Cam Newton, honor codes and Facebook
What do the founder of Facebook, Mark Zuckerberg, and Auburn Tigers quarterback Cameron Newton have in common? In the past month, both have been thrust into the headlines for things they did in college that allegedly violated their school's honor codes. And neither seems too shaken up about it.
Honor codes are the redheaded stepchild of college sports, the second cousin of undisclosed violations of team rules. They're talked about solemnly, but for the most part they're vestiges of another era, like when gentlemen settled fights with two fingers of scotch and pistols at 20 paces.
Their seeming irrelevance is captured in the new movie about the rise of Facebook, "The Social Network." In a key scene taken from the public record, two brothers, Tyler and Cameron Winklevoss, get a meeting with Harvard's president in 2004 to complain that Zuckerberg stole their idea for a social networking site, ConnectU, and renamed it "thefacebook.com." When they suggest that Zuckerberg should be brought up on charges of violating Harvard's honor code, however, they're tossed out of the office.
The brothers, who represented the U.S. in rowing at the 2008 Olympics in Beijing, turned to the courts for their revenge. And newly discovered instant messages obtained from Zuckerberg's computer at the time seem to bear out their claim. As one of the messages reads:
FRIEND: so have you decided what you are going to do about the websites?
ZUCK: yea i'm going to [redacted] them
ZUCK: probably in the year
In an interview with The New Yorker in September, Zuckerberg acknowledged the authenticity of the exchange. So why is he laughing? Because the brothers settled their federal suit two years ago, meaning the new information doesn't change a thing; they can't touch another penny of his fortune.
Now on to Cam Newton.
Last week, Fox Sports reported that Newton was accused of violating the honor code at Florida when he played there. According to Fox, he did it once as a freshman by cheating in class and twice as a sophomore by allegedly turning in two separate papers that he did not write.
What happened? Apparently, nothing. He transferred to tiny Blinn College in Texas before Florida's Student Conduct Committee could get its hands on him.
Asked about it the other day at Auburn, Newton brushed off the charge without directly refuting it. "I don't want to beat a dead horse talking about it," he said. "It's not going to affect me."
Dead horse? How about dead code? Because it seems like one more instance in which academic honor codes are laughed off. Check out these eye-opening stats about the percentage of sophomore-through-senior students who admit engaging in dishonorable conduct:
22 percent Serious test/exam cheating
44 percent Serious written cheating
37 percent Internet plagiarism
43 percent Unauthorized collaboration**
Given these stats, which come from The Center for Academic Integrity at Clemson University and deal with students in the general population, how scared do you think star athletes are about getting caught cheating when they have coaches and athletic directors looking out for them?
"The untold story is that there is a lot of unspoken tension between university conduct officers, athletic directors and coaches," said Scott Lewis, a conduct code writer who heads the National Center for Higher Education Risk Management.
Lewis knows that athletic departments like to keep their dirty laundry to themselves. "Are there programs that keep stuff away from conduct code offices? Yes, of course," he said. "But by the same token, I know athletic directors who really struggle mightily with the relationship."
Lewis divides codes into two types. The first, he says, are the "purely aspirational," which is a nice way of saying they don't have any teeth. (He points to his alma mater, Texas A&M, whose honor code reads: An Aggie does not lie, cheat or steal, or tolerate those who do.) The other is the kind that embeds specific violations in the school's policy manual, and results in real trials and expulsions.
For Lewis, it's simply about teaching morality. "If a student isn't held accountable for a violation, then the question is what's going to happen two years later, when he's faced with another ethical choice?"
Then again, Zuckerberg's message may be the most powerful one of all: violate an honor code now, laugh all the way to the bank later.
** Speaking of unauthorized collaboration ...
On Nov. 5, University of North Carolina athletic director Richard Baddour sent this letter to a tutor for the football program who gave "impermissible academic assistance" to Tar Heels players in 2009 and 2010.
The letter informs Jennifer Wiley, a Durham elementary school teacher, that she is banned from having contact with "current or future student-athletes" for the next five years. Wiley's unusual closeness to several football payers she mentored led UNC's academic support program to cancel her contract in 2009. After that, she continued the work on her own.
In a statement to reporters, the 2009 grad insisted that she didn't intend to skirt any rules or do anything wrong.
The most interesting tidbit in this mess comes from the Tar Heels' former academic coordinator, Cynthia Reynolds, who says she started hearing whispers about Wiley in May 2009.
She told The Charlotte Observer and Raleigh News Observer that she thought Wiley had crossed a line, but she was afraid to alert coach Butch Davis to the potential NCAA violation. Why? Because Wiley was also mentoring his son, Drew, as well as driving him around town, and she thought Wiley had become close to his family.
"In my opinion, if I had gone to Coach Davis, my job would have been on the line," Reynolds told the newspapers. As it turns out, she lost her job anyway last summer, and she's filed a federal claim against the school for age discrimination.
So far, 14 UNC players have missed at least one game as a result of the ongoing NCAA probe.
Grady Sizemore computer hacker gives cops tips
Give Leah Ayers credit. At least she's a helpful (alleged) computer hacker.
The 19-year-old student from Minnesota's St. Cloud State University came to the attention of police this spring after Los Angeles investigators started looking into the bizarre break-in of a computer belonging to Playboy Playmate Brittany Binger. The hacker stole cell phone photos that Binger stored of her boyfriend, Indians CF Grady Sizemore. Several of the ones of him nearly naked ended up all over the web, and Sizemore had to threaten legal action to get sites to stop posting them.
According to this search warrant affidavit, which was unsealed in Minnesota's Dakota County Court this week, Ayers broke into Binger's Facebook, Twitter and MySpace accounts on six occasions in August 2009. But she wasn't quite as smart a hacker as she thought. When Binger reported the crime, the L.A. cops were able to do a reverse trace and follow the hacker's electronic fingerprints back to an IP account registered to Ayers' father.
When police arrived at the Apple Valley, Minn., address listed on the account, Ayers professed her innocence. But she also gave the cops a startling hacking tip:
"Ms. Ayers stated that Yahoo.com uses security questions to change passwords and one of the questions the site uses is knowing where a person's father was born." As it turned out, Binger's father's birthplace was mentioned on her Facebook page.
This complaint filed in Dakota County District Court on Nov. 9 charges Ayers with two counts of unauthorized computer access. Prosecutors haven't provided a motive for why she allegedly picked Binger, but maybe she'll explain when she arrives in court for a hearing later this month.