According to the numbers below, Russell Westbrook should not be blamed for the Thunder’s Game 2 loss.After the Oklahoma City Thunder’s loss to the Miami Heat in Game 2, many people are placing the blame on Russell Westbrook.
Westbrook took the most shots of anyone in the game, going 10-of-26 from the field and scoring 27 points. In some cases, the main thought seems to be that Kevin Durant, who went 12-for-22 from the field and finished with 32 points, should have gotten some of the opportunities Westbrook “took away.”
In fact, the refrain that “he takes away too many shots from Durant” has been a common criticism of Westbrook all season. The problem with this attack is that the numbers show the Thunder haven’t actually done better in games in which Durant has had more opportunities than Westbrook this season.
Thunder By Durant/Westbrook Usage Pct
2011-12 Season Including Playoffs
When looking at it the simple way, it’s apparent the team does better when Westbrook takes more shots. This is in terms of both offensive efficiency and win percentage.
Of course, field goal attempts are just one part of a player’s offensive game -- free throws and turnovers are also part of it. If we look at usage percentage -- the percentage of team plays used by a player while he’s on the floor -- we can see how often the ball ends with Westbrook or Durant, whether it be with a field goal attempt, a trip to the free throw line or a turnover.
For some perspective, the average usage percentage is 20 percent, Durant’s average this season is 30.3 percent and Westbrook’s average is 31.7 percent (fifth highest in the NBA).
Looking at which player had a higher usage percentage in each game, we can see a pattern emerge: The Thunder are more efficient offensively and win more games when Westbrook’s usage percentage exceeds Durant’s.
Another thing we can look at is how the Thunder have performed when Westbrook and Durant use a lower/greater percentage of their team’s plays than usual.
Looking at the four combinations of each player's usage percentage relative to his average:
• The Thunder offense is at its worst when Durant has an above-average usage percentage and Westbrook has a below-average usage percentage, averaging just 104.0 points per 100 possessions in those 20 games, with the team winning less than half of those as a result.
Meanwhile, the Thunder offense is still OK (slightly below-average efficiency) when Westbrook uses more plays than usual and Durant uses fewer than usual. So shifting offensive opportunities directly from Westbrook to Durant, at least how that has been done in some games this season, does not seem to be optimal for OKC.
• The Thunder offense is at its best when Durant and Westbrook are both below average in terms of usage percentage, averaging an efficient 111.8 points per 100 possessions in those games. This would imply that getting others involved is the real key in the Thunder’s most effective offensive games.
Is this just about Westbrook setting others up better in those low-usage games? It doesn't look like it. In those 22 low-usage games, it is Durant's assists that go up (4.9 apg versus 3.1 in all other games), not Westbrook's (5.2 apg versus 5.7 in all other games).
Statistical support for this story from NBA.com.