Catfish Hunter tallied just 224 wins and won only one Cy Young. His Black Ink Test score at Baseball-Reference.com is 20 (the average Hall of Famer's is 40). He never struck out 200 batters in a season, and he gave up 374 home runs in 15 years.
And he's in the Hall of Fame.
Some guys are just bigger than they were.
Some guys are named Catfish by their crazy green-and-gold owners. Some guys have Dylan songs written about ...