Discussion

All 15 finalists belong in the Hall

How can you leave Shannon Sharpe or Andre Reed or Curtis Martin off your ballot?

Originally Published: February 4, 2011
By Michael Wilbon | ESPN.com

DALLAS -- It might not be the greatest class of finalists Pro Football Hall of Fame voters have ever had to consider, but it could be the most difficult to judge. One of the oft-repeated phrases used by selectors to justify turning thumbs down on a candidate has always been, "It's not the Hall of Very Good; it's the Hall of Fame." In other words, only truly great players should be granted entry.

Well, here the voters are in 2011, confronted by an entire list of great players. If ...

Read full story

Comments

You must be signed in to post a comment

Already have an account?

EDITORS' PICKS

  • Cold Turkey
    At 5-7 after their Thanksgiving flop in Detroit, the spoiler role might be all that's left to these Bears, Jon Greenberg writes.

ALSO SEE