Gordon Edes' interactive midseason Red Sox report card

Check out our expert's first-half grades, then share yours for each player on the 2011 team

Updated: July 8, 2011, 11:53 AM ET
By Gordon Edes |

BOSTON -- Here are the midseason grades for Red Sox players and members of management plus your chance to evaluate each one. Agree or disagree with my grades? Share your thoughts in the comments section.

Position players

J. Ellsbury, OF

Edes: Entering door marked "prime." Grade: A-

D. Pedroia, 2B

Edes: Knee oiled, bat ignited.
Grade: A-

A. Gonzalez, 1B

Edes: He has been crazy good.
Grade: A+

K. Youkilis, 3B

Edes: Bang-up despite banged up. Grade: A-

David Ortiz, DH

Edes: Turn back the clock, indeed. Grade: A

C. Crawford, LF

Edes: .275 OBP? Are you kidding? Grade: D+

J.D. Drew, OF

Edes: Slippage has been dramatic. Grade: D

J. Saltala., C

Edes: Chance for patience rewarded. Grade: C+

Jason Varitek, C

Edes: The Captain overachieves. Grade: C+

Jed Lowrie, SS

Edes: Injuries mar strong start. Grade: B-

M. Scutaro, SS

Edes: Lost his job, showing slippage lately. Grade: C

J. Reddick, OF

Edes: Primed to jump off Pawtucket shuttle. Grade: B

D. McDonald, OF

Edes: Not the guy we saw last year. Grade: F

D. Sutton, IF

Edes: Has done what's been asked. Grade: B-

Y. Navarro, IF

Edes: Kid could end up at short. Grade: Inc.

Starting pitchers

J. Beckett, SP

Edes: His place card reads "ace" again. Grade: A

Jon Lester, SP

Edes: Throw out May, he's an A. Grade: B

C. Buchholz, SP

Edes: Back issue now a major worry. Grade: B-

John Lackey, SP

Edes: Disaster of epic proportions. Grade: F

T. Wakefield, SP

Edes: He's up, he's down, he's eternal. Grade: C+

A. Miller, SP

Edes: Lester out, Miller's importance grows. Grade: Inc.

Relief pitchers

J. Papelbon, RP

Edes: More K's, fewer walks, one BS. Grade: A-

Daniel Bard, RP

Edes: WHIP it (0.816) good. Grade: A

Matt Albers, RP

Edes: Unsung star in a key role. Grade: B+

D. Wheeler, RP

Edes: Encouraging signs after slow start. Grade: C

A. Aceves, P

Edes: Starts, relieves, competes. Grade: C

F. Morales, RP

Edes: Could become sleeper. Grade: Inc.

Bobby Jenks, RP

Edes: Hurt and ineffective.
Grade: D


Terry Francona

Edes: Held firm during slow start. Grade: A

Theo Epstein

Edes: AGon a coup, others not so much. Grade: B

Gordon Edes

Red Sox reporter,



  • Coming Up Short
    The Red Sox lost on a Xander Bogaerts error in the ninth, falling to 5-9.
  • The Hurt Lingers
    On the anniversary of the Marathon bombings, Boston pays tribute.
  • Running Strong
    Tales of perseverance remind us that Boston still is running strong.
  • What's The Plan?
    Mailbaggers know Bill Belichick's draft history, so they're ready for anything.
  • Healthy Respect
    Peter Chiarelli likes his team, but the B's GM is a fan of the Red Wings too.