Discussion

FFL mailbag: April 28

Originally Published: April 28, 2006
By Scott Engel | ESPN Fantasy Games
Matt, Fox Lake, Ill.: I am in a 10-team league with a two-keeper maximum. You lose the round in which the player was drafted in the past. Of the following, which two would you keep?: Peyton Manning (first round), Ronnie Brown (10th), Carnell Williams (sixth) or Tiki Barber (third)?

Engel: Manning should be your first keeper. He is worth the first-rounder you sacrifice because he annually delivers outstanding fantasy numbers at a position where stability isn't easy to come by. Manning is durable and no quarterback in fantasy football is more dependable when it comes to providing you with high-level production every season. While "Cadillac" is certainly a top keeper if he is healthy, and Barber should give fantasy players another fine year or two (his age is an overrated factor when you consider he hasn't always been a full-time featured back), Brown is the best choice when you are only sacrificing a 10th-rounder. He now becomes a highly valued fantasy RB with Ricky Williams suspended, and could rush for 1,300-plus yards and at least eight touchdowns in an expanded role this season. Playing with Daunte Culpepper could give him a chance to flash the receiving skills that went mostly untapped in his first pro season. Manning and Brown should be your keepers.

Bill, New York, N.Y.: My league allows three keepers, with each player counting as the draft pick in the round they were originally picked. I have Chad Johnson, who was drafted in the second round, and Joey Galloway, who was picked in the 13th round. This year, I will have the first pick in the second round. I am wondering if I should keep Galloway over Johnson given the round and hope maybe I can retain Johnson with the first pick in the second round. My other two keepers will be LaDainian Tomlinson and Larry Johnson, drafted in the first and sixth rounds,

ALSO SEE

FANTASY TOP HEADLINES