Ranking Super Bowl QBs

From No. 1 (Montana '90? Simms '87? Brady '04?) to No. 80 (Kerry Collins), Page 2 ranks the performance of every QB in Super Bowl history.

Updated: August 12, 2005, 11:38 AM ET
By Aaron Schatz | Special to Page 2

New England fans maintain that Tom Brady doesn't need impressive statistics to prove his greatness. But let's be honest -- they can't hurt. And a statistical look at all 38 Super Bowls shows that Brady's MVP performance in Super Bowl XXXVIII was the greatest single game by any quarterback in Super Bowl history.

To rank the quarterbacks, I started with conventional statistics and turned them into an estimate of the Points Above Replacement measure used all season long in Page 2's Snap Judgment ...

Read full story


You must be signed in to post a comment

Already have an account?