home team, you're more predisposed to cheer LeBron for coming home. If you like rooting for local clothing, you were probably rooting for Cleveland.
Here's how James looked at the end of the 2014 NBA Finals:
And here's how he looked on a trip to China in late July:
A week later, James was spotted in New York filming the movie "Trainwreck," looking even trimmer.
Then on Monday, James posted this photo on his Instagram account, in which he looked slimmer than he had since his early days with the Cavaliers.
So what's with the extreme makeover? Our Brian Windhorst reports that James decided to lay off the carbohydrates this offseason, and so far it seems to be working.
LeBron James decided to cut carbs this summer & dropped significant weight as tweeted photo shows: http://t.co/bpbGvYi5Bx— Brian Windhorst (@WindhorstESPN) August 4, 2014
James continued to show off his revamped frame on Instagram during a workout with Mike Miller, looking much like he did in his rookie season (with a few more tattoos and a little less hair):
LeBron James announced Sunday that after four seasons of wearing No. 6 with the Miami Heat, he'll go back to his original No. 23 when he rejoins the Cleveland Cavaliers this season. When James originally announced his decision to change to No. 6, he did so out of respect for Michael Jordan -- who, coincidentally has his jersey hanging on the wall in Miami, despite never having played for the Heat.
However, James is far from the first superstar to change his number, then have a change of heart and change back.
Ray Allen (34 to 20 to 34)
James' old Miami teammate Ray Allen has some experience with this type of jersey switch. Allen came into the league wearing No. 34 -- his college number -- for the Milwaukee Bucks, then held on to it with the Seattle SuperSonics. However, when Allen was traded to the Boston Celtics, 34 was taken by Paul Pierce, so Allen switched to 20. Upon signing with the Heat, Allen had his choice of 20 or 34, and went back to his original number.
Dominique Wilkins (21 to 12 to 21)
Dominique Wilkins most famously wore No. 21 for the Atlanta Hawks, where his number hangs in the rafters. He kept the number when he was traded to the Los Angeles Clippers late in the 1993-94 season, but when he signed with the Celtics, 21 wasn't available (it's retired for Bill Sharman). Wilkins played one season in Boston wearing the unfamiliar No. 12, before bolting for Europe. When he returned to the NBA in 1996-97 with the San Antonio Spurs, he was back in his trademark No. 21 -- becoming the last Spur to wear it before Tim Duncan.
Charles Barkley (34 to 32 to 34)
After Magic Johnson announced his sudden retirement due to HIV, Charles Barkley chose to change his jersey number from his original 34 to 32 to honor Johnson -- getting permission from Philadelphia 76ers legend Billy Cunningham to have the number temporarily unretired. However when Barkley was traded to the Phoenix Suns in the offseason, No. 32 was already being worn by Negele Knight, so Barkley switched back to 34, before finishing his career in Houston wearing No. 4.
Shaquille O'Neal (32 to 34 to 32)
In the exact reverse of Barkley, Shaquille O'Neal started his career wearing 32, switched to 34, then went back to 32 (before moving on to 33 and 36 in his twilight years). O'Neal actually wanted 33 -- his college number -- when he was drafted by the Orlando Magic, but that was taken by Terry Catledge, so O'Neal settled for 32. When he signed with the Los Angeles Lakers, both 32 (Magic Johnson) and 33 (Kareem Abdul-Jabbar) were retired, so he took No. 34, which was available after George Lynch was traded to the Vancouver Grizzlies. When O'Neal was traded to the Heat, he had his choice between 34 and 32, and decided to go back to his original number.
Michael Jordan (23 to 45 to 23)
Perhaps the most famous jersey number reversal, Michael Jordan wore No. 23 during his original stint with the Chicago Bulls, up until his retirement in 1993. When he returned to basketball in 1995, he chose to wear No. 45 -- the number he'd worn during his brief professional baseball career -- and leave No. 23 in the rafters. However, during the Bulls' Eastern Conference semifinal loss to the Magic, Jordan switched back to his customary No. 23, a move he said made him more comfortable, but cost his team a $25,000 fine. Jordan remained in 23 for the rest of his time with the Bulls, and kept the number during his brief comeback with the Washington Wizards.
Durant was cast as a protagonist for the digital age, a star displaying the "right way" to announce a career choice, while James found himself somewhere between He Who Must Not Be Named and King Joffrey on the likability scale.
It was inevitable to compare and contrast. James left; Durant stayed. James took his talents somewhere on television; Durant stayed put in 140 characters or less. There was a certain charm to the misspelling -- "extension" as "exstension" -- that illustrated how little premeditation Durant had seemed to invest, while James had everything meticulously orchestrated for his one-hour special.
What was lost, though, is that Durant actually made the same choice James did some four years earlier. Durant was coming off his rookie scale deal and did what virtually every player in his position does: take a maximum extension. Nobody turns down that money at that time.
Still, there was one big difference between the two extensions. James signed his in 2006 for three years, a strategic financial move that would make him a free agent after seven seasons, which allowed him to get a max at 30 percent rather than 25. Durant, on the other hand, specifically requested there be no early opt-out. This locked him in for the full five years.
Yet even with the gesture -- and all of the nice things he has said about the team and Oklahoma City -- as soon as Durant hit "send" on that tweet, the clock started ticking toward his next decision, the actual decision, the one he makes in 2016 as an unrestricted free agent.
James spent his first seven seasons in Cleveland, falling short of a championship seven times. Durant will spend his first nine seasons with the Thunder franchise and thus far has failed seven times to reach the ultimate goal. Should the Thunder fall short the next two seasons, the assumption is Durant will depart as James did, even if the optics are different.
But there's something for Durant to learn from Decision 2.0. James' choice was painted primarily as a homecoming story, the prodigal son returning to right his wrongs. All true, no doubt. Except there's another, more practical reason he picked Cleveland: sustainability.
In some ways, his departure is what put the Cavaliers in the position to bring him back, meaning they got so bad that they piled up young talent and assets. When James turns 34, Kyrie Irving, the No. 1 overall draft pick in 2011, will be 26. Andrew Wiggins, the 2014 No. 1 overall draft pick, will be just 23. The Cavs provide an opportunity for James to chase a championship for his hometown, and do it over and over again for the next decade. In a lot of ways, James found his Thunder.
Oklahoma City's buzzword from day one has been sustainability, and for the past four years, it has sustained one hell of a run. A winning percentage near .750, three trips to the Western Conference finals, and one to the Finals. In James' final four seasons in Cleveland, the Cavs won 68 percent of their games, made two conference finals appearances, and one in the NBA Finals. For both, there is a common, painful denominator: no championship.
For Durant, when the time comes to make his choice in 2016, it's not going to be about if he won a championship. It's about where he can win his next championship. We can't be entirely sure that had the Cavs won a title with James before 2010 that he would've stayed. We can assume, but we can't know.
That roster, with Antawn Jamison and Mo Williams and Delonte West and Shaquille O'Neal, wasn't built to contend for a decade. It was built to try to appease James on a year-by-year basis. Durant will be 27 when he signs his next contract somewhere, and that decision will be informed by the future, not the past.
Teams are already clearing space to have their pitch lined up for Durant. The Knicks have about $30 million in committed salary for 2016-17, the Nets $6.3 million. The Wizards owe $34.8 million, enough room to fit a max for Durant. The Lakers don’t have a single penny committed. The Thunder have $30.1 million committed, but that’s also their advantage -- because it’s for Russell Westbrook and Serge Ibaka.
The likely market for 2016 doesn’t include a Chris Bosh or Dwyane Wade out there for Durant to team with. Unless Durant wants to play with James, or Kevin Love exercises his player option, the best available free agents in summer 2016 are Dwight Howard (who will be 30), Deron Williams (who will be 32) and Al Horford (who will be 30).
Westbrook will be just 27; Ibaka will be 26.
There is the fact Durant plays in one of the league’s smallest markets and the financial realities that come with that. The Thunder have actively resisted dipping into the luxury tax, which reaffirms the perception that ownership is cheap and unwilling to spend for a contender (this is where you bring up the James Harden trade).
The reality is the team is planning for the future, avoiding years of the luxury tax that would place them as repeat offenders in 2016 and 2017, when they have to re-sign their core. Over-extending for the present is dangerous, and as the Thunder have harshly been forced to learn the past two postseasons with injuries to key players, there are no guarantees. “Going for it” can often only complicate your future.
Maybe Durant will be drawn back home like James, or maybe he'll want the big lights and big pressure of bringing a championship to New York. But what he'll really want is the best possible chance to win. And as long as the Thunder can provide that better than anyone else, his next decision will be just as simple as his first.
Any No. 1 overall pick works under a lot of scrutiny, but today’s events created a bizarre strain of scrutiny trained on Andrew Wiggins. His showdown with Jabari Parker at Las Vegas Summer League was sure to be hyped before Friday’s LeBron James news. After James’ epic announcement, the main Summer League event reached another level of intrigue.
LeBron’s entrance to Cleveland brought with it Kevin Love’s shadow. James did not mention Wiggins by name in his “I’m coming back to Cleveland” announcement letter, leading to questions about whether the Cavs might trade their 19-year-old rookie for the services of Minnesota’s available, unhappy star.
The Cavs have made pitches for Love, according to reports, but none so far that involve Wiggins. Given the struggles of Cleveland’s previous No. 1 pick, Anthony Bennett, it’s difficult to envision how the Cavs could get a Love deal done without surrendering Wiggins. For now, the Cavs seem unwilling to part with him.
All the LeBron and attached free-agency frenzy was enough to make you forget that Jabari Parker is Wiggins’ perceived rival as a rising young wing. This would be the first time we’ve seen the two measure up against each other since Kansas beat Duke at the United Center last November.
The suspense in the cozy Cox Pavilion was palpable from the jump. Kyle Lowry, DeMar DeRozan and Amir Johnson took courtside seats to watch their Raptors play in the game before Bucks vs. Cavs. That’s not notable, but here’s what is: The Raptors players didn’t move after their team’s game ended, preferring to hold their seats as the crowd slowly entered the arena. That’s rarely seen in a Summer League setting where established veterans file in and out.
Wiggins’ athleticism was on display, even if his shot and handle were shaky (he finished with 18 points on 18 shots). Terms like “athleticism” can be too reductive when describing players because everyone moves in their own way. Wiggins’ way is so much lighter than commonly seen. He’s perpetually on the balls of his feet, bouncing softly around in a manner that feels more ballet than basketball. That is, until he uncoils those springs in his legs and attacks. He probably didn’t attack enough, electing to loft eight 3-point attempts, but the Cavs did win in the end 70-68.
Parker impressed in spurts, but might have to do something about his conditioning. He was noticeably winded throughout the contest, but he didn’t let that stop him from scoring 17 points on 11 shots. His strength was on display when he converted a late bucket by posting up Wiggins out of the picture.
Giannis Antetokounmpo and Anthony Bennett actually generated the best highlights in this one. Bennett uncorked a monster two-handed slam in transition, and Antetokounmpo managed to easily dunk after dribbling twice from behind half court. It was a great game for yet-to-be-realized potential.
Maybe LeBron sees the talent on Cleveland’s side and believes in that potential. Maybe he believes in David Blatt’s ability to get something more out of this Cavs roster, even if he’s met Blatt only twice, as Cleveland’s new coach indicated in an interview.
James is approaching 30 years old, but betrays little fear of his own aging process. Despite not mentioning Wiggins upon arrival, he’s waxing patient. In his announcement letter, James specifically said, “I’m not promising a championship. I know how hard that is to deliver. We’re not ready right now. No way. Of course, I want to win next year, but I’m realistic.”
If James is indeed willing to help rebuild the Cavs slowly, then Wiggins is more protégé than trade piece. It’s difficult to foresee if Wiggins will eventually fulfill his promise, but the future feels bright in Cleveland. The question is whether LeBron’s talents will last long enough for it to arrive.
The return to Cleveland is a staggering comeback tale, an earthquake to the NBA’s ecosystem. So it’s a bit surprising to see James offer humble expectations along with a decision so epic. “I’m not promising a championship,” he says in his explanation letter. “I know how hard that is to deliver. We’re not ready right now. No way.”
Before the Cleveland rumors started, the consensus opinion was that James would choose whatever situation offered him the best chance at winning -- which Miami did in 2010. Four years later, he is explicitly saying that this route home is about something else entirely. Given the language James is using, he’s on a mission far larger than winning mere titles:
“I feel my calling here goes above basketball. I have a responsibility to lead, in more ways than one, and I take that very seriously. My presence can make a difference in Miami, but I think it can mean more where I’m from. I want kids in Northeast Ohio, like the hundreds of Akron third-graders I sponsor through my foundation, to realize that there’s no better place to grow up. Maybe some of them will come home after college and start a family or open a business.”
Claiming that you aren’t ready to win a championship might seem unambitious, but despite that disclaimer, consider the scope of what James is aspiring to. Ohio’s communities have been hit especially hard by the decline in manufacturing over the decades. Cleveland once had roughly three times the population it claims today. Akron has been losing residents since the 1960s. James is far from the only person to abandon his northeast Ohio home for opportunities elsewhere -- he’s just the most notable to try it.
But James wants to reverse a massive socio-economic phenomenon that’s been going strong for a half-century. By coming home, he wants to make Ohio whole again. Michael Jordan might be the greatest of all time, but he didn’t dare leverage basketball into something far greater than commerce. LeBron doesn’t just want to change the game -- he wants to change the economy.
There are more prosaic reasons for why this is happening, too. As James explains, leaving home can give you perspective on what you left behind and how much you miss it. Time can heal wounds, as evidenced by Cavaliers owner Dan Gilbert and James patching things up after an ugly divorce. James said leaving for Miami was the college experience he never had. Many of us can relate to how finding some separation makes the allure of home that much more appealing.
As many have already noted, the letter offers no mention of No. 1 draft pick Andrew Wiggins. If there’s a Kevin Love trade in the works, James might be selling this Cavs team’s chances short.
For now, Cleveland is indeed short on championship-ready players. It's long on so much else, though. The future is murky, and the past was ugly, but today, the most compelling sports story lives in northeast Ohio.
• Going rogue: Miami’s Big Three do not appear to be acting in concert -- yet. These are ominous early signs for Heat fans, who would be far more comforted had Dwyane Wade and Chris Bosh opted out of their contracts simultaneously with James. That scenario would have strongly indicated that the three of them had a plan for returning to Miami. This scenario gives the appearance that James is either putting pressure on Miami to make the choices he wants, or that he has one foot out the door.
• Finals not a factor? James has indicated that the result of the Finals has no bearing on decisions happening right now. While this could be true, you have to wonder if Miami had a Finals disastrous enough to change one’s vision of its future. After a season of carefully managing Wade’s minutes, he looked old and ineffective for much of the Finals. The Heat went from being considered a roughly even bet against San Antonio to losing by the most points per game of any Finals team in history.
• What about Wade? The educated guess is that if James leaves, Miami’s on the hook to pay Wade the remainder of his expensive contract. If Miami isn’t contending with a returning James, there’s little incentive for Wade to opt out of his deal right now and take a pay cut. If Wade does opt out of his deal right now, that’s a positive indicator that James is returning.
• Remember Serge Ibaka: NBA history may have turned on Ibaka’s calf, as the injury compromised the Thunder’s effort against the Spurs. The Heat matched up much better against Oklahoma City than against the San Antonio team that ended up throttling Miami. It’s hard to envision the possibility of James leaving had the Heat just won a third title –- as opposed to the current reality of James making this choice in the aftermath of the Heat losing three consecutive games in embarrassing fashion.
• Panicky Pat Riley: He’s the definition of cool, but Riley seemed less than in control during a June 19 news conference in which he exhorted other people to “get a grip.” If James leaves, certain Riley quotes will seem telling in retrospect. For instance, Riley said of his exit meeting with James, "He was restless. He wanted to get out of town with his family." On his relationship with James, Riley didn’t exactly betray a close working bond: "It's a texting relationship. It's a short meeting in the hallway. He knows I love him. He knows I respect him."
• Remember Mike Miller: Would Miller have been the difference against the Spurs? Probably not, but James was reputedly less than happy to lose a versatile floor spacer because owner Micky Arison wanted to save money. After getting amnestied by Miami, Miller had a fine season with Memphis. He was sorely missed by a Heat team that relied on his production in past playoffs. If Miami wishes to keep its Big Three at a discount, there’s perhaps hypocrisy in ownership asking for monetary sacrifices from players after Arison refused to foot the bill last season.
• LeBron gets lambasted for leaving: There’s a pattern to this, as we learned in 2010. Few criticize James till he finally chooses a new team and incurs the wrath of 29 LeBronless fanbases. He won’t be pilloried for returning to Miami. Fair or unfair, he will likely suffer an image hit if he does leave to compete in a more favorable situation. That’s the reality of spurning a fan base that’s rooted for you over a long period of time. Its pain gets amplified by the jealousy of others, and it builds into a storm of ill will directed at James and his newest team. That’s what happened when he left Cleveland. Ironically, this calculus is different if he actually comes back to Cleveland, as many have a sentimental preference for LeBron returning to his home state.
On Sunday night, Kawhi Leonard did an incredible job guarding LeBron James. He blew up screens, forced him toward help and ultimately, compelled James to take difficult, contested shots. It worked except that it didn’t.
As epitomized by LeBron’s pull-up 3-pointer with 6:08 left in the fourth quarter of the Miami Heat's 98-96 NBA Finals Game 2 win over the San Antonio Spurs, there wasn’t much Leonard could do. He shielded LeBron away from a Mario Chalmers screen, then angled him toward the sideline as the shot clock dwindled, but James still got off a shot. The ball swished as the buzzer sounded, and a snarling LeBron stomped past some courtside fans who looked none too happy.
It’s obvious what compels the San Antonio fans who hold up “LeCramp” signs and mock the Game 1 sequence where an injured athlete was carried to the sidelines. They want their team to win. But what about the others who would rather see LeBron fail? What’s in it for so many to root against the best individual expression of the sport?
That question is hard to answer, but it doesn’t seem to faze the Heat at this juncture. In 2011, the criticism amplified as LeBron played worse and worse in the Finals. Since then, his moments that inspire doubt and derision are usually quickly met with games like this.
On a smaller scope, Chris Bosh is going through a similar rinse cycle of, “Doubted, prevails, doubted.” He has been assailed for being soft, for playing like a 6-foot-11 guard. The two were ripped in tandem when LeBron passed to Bosh for an errant corner-3 in Game 5 against Indiana.
You could almost hear the screams of anger when, at 2:07 left on Sunday night, a LeBron pass led to a Bosh corner-3 that clanged out. Immune or oblivious to the pressures of what the Heat should or shouldn’t do, LeBron promptly found an open Bosh on the next possession. It was the right play, irrespective to popular opinions of who should or shouldn’t take the big shots.
Bosh sank the 3-pointer, and the Heat seized a lead they wouldn’t relinquish.
Playing like a 6-foot-11 guard has its benefits. You’re watching one of the most versatile big men in the game. It’s strange that he’s also one of the most mocked.
The Heat have survived the storm of criticism of 2011 much the way their Finals opponent continues to succeed. Both teams trust each other, trust the process, and strive to make the right play, ego be damned. Internal trust can triumph over the world’s sometimes not-so-favorable opinions. Well, at least your trust has a great shot of triumphing if you have the era’s best player on your side.
It’s very LeBron James for a moment that speaks to his greatness to double as a moment that brings great criticism and mockery. James suffered fourth-quarter cramps and had to take to the bench in the San Antonio Spurs' 110-95 Game 1 NBA Finals win over the Miami Heat. Without James' transcendent skills, his team crumbled both defensively and offensively and melted as the Spurs closed out the game with a 21-7 run.
The Spurs’ defense is formidable, but their arena presented a larger obstacle for James on Thursday night. The AT&T Center has challenged people with a bat, a snake and spotty wireless access. On Thursday, players and fans were subjected to temperatures up to 90 degrees due to what a Spurs Sports & Entertainment official said was an electrical failure that crashed the arena’s air-conditioning system. Earlier in the game, James was recorded by cameras joking, “They’re trying to smoke us out of there.” In the end, his seemingly indestructible body forced him from the action.
If the climate around James had been a bit different -- a bit more reasonable -- this might be occasion for near-universal sympathy. How sad it is to see a great athlete not able to engage at the height of competition. What unfortunate timing, what awful conditions. But while James certainly has his sympathizers, social media was replete with unfavorable comparisons to Michael Jordan, Kobe Bryant, Larry Bird and yes, even hockey players. If the greats could play under any circumstances, why couldn't James triumph over his lactic acid?
If Tim Duncan suffers those cramps, it’s probably a footnote. When James suffers them, it’s a trial. Obviously, this is because few people have anything against the former, and many people have something against the latter.
This moment is indicative of how, no matter how much he wins, James continues to play before a constituency that still harbors resentment toward him. The ranks can lessen a bit as the victories pile up. The ranks can go dormant during championship parades. But the group is always there -- waiting for situations such as this.
Perhaps it’s the Jordan comparisons that have rankled a certain bloc of those who traffic in 90s nostalgia. Perhaps it’s also the legion of Kobe fans who would rather not see another perimeter player eclipse their favorite. That anxiety of comparison plays a role, but the dominant factor is probably a decision that’s in the past but continues to permeate the present.
On the face of things, James’ relocation to Miami and the reaction that ensued could not be less like the man cramping up in the heat of battle. There are similar dynamics in play, though. When James had millions waiting on his every televised word, it was illustrative of just how powerful a basketball force he was. When the Heat fell apart after James left the game, it was illustrative of just how powerful a basketball force he is.
In many circles, the response to both testaments to greatness was and continues to be rage. It’s difficult to deny James’ on-court prowess, so anger quickly morphs into attacks on his character. If you don’t like somebody, you’re liable to assume the worst about them. To many, it doesn’t matter that James’ choice was validated with championships. To them, it doesn't matter how well James plays. They’re waiting for the moment when that isn’t happening.