- Lester Munson, Legal Analyst
- 0 Shares
In a federal lawsuit filed on Monday, Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Corbett attacks the NCAA and the sanctions applied to Penn State as a result of the Jerry Sandusky scandal.
Corbett and his lawyers claim the NCAA violated the nation's antitrust laws when the NCAA insisted that the university agree to severe sanctions. The lawsuit demands that the NCAA's sanctions be lifted and raises questions about the authority of the NCAA to govern college sports and on other legal issues. Here are some of the questions and their answers:
Q: Will Gov. Corbett succeed in his attempt to undo what the NCAA has done to Penn State?
A: No. There are two basic legal rules that are likely to result in an early dismissal of Corbett's lawsuit. The words that describe these legal rules are "standing" and "waiver." To succeed in any civil lawsuit, the person filing the lawsuit must have standing to sue, a stake in the outcome of the dispute. If, for example, a former Penn State player filed suit over the NCAA's elimination of Penn State victories and championships, he would have standing to challenge the NCAA, because he played in the games. Corbett has no identifiable interest or standing in the welfare of the Penn State football program. His lawyers, clearly worried about the standing question, attempt to establish standing for Corbett with multiple mentions of supposed damage to the "state revenue base," but it won't work. Corbett is the wrong guy to file this lawsuit.
"Waiver" describes an action that has already been agreed to and accepted -- the NCAA sanctions that Corbett attacks. The university agreed to the sanctions in a "consent order" last summer. If Corbett ever had any chance to attack the sanctions, it disappeared with the university's agreement and its waiver of the right to question the sanctions.
Q: Could Corbett's lawsuit benefit from his role as governor, given the case will at least initially be heard in Pennsylvania?
A: If Corbett and his lawyers manage to find a judge who will lean in the direction of Penn State, they may succeed in the early litigation stages as the beneficiaries of a home-court advantage. Even a federal judge with lifetime tenure can be subject to local pressures. But even this possibility looks remote. The case is currently assigned to U.S. District Judge Yvette Kane in Harrisburg. Kane, 59, is a graduate of Nichols State University and Tulane Law School and has no immediately apparent connections to Penn State.
Q: What is Corbett's legal theory?
A: The 43 pages of Corbett's lawsuit are filled with political rhetoric and almost devoid of anything resembling jurisprudence. The only apparent legal theory is based on antitrust laws that govern monopolies that use their powers to fix prices or to manipulate markets. There is, of course, no doubt that the NCAA is a monopoly. It has the power of a cartel and is clearly subject to antitrust scrutiny.
Corbett asserts that the NCAA is using its monopoly powers to restrain one competitor (Penn State) from competing with other member schools, labeling the sanctions a "clumsy attempt to harm a competitive member school." The problem for Corbett is that the NCAA in its punishment of Penn State is doing exactly what its members created it to do. It is not conspiring to manipulate any market. It is, instead, performing the regulatory function that the Division I schools want it to perform.
Q: What is the next step in the lawsuit?
A: Corbett wants the court in Harrisburg to issue an injunction that would prevent the NCAA from enforcing the Penn State sanctions. Even if Corbett and his lawyers avoid an early dismissal, they face serious obstacles. Injunctions in antitrust cases are rare. To obtain the injunction -- the most drastic relief a judge can give in a civil case -- the governor must show irreparable harm and a probability that he will succeed in any appeals.
The NCAA, in its resistance to the request for the injunction, will argue that the sanctions are a reasonable exercise of NCAA powers. It's an argument that usually succeeds in stopping an injunction. In antitrust litigation, the question of whether something is reasonable is determined by a jury. If the case goes to a jury trial, there would be months, even a year or two, of exchanges of documents and pretrial interrogations of witnesses. By the time the trial was concluded and appeals were decided, the Penn State football program almost certainly would have completed its compliance with the four years of sanctions.
The Southeastern Conference's agenda for spring meetings leans heavily toward ensuring that other leagues don't have any competitive advantage, either from satellite camps or graduate transfers.
Indiana wide receiver Isaac Griffith is out of jail after being arrested for driving while intoxicated.
Running back Keith Ford, who decided to transfer from Oklahoma after being suspended in March, has chosen to enroll at Texas A&M, he told 247Sports.
Edward Oliver, the No. 6-ranked prospect in the country, is staying home for college, committing to the Houston Cougars over LSU, Texas A&M and Texas.
Syracuse on Wednesday clarified its position on the use of the No. 44 a day after it received criticism from the announcement that a committee would pick players to again don the retired number.
The founder of the UAB Football Foundation said Thursday that he feels a "whole lot better today than I have in the past" after meeting with UAB president Ray Watts, according to AL.com.
North Carolina announced Friday it has received a notice of allegations from the NCAA regarding the re-opening of its academic fraud investigation.
The Utah Utes' Devontae Booker led the Pac-12 with 815 rushing yards after contact.
His signature long hair is no more -- Beathard donated his hair to a charity for children with cancer.
Kendell Jones is a 6-foot-5, 361-pound monster of a recruit who is down to Alabama, Texas, Texas A&M, LSU or Baylor. But it wasn't always that way. He had to learn to get tough.
Oklahoma has a strong group of running backs, but needs help in the defensive secondary.
The former Texas A&M quarterback will enroll in June and acknowledged he attended TCU practices this spring in an effort to get a head start.
Fans are in favor of an annual Penn State-Pitt game, but scheduling such a series is anything but easy.
In order to create balance in the ACC, ESPN.com took a crack at reshuffling the Atlantic and Coastal divisions. But creating harmony in the conference could mean separating Clemson and Florida State.
The Hurricanes posted a six-minute video to YouTube documenting the conversations the staff has when deciding whether to make a scholarship offer.
The Pac-12 brought in $374 million in total revenue during the last fiscal year, the most of any Power 5 conference.
What does it mean to the Cougars that defensive tackle Edward Oliver, the No. 6 player in the ESPN 300, just committed to their program over the likes of LSU and Texas A&M?
The Rebels currently have 18 former players in the NFL, and between them they make an average salary of $4.1 million per year.
Silver linings are great, but Minnesota is tired of finding the positive in the progress the program has made. Now it's time for the Gophers to reach their goals instead of just coming close.
After its third-down conversion rate took a serious dip in 2014, LSU should be better with a year of experience under its belt.
How good should NC State be in 2015 and how many wins will constitute a successful season?
With five-star cornerback Levonta Taylor, Florida State has yet another commit from Virginia. The state is proving to be key to the Seminoles' success.
For all the talk about the important of academics and the need to reduce the time demands on football and basketball players, what happens next?
College football players are used to living in dorm rooms that are more like apartments. They're not used to life in a country like Haiti.
The linebacker who chose UCLA on signing day and then flipped to Georgia has potential to make an impact from the jump.