The Texas Rangers are talking about a possible trade of Michael Young, who would welcome a change of scenery and a deal to a place where he could be an everyday player. In light of that, I e-mailed some rival talent evaluators to give me their current assessment of the 34-year-old Young, and where they think his best position would be going forward. Their responses make it clear he is still a respected performer and leader; there are concerns about how he would hit in another ballpark.
Evaluator No. 1 (AL team)
"We still see him as an everyday option for a contending team. Our hit and power tools would equate to about a 770-780 OPS (using OPS as a quick and dirty number but specifically around .280-.290 avg with 17-19 HR's). His swing is low maintenance and his ability to put the bat on the ball will always allow him to hit for a higher batting average. He's always had some firmness to his hands, so that will show up no matter where you play him. We do not show that he has lost a step, which is a common theme for players in their mid 30's. I think what draws clubs to him is his intelligence, competitiveness and the uncomplicated nature of his swing, he's pretty reliable, and that makes coaches and the front office sleep easier."
For the full take, you need to be an Insider.