| RK | PLAYER | POS | HOMETOWN | HT | WT | STARS | GRADE | SCHOOL |
| 1 |  | QB | Buffalo, NY Saint Joseph's Collegiate Institute | 6'3'' | 205 | 81 |  Clemson Signed | |
| 2 |  | OT | Rochester, NY Aquinas Institute | 6'6'' | 295 | 80 |  Notre Dame Signed | |
| 3 |  | S | Brooklyn, NY Erasmus Hall High School | 5'11'' | 190 | 80 |  Syracuse Signed | |
| 4 | OT | Manorville, NY Eastport-South Manor High School | 6'6'' | 284 | 78 |  Virginia Signed | ||
| 5 | OT | Athol Springs, NY Saint Francis High | 6'4'' | 270 | 77 | |||
| 6 |  | DT | Newburgh, NY Newburgh Free Academy | 6'0'' | 300 | 77 |  Connecticut Signed | |
| 7 | CB | New Rochelle, NY Iona Prep School | 5'9'' | 175 | 76 |  UCLA Signed | ||
| 8 | RB | Athol Springs, NY Saint Francis High | 6'1'' | 205 | 75 |  Penn State Signed | ||
| 9 | DE | Tarrytown, NY Hackley School | 6'4'' | 243 | 75 |  Duke Signed | ||
| 10 | DE | Rochester, NY East High School | 6'3'' | 220 | 75 | Syracuse Committed 06/16/2011 | ||
| 11 |  | WR | Staten Island, NY Tottenville High School | 6'2'' | 183 | 74 | Syracuse Signed | |
| 12 |  | RB | Mastic Beach, NY William Floyd High School | 5'10'' | 175 | 74 |  Massachusetts Signed | |
| 13 | WR | Rochester, NY Gates-Chili High School | 6'0'' | 190 | 74 |  Buffalo Signed | ||
| 14 |  | K | Delmar, NY Bethlehem Central High School | 6'3'' | 165 | 74 | ||
| 15 |  | CB | Rochester, NY Aquinas Institute | 6'0'' | 175 | 74 |  Pittsburgh Signed | |
| 16 | OT | Depew, NY Depew High School | 6'4'' | 290 | 73 | Buffalo Signed | ||
| 17 |  | RB | Dix Hills, NY Half Hollow Hills West High School | 6'0'' | 195 | 73 | Syracuse Signed | |
| 18 |  | DT | Buffalo, NY Canisius High School | 6'3'' | 280 | 73 | Buffalo Signed | |
| 19 | QB | Amherst, NY Sweet Home High School | 6'1'' | 200 | 71 | Buffalo Signed | ||
| 20 | K | Rome, NY Rome Free Academy | 6'1'' | 180 | 71 | |||
| 21 |  | RB | Lake Ronkonkoma, NY Sachem High School | 5'11'' | 185 | 71 |  New Hampshire Signed | |
| 22 |  | K | Spring Valley, NY Ramapo High School | 5'10'' | 160 | 67 | ||
| 23 | OC | Pittsford, NY Pittsford Sutherland High School | 6'2'' | 265 | 66 |  Princeton Committed | ||
| 24 | OG | Depew, NY Depew High School | 5'11'' | 279 | 65 | |||
| 25 |  | RB | Port Washington, NY P. D. Schreiber High School | 5'7'' | 149 | 64 | ||
| 26 |  | RB | New York, NY Xavier High School | 5'10'' | 159 | 63 |
