College Football Awards - Buck Buchanan Award
| Buck Buchanan Award | ||
| YEAR | PLAYER | SCHOOL |
| 1995 | Dexter Coakley | App St |
| 1996 | Dexter Coakley | App St |
| 1997 | Chris McNeil | |
| 1998 | James Milton | W Illinois |
| 1999 | Al Lucas | Troy |
| 2000 | Edgerton Hartwell | W Illinois |
| 2001 | Derrick Lloyd | JMU |
| 2002 | Rashean Mathis | Beth-Cook |
| 2003 | Jared Allen | Idaho St |
| 2004 | Jordan Beck | Cal Poly |
| 2005 | Chris Gocong | Cal Poly |
| 2006 | Kyle Shotwell | Cal Poly |
| 2007 | Kroy Biermann | Montana |
| 2008 | Greg Peach | E Wash |
| 2009 | Arthur Moats | JMU |
| 2010 | J.C. Sherritt | E Wash |
