- Lester Munson, Legal Analyst
- 0 Shares
A federal judge in Philadelphia has rejected a proposed settlement of more than 4,500 NFL concussion lawsuits. Her decision raises legal questions about the settlement, its terms and its future:
Q: The attorneys for the players and the attorneys for the NFL agreed on the terms of the settlement. Why would the judge reject it at this stage?
A: U.S. District Court Judge Anita Brody, in the 12-page opinion she issued Tuesday, expressed concern about whether all NFL retired players who suffer concussion-related injuries "will be paid." She suggested that the $765 million fund "may lack the necessary funds" to pay all of the retired players who qualify for awards.
In addition to her concern about payments for dementia and other concussion-caused conditions, she is not happy with the funds set aside for measuring and treating future injuries and the settlement's proposal to bar all NFL players from any claims they may have against the NCAA.
Although the lawyers proposing the settlement submitted more than 300 pages of paperwork, they did not offer Brody detailed actuarial analysis covering the adequacy of the settlement or any projections of why the funds would be sufficient for payments over the 20 years proposed in the agreement. Further, they did not offer any detail about the fund's adequacy for future medical treatment.
Q: What is the significance of the judge's ruling?
A: Brody's ruling is significant in two ways. First, it is an embarrassing setback for the players' attorneys who have submitted the proposal. These lawyers included in their proposal a request for $112 million in fees for themselves. It is difficult to imagine how the lawyers could have done $112 million in legal work and not submitted the expert reports to the judge. After spending more than four months preparing these legal papers, the player-clients now learn that the lawyers omitted critical materials from the paperwork.
Second, the rejection, even if temporary, will add to the growing skepticism among players and their personal attorneys about the settlement terms. In addition to the demand for enormous fees and delays in preparing paperwork, the judge's concerns about the adequacy of the settlement funds will fuel player concerns that their representatives have settled for too little. It could add to the number of players who will opt out of the settlement and take their chances in the litigation process.
Q: Does this mean that the settlement will fall apart and the players and the league will return to a litigation battle?
A: Not necessarily. In the settlement proposal, the attorneys for the players asserted that they had consulted extensively with actuaries and economists to ensure that settlement funds would be adequate for as many as 20,000 potential claims. They did not, however, include any reports from the experts whom they consulted. Brody wants the lawyers to submit the expert opinions for her consideration.
Q: What happens next?
A: The lawyers who are leading the players' efforts will submit the expert reports to the court. Brody has appointed a special master who will review the reports and make a recommendation to the judge.
If Brody is satisfied with the experts' opinions and their analysis of the settlement proposal, she will reconsider the proposed settlement. If the experts' reports are as impressive as the players' lawyers suggest, then the settlement could move to the next step in the approval process. If the experts' opinions are less than persuasive (a real possibility), then the judge may issue a final and conclusive rejection of the proposal, sending the players and team owners back to the bargaining table.
Los Angeles' focus in its key win over San Antonio can be traced to Doc Rivers' canceling practice.
Cavaliers forward Kevin Love suffered a dislocated left shoulder on a "bush-league play" against the Celtics on Sunday, while Boston center Kelly Olynyk says there wasn't any intent to injure.
Monta Ellis scored 31 points, J.J. Barea had 17 points and 13 assists in his first playoff start since boosting Dallas' run to the 2011 championship and the Mavericks avoided elimination with a 1
The Albuquerque Police Department is currently seeking UFC light heavyweight champion Jon Jones for questioning related to a hit-and-run incident on Sunday.
The Washington Wizards emphatically completed the first sweep of a seven-game series in club history, beating the Toronto Raptors 125-94 Sunday night.
Cardinals ace Adam Wainwright is expected to miss the rest of the 2015 season due to an Achilles injury he suffered Saturday while stumbling out of the batter's box, a source told Jim Bowden.
Memphis Grizzlies guard Mike Conley will not play Monday night in Game 4 of the series with the Portland Trail Blazers because of a facial injury.
Kurt Busch dominated once he took the lead and won the rain-delayed NASCAR Sprint Cup race at Richmond International Raceway on Sunday.
Mel Kiper and Todd McShay play GM for all 32 NFL teams, alternating mock draft picks for the first three rounds of the 2015 draft.
The Cavaliers' J.R. Smith was called for a flagrant-2 foul for striking the Celtics' Jae Crowder in the face and subsequently ejected.
While Cleveland plays the waiting game, the availability of Kevin Love and J.R. Smith is suddenly in jeopardy.
With star forward Anthony Davis eligible for a contract extension this summer, Pelicans officials plan to present him with a maximum five-year deal that could exceed $140 million, sources said.
The Dodgers put Yasiel Puig on the 15-day disabled list due to a tight left hamstring, marking the first time the mercurial outfielder has been on the DL in his big league career.
Carey Price decided to put the breaks on another Senators fairy tale and booked the Canadiens' ticket to the second round.
Royals outfielder Lorenzo Cain is ready to move on after the Royals brawled with the Chicago White Sox in the series opener on Thursday night.
Adrian Beltre had a rough night at the plate Friday against Garrett Richards, but the Rangers third baseman got the last laugh, sending the Angels pitcher an invoice for three broken bats.
A pair of Nikes that were the earliest NBA-worn shoes of Michael Jordan's that have ever come to market have sold for $71,553.
The Celtics moved Jae Crowder into the starting lineup and rookie Marcus Smart to the bench for Game 4 against the Cavaliers.
Washington notched its first 4-0 sweep in franchise history by knocking down a team-record 15 3-pointers.
Thousands of protesters took to the streets around Camden Yards Saturday to demand answers in the case of Freddie Gray, the largest rally since the 25-year-old black man died in police custody.
Jerry Crasnick has the latest on Cardinals ace Adam Wainwright, who is expected to miss the rest of the season with an Achilles injury, which he suffered Saturday night while stumbling out of the batter's box.
Heavyweight champion Wladimir Klitschko was not at his devastating best, but he still cruised to a lopsided decision against Bryant Jennings to retain the title for the 18th time.
Mark Sanchez doesn't seem worried about Tim Tebow's presence on the roster, calling him "another guy to throw while [Sam Bradford] is still recovering."
The past six months of Kurt Busch's life have been tumultuous as he faced a domestic violence charge. With that now behind him, his dominant victory Sunday was one of his proudest moments.