12th annual Herbie Awards
Originally Published: August 21, 2012
By
Kirk Herbstreit | ESPN
Editor's note: Check out "The Herbie Awards" airing on ESPN at 7 p.m. ET Tuesday.
It's that time of the year again, a chance to honor the best of the best. Welcome back to the Herbie Awards, where the elite players and coaches of college football are celebrated.
A reminder: This is just my list. These are my choices, and not everyone will agree. That's what makes it so fun.
With that being said, let's get the 12th annual Herbie Awards started.
STARRING ROLE: BEST RUNNING BACKS
![]() Marcus Lattimore is primed for a big season. (Photo by Gerry Melendez/The State/Getty Images)
1. Marcus Lattimore, South Carolina
2. Montee Ball, Wisconsin 3. Knile Davis, Arkansas 4. Kenjon Barner, Oregon 5. Stepfan Taylor, Stanford |
CATCHING ON: TOP WIDE RECEIVERS
|
1. Marqise Lee, USC
2. Tavon Austin, West Virginia 3. Robert Woods, USC 4. Da'Rick Rogers, Tennessee 5. Marquess Wilson, Washington State ![]() Marqise Lee and USC have their eyes on the big prize. (Photo by Ric Tapia/Icon SMI)
|
QUARTERBACKS: POCKET PASSERS
![]() QB Matt Barkley is a Heisman contender for USC. (Photo by Ric Tapia/Icon SMI)
1. Matt Barkley, USC
2. Aaron Murray, Georgia 3. Tyler Wilson, Arkansas 4. Geno Smith, West Virginia 5. Keith Price, Washington |
QUARTERBACKS: DUAL-THREAT
![]() Logan Thomas rushed for 11 TDs in 2011. (Photo by Chris Graythen/Getty Images)
1. Logan Thomas, Virginia Tech
2. Collin Klein, Kansas State 3. Denard Robinson, Michigan 4. James Franklin, Missouri 5. Braxton Miller, Ohio State |
TIGHT ENDS: BEST IN THE BIZ
![]() ND's Tyler Eifert knows what to do once the ball is in his hands. (Photo by Brad Barr/US Presswire)
1. Tyler Eifert, Notre Dame
2. Jake Stoneburner, Ohio State 3. Zach Ertz, Stanford 4. Philip Lutzenkirchen, Auburn 5. Chris Gragg, Arkansas |
END GAME: DEFENSIVE ENDS -- THE DIRTY DOZEN (I'm allowing myself to exceed the limit of five per category!)
![]() Sam Montgomery can cause havoc for opponents. (Photo by Derick E. Hingle/US Presswire)
1. Sam Montgomery, LSU
2. Brandon Jenkins, Florida State 3. William Gholston, Michigan State 4. Barkevious Mingo, LSU 5. Bjoern Werner, Florida State 6. Jadeveon Clowney, South Carolina 7. Corey Lemonier, Auburn 8. Jackson Jeffcoat, Texas 9. Dion Jordan, Oregon 10. Alex Okafor, Texas 11. John Simon, Ohio State 12. Malliciah Goodman, Clemson |
INSIDE JOB: DEFENSIVE TACKLES
![]() You can't miss where Utah's Star Lotulelei is on the field. (Photo by Russ Isabella/US Presswire)
1. Star Lotulelei, Utah
2. Johnathan Hankins, Ohio State 3. Jesse Williams, Alabama 4. Kawann Short, Purdue 5. Bennie Logan, LSU |
GOT YOUR BACK: OUTSIDE LINEBACKERS
|
1. Jarvis Jones, Georgia
2. Chase Thomas, Stanford 3. Jonathan Brown, Illinois 4. Jamie Collins, Southern Miss 5. Jelani Jenkins, Florida ![]() Jarvis Jones plays a big role in Georgia's defense. (Photo by Kim Klement/US Presswire)
|
INSIDE LINEBACKERS
![]() Kevin Reddick is ready to dominate for UNC. (Photo by Bob Donnan/US Presswire)
1. Kevin Reddick, North Carolina
2. Shayne Skov, Stanford 3. Manti Te'o, Notre Dame 4. Nico Johnson, Alabama 5. Chris Borland, Wisconsin |
TAKE COVER: DEFENSIVE BACKS
|
1. David Amerson, NC State
2. Xavier Rhodes, Florida State 3. Johnthan Banks, Mississippi State 4. Nickell Robey, USC 5. Johnny Adams, Michigan State ![]() David Amerson is a playmaker in NC State's secondary. (Photo by Jeff Siner/Charlotte Observer/Getty Images)
|
SAFETY FIRST: TOP SAFETIES
![]() Opponents are very familiar with Oklahoma's Tony Jefferson. (Photo by Mark D. Smith/US Presswire)
1. Eric Reid, LSU
2. Tony Jefferson, Oklahoma 3. Robert Lester, Alabama 4. Bacarri Rambo, Georgia 5. Kenny Vaccaro, Texas |
RIGHT TO EXCITE: MOST EXCITING PLAYERS
![]() WVU's Tavon Austin is fun to watch with the ball in his hands. (Photo by Douglas Jones/US Presswire)
1. Tavon Austin, West Virginia
2. De'Anthony Thomas, Oregon 3. Denard Robinson, Michigan 4. Sammy Watkins, Clemson 5. Onterio McCalebb, Auburn |
RODNEY DANGERFIELDS: PLAYERS WHO DON'T GET ENOUGH RESPECT
|
1. David Amerson, NC State
2. Geno Smith, West Virginia 3. Johnathan Franklin, UCLA 4. Chase Thomas, Stanford 5. Bjoern Werner, Florida State ![]() Geno Smith deserves respect. Is he getting it? (Photo by Rob Carr/Getty Images)
|
SHHHHH, DON'T TELL: BEST-KEPT SECRETS
![]() Fans will soon know more about Le'Veon Bell. (Photo by Robin Alam/Icon SMI)
1. Le'Veon Bell, Michigan State
2. Giovani Bernard, North Carolina 3. Cameron Marshall, Arizona State 4. Michael Clay, Oregon 5. Marquess Wilson, Washington State |
DON'T TURN YOUR BACK: BACKYARD FOOTBALL
![]() Arizona State's Jamal Miles can play on Herbie's team any day. (Photo by Gary A. Vasquez/US Presswire)
1. Kyle Fuller, Virginia Tech
2. Jared Abbrederis, Wisconsin 3. Jamal Miles, Arizona State 4. Tony Jefferson, Oklahoma 5. Eric Reid, LSU |
DRESS FOR SUCCESS: LOOKS THE PART
![]() William Gholston is a man on a mission. (Photo by AP Photo/Al Goldis)
1. William Gholston, Michigan State
2. Jadeveon Clowney, South Carolina 3. Shayne Skov, Stanford 4. Da'Rick Rogers, Tennessee 5. Marqise Lee, USC |
OFF AND RUNNING: READY TO TAKE IT TO THE NEXT LEVEL
![]() Look for Braxton Miller to keep getting better for Ohio State. (Photo by Joe Robbins/Getty Images)
1. Marqise Lee, USC
2. Keith Price, Washington 3. Braxton Miller, Ohio State 4. Nico Johnson, Alabama 5. Cobi Hamilton, Arkansas |
OLD SCHOOL: THROWBACK PLAYERS
|
1. Collin Klein, Kansas State
2. Rex Burkhead, Nebraska 3. Marcus Lattimore, South Carolina 4. Max Bullough, Michigan State 5. Philip Lutzenkirchen, Auburn ![]() Collin Klein could play in any era. (Photo by Tim Heitman/US Presswire)
|
AHEAD OF THE CURVE
![]() Marcus Mariota will provide a big spark for Oregon. (Photo by Steve Dykes/Getty Images)
1. Marcus Mariota, Oregon
2. Andrew Maxwell, Michigan State 3. Michael Holmes, Virginia Tech 4. Trey Metoyer, Oklahoma 5. Matt Miller, Boise State |
OUCH! THE ANKLE BREAKERS
|
1. Denard Robinson, Michigan
2. Kenjon Barner, Oregon 3. Robert Woods, USC 4. Jamal Miles, Arizona State 5. Dustin Harris, Texas A&M ![]() Catching Michigan QB Denard Robinson isn't easy. (Photo by Derick E. Hingle/US Presswire)
|
BASIC INSTINCT: IT'S EVERYTHING
![]() Arthur Brown always has his eyes on the ball. (Photo by Peter G. Aiken/Getty Images)
1. Chris Borland, Wisconsin
2. Arthur Brown, Kansas State 3. Dion Bailey, USC 4. Manti Te'o, Notre Dame 5. Cameron Lawrence, Mississippi State |
SURPRISE PARTY: TEAMS
|
1. Mississippi State
2. Purdue 3. Boise State (Chris Petersen!) 4. Tennessee 5. UCLA ![]() Chris Petersen will keep Boise State relevant. (Photo by Kirby Lee/Image of Sport/US Presswire)
|
SUDDEN IMPACT: BEST COORDINATOR HIRES
|
1. Mike Stoops, Oklahoma
2. Doug Nussmeier, Alabama 3. Sal Sunseri, Tennessee 4. Brian VanGorder, Auburn 5. Justin Wilcox, Washington ![]() Doug Nussmeier takes over Alabama's offense. (Photo by AP Photo/Butch Dill)
|
MOVIN' ON UP: HEAD COACHES WHO WILL GET HIGHER-PROFILE OPPORTUNITIES
![]() Charlie Strong may find his way into a bigger spotlight. (Photo by AP Photo/Chris O'Meara)
1. Charlie Strong, Louisville
2. James Franklin, Vanderbilt 3. Skip Holtz, South Florida 4. Dave Doeren, Northern Illinois 5. Mario Cristobal, FIU |
THE ULTIMATE HERBIE
|
1. Matt Barkley, USC
2. Collin Klein, Kansas State 3. Marcus Lattimore, South Carolina 4. Barrett Jones, Alabama 5. Montee Ball, Wisconsin ![]() Montee Ball represents the best in college football. (Photo by Michael Hickey/US Presswire)
|
ALL-HERBIE TEAM: WHAT A COLLEGE TEAM SHOULD LOOK LIKE
| Offense | Defense |
|---|---|
| QB Logan Thomas, Virginia Tech | DL William Gholston, Michigan State |
| RB Marcus Lattimore, South Carolina | DL Sam Montgomery, LSU |
| RB Rex Burkhead, Nebraska | DL Corey Lemonier, Auburn |
| WR Marqise Lee, USC | DL Jadeveon Clowney, South Carolina |
| WR Tavon Austin, West Virginia | LB Shayne Skov, Stanford |
| WR Da'Rick Rogers, Tennessee | LB Jarvis Jones, Georgia |
| TE Jake Stoneburner, Ohio State | LB Jamie Collins, Southern Miss |
| T Oday Aboushi, Virginia | |
| T Jake Matthews, Texas A&M | CB Kyle Fuller, Virginia Tech |
| C Barrett Jones, Alabama | CB Xavier Rhodes, Florida State |
| G Chance Warmack, Alabama | S Kenny Vaccaro, Texas |
| G Braden Hansen, BYU | S Tony Jefferson, Oklahoma |
CONFERENCE PREDICTIONS
| Conference | Champion | Player of the Year |
|---|---|---|
| ACC | Florida State over Virginia Tech | Logan Thomas, Virginia Tech |
| Big 12 | Oklahoma | Tavon Austin, West Virginia |
| Big East | Pitt | Ray Graham, Pitt |
| Big Ten | Michigan State over Wisconsin | Montee Ball, Wisconsin |
| Conference USA | Southern Miss over SMU | Jamie Collins, Southern Miss |
| MAC | Ohio over Western Michigan | Alex Carder, Western Michigan |
| Mountain West | Boise State | Robbie Rouse, Fresno State |
| Pac-12 | USC over Oregon | Matt Barkley, USC |
| SEC | Alabama over Georgia | Marcus Lattimore, South Carolina |
| Sun Belt | Florida International | Ryan Aplin, Arkansas State |
| WAC | Louisiana Tech | Quinton Patton, Louisiana Tech |
Kirk Herbstreit has been an ESPN college football studio analyst since August 1996. Herbstreit, who joined ESPN in September 1995 as a college football sideline analyst for ESPN2, is also a game analyst for ESPN's Thursday night college football telecasts.
SPONSORED HEADLINES
MORE COLLEGE FOOTBALL HEADLINES
- QB Lunt mulls Illinois after visit, sources say
- Former Arkansas QB Mitchell picks NC State
- McCartney back on WVU roster after 6 months
- Sources: C-USA to put team in Military Bowl
MOST SENT STORIES ON ESPN.COM
2012 COLLEGE FOOTBALL KICKOFF

After a traumatic offseason, it's time for the games to start again. Gene Wojciechowski »
2012 PREVIEW
- The 12th annual Herbie Awards »
- Schlabach: Hot or not for 2012 »
- Conference roundup: Stopping the SEC »
- McGee: Programs that could topple SEC

- Bloggers: State of the conference »
- Miller: Star power returning in 2012 »
- Heisman Watch » Hopefuls » Dark horses

- Haney: Title timelines for top 10 schools

- RecruitingNation sites: Brands »
- Power rankings » | Preview home »
ACC
- Dinich: Star power returns at QB »
- Dinich: Up-tempo offenses all the rage »
- Dinich: Miami, Golden keep climbing uphill »
- FSU's foreign All-American » NoleNation »
- ACC recruiting rankings: FSU on top

- ACC preview
Podcast 
BIG 12
- Maisel: Renewed sense of optimism »
- Ubben: K-State fueled by its skeptics »
- Strickland: Familiar pattern at Texas »
- Chatmon: OU's game-changing move »
- Maisel: Baylor's life without RG3 »
- Ubben: Comparing West Virginia and TCU »
- Big 12 recruiting rankings: Texas on top

- Big 12 preview
Podcast 
BIG EAST
- Adelson: Who will carry the torch? »
- Adelson: Big East uncertainty »
- Adelson: All eyes on Pitt RB Graham »
- Sobleski: Concerns for Big East

- Big East recruiting rankings: USF on top

- Big East preview
Podcast 
BIG TEN
- Rittenberg: Big Ten offenses a mixed bag »
- Hot Button: Golden era in UM-OSU rivalry? »
- Ward: Meyer sticks to the Buckeye script »
- Rothstein: Michigan seniors come full circle »
- Bennett: Meyer, O'Brien add their stamps »
- Rittenberg: Wisconsin adapts to transition »
- NittanyNation: In-state dreams »
- Rittenberg: Opportunity knocks at PSU »
- Big Ten recruiting rankings: UM No. 1

- Big Ten preview
Podcast 
PAC-12
- Maisel: USC tries to squeeze in window »
- Miller: Are new coaches ready? »
- Gemmell: Getting defensive »
- Maisel: USC tries to squeeze in window »
- Recruiting rivalry for Washington schools »
- How Chip Kelly recruits for his offense »
- Recruiting rankings: USC rules

- Pac-12 preview
Podcast 
SEC
- Maisel: Depth rules in SEC »
- Low: It's (still) an SEC world »
- Low: Alabama focused on the present »
- Low: Impressive QB pool »
- Schlabach: Next quest for John L. Smith »
- Aschoff: Pass rushers dominate »
- Aschoff: Distractions don't deter Dawgs »
- Schlabach: Tigers and Aggies in SEC »
- TideNation: Bama's options on offense »
- GatorNation: Florida's uphill climb »
- DawgNation: Wins on Murray's mind »
- Recruiting rankings: SEC's presence felt
- SEC preview
Podcast 
INDEPENDENTS
- Fortuna: Irish name Golson starting QB »
- Fortuna: Has Brian Kelly found his man? »
- Schlabach: Notre Dame still resonates »
- Reilly: Spare me the Notre Dame hype »
- Golson's impact
Notre Dame blog » - Maisel: BYU's Nelson reclaims starting job »
ESPN THE MAGAZINE
- Schonbrun: WVU's Smith has artistic side »
- Thompson: Meyer will be home for dinner »
- Van Valkenburg: The Honey Badger »
- Bragg: Down here »
- McGee:The SEC according to Spurrier »
- Forrest: Trojan force goes deep »
- Brachmann and Grossman: SEC info »
VIDEO
- Kiper: Top prospects for 2014, by position
- Recruiting: Michigan tops 2014 class ranks
- Haney: CFB's top 10 teams based on talent
- Kiper: Top QB prospects for 2014 | RBs | WRs
- Fremeau: Who will win the SEC? | Pac-12



























